10 Franchises That Should've Quit After Two Films
Emo Peter Parker should never have strutted down that street.
Franchises are all the rage now thanks to the success of the MCU, Fast & Furious and Star Wars, but that does not mean that every film should be granted a sequel just because it did well. Even a director who managed to churn out two good films should think twice before potentially ruining their legacy with a lazy third entry that exists purely to make more money.
Imagine how incredible the Alien films would be regarded if David Fincher had not been drafted in to churn out a joyless sequel - one which led to a lacklustre crossover with the Predator franchise, before a forgettable attempt to reboot the series with Prometheus.
Similarly, if Francis Ford Coppola had not written The Godfather Part III outside the first two's source material, the series would consist of perfect films without the blemish that the third entry turned out to be.
Whether it was a disappointing third film or the franchise simply ran out of steam after two movies, these franchises should have called it a day after two outings.
10. The Godfather
Francis Ford Coppola's decision to make a third film in this Godfather series was one motivated out of a need to stay relevant and to score a much needed success after his 1982 film One From the Heart flopped at the box office.
Had he not been in financial trouble due to this loss, we would never have seen the Godfather films become a trilogy. Potentially a third film could have acted as a touching tribute and epilogue to the beloved - and critically adored - saga but by Coppola's own admission he had nothing to say.
Feeling that he had completed the Corleone saga with his first two films, it is very clear that The Godfather Part III was a mistake which only left a sour taste in the mouth after two of the greatest films committed to cinema. Although this threequel was a hit, Coppola was unable to direct another great film as he churned out Bram Stoker's Dracula and Jack in the following years which have - like the third Godfather film - aged poorly.
THE OFFENDING SEQUEL(S) ROTTEN TOMATOES SCORE: The Godfather Part III - 69%
9. Beverly Hills Cops
Beverly Hills Cop proved that Eddie Murphy could hold his own as a movie star, after playing second fiddle to Nick Nolte in his debut 48 Hrs and Dan Aykroyd in Trading Places. Beverly Hills Cop II was a much anticipated sequel that came out the same year as his stand-up show Raw which cemented Murphy's status as the king of 80s comedy. Beverly Hills Cop III, however, was a mistake.
By the time this third film rolled out it was clear that Murphy had no interest in the hit film series which had made him a star. After a series of flops in the early 90s, Murphy reluctantly agreed to star in this sequel but with no wisecracking antics and none of the joy displayed in the previous two.
Murphy even went on record after the release of Beverly Hills Cop II stating: "The only reason to do a Cop III is to beat the bank, and Paramount ain't gonna write me no check as big as I want to do something like that. In fact, if I do a Cop III, you can safely say, 'Ooh, he must have got a lot of money!'"
Well, Eddie Murphy, you must have got a lot of money.
THE OFFENDING SEQUEL(S) ROTTEN TOMATOES SCORE: Beverly Hills Cops III - 10%
8. Blade
Blade: Trinity is not just regarded by critics and audiences as a terrible film but by most of the cast and crew. The third entry to the film series was dominated by star Wesley Snipes' crazy antics whether he was allegedly strangling the director or - for the majority of filming according to co-star Patton Oswalt - staying in his trailer smoking weed everyday.
Perhaps it was this on set behaviour, the lousy script or franchise fatigue but Blade: Trinity failed to recapture the magic of its two predecessors. After a game-changing first instalment which showcased Snipes as a dynamic presence and an inventive sequel helmed by Guillermo del Toro, this disastrous finale spelled out the end for the franchise and Snipes' career.
This is especially tragic considering the Blade films essentially crafted the formula for the modern day superhero films. After Joel Schumacher's Batman had limped out of cinemas in the late 90s and before the X-Men films had picked up the reins in the 00s, Blade 1 and 2 showed many how it was done.
Hopefully the upcoming reboot starring Oscar-winner starring Mahershala Ali will restore love for this ill-fated series.
THE OFFENDING SEQUEL(S) ROTTEN TOMATOES SCORE: Blade: Trinity - 26%
7. Cloverfield
The Cloverfield franchise is a strange one, the first instalment being a found footage monster film and its loose sequel (maybe even prequel) acting as a claustrophobic drama. However, the bland third offering The Cloverfield Paradox managed to kill off any interest for this franchise after its straight-to-Netflix release.
Inventive The Cloverfield Paradox's Super Bowl advertising may have been but a good - or even solid - film it definitely was not. Unsure of what genre it wanted to be classified as, this third instalment was a mish mash of a space exploration movie with elements of body horror and some vague nonsense about alternative realities shoved in for good measure.
With a notable silence on any upcoming projects in the Cloverfield universe, perhaps its best to simply let this franchise go the same way as the infamous Dark Universe: to a quick and painless death.
THE OFFENDING SEQUEL(S) ROTTEN TOMATOES SCORE: The Cloverfield Paradox - 21%
6. Shrek
Shrek is a classic cartoon fantasy epic which introduced an unlikely green Scottish ogre as its protagonist and Shrek 2 is arguably the rare beast of a sequel which improves on its original. Anything after these two pioneers of animation is best forgotten.
The problem with Shrek the Third and Shrek Forever After may be the decision to introduce the Ogre children which tied Fiona and Shrek down for the final two entries. The final Shrek film had to magic them out of existence to create a compelling narrative and by doing so marginally improved on Shrek the Third.
Whatever spark these sequels were unable to recover, they at least had the grace to eventually bow out after outstaying their welcome for two forgettable films. However, as is the case with any series which has lain dormant for 10 years or more, there are constant rumours of a reboot in the near future. Please Hollywood, just leave Shrek alone.
