10 Great Directors Who Keep Making Terrible Movies

The once-promising directors who can't stop propping up flop after flop...

The Green Inferno Eli Roth
High Top Releasing

Sometimes, a great director simply can’t be convinced that their latest idea is a non-starter.

Generally, this phenomenon is quickly blamed on an outsized ego, an attribute which it’s assumed many directors suffer from. However whilst this can be the case, often times directors are simply handed the wrong project by studio and think they can make a dud work despite the warning signs.

So some of the directors listed here were over-ambitious and let their vision get the better of their common sense, resulting in some woeful films from talented filmmakers. Some, however, simply said yes to the wrong project assuming anything with a big budget and a recognizable franchise behind it was bound to turn out alright.

But whatever the cause, all of the ten directors listed here have one thing in common: they all showed some serious promise early on, only to somehow produce a string of shoddy films in the years since their debuts.

With that in mind, here are ten filmmakers who proved they had a great movie in them... then followed it up by proving they had a ton of bad ideas to share too.

10. M Night Shyamalan

Hollywood director Manoj Night Shyamalan looks on during a press conference in Mumbai, India, Monday, May 5, 2008. Shyamalan is to be awarded the Padmashri, one of India's highest civilian awards. His latest film
Gautam Singh/AP

Whilst he's often called one of the worst to ever pick up a camera, that's not fair to Unbreakable director M Night Shyamalan.

What is much more fair is calling him the most inconsistent filmmaker in Hollywood history.

The director wowed the world with The Sixth Sense, Unbreakable, and Signs, a trio of hits which left viewers thinking they were witnessing the rise of a new genre film making legend.

Then he left cinema aisles roaring with laughter with The Village.

But don't worry film fans, because he then (kind of) came back via the more modest and mature effort Lady in the Water.

Then he truly screwed up with The Happening, The Last Airbender, and After Earth, a trio of total flops in a row, each worse than the last.

But M Night proved his cold streak was over and his critics were misguided with the one-two punch of The Visit and Split!

Then he made Glass. Honestly, at what point can audiences sue for damage caused by persistent whiplash?


9. DJ Caruso

Disturbia Movie
Paramount Pictures

With 2002's edgy neo-noir debut The Salton Sea, DJ Caruso marked himself out as one to watch.

The Val Kilmer comeback was a gritty, grimy crime thriller whose splintered, foggy narrative and intense visual style marked it out as a surprise success amongst a sea (hoho) of Tarantino imitators in the early noughties. Caruso soon lived up to his early potential with the superb teen thriller Disturbia, a 2007 hit which saw the director remix Rear Window for the ASBO generation and make suburbia a scary setting for the first time in a decade.

Funny, tense, and clever, this not-quite-remake solidified Caruso's status as an in-demand thriller helmer.

So it's a damn shame that he then made the espionage flop Eagle Eye only a year later. Another Shia LaBoeuf vehicle, this one was free of Disturbia's charm, tension, and humour, and set the director off on a brutal losing streak he's yet to escape from.

Soon came I Am Number Four, a flat and uninventive YA adaptation, and the aptly titled would-be "horror" The Disappointments Room.


8. James Franco

James Franco Zeroville
Rabbit Bandini Productions

Okay, this one is harder to defend than a lot of names on this list. Because good God has James Franco more than proven that he can make a bad film if he puts his mind to it. Many might even argue that, according to the law of averages at least, it’s actually easier to claim Franco is a bad director who made a good film and not the other way around. But what a good film 2017’s The Disaster Artist is.

The would-be auteur seemed to end his brutal cold streak of directorial flops with (ironically) this tragic-comic Tommy Wiseau biopic.

The film saw Franco disregard the pretensions of his critically maligned literary adaptations in favour of a simple and surprisingly poignant story of one demented director and his vision.

But then came Zeroville and Future World to dispel any notions of a turnaround for Franco’s directing career. And now film fans are left with the tragic certainty that the man can make a great, moving, funny, and inventive film. He’s just choosing not to.


7. Adam Wingard

Blair Witch Lisa
Lionsgate

This one is breaking a lot of hearts, so this entry will try to be constructive.

After all, the early careers of frequent collaborators writer Simon Barrett and director Adam Wingard made it clear the pair had potential to be cult filmmaking legends. As the director of the pair, Wingard made a mark with the phenomenal indie genre movies You’re Next and The Guest, a duo of efforts which fused razor sharp wit with propulsive pace and a crisp visual palette.

These early efforts were marked by peerless use of small budgets, masterful action and tension, a streak of dark humour and surprisingly smart, incisive satire which made Wingard and Barrett natural successors to the likes of Joe Dante and John Carpenter.

But then they followed them with the bigger budget efforts Blair Witch and Death Note, a pair of remakes which were flat, lifeless, and committed one cardinal sin of filmmaking. Both movies featured plots which were somehow both convoluted and too predictable, proving that a studio just needs to give these two total creative freedom to make their own original project.

Or you know, Godzilla Vs Kong.


6. Henry Joost

Catfish 2010
Universal Pictures

To be fair to Henry Joost, fellow film makers Eduardo Sanchez and Orin Peli also struggled to follow up their bombshell debut hits.

What does Joost have in common with the directors of The Blair Witch Project and Paranormal Activity? Well, his debut Catfish also relied on a gimmick in order to succeed with audiences.

The co-director showed some incredible promise with the 2010 documentary debut, a gripping (and maybe fake) hit which followed a naive filmmaker as he discovered his online crush was a loner's fictional invention.

But all that came from this promise in the years since is a set of lesser Paranormal Activity sequels and two corny online thrillers, Nerve and Viral. The Paranormal Activity gigs make sense, as Joost proved he didn't need a big budget to build tension. And the online thrillers speak to his experience as the creator of a documentary detailing the creepy reality of online life.

