10 Films With Multiple Different Cuts

Why couldn't they leave Blade Runner how it was!?

Blade Runner Darly Hannah
Warner Bros.

The great Alfred Hitchcock once said, “The length of a film should be directly related to the endurance of the human bladder”. A quote that has long lived in infamy and while directors like Quentin Tarantino laugh in the face of that quote with the 70mm snow porn that was The Hateful Eight, more and more studio executives are starting to realise this and it's become the norm for films to have their length trimmed a bit.

While this sort of dilligence does a great job of keeping audiences engaged, it doesn't necessarily help the medium itself. Films see entire subplots taken away and some even seen a whole character removed from the film for the sake of time.

But at least it means we can sometimes get different cuts of movies to contrast the different visions.

Plenty of directors accept heavy edits as a part of the business and a part of life, and others actively encourage cutting their masterpieces down, whereas as others take out full newspaper adverts to complain about it (more on that later)...

10. Brazil

Brazil Terry Gilliam
Universal Pictures

A showdown for the ages! In one corner, we have a power-hungry movie studio hellbent on adding a totally out-of-place happy ending for absolutely no reason at all and in the other corner, we have a director willing to fight tooth and nail for the right to cut the film his way, who will win!?

Such is the history of the battle for the final cut of 1985's Brazil that it's been parodied and referenced every time there's a battle for autonomy over a film's cut.

Brazil was released without complaint originally, however, the distributor eventually took issue with the somewhat bleak ending and insisted on re-editing it, something that the film's director Terry Gilliam vehemently opposed.

Gilliam was insistent that the film not be changed and resorted to a number of stunts, ranging from hiding in the editing room with the door locked so no one could take the film print away, all the way through to taking out a full-page advertisement in Variety to protest the changes!

Eventually, after the film's success at the Los Angeles Film Critics Association, Universal relented and reluctantly released a modified 132-minute version supervised by Gilliam, in 1985.

Brazil remains a classic and one of Gilliam's greatest films, but the battle of final cut was a bloody one and one that probably meant he was off the studio's Christmas card list.


9. Once Upon A Time In America

Once Upon A Time In America Robert De Niro
Warner Bros.

Once Upon a Time in America tells the story of the lives of best friends David "Noodles" Aaronson and Max Bercovicz as they lead a group of Jewish ghetto kids who rise up against the odds to become Jewish gangsters in New York City's world of organised crime.

It was Leone's last film before his untimely death aged 60, but the film completed his final entry in the Once Upon a Time Trilogy, following 1968's Once Upon a Time in the West and 1971's Duck, You Sucker!

Coming in at a whopping 229 minutes, Once Upon a Time in America had to be trimmed for audiences. Leone reportedly shot over ten hours worth of footage, which in turn was only trimmed down to 6 hours and Leone's idea of releasing the film in two parts was ultimately abandoned.

Leone's first cut of the film ran at 269 minutes (4-and-a-half-hours), which had to be cut down for its premiere at the 1984 Cannes Film Festival, and this was the version that was shown in Europe. However, the American wide release was again edited even further to a still very long 139 minutes (2 hours and 19 minutes) by the studio, which angered Leone and is part of the reason that he disliked the film so much.

However, in 2011, Leone's children supervised a restored version of the film, the original 269-minute version at a lab in Italy, although the film ran into rights issues, for which, veteran film director Martin Scorsese had to step in and help with.


8. Terminator 2: Judgement Day

Terminator 2: Judgement Day Nuclear Nuke scene
Paramount Pictures

The Terminator films have faced their fair share of criticisms over the years, whether that be through the breaking of their own rules and failing to comply with their own logic or because Terminator Genisys was a thing that was allowed to happen unironically, there was a time when the Terminator films were pretty darn impressive.

When Terminator 2: Judgment Day dropped in 1991, the critics lapped it up, praising the sequels ingenuity and the brilliant performances from Arnold Schwarzenegger, Linda Hamilton, Robert Patrick, and Edward Furlong, as well as the fantastic use of CGI.

Over the years, the Terminator films have received modest modifications here and there, a remastering of the soundtrack and a quick little polish of the special effects here and there, have been welcomed by fans (unlike certain other Sci-Fi films), however, in 2015 the fans received a different treat, in the form of the Extended Edition.

While the Extended Edition featured a number of re-added deleted scenes, the Extended Edition also features an alternate ending, which shows an elderly Sarah Connor watching an adult John Connor, (now a U.S. Senator), playing with his daughter in a playground in 2029, telling the audience that Judgment Day never happened.

