10 Genius Ways Directors Got The Actor They Wanted

These directors thought outside the box when it came to securing their preferred actor!

Pete Davidson Suicide Squad
Warner Bros.

In a perfect world, when assembling a talented cast of thespians to bring their chosen big screen personalities to life on a cinematic stage, a director would be blessed with their undoubted number one choice for each and every role in question before setting their production in motion.

However, as you're likely more than aware of at this point, the casting process isn't always that straight forward, sadly.

For a whole host of reasons, a lot of the time it just isn't as easy as presenting a headshot of your desired acting sensation to the studio, handing over a contract and getting the show on the road. But these often frustrating hurdles only led to the incoming collection of directors having to think outside the box a touch in order to land an actor they clearly felt was the perfect fit for a character.

From playing Jedi mind tricks on some of Hollywood's finest, to making things a bit more personal with a pen, these directors had to resort to some wholly unexpected tactics to bring the star of their choosing to the party.

10. Martin Scorsese Sends Leonardo DiCaprio In To Convince Daniel Day-Lewis - Gangs Of New York

Daniel Day Lewis Gangs Of New York
Miramax Films

Despite unquestionably acting as one of the most captivating and routinely mesmerising performers of his generation, Daniel Day-Lewis doesn't half have a habit of calling it quits.

And it was because of his self-imposed retirement from show-business to focus on being a cobbler, nearly two decades before his latest decision to kiss goodbye to the acting world, that Martin Scorsese had to call in a favour from arguably the most famous thespian on the planet at the time.

With the iconic director just about beginning his eventually fruitful partnership with Leonardo DiCaprio heading into his 2002 staggering feat of cinema by the name of Gangs of New York, Scorsese actually nudged his new leading man into trying to get Day-Lewis out of retirement to play the part of Bill "The Butcher" Cutting.

As Leo would confess to The Screen Actors Guild Association:

“Scorsese had actually said to me, ‘I’m not sure how Daniel feels, if he’s ready to work or not... You should have a conversation with him and suss it out.'”

A not at all awkward walk through Central Park eventually led to DiCaprio finally convincing Day-Lewis to join the crew on the back of himself and pal Tobey Maguire talking him into the eventually Academy-Award-nominated role over dinner.


9. Kevin Bacon's F***able Screen Test Convinces A Studio Head To Cast Him - Footloose

Footloose Kevin Bacon
Paramount Pictures

While it may seem somewhat insane to imagine a world where folks wouldn't take one look at the thrusting hips of a young Kevin Bacon and see an abundance of dollar signs in their immediate future, one rather important person in particular wasn't actually convinced the future Hollywood superstar was the youngster for the job heading into 1984's Footloose.

But with director Herbert Ross and many others behind the flick feeling that Bacon was the only guy for the part of Ren McCormack, they decided to dump the talented performer into a screen test depicting him trying on a number of outfits to the sound of a rock soundtrack. This was all in a bid to convince Paramount executive Dawn Steel that Bacon was indeed, contrary to what she believed, "f***able".

Sure enough, Steel quickly changed her opinion upon seeing the hip-shaking star strut his stuff in the rather expensive and elaborate screen test, with Bacon going on to become something of a pop culture icon thanks to his chosen set of moves and a frankly barmy $1,500 haircut.


8. Tom Gormican's Letter To Nicolas Cage Seals The Deal - The Unbearable Weight Of Massive Talent

The Unbearable Weight of Massive Talent Nicolas Cage
Lionsgate

It's not too difficult to see why the legendary Nicolas Cage wasn't in too much of a rush to commit himself to a project that involved him playing a fictionalised version of himself, turning down the role in Tom Gormican's The Unbearable Weight of Massive Talent on a number of occasions due to being "afraid that the director would want to push it into that kind of ‘Saturday Night Live’ mockery zone.”

So, in order to secure the most important piece of his Nic Cage puzzle for this celebration of all things Cagey, Gormican decided to add a more personal touch to his overall pitch, writing the acting titan a letter explaining his unique vision for the out-there feature and why he simply had to make this movie.

It was this letter, revealing the sheer level of genuine admiration Gormican had for the one-of-a-kind performer, that convinced Cage to finally pursue this utterly bizarre endeavour.

