10 Films With Glaring Historical Inaccuracies
Not all films are created equal. Some try to completely rewrite history.
Historical films are a staple of Hollywood, often drawing huge budgets and, more importantly, huge profits. Some films stay true to their time period and their characters, with films such as Lincoln or Agora providing exceptionally interesting stories with few real changes to the history.
Others, however, have no quandaries about changing dates, numbers, characters, and occasionally, history altogether. Whether it's confusing one person's story with that of another, or mixing up entire civilisations, Hollywood likes to play it fast and loose with what really happened.
Most of the time, directors will push these changes under the bracket of "artistic license," or try to argue that they're attempting to tell the story, not the facts. This is often because a director wants to spin a movie a particular way, ignore what really happened, or because they don't think it would make a good movie.
The problem with this is that more often than not, the facts turn out to be a far more interesting story than what audiences end up receiving. This usually results in a mix of authentic moments blended with complete fiction, leaving viewers walking away thinking everything they saw was completely true.
At least until they look it up on Wikipedia...
10. Apocalypto
Using the real ancient Mayan language might give Apocalypto a feel of authenticity, but this covers up the reality of its historical roots. Documenting the fall of the Mayan kingdom, Apocalypto's makeup and the weapons used were heavily researched from images on pottery, as with Jaguar Paw's wife, Seven, who has a tattoo of the Mayan number seven on her arm. But this is a Mel Gibson film, and he isn't going to let something like "facts" or "history" stand in the way of his film.
Apocalypto received a huge backlash for its portrayal of the Mayan people as primitive savages, living in the middle of an uncleared jungle. In reality, the Mayans were extremely advanced, and understood the nature of crop cycles. Similarly, stone-built settlements were incredibly common, but Apocalypto displays them as being rare and only mentioned in stories.
One of the most controversial point of Apocalypto, however, is the portrayal of human sacrifice. While it is accepted that there was some human sacrifice in the Mayan kingdom, it wasn't to the extent displayed in Apocalypto, and it didn't involve heart extraction.
More often, the Mayans performed their sacrafices via decapitation, or used non-lethal blood-letting. Mel Gibson seemed to be confusing the Mayans with the Aztecs, and it's not the only time he did this. The end of the film shows the Spanish conquistadors beginning to land on the beach. In 900AD. Six hundred years before that actually happened. To the Aztecs.
9. Mulan
Time to crush some childhoods.
Mulan is based on the story of Hua Mulan, a character in a sixth century Chinese poem. Mulan was considerably more badass than Disney made her out to be, having been taught how to fight long before she decided to join the Chinese army. She definitely didn't need a musical training montage to teach her how to fight.
Disney did get Mulan's tomboyishness correct, but she didn't leave in the dead of night. She told her parents she was leaving, and given her father was too old to fight, they thought it was the right thing to do. Also Mulan never had to go through a big gender reveal, then save the Chinese Emperor in order to prove herself. In reality, after twelve years of war, Mulan requested that she be permitted to return to her home, and it was only there that she unveiled herself as a woman.
At the end of her time with the military, Mulan's story splits, with one version seeing her happily married, but another version having her return to her family to find that her father had died, her mother had remarried, and Mulan herself was to be sent to Heshana Khan as a concubine. Refusing to become a sex slave, Mulan committed suicide, which wouldn't have suited a Disney ending.
Pixar maybe, but not Disney.
8. Gladiator
Artistic license is fine, but Gladiator completely rewrites history. Here, Russell Crowe stars as a Roman general who, having been betrayed by the new Emperor Commodus, is forced to fight as a gladiator in the arena. Eventually, Crowe makes his way to the Colosseum, and kills Commodus in single combat.
Suffice to say, the plot is completely fictional, but many of the characters are real. Emperor Marcus Aurelius, the father of Commodus, wasn't killed by his son, with whom he had actually jointly ruled for several years. Instead, Marcus Aurelius died of disease (most likely chickenpox), leaving the Roman Empire to Commodus, and harboured no desires to return to the days of the Roman Republic.
There is little documentation of Commodus' rule, although it is correctly shown in the film that he had little interest in managerial affairs, and he enjoyed fighting fixed battles as a gladiator, often battling against poorly-equipped opponents with little skill. However, Commodus' real death came about at the hands of his mistress.
After she discovered her name was on a list of people to be executed she, along with the others on the list, plotted the assassination of Commodus. After a failed attempt to poison the Emperor, his wrestling partner was paid to strangle him in a bath.
