10 Forgotten Horror Movie Scream Queens
Underrated horror movie scream queens! From Katie Cassidy to Betsy Russell & more!
When one hears the term "Scream Queen," it is inevitable that a single name pops into your head. Jamie Lee Curtis was the first actress to be given this moniker in the early 1980s after following up her breakout role in Halloween with a series of similar slasher films.
Since then she has become known as the "definitive" scream queen and proudly owns that title, however a number of equally high-profile actresses have also garnered the title after appearing in a string of scary movies.
That said, for every Jamie Lee Curtis, Neve Campbell or Sarah Michelle Gellar that gets noticed, there are others of the same or greater stature that don't get the recognition they deserve. One of the downsides of the horror genre being SO vast is that a lot of very fine work goes unnoticed.
With the same names mentioned constantly, to a casual fan it would seem that the genre doesn't offer a lot of variety in terms of its "name" stars. So, let's celebrate some lesser appreciated actresses that gave their all to an impressive number of genre roles. Here are 10 Unappreciated Horror Movie Scream Queens.
10. Katharine Isabelle
Katherine Isabelle started her genre career with a bang when she landed the role of Ginger Fitzgerald in Ginger Snaps. This cult favorite ingeniously frames a young woman's transformation into a werewolf around her struggles with puberty.
Receiving acclaim for her sinister slide into lycanthropy, genre roles came Isabelle's way quickly. A serious turn in the Stephen King-penned Insomnia soon followed and she showed great versatility by then playing Gibb, the horny best friend in 2003's Freddy Vs. Jason.
Isabelle also committed to returning for both Ginger Snaps sequels. Soon after, with a tally of 5 horror films, Isabelle swapped up her career, choosing to focus on television and light comedy.
The 2010s saw Isabelle revive her genre career when she played the title role in The Soska Sisters body horror flick American Mary. This dark and twisted tale tells of a young woman using body modification surgery to avenge her brutal rape. The Soska Sisters re-teamed with Isabelle for 2014's See No Evil 2.
Away from film, Katherine has also dabbled in horror television projects, with a recurring role as Margot Verger in Hannibal, and a two season run on Netflix's The Order.
These recent parts show a woman expanding within in the genre to tackle more mature roles, and tell us that Katherine Isabelle isn't hanging up her Scream Queen crown any time soon.
9. Betsy Russell
Betsy Russell was well on her way to becoming an eighties teen idol with roles in films like Private School, Avenging Angel and Tomboy. However by taking on the lead in 1989's slasher cheese-fest Cheerleader Camp, she began a path to becoming a very different kind of icon.
Russell would make another genre appearance in 1991's schlocky and confused Camp Fear. Following this her acting career quieted as she concentrated on raising her children.
It was Russell's engagement to Saw franchise producer Mark Burg that saw her career roar back to life. Sensing a fun tie-in to her early genre days, Burg cast Russell in a brief cameo role as Jigsaw's wife Jill in 2006's Saw III.
Although their engagement didn't last, Russell found herself given plum roles in the following 4 sequels as her character expanded. Here she exhibited an emotional rawness and a calculating villainous way that quickly made Jill Tuck a fan favorite.
Outside of the franchise, Russell accepted roles in other genre projects, including 2010's Chain Letter and 2014's My Trip Back From the Darkside. This brings her horror film tally to an impressive 8.
Although Betsy appears to have stepped away from the genre for the time being, preferring to concentrate on being a Life Coach, we do hope she can be lured back to add to her impressive repertoire.
8. Joan Collins DBE
I know what you're thinking, how can one even consider a British DAME a Scream Queen?!
Well, these aren't my words - they come from the legendary Dame herself. In a 2010 interview with Piers Morgan, Collins described herself during the 70's as "the queen of bad horror films!"
From the years 1970 to 1977 Dame Joan Collins appeared in 7 horror films, but of course, whether they are "bad" or not is a matter of opinion.
Most of these movies are light, campy affairs that are good for a one time watch. It always raises a chuckle seeing Collins fight off paper-mashe creatures in 1977's Empire of the Ants or become murderously jealous of a tree in 1973's Tales That Witness Madness.
However, some of these parts gave Collins a real chance to shine as an actress, chief among them her nail-bitingly tense segment in 1972's Tales From the Crypt. Here, Joan plays a woman trapped inside by a homicidal Santa, but unable to call for help as she has just murdered her husband.
Collins shines as the cold-hearted vixen, but also sells her fear so well that we genuinely don't want to see any harm come to her. One can only wish this 15 minute piece was a full movie.