And so, the world was once again ultimately treated to what the actor would himself brand "full Cage" in everything from the most epic "NICK F'N CAGE!" ever committed to screen to planting a smacker on a younger version of himself throughout the nutty and heartfelt runtime.


7. Chris Columbus And J.K. Rowling's Unusual Convincing Of Alan Rickman - Harry Potter

Severus Snape Philosopher's Stone
Warner Bros.

Though the late great Alan Rickman's Severus Snape would go on to become quite possibly the most compelling, complex, and unexpectedly beloved character ever to wave a wand in the Wizarding World, it wasn't simply a case of offering the star the conflicted role and throwing him straight into a jet-black robe.

Rickman was said to have been a tad reluctant to appear in the cinematic adaptations of J.K. Rowling's fantastical world, with Chris Columbus noting how the Die Hard and Robin Hood actor wasn't exactly over the moon about playing yet another apparent villain.

So, in a bid to get him thoroughly onboard the Hogwarts Express, after begrudgingly saying "yes", Rowling herself took Rickman out for a spot of dinner. It was here when the author revealed to the Snape star what his rather tragic character arc would actually entail, completely changing the way the actor saw and played the role.

In fact, it got to the point where Rickman would add little elements to his performance on set that made little sense to Columbus while filming Philosopher's Stone, only for the actor to quip "Oh, you'll know when you read the seventh book."


6. Jon Favreau's RDJ Screen Test Was All He Needed To Convince The Studio - Iron Man

Iron Man Robert Downey Jr.
Marvel Studios

Returning to the wonders of a well-made screen test now, and to that time Marvel Studios weren't exactly entirely convinced about a burgeoning world with Robert Downey Jr. at the centre of it.

This being a time long before RDJ was the celebrated household name MCU fans know and adore today, the idea of the troubled Oscar-nominated actor being the focal point of not just Jon Favreau's game-changing first Iron Man outing but the daring adventure that was the soon-to-be sprawling Cinematic Universe as a whole wasn't an exciting one for Marvel Studios.

In fact, as Favreau would confess later down the road:

"What happened was they didn’t like the idea of Robert – they were scared of him, they told me ‘no, I couldn’t hire him’ and it felt like too big of a risk."

Sensing it would take just one glance at RDJ doing his Tony Stark thing to convince the studio he was more than the (Iron) man for the job, Favreau soon put the star down on tape, with the director revealing, "from the minute he opened his mouth everybody who saw the screen test was convinced..."

And the rest was Marvel Cinematic history...


5. Joseph Kosinksi Had Just 30 Minutes To Get Tom Cruise Onboard - Top Gun: Maverick

Top Gun Maverick Tom Cruise
Paramount Pictures

Currently sitting as quite easily the most successful feature he's ever had the honour of being a significant part of, it may come as a bit of a shock to hear that Tom Cruise wasn't actually always a big fan of stepping back into the boots of Maverick.

In fact, as director Joseph Kosinski would hilariously discover himself upon touching down in Paris to pitch the idea of heading back into the "Danger Zone" with Cruise and co., the acting legend "really didn't want to make another 'Top Gun," so the eventual sequel-helmer had just 30-minutes to convince him otherwise.

It was here, in-between set-ups for Cruise's shoot on an incoming Mission: Impossible flick, where the director went into overdrive, with Kosinski describing it as "one of those moments as a director, you have one on every film, where you're on the spot to make a case for why this movie should be made."

Thankfully, his 30 minutes of high-speed selling more than did the trick, with Cruise being said to have picked up the phone straight after Kosinski had finished his pitch and telling Paramount Pictures, "We're making another Top Gun."

There's movie stars. And then there's Tom Cruise, folks.


4. James Gunn Sells Pete Davidson On An Appearance With A Name - The Suicide Squad

Suicide Squad Blackguard
Warner Bros.

The promise of simply getting to work under the guidance of one of the most exciting directors in the business today is sometimes enough to guarantee an actor's signature out of the gates. But that wasn't the sole reason Pete Davidson eventually agreed to appear in James Gunn's spin on all things The Suicide Squad in 2021.

As the Saturday Night Live star would reveal during an appearance on The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon, the Guardians of the Galaxy director knew exactly how to pitch the role of Blackguard to the funny man who is also "a huge James Gunn fan".