While the film doesn't really mess with the tone too much, most fans tend to prefer the original cut, as not only are they used to it, but the new scenes don't really add too much by way of narrative, especially since the alternate ending isn't considered canon in the Terminator world. While it certainly adds some context to scenes, its really just something that adds to the Terminator lore, but it's definitely worth a watch and you'd be a fool not to!


7. The Lord Of The Rings Trilogy

The Lord Of The Rings Return Of The King
New Line Cinema

Peter Jackson's large, sprawling epic sweeping across three excellent films that pretty much-redefined cinema for a while, nerds everywhere rejoiced the joyous news that Peter Jackson had even longer instalments of his hugely popular franchise in store.

While many of the additions to the film seem to be revolved around extending scenes or adding in small portions here or there, the films do still receive what are known as "Fan Credits" as a small thanks to those who helped out and who had paid to be on there.

The Fellowship of the Ring added in 30 minutes of extras to take the run time up to a whopping 208 minutes. The Two Towers added 44 minutes and The Return of the King added 51 minutes.

The Two Tower's addition of a flashback scene between Boromir (Sean Bean) and Faramir (David Wenham) is a standout and one that has many fans talking and wondering why it wasn't in the original, while The Return of the King sees some truly epic battles expanded upon even more.

What's great about the Lord of the Rings Trilogy is that the pacing remains the same and the inclusions of these scenes don't feel too out of place. Here we can see everything as Peter Jackson had intended and can even see some more of the epic world JRR Tolkien created.

And hey, who needs another excuse to revisit Middle Earth?


6. Batman Vs. Superman: Dawn Of Justice

batman vs superman poster
Warner Bros.

While it certainly divided fans on its release and was pretty much universally panned by the critics, it's fair to say that DC didn't really give Zack Snyder a fair crack at the whip for Batman vs. Superman.

While the theatrical cut can still be bought today, it's often released alongside what is dubbed the Ultimate Edition. While Dawn of Justice received a PG-13 rating in the States, the extended version was given an R-Rating, something fairly rare for comic book movies.

Though the cut isn't much longer, it still adds a little more context to certain scenes, characters and motivations, with its extra 31 minutes of footage.

In fact, upon its release, many critics felt that the Ultimate Edition would have probably resulted in a much better-received film, rather than the panning it got upon release.

With the Ultimate Edition we see the addition of the fantastic Jena Malone in the role of Jenet Klyburn, a small role, but an important one nevertheless, as she runs the analysis on a mysterious bullet that Lois Lane had found, something that was left out of the original.

There is also a little more context as to why Clark Kent was so fascinated with Gotham City as well. While these changes still don't really save the movie, it does make it a little easier to follow and does provide some much-needed subtext and context to a very muddled film.

There is reportedly also a Director's Cut for Suicide Squad available as well, but let's hope that DC just sits on that one.


5. Superman II

Superman II
Warner Bros.

While Superman II was released to widescale acclaim, there was still a feeling of "what if?" among fans, who wondered what the film would have looked like if Richard Donner had been allowed to stay on the project and realise his full ideas and not been sacked midway through production.

While the story of how Richard Donner was replaced is a long and confusing story that spans many different people and changes with every person who talks about it, fans were eventually given their wish to realise Donner's full film in 2006.

While veteran actor Marlon Brando had been originally cast in the film he was eventually cut owing to a disagreement with the film's producers, however, Donner's cut included all of Brando's footage, long thought to be lost.

The difference between this and the original is very different from the Director's Cuts you usually see. This Director's Cut turned the film into an almost totally different movie! The Director's Cut features the original opening and the original ending, alternate takes and scenes from alternate camera angles, and deleted scenes featuring Marlon Brando.

The re-release saw huge critical appraisal, seeing the somewhat campy stylings of the original replaced with far grittier and more mature scenes, which were praised highly.

It's rare to see a film that has a Director's Cut so well thought of as well as the original, but audiences were treated to two great films by two great directors and we had a blast with both!


4. Star Wars: The Whole Series

Star Wars Anakin Force Ghost
Lucasfilm

Why George, why!?

George Lucas has earned something of a reputation over the years of failing to adhere to the classic phrase "Let sleeping dogs lie". What started off as a couple of special effects tweaking here and a little airbrushing there, turned into a full-on revamp of the films that basically no longer reflects the charming special effects-driven behemoths that ruled the '70s and '80s.

While some small changes have felt understandable, changes such as making Greedo shoot first and adding in the Cringe-Coma-inducing "Jedi Rocks!" scene has angered the fanbase a lot.

However, possibly the most egregious change that Lucas made to the films was the addition of Hayden Christensen as Anakin Skywalker in Return of the Jedi. Christensen's performance has already been the subject of multiple think pieces and the stuff of real Star Wars hatred, so adding him in as Anakin's force ghost at the end of Return of the Jedi was about as welcome as lube at a funeral.