But it didn't all end badly for Commodus. In 195, the reigning Emperor had the Roman Senate deify Commodus in an attempt to gain favour with his descendants.
7. Pocahontas
Crushing dreams in Mulan wasn't enough, so here's another childhood film to ruin.
Pocahontas follows the titular character as the Native Americans are brought into contact with the British Empire, particularly the explorer John Smith. Both were real people, and the film does follow some of Smith's account of what happened. After landing in Virginia, he led the British expedition and found himself captured by the Powhatans and taken to their chief at Werewocomoco.
This is when things get a little shaky.
The film's portrayal of Pocahontas throwing herself across John Smith before he is executed is sort of true. At least, it's true that John Smith wrote that it happened that way, but this has been largely dismissed as embellishment, as Smith's first actual recording of meeting Pocahontas occurred ten years later.
One of the biggest issues is the portrayal of Pocahontas herself. John Smith landed in Virginia in 1606, when Pocahontas was only ten years old. She definitely wasn't in any position to be having relationships with men almost three times her age. The ending is made a bit more Disney-friendly. The real Pocahontas was married off, renamed Rebecca, and converted to Christianity before dying at the age of 22.
It's not hard to see why they didn't finish a film for children with that.
6. Argo
Following the thrilling account of refugees from the US embassy in Tehran as they - with the help of the CIA - escaped from revolutionary Iran under the guise of a film crew. The real Argo was considerably less exciting, and a lot more Canadian.
In a CNN interview, former US president Jimmy Carter stated that, in contrast to the glorified portrayal of the CIA, "90% of the contributions to the ideas and the plan were Canadian.” In fact, the Canadian involvement was such that the entire event was named "the Canadian Caper."
Additionally, Argo changed the actions of other embassies, or outright ignored them, particularly the British and New Zealanders. The British embassy did not, as was portrayed in Argo, turn away the refugees. Instead, the British temporarily hosted them at great risk to themselves, only transferring the fugitives to the Canadians because mobs were threatening the British embassy itself. The New Zealand embassy offered to take in the fugitives should they ever need to escape from the Canadian embassy.
Argo gets most of the plan itself correct. Ben Affleck's character, Tony Mendez, was the focal point of the CIA operation to extract the fugitives, using an elaborate backstory of a film production. An office was established in Hollywood, and advertisements for Argo were placed in newspapers (one of which was carried by one of the fugitives as part of her cover). But that's about the extent of the film's accuracy.
And in contrast with the incredible, tense finale, the fugitives easily made their way through Tehran's Mehrabad International Airport, and escaped to Switzerland.
5. 1492: Conquest Of Paradise
Oh look, it's Ridley Scott again, and this time he's back to try and cover up a man that would be a war criminal in the modern day.
Following the exploits of Christopher Columbus as he attempts to discover Asia, Conquest of Paradise decided not to follow the real story of one of the most terrible human beings in history. Instead, the film was based on outdated misconceptions and outright lies, romanticising Columbus' expedition.
Let's get something out of the way first: Christopher Columbus didn't prove that the world was round. That had already been discovered by Eratosthenes of Cyrene over 1500 years before Columbus was even born. Eratosthenes also correctly worked out that the world had a circumference of 40,000 miles. Ridley Scott's attempt to portray Columbus as a man ahead of his time is completely false, and most of his assertions (such as believing that Asia was three thousand miles away from Spain) were based on shoddy mathematics.
The worst part of the film is when it gets to America. Unlike the in the film, the real Christopher Columbus had no respect for the Native Americans. He believed that he could use the innocence of the indigenous peoples in order to subjugate them, which he promptly did after discovering there was no gold.
Conquest of Paradise also takes a completely reversed view of Columbus when it comes to his brutality to the Native Americans, and passes these off to other film characters, such as cutting off hands for stealing (a practice Columbus introduced).
4. Kingdom Of Heaven
From the beginning, Kingdom of Heaven ignores its historical roots in the period around the Second Crusade. Orlando Bloom plays Balian of Ibelin, a blacksmith from France who joined his estranged father as he journeyed to the Holy Land, eventually fighting the Muslim leader, Saladin, to a stalemate at the walls of Jerusalem. Except... nope, that's not what happened at all.
