10 Films That Were Prosecuted For Obscenity

Horror doesn't get more scandalous than this.

When the first British video stores opened for business, the tapes they rented didn€™t fall under the jurisdiction of the British Board of Film Censors (BBFC), which meant that films the BBFC had denied a cinema certificate €“ such as The Texas Chain Saw Massacre - could be viewed at home. Moreover, the tapes usually sported sensational artwork, so if you were a child in the early 80s you could wander into a video store and gaze at a crude rendering of a native eating intestines (Cannibal Holocaust) or see a drill boring into a man€™s skull (The Driller Killer). It wasn€™t long before Mary Whitehouse, who had previously rallied against such TV shows as Benny Hill and Doctor Who, campaigned to ban such €œVideo Nasties.€ She had an ally in Conservative MP Graham Bright, who said in an on-camera interview, €œI believe there is research taking place and it will show that these films not only affect young people but I believe they affect dogs as well.€ Bright sponsored a Bill that amended the Obscene Publications Act of 1959 to include movies, and a list of 72 offending titles was drawn up by the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP), 39 of which were successfully prosecuted. Even though most of the films were chosen at random, anyone who owned or distributed them faced fines and imprisonment. As movie lists go, this one€™s more attractive than the AFI€™s Top 100.

10. The Last House On The Left (1972)

One of the most famous titles ever to be banned in the UK, The Last House On The Left owes its fame not just to its status as a Video Nasty but also its brilliant ad campaign (€œTo avoid fainting, keep repeating €˜It€™s only a movie€€™€) and director Wes Craven€™s determination to explore the dehumanizing nature of violence. Whether or not Last House is a very good examination of violence is a matter of opinion, but there€™s no denying its raw power, which proved both influential and divisive. Refused a certificate for theatrical release in 1974, the video was banned outright a decade later, and as late as 2002 the BBFC refused to pass the film uncut, despite critic Mark Kermode making a case for its importance. Perhaps not surprisingly, censors took issue with the humiliation and murder one of the lead characters, objections that were not waived until March 2008 €“ 36 years after the film was first shown.

9. Evilspeak (1981)

Clint €œBrother of Ron€ Howard plays Stanley Coopersmith, a bullied military cadet who discovers the diary of an excommunicated Spanish monk. Using his Apple PC to translate the diary, he unleashes a malevolent spirit that starts taking revenge on his enemies. Evilspeak is a very silly film, never more so than when a woman is attacked by killer boars while bathing. The BBFC were unimpressed and in March 1984 (the same month that Brother Ron€™s Splash was released in the US) the picture was banned as a Video Nasty. As well as the boar attack, the censors were concerned that the devouring of entrails, a neck snapping and the numerous decapitations would somehow deprave and corrupt the audience, so when the picture was re-released in 1987, it was with nearly 4 minutes of cuts. The film wasn€™t available again in its uncut form until 2004.

8. SS Experiment Camp (1976)

Few subgenres baited the censors as eagerly as Nazisploitation, and of all the films banned in the UK, few were more deserving than SS Experiment Camp. The video art, which showed a nude woman on a cross being leered over by a Nazi, left no doubt that this was not The Sound Of Music. Unlike the previous year€™s Ilsa: She Wolf Of The SS, however, the film has more on its mind than gratuitous female nudity. Seeking a new pair of testicles, a Commandant castrates one of his guards, which leads to an unintentionally funny moment when the guard says, €œYou bast**d, what have you done with my balls?€ The BBFC were unamused and banned the film, more for its artwork than its content, which they later described as mild and poorly executed. In fact, when the film was resubmitted with different artwork in 2005, it was passed uncut.

7. The Werewolf And The Yeti (1975)

Born Jacinto Molina Alvarez, Paul Naschy played every horror villain from Count Dracula to Dr Fu Manchu, but he was best known for playing Waldemar Daninsky (aka The Wolf Man) in a series of cheaply-made Spanish exploitation films. The Werewolf And The Yeti is the 8th of the 12 Daninsky films, and it€™s one of the most ludicrous, with Naschy captured (and used as a sex slave) by a pair of female vampires while searching for the Yeti in the Himalayas. When he attempts to escape, they bite him and transform him into El Hombre Lobo, setting up everything you could want from a Yeti vs werewolf movie. There€™s nudity, flagellation plus several torn out throats, and even though the climactic confrontation takes up about a minute of screen time, it was enough for the BBFC to ban the movie in 1984. The film has never been resubmitted for classification and so remains banned.

6. Axe (1974)

An inoffensive, unremarkable thriller about a young girl who murders the escaped convicts that€™ve invaded her home, Axe€™s successful prosecution for obscenity remains something of a mystery. The Evil Dead, with its eye gouging and dismemberment, escaped prosecution but Axe was banned and unavailable in its uncut form until 2005. Since most of the grisly violence in Frederick R Friedel€™s film is left offscreen, that might be due more to bad timing than anything else. Not only was the picture released in the same year as The Texas Chain Saw Massacre, it played under the title California Axe Massacre to cash-in on Tobe Hooper€™s film, and therefore may have become confused in the minds of censors. Hooper€™s movie was never listed as a Video Nasty, it was simply denied a BBFC certificate until 1999, initially because BBFC Secretary Stephen Murphy took issue with €œthe level of terrorisation€ in the film, then in later years because Murphy€™s replacement, James Ferman, considered the picture to be about €œthe pornography of terror.€ This had a strange knock-on effect: Hooper€™s later films Eaten Alive and The Funhouse found their way onto the Video Nasty list, as did The Driller Killer and The Toolbox Murders, whose titles also seemed to reference murder committed with household items.