So, er, why are all four of these later films tension-free, uninvolving flops which were dismissed by critics and forgotten by audiences?


5. Dario Argento

Dario Argento Promo Shot
Eric Robert/Sygma/Corbis

This one feels a little mean, as it appears the director in question may have retied from filmmaking.

But that's no excuse to leave the legendary creator of Suspiria off this list when he's one of the most infamous cases of a talented director who can't stop making awful movies.

This horror icon had what has to be acknowledged as one of the genre's most impressive streaks ever between the seventies and nineties. For those decades, everything he released was another hallucinatory nightmare which disregarded logic in favour of sheer terror and succeeded as a result.

Those searching for genre classics could just cue up a string of Tenebre, Inferno, Phenomena, Opera...

And then somehow end up seeing one of the director's post 2000 films and wonder when he transitioned into comedy.

Argento ended an extraordinary career on a flat note with the trio of flops Mother of Tears, Giallo, and Dracula 2012, a disastrous triumvirate which grew less embarrassing but more boring as it continued. Sure, Mother of Tears may be laughably over-the-top, but at least it's worth a watch, which is more than can be said for the sleepy Giallo.


4. Rob Reiner

Shock And Awe Rob Reiner
Vertigo Entertainment

Much like Dario Argento, actor/director Rob Reiner had one of the most impressive directorial streaks in film making history.

Unlike Argento though, there isn't one genre this film maker failed to impress in. Never one to rest on his laurels, Reiner followed up the instant classic nostalgic coming-of-age tale Stand By Me with the peerlessly romantic, hilarious rom com When Harry Met Sally. As if that weren't enough, he only went and threw in the classic teen comedy The Sure Thing during the same decade.

And that's not even mentioning his best loved film of the eighties, a little comic fantasy called The Princess Bride. Oh, and did we mention his foray into horror? Because the Oscar winner Misery is pretty well remembered too.

Which makes it all the sadder that this once-legendary director can’t stop letting down audiences with his last decade of so-so efforts.

It's not just the lifeless biopic LBJ, which made one of America's most interesting presidents and one of Hollywood's most interesting actors boring. It's also Shock and Awe, a would-be Spotlight knock-off which dramatically uncovers Bush's lies about WMDs only about a decade and half too late to be interesting or, god forbid, actually daring.


3. Jonathan Levine

Jonathan Levine Warm Bodies
2013 Getty Images

Remember All the Boys Love Mandy Lane? Way back in 2006, before its star Amber Heard was better known for her real life legal woes, this gritty, intense teen horror brought slashers back to their grim eighties heyday.

Stripped of irony and boasting a sunburnt seventies visual palette, the bloody psychological thriller heralded the arrival of a major directorial talent.

Director Jonathan Levine went from strength to strength, with the promising indie wunderkind bringing the same visual style and a newfound heart to stoner comedy of age dramedy The Wackness.

Unfortunately, the director behind 2011’s coarse, poignant dramedy 50/50 is unrecognizable as the hack behind recent corny comedies Snatched and Long Shot.

The more recent efforts from David Gordon Green have proven that talented directors who end up lost in the Apatow comedy industrial complex can pull out of this tailspin. It’s not too late to call John Carpenter and as if he’s got any sequels he needs helmed, Jon.


2. Eli Roth

Eli Roth
MGM

It may be hard for readers to believe, but there was a time when Quentin Tarantino protégé Eli Roth was being hailed as the daring enfant terrible of horror.

Yes, the guy who has spent the last few years railing against “political correctness” and “social justice warriors” was once a thorn in the side of the critical establishment. His subversive torture horror Hostel saw Americans treated to the same torture they inflicted on prisoners of war at the height of the Iraq invasion and it was a gripping, intensely gruesome hit which shocked audiences and reviewers alike.

Nowadays, though, the director is no longer taking aim at corrupt governments and American ignorance in favour of bigger, bad-der enemies like… Cartoony eighties street gangs and college protestors.

The once-daring horror director has been relegated to predictable flops like Death Wish and The Green Inferno, his sharp edge dulled by years of over-indulgence. Although credit where it’s due, The House With the Clock in its Walls did seem to hint at some untapped potential as a kid’s filmmaker. Maybe Goosebumps Three is the career revival Roth needs.


1. Neil Marshall

The Descent
Lionsgate

This one stings, but after last year it really needs to be said. After all, a hard R reboot of Hellboy with gruff Stranger Things antihero David Harbour in the title role is a dream project.

So how did the 2019 film end up such a disastrous flop?

Well, to answer that you need to look at another, older question. How is the horror mastermind behind the unforgettable The Descent and underrated Dog Soldiers also the creator of 2008’s woeful Mad Max pastiche Doomsday?

How is the man who made some of Game of Thrones’ greatest episodes also the mind behind the flattest incarnation of Hellboy imaginable?

It’s hard to work out where Neil Marshall’s cinematic career was derailed. The Descent provides ample proof that the director is a horror genius and can build unparalleled tension and terror. Meanwhile, his acclaimed work on Game of Thrones proves he’s a propulsive action director with a kinetic vision and an eye for expansive, layered action set pieces.

So, what’s going on with this CV half filled by awful films? It’s impossible to tell why some projects aren’t a fit for the director, but here’s hoping he’s able to work on a winner again soon.


Watch Next


Famous Film Directors And Their Works Quiz!

The French Connection Gene Hackman
20th Century Fox

1. Which Film Director Earned An Academy Award For Best Picture For "The French Connection?"

In this post: 
Hellboy
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Cathal Gunning hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.