10 Films That Should Never Have Become Franchises

One gimmick. Five movies.

Saw Puppet
Lionsgate

Remember that episode of Family Guy where Peter steals the sequel to The Passion Of The Christ from Mel Gibson’s hotel room? Good news: Mel really is making a sequel and no, this is not a joke.

Called The Resurrection (which leaves little doubt as to the film’s plot), the film slots perfectly into modern multiplex filmmaking: an instantly recognizable brand based on a massively popular book with a built-in audience.

The question is, does it deserve to be a franchise?

If Hollywood asked itself that question more often, audiences wouldn’t now be bracing themselves for Ocean’s 8, Johnny English 3 and Mamma Mia: Here We Go Again. We wouldn’t be living in fear of the upcoming Transformers spin-offs, including the possibility of a G.I. Joe crossover movie.

Like McDonalds, Hollywood understands the importance of branding and franchising and recognizes that uniformity is key to a product’s success. People will always come back for more of the same, even if they got diarrhea the last time.

Here are 10 reasons why most audiences should have their viewing privileges revoked.

10. Robocop

RoboCop Shooting Gun
Orion

As much a satire as an action movie, Robocop owes a great deal to the verve of Paul Verhoeven, a Dutch director making his second Hollywood movie, who brings an outsider’s eye to what could have been a by-the-numbers sci-fi movie. Like the 2014 remake, you might say.

Verhoeven didn’t return for the sequels and it shows: the first one was mean-spirited and humourless, the other bland and unmemorable. Neither was particularly exciting and their attempts at satire seemed to have been filtered through a focus group.

According to Frank Miller, who co-wrote both sequels, that’s pretty much how it was. He’d turn in a draft and producers Orion would automatically demand rewrites until it no longer resembled his original story. Maybe that's why Robocop’s Directive #262 reads “Avoid Orion Meetings.”

Getting back to the 2014 remake, the makers of the next Robocop movie swear it isn’t part of their film’s timeline. Yeah man whatever.


9. The Terminator

Terminator 3 Sergeant Candy
C2 Pictures

The Terminator’s budget was low enough ($6 million) to give it a B-movie feel, and for all its car chases and cutting-edge technology, it’s the only film in the franchise that can be taken as a down and dirty exploitation picture. It’s also the one with the most heart and the best ideas, but if you want to see the same story mounted a $100 million budget, then Judgment Day is for you. Just don’t expect to see anything new.

T2 must also bear the brunt for convincing Arnie that Terminators could be funny. In the first sequel, he gets away with one quip (“I need a vacation!”), but by the time of Rise Of The Machine, he’s content to play off his old catchphrases every few minutes. Until near the end, there was more than a touch of déjà vu to the plot, which was basically a facsimile its predecessor.

The dour, humourless Terminator Salvation polarised audiences, but Terminator Genisys deserves credit for turning the franchise into a Mel Brooks movie, complete with “jokes” about how humanity won’t survive unless Kyle Reese and Sarah Connor get it on.


8. The Texas Chainsaw Massacre

Viggo Mortensen Texas Chainsaw Massacre
New Line Cinema

As blackly comic as Night Of The Living Dead was subversive, The Texas Chain Saw Massacre (the onscreen title) is a virtual textbook on how to make a claustrophobic, trend-setting genre piece with modest resources. Sensational but unforgettable, violent but not gory and unrestrained but never overblown, Chain Saw should be screened for every wannabe horror filmmaker as an example of how to get it right.

Aside from Tobe Hooper’s own Chainsaw 2, the most interesting aspect of the sequels is the casting. Viggo Mortensen appears in Leatherface: Texas Chainsaw Massacre III, Renee Zellwegger and Matthew McConaughey are in Texas Chainsaw Massacre: The Next Generation and Jessica Biel turns up in the remake. Other than that, each new movie was slung together by clods who couldn’t direct traffic.

Released in 2017, Leatherface is the seventh film spun off from Hooper’s original, the second to be titled Leatherface and the second that purports to be a prequel, which ought to answer the question of whether it adds anything of note to the franchise. Unlike The Texas Chainsaw Massacre: The Beginning, though, it’s a prequel to Hooper’s original.


7. Predator

Predator 2
20th Century Fox

Predator might be a B-movie writ large but it’s so well-cast, tautly directed and smoothly conceived that it’s some kind of classic. It serves up everything a suspenseful monster movie ought to be in a triple portion, but doesn’t take itself so seriously that the audience doesn’t have any fun.

Incredibly, the same writers and producers reunited for Predator 2, a movie so unforgivably rubbish that Arnie turned it down in favour of Kindergarten Cop. It’s basically a third-rate cop movie with monotonous characters, blah action and zero suspense. The lowest-grossing Predator movie to date, it sank the franchise for 14 years and left the door wide for Alien Vs Predator.

Both AVP films rely on the corniest clichés imaginable, from Lance Henriksen’s cough being a sure sign of terminal illness to the teenagers in Requiem who just want to sneak out and go skinny-dipping, unaware monsters have crash-landed in their town. Even the action is this installment is sub-par, usually taking place in locations so poorly lit you can barely tell what’s happening.


6. Paranormal Activity

Paranormal Activity 4 A L
Paramount

You might think Paranormal Activity is about ghosts, but it’s really a savage critique of the banking industry with a demon wreaking havoc on a day trader for his role in the 2008 financial crisis.