While the changes have certainly shown that Lucas knows what he's doing with special effects, many have argued that it's stripped away all the groundwork that Star Wars laid years ago with regards to practical effects.

They might not be Director's Cuts in the same way as others on this list, but the different versions of scenes that have come out and the constant chopping and changing were insufferable.


3. Apocalypse Now

apocalypse now
United Artists

The story of the making of Apocalypse Now is as legendary as the film itself.

When Martin Sheen wasn't having a heart attack, when natural disasters weren't ruining whole sets or Marlon Brando wasn't turning up overweight, underrehearsed and fighting with Dennis Hopper or the budget was getting bigger by the second, but somehow Francis Ford Coppola was able to deliver Apocalypse Now nearly a whopping two years behind schedule!

While there's a truly great documentary about the making of Apocalypse Now, Hearts of Darkness: A Filmmaker's Apocalypse (which also inspired a hilarious episode of Community), the main thing that comes out from Apocalypse Now, was the full, extended cut of the film - Apocalypse Now: Redux.

The new film adds 49 extra minutes of material onto the original and contains several alterations and two entirely new scenes! One, has Willard's boat meeting the Playmates again, further up the river; the other has them meet a family of holdout French colonists on their remote rubber plantation.

While Redux is revered as a great piece of filmmaking, it's probably one of the few examples where a film does sort of ruin the foundations a little bit. The film drags on a lot, the scenes just add a bit of unneeded context and break up the narrative and slows the pace of the film down to a long, slow slog.

It's worth it, just for a bit of cinematic history, but Redux probably won't be knocking the original of its perch anytime soon.


2. Touch Of Evil

Touch of Evil Orson Welles
Universal International

Widely regarded as one of the greatest film noirs ever made, Touch of Evil has endured some of the worst production releases in history.

When seeing the finished film Orson Welles saw to his horror that his film had been cut-to-pieces like a breadstick at a picnic by the studio. So as to try and regain some artistic control, Welles wrote a 58-page memo, detailing how the film should be recut and put together.

The 1958 cut of the film featured scenes that weren't even directed by Welles! While there are conflicting tales as to who did what, it's largely thought that Welles was not aware that these scenes had been filmed, meanwhile, Universal claim that the director refused to comply with the reshoots and simply rejected the chance to direct them.

The studio subsequently ignored his memo and released the film as they liked it.

While there is a 1976 version of the film, this isn't really so much a cut of the film, so much as a preview version that was never authorised by director or studio and featured mainly footage that was ultimately left on the cutting room floor in the 1958 cut.

Then, finally, in 1998, Walter Murch and Rick Schmidlin decided to recut the film using Welles' memo. Since the original rough cut of the film cannot be found anywhere, a tue Director's Cut is unlikely, but this is as close to the memo that Welles ordered that they could make.

Touch of Evil is a classic film and is home to one of the most breathtaking long takes in cinema history and an undeniable classic in the filmography of a near unparalleled genius.


1. Blade Runner

Blade Runner
Warner Bros. Pictures

At the last count, Blade Runner has nearly seven different cuts of the film, a feat that few other films will ever reach.

Blade Runner's ending was one that the studio disliked. The fact that Rick Deckard and Rachel's stories weren't properly resolved, their want for a totally unnecessary voice-over narration by Harrison Ford and the open-ended and somewhat bleak ending to the film meant that the studio had Scott direct a "happy ending" and add the narration in, much to the director's chagrin, meant having to tap Stanley Kubrick up to incorporate unused footage from The Shining!

The narration, in particular, has annoyed Scott and Ford over the years, both of whom cited its unnecessary place in the film, the fact that it ruined the mystique of the film, explained too much for the audience and just how poor the writing itself was, meant that it was the first thing to go in the later cuts.

While Scott eventually saw his own release of the film titled - Blade Runner: The Director's Cut, hit screens in 1992. This was certainly a lot better than the original cut, however, the film still did not fully meet the director's standards.

Thus lead to Blade Runner: The Final Cut. This seemed to satisfy Scott as he had total freedom over the project. In this cut, we have more of an idea of the main mystery of the film and a bit more fuel to the argument fire of "Is Deckard a replicant or not?", something that both actor and director have disagreed upon for decades.

Two things are for certain with The Final Cut, Ridley Scott is probably happy to see the back of it, and it lead to an absolutely fantastic sequel in Blade Runner 2049, so let's hope there are no more versions of that one!


In this post: 
Blade Runner
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Ben Maples hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.