No matter what she's doing, in each of her numerous horror roles, Collins gives her all and more than earns a spot on this list.
7. Katie Cassidy
Beginning in 2006, Katie Cassidy found turns in the Black Christmas and When a Stranger Calls remakes. The latter was quickly forgotten as generic fluff, however Katie's performance as the best friend seeking forgiveness was singled out for praise.
Fans were much more receptive to her turn as final girl Kelly in Black Xmas. There, Cassidy embodied the likeable naive college girl perfectly and earned her final girl stripes with some ballsy fighting back. Although derided at the time, Black Xmas has since garnered a reputation as a seasonal favorite.
Next, Cassidy would be criminally underused in the criminally bad 2010 remake of A Nightmare on Elm Street. Set up as the final girl, series fans familiar with her character know her time is limited. Upon her swift death, the movie is passed over to Rooney Mara's perpetually bored Nancy, making us long for Katie to return.
Cassidy's final horror film appearance to date was 2014's Wolves At the Door, a graphic re-telling of the infamous Manson family murders. Despite its 0% rating on Rotten Tomatoes, it's undeniable that Cassidy shines as an actress here. At times it is eerie just how much she resembles the late Sharon Tate.
For fans of small screen horror, Cassidy can also be seen in a recurring role on Season 3 of Supernatural. Please, somebody just put her in a movie that does her talent justice!
6. Barbara Crampton
Anyone that's seen Barbara Crampton's turn in 1985's Re-Animator know's that a certain scene with a severed head ensured she would never be forgotten by genre fans.
Evidently, Crampton herself thought this too, and through the 1980s she rode the wave of cheesy and gross-out horror to make a name for herself.
Becoming a protege of director Stuart Gordon, Barbara would work with him again on the wonderfully gory From Beyond and the sadly forgotten Castle Freak.
Away from her work as member of Gordon's "gore stable," Crampton starred in the 1986 oddball sci-fi/slasher Chopping Mall. Barbara sports a gloriously eighties look as she whines and shudders her way through the movie.
Stepping back from horror cinema, Crampton spent most of the nineties appearing in a staggering 390 episodes of daytime soap opera The Young and The Restless, ensuring she remained familiar to audiences.
In her first genre role in 14 years, Barbara returned to horror with a small part in Rob Zombie's divisive The Lords of Salem in 2011. However she was propelled back into the mainstream with a supporting role in Adam Wingard's surprise blockbuster You're Next.
Since then, Crampton has continued to ride the wave of horror recognition, with a starring turn in 2015's We Are Still Here and countless indie projects, taking her horror movie tally into double digits.
5. Joan Crawford
Although she was a Hollywood legend, Academy Award winner Joan Crawford relied on quick cash from horror films by the end of her career.
Beginning with the release of 1962's Whatever Happened to Baby Jane? Crawford found herself trapped in a niche she couldn't escape. Audiences adored her "woman in peril" sagas, resulting in offers to star in horror pictures.
From 1964 until her career's finale in 1977, Crawford appeared in an additional 4 horror films. These include two William Castle produced thrillers, Strait-Jacket and I Saw What You Did, which have since found renewed popularity due the company Scream Factory.
Away from Hollywood, Crawford also made two British genre pictures. 1967's surprisingly charming proto-slasher Berserk teams her with England's "Marilyn Monroe" Diana Dors. However, 1970's Trog was sadly a very cheap, schlocky end to a glittering screen career.
Away from the big screen, Crawford's final television appearances were also horror-based. In 1969 she starred in an episode of The Night Gallery where she was directed by a nobody named Steven Spielberg - have you heard of him?
Completing her horror catalog would be her final role in the supernatural anthology series The Sixth Sense in the unfortunately titled episode "Dear Joan, We're Going to Scare You to Death!"
In the decades since the term has been coined, Joan Crawford has been embraced and posthumously given a Scream Queen crown.
4. Adrienne Barbeau
This lucky lady has made 3 films with then-husband John Carpenter, as well as starring for Wes Craven, George Romero and Dario Argento.
Beginning with 1978's made-for-TV masterpiece Someone's Watching Me! Barbeau began a new path that endeared her forever to a whole new audience. This movie was quickly followed by a starring turn in Carpenter's The Fog wherein she enticed us with her smoky radio voice and fought some worm-faced specters.
1982 saw Barbeau toil in the Louisiana swamps in Wes Craven's cult comic adaption Swamp Thing. That same year George Romero cast her in the Creepshow segment "The Crate." Barbeau hams it up as a drunkard wife who pushes her husband to his limit and is fed to "Fluffy" the gorilla-creature.