5. Absurd (1981)

Working under dozens of aliases, Joe D€™Amato directed at least 200 films before his death in 1999, and the fact that two of his productions were prosecuted for obscenity comes as something of a surprise €“ none of his pictures are even remotely watchable. With Absurd, he hoped to build upon the success of his previous film, Anthropophagous: The Beast, where a cannibal killer stalked some characters that admired the scenery for 87 of the movie€™s 90 minutes. He also rips off John Carpenter€™s Halloween, pitting a babysitter and some imperilled children against an indestructible killer, but with more outrageous gore sequences. A nurse is killed by a screwdriver to the brain, an orderly has his head torn open by an industrial saw and a woman has her head rammed into a lit oven, all of which were enough to land the movie in the dock in 1984. More than 30 years later, the movie still has not been resubmitted to the BBFC.

4. Fight For Your Life (1977)

Fight For Your Life is an in-your-face home invasion movie, but with the typical racial roles reversed, with a well-to-do African-American family being taunted by a white trash gang leader. Judging from William Sanderson€™s performance in Blade Runner, you wouldn€™t expect him to play the racist villain, but he€™s plenty unhinged in the role, sweating and leering and even placing his gun to a baby€™s head when people don€™t take him seriously. If anything, his performance is probably too convincing €“ the movie was rejected for a UK theatrical release in 1981, more for the racial abuse on display than the explicit violence (though there€™s still plenty of that). It later appeared uncut on VHS, and was subsequently banned. If you have a copy in your attic, hold on to it €“ not only was the film never cleared by the UK censors, but the original negative was destroyed in 2012.

3. Snuff (1976)

Proving that you can fool some viewers some of the time and censors all of the time, Snuff purports to be an actual snuff film and despite some hysterically bad acting and effects, the film was banned in the UK in July 1983 and successfully prosecuted. In fact, the picture is nothing more than an unreleased clunker given a new ending and a savvy marketing campaign. Filmed on the cheap in the Philippines, Slaughter depicted the depredations of a Manson-like cult but when it failed to find national distribution it was acquired by distributor Allan Shackleton and retitled. After shooting an epilogue where Slaughter€™s lead actress is disembowelled by the film crew, Shackleton promoted Snuff as €œthe bloodiest thing that ever happened in front of a camera€ and hired bogus protestors to picket screenings of the movie. The ruse worked too well: he was later forced to produce his lead actress in court to prove she was still alive, and a legend was born.

2. The House By The Cemetery (1981)

To be prosecuted once for obscenity is bad enough, but (to paraphrase Oscar Wilde) twice is simply careless. Not content with declaring Zombie Flesh Eaters obscene, Britain€™s moral watchdogs also took issue with director Lucio Fulci€™s The House By The Cemetery, much to the puzzlement of the filmmaker€™s fans. Far more explicit than THBTC is City Of The Living Dead, which despite several gruesome sequences never even found its way onto the Video Nasty list. At no point in THBTC, for instance, does anyone throw up their own intestines, tear out a man€™s brains or thrust a drill through someone€™s cheek. Essentially an Old Dark House gothic tale, albeit one with gory set pieces, THBTC rubbed the censors up the wrong way with its shots of mutilated corpses and scenes where throats are ripped out, which were enough to get the picture banned. In 2001, the film was prosecuted for obscenity a second time following the discovery of bootleg copies of the uncut VHS, meaning that it wouldn€™t be until 2009 €“ nearly 30 years after it was first shown €“ that the film would be available in its uncut form.

1. Tenebrae (1982)

Tenebrae is Dario Argento at the top of his game: a demented giallo full of arresting camerawork (by Luciano Tovoli, who also shot The Passenger) with an equally memorable synth-heavy music score composed by several former members of Goblin. In order to keep it from corrupting British viewers, it was unavailable in its uncut form until 2003. In March 1984, the film was cited as one of the most offensive Video Nasties in the UK and subsequently banned. The major bone of contention was a 4-second shot where, after losing an arm to the killer€™s axe, a woman€™s bloody stump continues to spray crimson across her apartment. When the movie finally returned to British screens in its original form, it arrived on DVD just before the far more explicit Texas Chain Saw Massacre remake (which was backed by Michael Bay and New Line Cinema) played uncut in UK cinemas. But that€™s probably just a coincidence. Like this list? What's your favourite Video Nasty? Discuss all things gory and depraved down in the comments.

Contributor

Ian Watson is the author of 'Midnight Movie Madness', a 600+ page guide to "bad" movies from 'Reefer Madness' to 'Poultrygeist: Night of the Chicken Dead.'