10 Films That Were Blatant Propaganda

Remember when Rocky solved the Cold War?

Rocky IV Poster
MGM/UA Entertainment Company

"Propaganda all is phony." Bob Dylan practically screeches those words in one of many explosive verses of "It's Alright Ma, I'm Only Bleeding." And it's the same kind of punk rock sentiment that engendered much of Dylan's youthful writing. It's also a relatable idea.

For in days past, we ate up some of the most obvious, transparent attempts to sway general public opinion.

The most flagrantly obvious example that still haunts screening rooms of cinema classes is Birth of a Nation, D.W. Griffith's adaptation of Thomas Dixon Jr.'s novel The Clansman. At the time, President Woodrow Wilson described the film as "writing history with lightning" (It's worth noting, however, that he added that "my only regret is that it's all terribly true.")

Today, we like to think we're less susceptible to naked propaganda, or even the more insidious kind, though that won't stop politicians and filmmakers from trying. There have been occasions, however, when the political or social objective of a picture was far from accomplished. Worse, other films have been rendered moot once their usefulness has expired due to shifts in foreign policy.

Whatever the case, here are a few that didn't sell.

10. Reefer Madness

reefer madness
Roadshow Attractions

Everything you've heard so far about Reefer Madness' reputation, particularly in an age when the drug is well on its way to legalization, is well-earned and worth seeing. Every absurd D.A.R.E. officer story, everything Nancy Reagan preached is on full, campy display. And it's made all the better that there is no running joke commentary through the film, though you could easily purchase or download a Rifftrax of your choice. The film, on its own, is played completely straight.

It started when a church group began funding a film they intended to call Tell Your Children, warning parents about the dangers of cannabis. Said dangers include a hit and run accident, manslaughter and attempted rape, according to Reefer Madness, which the producer titled it after he re-cut it and sent it around the exploitation market.

Of course, anyone who had ever tried the drug knew its effects were not at all as depicted. The film's popularity only grew and by the 1970s it was a regular on the Midnight Movie Circuit.

In a roundabout way, Reefer Madness gave birth to A Nightmare on Elm Street, as it was the film producer Bob Shaye used to sell around campuses to fund New Line Cinema.

But if the question is whether or not Reefer Madness accomplished its goal of sending parents into a frenzy, the answer is resounding no.


9. The Green Berets

Green Berets The
Warner Bros

Cowboy actor/President Ronald Reagan's administration was the last time John Wayne was a relevant figure. He's a walking anachronism, now, and he was already seeing his waning days in 1968 when Westerns had moved past the silent strong man and into Peckinpah territory, where he'd never fit right.

He did, however, struggle desperately for relevancy, falling back on old tricks when he stumbled upon Robin Moore's novel The Green Berets. In Moore's novel, Wayne and co-director Ray Kellogg found a strong, anti-commie war film, perfect for showcasing The Duke's America. In The Duke's America, he punches Stalin harder than Captain America walloped the Furher, by gum. No commie was safe.

Wayne even secured funding and support from Lyndon Johnson and the Department of Defense.

It may not have helped matters that Warner Bros. demanded less talk, more action - something that for which The Alamo was criticized. That limited Wayne's desire to have more well-drawn characters. But none of those characters would have been members of the Viet Cong. They are portrayed as savages, having no frontline or strategy. It was the year of the Tet offensive, so Wayne wanted them as despicable as possible.

One journalist described coming home from covering Vietnam and seeing the film thusly: "I laughed out loud...and my companion...said, 'Let's get the hell out of here and run like hell'."


8. Rocky IV

Rocky IV
MGM

Nostalgia for Rocky IV is currently at a high and understandably so. At least it was crying for peace during a rather dicey period in U.S./Russian Relations. Foreign policy between the two countries hasn't been this as heightened since the end of the cold war, and cinema hasn't been as quick to fire on their former enemy this time around. There have been light shots across the bough but they are just as indicative of the U.S. as its former nemesis.

You won't, for instance, see a Red Heat II this time around, as much as we'd honestly sort of like to. But it is likely that we'll get a few hammy cries like Rocky Balboa's again.

By the fourth Rocky, the Italian Stallion had done TV commercials, fought Mr. T and won Best Picture. Stallone felt like he had to speak up, and for that to be done, it meant killing off a series regular. It would have been a dynamic plot shakeup had it not happened in the previous film with Mickey Goldmill, making Apollo Creed's death a lazy retread.

As for the cringe-worthy end speech, let's let Hunter Thompson sum it up: "a series of horrible beatings climaxed abruptly in a frenzy of teenage political blather from Sylvester Stallone...the only excitement came when Sly beat the huge Russky like a mule."