Nah, just messing with you. That’s thinking too deep because there is absolutely nothing at the core of Paranormal Activity, whose found footage gimmick was looking shopworn even in 2009. It was still good enough for five sequels as well as several imitations and parodies, though, so you have to credit Paramount for having the chutzpah to pull it off and blame the audiences who fell for it.

The found footage gimmick means the filmmakers aren’t required to bother with such things as structure, dialogue or likeable characters so each sequel is another trawl through the same old routine where a bunch of idiots end up videotaping themselves while sleeping. Talk about your first world problems.


5. Saw

Saw V Strahm
Lionsgate

This first Saw isn’t really about the traps or about Jigsaw – it’s a movie for the head, whose elaborate plot unfolds with one startling twist after another. The trouble with releasing a sequel every year quickly became apparent when the rushed-looking Saw II arrived in cinemas, boasting a plot that wasn’t as clever as the filmmakers seemed to think.

The rot set in with Saw III, which abandoned any semblance of logic in favour of more traps, more grue and more screaming. Most franchises would die along with their main character, but when Jigsaw breathes his last at the end of the film, he’s already left behind enough traps to set up the next four movies. For a character on his deathbed, that’s not bad.

By the time of Saw 3D there was no plot, just a sense that the train wreck was coming to a halt. Shtick is recycled from earlier installments and more characters return from the grave, but as another victim faces another round of torture porn, you’re reminded that you’ve seen it all before and simply upping the volume can’t change that.


4. Halloween

Halloween 4: The Return Of Michael Myers Screenshot
20th Century Fox

John Carpenter’s 1978 original is the movie that for better or worse changed modern horror. After proving that you could mount a tight, suspenseful movie on a $330,000 budget, the movie opened the door for a seemingly endless succession of clones.

In the sequels and remakes that followed, Michael Myers was stabbed, blinded, blown up, run over and shot more times than A Christmas Carol. He was outsmarted by text messaging teens, survived being decapitated and became a laughing stock when he appeared alongside Busta Rhymes without killing him. Then he did a couple of movies with Rob Zombie. Hey ho.

2018 marks 40 years since Michael first returned to Haddonfield and to celebrate they're bringing him back to menace more teenagers. Now 61 years old, he’s slower and grayer than he used to be, suffers from back pain and gets up four times a night to pee but he’s still the most lethal horror icon to use a chairlift.

Fans can expect action, excitement and a scene where Michael gets winded and decides to chase Jamie Lee Curtis on a Segway. The tagline for the new movie is, “The Night HE Came Home And Fell Asleep Watching Downton Abbey.”


3. Pirates Of The Caribbean

Paul McCartney Pirates Of The Caribbean
Disney

As charming as the first Pirates movie was back in 2003, if someone touted the idea of four sequels in fourteen years back then, you might’ve wished that person well but you wouldn’t lend them any money.

We got a glimpse of just how bloated, noisy and unfunny those films were going to be in the summer of 2006 when, because we weren’t yet addicted to Netflix and social media, we turned Dead Man’s Chest into the year’s biggest movie. A year later, we all watched At World’s End thinking it couldn’t possibly be any worse and after nearly three hours of overblown spectacle conceded that we’d been overly optimistic.

Mark Kermode does an amusing rant where he claims nobody really enjoys these films, they just think they do because of diminished expectations. You’re watching $300 million worth of action, spectacle and special effects, so how could you fail to be satisfied?

Well, the effects might be expensive but soul and a sense of fun cost nothing, and they’re lacking in these movies.


2. The Crow

The Crow Wicked Prayer
Dimension Films

With its trend-setting urban hell production design, cool soundtrack and terrific cast, The Crow has a real shot at being the best comic book adaptation of the 1990s. After more than 20 years, the movie stands up as an example of what can be accomplished when the demand for tie-ins doesn’t overwhelm the content.

Alas, this was as good as it got for James O’Barr’s creation and by the time The Crow: City Of Angels rolled around three years later, the series was ready for the scrapyard. It set the trend for each subsequent movie: it was the same story all over again, only without any heart or style, and the actors looked like they’d rather be appearing in another movie.

The best you can say about The Crow Salvation is that it has it has a cool soundtrack album (with The Infidels, Rob Zombie and Pitchshifter – check it out), but The Crow: Wicked Prayer (starring Edward Furlong and Tara Reid) was so listless you wondered why they bothered.

Here’s hoping the proposed remake never sees the light of day.


1. I Spit On Your Grave

I Spit On Your Grave 2
Anchor Bay

If you haven’t seen I Spit On Your Grave, all you need to know is that it’s about a young woman’s revenge on the four men who raped her and left her for dead. One is hung from a tree, another has his penis cut off and bleeds to death, and so on.

The 1980 release of Meir Zarchi’s movie was protested by feminists, who felt the filmmaker had turned rape into entertainment. In his review, Roger Ebert called it “a movie so sick, reprehensible and contemptible that I can hardly believe it’s playing in respectable theaters.”

In 2010, the remake met with a muted response despite adhering closely to the original narrative. A sequel followed that told essentially the same story with a different character, then in I Spit On Your Grave: Vengeance Is Mine the original lead character returned to punish the city’s rapists.

Due out in 2018, I Spit on Your Grave: Déjà vu is a direct sequel to Zarchi’s film but isn’t there something distasteful about franchising rape and revenge? Doesn’t being told the same story five times just dull our sensations and trivialize the subject?


In this post: 
Saw
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Ian Watson is the author of 'Midnight Movie Madness', a 600+ page guide to "bad" movies from 'Reefer Madness' to 'Poultrygeist: Night of the Chicken Dead.'