In a phone call with Gunn, the actor was told:

"There's this role for you in the movie. And you play a guy named Richard Hertz."

Without skipping a beat, Davidson responded by saying "Dick Hertz. I'm in!", claiming it was "the greatest" to be playing a character whose name was literally "dick hurts".

Some stars desire all the money in the world and top billing before giving a director the green light. Others simply need to boast a childish innuendo of a moniker before having their face blown off...


3. Drew Goddard Convinces His A-List Cast To Take Pay Cuts - Bad Times At The El Royale

Bad Times At The El Royale Chris Hemsworth
Fox

While the idea of assembling an absurdly star-studded cast to bring to life a gripping thriller on the big screen may seem like a bit of a no-brainer in theory, the reality of gathering together a collection of actors including the likes of Chris Hemsworth and Jeff Bridges for Drew Goddard's Bad Times at the El Royale was a potentially rather expensive one.

So, in order to get around the incoming obstacle of staggering wages getting in the way of his chosen neo-noir baby, Goddard had to resort to some rather unexpected measures to keep costs as low as possible.

Highlighting just how eager the folks involved already were to get to grips with Goddard's tale of one fateful night at the titular hotel, the director and the cast themselves all agreed to take a pay cut in order to be given the freedom to "take big creative bets" when forging this unsettling story.

But even with the film ultimately only costing around $32 million, its eventual haul of just $31.9 million likely didn't do Goddard any favours in the long-run, with the director still yet to commit to another big screen feature since his critically well-received Bad Time at the El Royale arrived on the scene in 2018.


2. Quentin Tarantino Got Michael Keaton Drunk Enough To Say "Yes" - Jackie Brown

Jackie Brown Michael Keaton
Miramax Films

When Quentin Tarantino sets his mind to something, more often than not, the eccentric mind behind the likes of Pulp Fiction and Reservoir Dogs achieves what he sets out to do. And in the case of the casting of Jackie Brown's ATF agent Ray Nicolette, the director had his heart set on one actor and one actor alone: Michael Keaton.

For whatever reason, though, the Batman star was hellbent on not playing the part of Nicolette, with Tarantino explaining how "Michael's whole thing is to deny himself and to say he's not right."

That still wasn't enough to convince Tarantino to give up hope, mind, with the enigmatic auteur eventually inviting Keaton out for some drinks in an attempt to finally persuade him to join the Jackie Brown adventure.

And in the end, a night fulled by Jagermeister wound up resulting in Keaton being tied into the feature before long, with the actor confessing down the road:

"...I don't know what happened but the next thing I'm heading home and I'm doing the movie. So I go, 'I guess I'm doing it.' My agent is all excited and goes, 'Really? Why?' And I'm like, 'I don't know, I just woke up an hour ago and I don't remember.'"

We've all been there...


1. Barry Sonnenfeld Convinces Chris O'Donnell He's "Not A Very Good Director" - Men In Black

Men In Black II
Columbia Pictures

Though he'd already undoubtedly announced himself on the cinematic stage in the likes of Bad Boys and Independence Day, it was Will Smith's starring appearance in 1997's Men in Black that really marked the actor out as a movie star to keep your eyes on.

But the role of Agent J wasn't always a part destined to be played by the Fresh Prince of Bel-Air star from the get-go, though. Before Smith was landed on, Columbia Pictures and Amblin Entertainment both wanted eventual Batman & Robin star Chris O'Donnell for the leading character.

Men in Black director Barry Sonnenfield's wife Susan, a.k.a Sweetie, had other ideas, however, telling him that she felt Smith was the actor best suited for Agent J. So, when forced by the studios to meet with O'Donnell, who was weighing up another film offer at the time, about the concept of starring in the upcoming sci-fi blockbuster, Sonnenfield had a trick up his sleeve.

As he'd eventually reveal to Vulture:

"...I told him, 'Here's the truth. I'm not a very good director. I really don't have a clue. I don't think the script is very good. If I were you, I would take the other movie.'"

Sure enough, Sonnenfield's blatant lie was enough to convince O'Donnell to steer clear of this alien escapade, paving the way for Will to step into the iconic suit instead.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Gareth has 6 years experience writing and presenting articles/videos covering all things professional wrestling within the fantastic WhatCulture team. Gareth is also a life long wrestling fan, so is clearly living the dream!