7. Any Dinesh D'Souza

Hilary's America: The Secret History of the Democratic Party
Quality Flix

Politics aside, there are certain standards one must pass in order to be a successful filmmaker by any metric. Objectively speaking, there are simple things, like lighting (most critics include one star if they can just see the damn thing, which is more of a problem than you would think). But beyond technical issues, storytelling must be both a passion as well as an ability.

Dinesh D'Souza first appeared on the political scene, not the cinematic one, over two decades ago. The now-pardoned lawbreaker came out of Dartmouth a razor-tongued conservative pundit. But there was something a little different about him - just slightly more extreme. D'Souza holds his opinions to be self-evident, that no man but Glenn Beck before him tend to one main thesis, no matter how outlandish supporting it becomes.

Beyond being objectively poorly made films that critics have called "too incoherent for an argument", they have also been labeled as "pseudo-history lessons" and "feature-length dog whistles".

All of those are cherry-picked from reviews of Hilary's America: The Secret History of The Democratic Party. One can argue about the various facts and obfuscations about the Clintons, the Trumps, and every other powerful family in America. Nine times out of ten, they're going to have some skeletons worth digging up.

When your propagandist documentary is literally able to be proven factually inaccurate by Wikipedia, you don't have a leg to stand on.


6. Act Of Valor

Act of Valor
Relativity Media

Anyone who has ever experienced a recruitment drive for the armed services knows what it's like to watch Act of Valor, a hard sell posing as a movie that preaches just how cool it is to be in the Navy SEALS.

But if your intention as a body of the armed services is to show potential enlistees all the excitement and tactical radness of blowing away brown people, then that whole campaign about "hearts and minds" was the exact kind of hogwash everyone saw through initially. The film's plot is somehow lazier, action movie-wise, than both Navy SEALS and Commando.

It all began when Bandito Brothers Productions were tasked with filming a promotional ad for U.S. Navy special boat teams and saw the potential of having access to the real equipment in an action film.

The Navy became aroused and demanded that SEALS participate. Unfortunately, trained seals have better acting skills.

The film makes the same mistake Clint Eastwood's 15:17 to Paris did, but where that film utilized unsuspecting heroes who were forced into the unthinkable, at least suggesting their reactions had a modicum of genuine emotion behind them, Act of Valor is all flexing muscles, all the time.

It's jingoistic, uncomfortable, poorly acted and its the kind of chest-beating America should probably table for now. The Navy has sanctioned this as a recruitment film, so it's fair game to criticize its technique.


5. The Mask Of Nippon

The Mask of Nippon
NFB

Let it never be said that Canadians can't be jerks, too.

We've all seen offensive wartime Bugs Bunny and Superman cartoon shorts that featured the leads humiliating some yellow-skinned cartoon of an Asian man, and we still kind of giggle at how silly it is, but the actual racism on display during World War II is often downplayed. Japenese internment is the kind of mortal sin the U.S. prefers not to address.

A such, Canada did their part to hate too, though the film did get some play in the U.S. The Mask of Nippon was produced by the National Film Board of Canada as a piece of blatant anti-Japanese propaganda. In it, Bonanza's Lorne Green narrates: "The soldiers of the rising sun are little men. Two-faced, with a modern and progressive surface thinly hiding their savage and barbaric double character.”

It goes on to inform viewers that Japenese citizens believe their Emporer is a literal God with supernatural abilities, pre-empting the release of countless B-Movies of the seventies and video games today.

This was, of course, an intentional misread of Japanese culture, as the reality is that even in feudal times, most of the citizenry was atheist. Their obedience was actually just a generational thing about respecting your elders.


4. Left Behind

Kirk Cameron in Left Behind: The Movie
Cloud Ten Pictures

Religion has often been considered one topic too controversial for the dinner table, but it's fair to say that Left Behind, the series of novels by Protestant Reverend Tim LaHaye and Larry B. Jenkins is... problematic. There's no shortage of critics targeting the franchise for its alleged anti-Catholic stance, among other prejudices it carries.

Even those supportive of the novels still tend to find problems with the violence in the books, seemingly glorifying war in rapture fiction.

That's right, for those who don't see movies in church basements, Left Behind is pure, unadulterated rapture fiction that preaches the dangers of leading a non-Protestant life. Such sins will lead to you being blackballed from Heaven, and being left on Earth to contend with the antichrist.

That antichrist, by the way, is the UN Secretary-General, just to give you a sense of where these novels stand politically.