Open House came in 1986, with Barbeau taking on the "final girl" role in the low budget slasher. The actress has never spoken of this project except to say "I had bills to pay."
She rounded out the decade with a turn in the 1990 Italian anthology Two Evil Eyes. Directed by Romero and Dario Argento, Barbeau plays a counterpoint to her Creepshow role as a woman that murders her wealthy husband.
In more recent years Adrienne has continued to make guest appearances capitalizing on her horror caliber. She narrated 2017's Tales of Halloween and had a guest spot opposite Tobin Bell in the 2019 revamp of Creepshow. However we'd love to see her take the lead once more!
3. Linda Blair
Although primarily known for starring in The Exorcist, Linda Blair continued working in the realm of horror long after that breakout role. With over 10 genre appearances to her name, she evolved from playing innocent victims to a proper established Scream Queen.
In 1978, Blair's first job after her career was derailed by a narcotics arrest was the television movie Summer of Fear. Here she is directed by the legendary Wes Craven and plays a teen struggling to convince her family that their lodger is in fact a witch.
No longer being offered plum roles, Blair became somewhat of a B-movie star after this. 1981's Hell Night is a delightfully Gothic slasher wherein Blair finds herself the final girl pursued around a rambling old mansion. From the producers of Halloween, this classy flick is among the best the 80s has to offer.
1984's Savage Streets sees her don a leather catsuit and take bloody revenge on the men that raped her sister, and the actress delights in a more sinister turn. So much so we can forgive her for hamming it up slightly.
Although her roles through the nineties were less notable, of course we can't forget her self-deprecating turn in 1993's Repossessed and her cameo in 1996's Scream.
Speaking of epic cameos, Blair's last piece of genre work came in 2006 with guest role on Supernatural with Jensen Ackles mentioning his peculiar craving for pea soup after meeting Blair.
Given her legacy, we'd love to see this underrated Scream Queen return in a big way.
2. Bette Davis
Did you know that Hollywood legend Bette Davis has starred in more horror films than reigning queen Jamie Lee Curtis? I kid you not, folks.
Falling into a similar career pattern to co-star Joan Crawford, Davis had more luck with the genre after receiving an Oscar nod for Whatever Happened to Baby Jane. She chose to capitalize on this by appearing in a series of similar chilling thrillers wherein she often played the villain.
Whereas Crawford took her roles out of necessity, Davis was careful to choose "character" parts that appealed to her. These included spellbinding performances in 1964's Hush... Hush, Sweet Charlotte; 1964's Dead Ringer and a truly chilling turn in 1965's The Nanny.
Other big screen genre roles included 1976's Burnt Offerings and two horror-lite projects for Disney with 1978's Return From Witch Mountain and 1982's Watcher in the Woods.
Away from the big-screen Davis also embraced the popular seventies trend of made-for-TV horror movies of the week. 1973's Scream Pretty Peggy starred Davis as a matriarch convinced her sanity was targeted by money hungry family.
It would be due to television that Davis' impressive body of genre work would earn a reappraisal. Much like how Crawford's late-career turns were eventually reconisdered, the FX drama Feud brought renewed attention to her later work. Again it becomes quite evident that this Hollywood legend was a Scream Queen before it was "cool."
1. Dee Wallace
Dee Wallace is criminally underrated as both an actress and a horror movie icon. Although most know her as Elliot's mom from 1982's E.T. it is in these genre roles that Wallace truly shines.
Wallace first broached the genre with 1977's The Hills Have Eyes playing Lynne Carter. In what would become a staple of her work, Wallace puts in an emotionally raw and draining performance as a mother desperate to save her child.
With her starring turn in 1981's The Howling, Wallace reached greater heights commercially and within the horror community,
Her harrowing role in 1983's Cujo depicted Wallace again as a desperate mother. Trapped in a hot car with her child, Wallace must choose between facing down a rabid dog or suffocating to death, and her performance here is considered so strong that many felt it an outrage that she failed to receive any notable recognition.
As the years have passed, Wallace has accepted countless other horror roles. She reprised the frantic mother trope for a further three flicks, 1986's Critter, 1991's Popcorn and 2007's Halloween. The latter project opened up a steady working relationship with director Rob Zombie too, keeping her in the genre.
Consequently, Wallace's horror filmography has continued to grow, with appearances in The Lords of Salem, 3 From Hell and Ti West's House of the Devil
Embracing each one of her past horror turns, Wallace is undoubtedly an actress of supreme depth and talent, making her perhaps the must underrated Scream Queen there is.
Watch Next
The Impossible Friends True Or False Quiz