THE OFFENDING SEQUEL(S) ROTTEN TOMATOES SCORE: Shrek the Third - 41%, Shrek Forever After - 58%
5. Sam Raimi's Spider-Man
Spider-Man 3 is widely regarded as one of the worst superhero films of all time and this was mainly due to studio interference as Sony wanted Venom to play a major role in the third film much to the detriment of the story.
Before this we had been introduced to the web slinger in Sam Raimi's 2002 classic origin story which was so faithful to the bright cartoony world of NYC that it could very well have been taken directly from the pages of the 60s comic books. Spider-Man 2 was the pinnacle of the 00s superhero craze as it managed to triumphantly balance the struggle Peter Parker goes through while showcasing the incredible Spider-Men set pieces we know and love.
If Sam Raimi had left it there, these Spider-Man films would be heralded as classics and a time capsule for future filmmakers to witness what a successful 00s superhero saga looked like. However, Spider-Man 3 was released in 2007 and is sadly now as much a part of the legacy of these films - immortalised with its famous Emo Peter Parker sequence - as its successful predecessors.
THE OFFENDING SEQUEL(S) ROTTEN TOMATOES SCORE: Spider-Man 3 - 63%
4. Tim Burton/Joel Schumacher's Batman
Tim Burton's Batman and Batman Returns are incredible pieces of filmmaking which managed to bring gravitas to the world's greatest detective after the campy Adam West 1966 debut film. Joel Schumacher's subsequent offerings of Batman Forever and Batman & Robin were seen by many as a step back to this era of ridiculous gadgets and cheesy dialogue which Burton had attempted to avoid.
To the casual viewer it would seem that Michael Keaton's time as the caped crusader in Tim Burton's two films were unrelated to Val Kilmer and George Clooney's solo ventures wearing the mask in the 90s.
However, these four films spanning nearly a decade with three different Batmans and two different directors are actually all in the same chronology thanks largely to Michael Gough's Alfred Pennyworth who appears in all of the films.
Perhaps Schumacher was attempting to create his own vision for Batman with extravagant set piece-led films after Burton's more gritty aesthetic which the studio wanted to desperately steer away from.
Whatever the reason, 1995's Batman Forever starring Kilmer did mark a downward trajectory in the film series before its final death throes in Clooney's Batman & Robin.
THE OFFENDING SEQUEL(S) ROTTEN TOMATOES SCORE: Batman Forever - 39%, Batman & Robin - 11%
3. Superman
Richard Donner is the man who directed the first two Superman films, which brought Superman and Clark Kent to life for the first time on the big screen, but the second film was famously and controversially re-cut by Richard Lester after Donner was fired. However, whether you prefer Lester or Donner's cut of Superman II it is an undeniable fact that they are both superior to the terrible Superman III.
While the first two films about the Man of Steel had done a good job at balancing the humour and drama of essentially a man flying around America in his red underwear, Superman III chose to emphasise the campy humour to the detriment of any drama. Richard Pryor was - rather unfairly - blamed by many for the downfall of this third film with his goofy hi-jinks seemingly at odds with the more sombre performance given by Christopher Reeve.
This was nothing compared to Superman IV: The Quest for Peace which was slated upon its release by critics and audience for its dull action and forgettable story line. As one critic quipped, "subtitled The Quest for Peace, this Superman sequel should have been called the The Quest for a Plot."
THE OFFENDING SEQUEL(S) ROTTEN TOMATOES SCORE: Superman III - 26%, Superman IV: The Quest for Peace - 11%
2. The Terminator
James Cameron is undeniably the secret sauce in the recipe of what makes a good Terminator film because there have only been two good ones - the two which saw Cameron directly behind the camera.
The main problem that all the sequels which followed these two classics had was their attempt to make sense of the original time travel chronology and an inability to make John Connor an interesting character. After three attempts to create a coherent sequel around the T-800 (including one which did not even feature the Terminator himself, Arnold Schwarzenegger) the franchise recognised that it would have to get Cameron involved to recreate that magic.
Terminator: Dark Fate decided to do this and made a big deal of the fact that Cameron was back as a producer and a story contributor but either audiences did not care or had given up on the franchise which bombed at the box office. Despite being the best entry in the franchise since Judgement Day it only achieved this by rehashing old plot points from the first two films and only managed to do so after three previous failed attempts over 15 years.
THE OFFENDING SEQUEL(S) ROTTEN TOMATOES SCORE: Terminator 3: Rise of the Machines - 69%, Terminator Salvation - 33%, Terminator Genisys - 27%, Terminator: Dark Fate - 70%
1. Alien
Ridley Scott's Alien is a perfect science fiction horror, James Cameron's Aliens is an incredible sci-fi action film but David Fincher's Alien 3 is a forgettable mess.
Fincher dropping the ball with the franchise only marked the beginning of a slow and agonising death for the Xenomorph series which has arguably not recovered from this failure since. While Sigourney Weaver's final entry in the series Alien Resurrection was a slight improvement on Alien 3 it would only get worse from there on out.
Crossing over the Alien series with the Predator franchise proved to be a disaster for both intellectual properties with critics ultimately giving Alien vs. Predator 21% on Rotten Tomatoes and its sequel Alien vs. Predator: Requiem a pathetic 12%.
Ridley Scott's prequel films may have restored some interest in the franchise with some thought-provoking concepts explored but nothing has touched the original two masterpieces from Scott and Cameron.
THE OFFENDING SEQUEL(S) ROTTEN TOMATOES SCORE: Alien 3 - 43%, Alien Resurrection - 55%, Alien vs. Predator - 21%, Alien vs. Predator: Requiem - 12%, Prometheus - 73%, Alien: Covenant - 66%