Noted right-wing Christian and nightmare-to-work-with Kirk Cameron immediately signed on for the film version, hawking copies of it during his ministry. But the films, released as a trilogy, had the same distribution power of the Atlas Shrugged trilogy. Read: no one who wasn't already a convert saw it.

The same can be said of the remake, which managed to take advantage of a debt-ridden Nicolas Cage, but didn't sign up any new members.


3. Red Dawn

Red Dawn
MGM/United Artists

Just to give readers a sense of who John Milius is, he once asked and was granted his salary for the screenplay to Jeremiah Johnson (the hero cannibal) in antique guns. Or one could just revisit The Big Lebowski, as John Goodman's Walter Sobchak is a carbon copy of the man.

Milius has a rather stunning resume, with credits on the first two Dirty Harry films, Apocalypse Now and lastly, Red Dawn.

Originally, Red Dawn was meant to be a poignant anti-war statement, with a script more in line with The Lord of Flies. That all changed when Milus joined the project. It fit, he was a known fan of war movies and had already written one of the most iconic action heroes of the seventies.

They didn't realize what kind of beast they'd unchained. Milius didn't just love war movies, he loved war. MGM brought on former Nixon advisor Alexander Haig for credibility.

Milus rewrote the script with Haig, basing the hypothetical (but in Milius' mind imminent) Russian invasion on an old plan Hitler had drawn up. When he started wanting to add in futuristic weaponry, the Pentagon withdrew support.

The nostalgia for Red Dawn is largely based on its young cast, as there's little else redeemable unless you share a severely right-wing worldview. It's simply too bloody, vulgar and mean-spirited to actually be any fun.


2. Mission To Moscow

Mission to Moscow cast
Warner Bros. Pictures

It's difficult still to fully explain the way World War II impacted foreign relations worldwide without sounding like a textbook. Taking Woodrow Wilson's "history with lightning" approach literally, the films released during the war represent a time when the US was willing to slum it to bring down the Nazis - even siding with Russia. FDR and the Office of War Information needed a pitchman, and they had one in director Michael Curtiz.

Mission to Moscow is a fairly straight forward political memoir, chronicling Ambassador Joseph Davies' experiences meeting with Joesph Stalin and other Soviets. It was the first of many pro-Soviet films made during the war effort to help normalize communism to the American everyman. And the film makes no secret of its intentions, opening with the real Davies in an armchair addressing the audience.

"No leaders of a nation have been so misrepresented and misunderstood as those in the Soviet government during those critical years between the two world wars," he says, before disappearing to be played by Walter Huston.

Consider hearing those words spoken seriously by a politician today without a Senate commission formed.

Most reviews at the time were savage, though Bosley Crowther did find their attempts to rehabilitate Stalin perfectly fine. As a film, it's dry as a piece of legislation, but as a time capsule, it's like a glimpse into the multiverse.


1. The Many Trials Of Billy Jack

Tom Loughlin in Billy Jack
Warner Bros.

One would think blending the ways of a Native American Warrior with hardcore action hero philosophy would make for a suitably kick-ass picture, but so far we've only been given the worst of the two; first, with Billy Jack and later in the spectacularly failed career of Steven Seagal.

Like Seagal would do with On Deadly Ground, Tom Laughlin wrote and directed Billy Jack, basing the script off a character in his previous film The Born Losers. Loughlin had written Jack as a half-Native American Vietnam veteran and had been attempting to give him his own feature since 1954 with little interest.

Billy Jack managed to secure funding during the spate of revenge films such as Dirty Harry, Walking Tall and Death Wish, but it differed greatly from those films.

While ultimately being about Jack taking on the son of a crime boss who raped and murdered a Native American, the film is less focused on revenge and more on peaceful resolutions and preachy lectures. That the film's theme, "One Tin Soldier", survived for years on those Sounds of the seventies CDs advertised between Murder, She Wrote reruns says more about the film's tone than it should.

Jack managed to be a hit but was certainly a film of its time. Laughlin spent the rest of his life with the character, making four films, including the unbearably long Billy Jack Goes To Washington.

Laughlin would run for the White House twice. He died in 2013.


Watch Next


A Brutal Quiz Of Famous Quotes From War Movies

The Deer Hunter Wedding
United Artists

1. "You Have To Think About One Shot. One Shot Is What It's All About"

Contributor
Contributor

Kenny Hedges is carbon-based. So I suppose a simple top 5 in no order will do: Halloween, Crimes and Misdemeanors, L.A. Confidential, Billy Liar, Blow Out He has his own website - thefilmreal.com - and is always looking for new writers with differing views to broaden the discussion.