Balian of Ibelin was born to a knight in the Crusader-held county of Jaffa, not in France, but he's not the only one that suffered extensive fictionalisation. Patriarch Heraclius of Jerusalem, who appears in the film only to propose converting to Islam to survive the siege of the Holy City, was the main proponent of surrendering the city to avoid this outcome. He personally paid for the ransom of 19,000 of the poorest citizens of Jerusalem.
One of the characters that wasn't completely fictionalised was Reynald de Chatillon, who was by all accounts not a particularly nice person. Fond of torturing priests, raiding the coast of Muslim-held land, and probably littering, Brendan Gleeson's character was one of the few that didn't undergo an enormous change from history to the screen, although he never beheaded Saladin's sister.
3. The Last Samurai
Telling the bloody story of the Satsuma Rebellion, a samurai uprising against Japan's transformation from feudal society to an industrial powerhouse, The Last Samurai presents a more romanticised version of how events played out.
The film likely means well by trying to show what was lost in the fall of the samurai, and Tom Cruise actually plays a rather compelling character, but nonetheless, it portrays a romantic view of the rebellion that could only be seen from an outsider's point of view. This can be forgiven to some extent, as the film is told entirely from the perspective of a captured American soldier.
The samurai rebellion was centred around the loss of status and influence with the Japanese Emperor, after the United States forcibly opened up the country to industrialisation at the point of a large number of very big cannons. This broke the military dictatorship of the Shogun, who had enforced a period of complete isolation across Japan. As Japan became more westernised, the country underwent a monumental shift to accommodate a new industrial middle class, which made the samurai a bit miffed when they saw all their money drifting away.
As is seen in the film, Japan's new army thoroughly crushed the Satsuma Rebellion in spite of fierce resistance, and the final, doomed charge of the samurai (with Tom Cruise in tow) does have a historical basis. However, by that point in the battle, the leader of the rebellion had committed suicide in order to avoid being captured.
2. Braveheart
Mel Gibson's back with a vengeance, this time in a film famed for its failure to correctly portray the Scottish Wars of Independence. There are some things that are historically accurate: William Wallace was Scottish (glad he didn't screw that one up); Edward I of England ruled Scotland through a puppet after the death of the last king, Alexander III; Wallace led a rebellion to regain independence from Scotland. That's everything that the film gets right.
Braveheart kicks things off badly, getting the dates wrong from the start. The film begins in 1280, six years before Alexander III died. Seriously, how do you get that wrong?
The film even gets Wallace's background wrong. The part where his wife is killed? Yeah, that didn't happen either, as Wallace was never recorded as having a wife. Wallace actually rebelled when the English attempted to confiscate his family lands.
It's difficult to work out which battle Mel Gibson thought he was in when he gave his uplifting speech, but it certainly wasn't the Battle of Stirling Bridge. The Scots won the battle not by believing in freedom, but by ambushing the English army as it crossed the bridge. They didn't just run at them across an open field, which would have been utter madness.
Finally, the horrific death scene at the end of the film was actually toned down. In real life, William Wallace was dragged naked through the streets and castrated before any of the disembowelling occurred. There's no way he was screaming "Freedom" after that.
1. 300
300 gets a bad rap for its portrayal of the Battle of Thermopylae, but there are a couple of things to remember during this: firstly, it was originally based on the Frank Miller graphic novel, not the actual history; secondly, the entire film is being told by Dilios, an unreliable narrator, who no doubt takes some liberties with the numbers and facts of what went on.
The film does get some of the history correct. Persia did invade Greece under Xerxes with a massive army (around 300,000), and they were met by King Leonidas and his three hundred Spartans at Thermopylae, alongside some of their allies. Meanwhile, the rest of the Spartan army stayed behind to celebrate the Carnea, a festival during which they refused to fight.
The Spartans and their allies were only defeated after they were betrayed by Ephialtes, although Dilios added that he looked like Quasimodo from the Hunchback of Notre-Dame.
300 takes some license with the facts when it comes to the battle itself, namely that the Spartans were not on their own at Thermopylae. They led a fairly sizeable coalition of Greek states, including Corinthians, Athenians, Phocians, and Thespians. Almost all of the Greek city-states had refused to bow down to Xerxes, although only the Spartans threw the messenger down a well.
The ending, showing the Spartans leading the Greek army at the Battle of Platea is similarly correct, and Dilios' real-life counterpart went on to die heroically, regaining the honour he lost by returning from Thermopylae.