10 Great Movies With Terrible CGI

How did these films get away with CGI this bad?

Black panther
Marvel

Until recently, computer-generated imagery was mainly used for movies that focus on action, fantasy, or super-heroics. But as cinema keeps evolving, so does the tools of the medium. In today's world, green-screen, motion-capture, and CGI are used more than ever. These visuals are also being implemented into every cinematic genre, whether it be rom-com, thriller, or drama.

What's interesting about this development is how you can usually tell if a movie is good or not purely based on the quality of the special effects. If the computer-generated imagery is unpolished, it's a sure sign the film isn't up to snuff.

But every now and again, a movie will come along that the whole world will fall in love with despite the fact the VFX aren't up to standard. Even though films like Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone, Black Panther, and Spider-Man are regarded as classics, the CGI isn't stellar.

You may love the movies on this list. Some may very well be among your favourite films of all time. But that doesn't change the fact that the CGI is absolutely terrible.

10. Deep Blue Sea

Deep Blue Sea - Samuel L. Jackson
Warner Bros.

In Deep Blue Sea, a group of marine explorers battle a school of super-intelligent sharks. Based on that storyline alone, you'd assume this will be a dumb B-movie in the same vein as Birdemic or Maximum Overdrive.

Even though Deep Blue Sea could've been trashy schlock, it's elevated by an excellent cast, including Samuel L. Jackson, LL Cool J, Stellan Skarsgard, and Thomas Jane. On top of that, it has some genuinely great jump-scares, including when Skarsgard's character gets his arm ripped off by a Great White.

But let's not forget what Deep Blue Sea is best remembered for. After Jackson's character gives an uplifting monologue, a shark comes out of nowhere and rips him to pieces. Because you genuinely don't see it coming, this moment is regarded as one of the best jump-scares in cinema.

That's why it's ironic how the film's defining moment happens to have the worst special effect. Not only does the computer-generated shark look like its composed of rubber, Jackson's CG counterpart looks hilariously unfinished and contorts its limbs like a rag doll rather than a human being.


9. Harry Potter And The Philosopher's Stone

Harry Potter Troll
Warner Bros.

Contrary to popular belief, there is way less computer generated imagery in Harry Potter than you would believe. Many moments that seemingly rely on CGI use alternative SFX like scaling, animatronics, puppetry, greenscreen, wirework, and forced perspective. The reason why the directors of the franchise limit digital effects is because they're expensive and time-consuming.

But another reason why CGI wasn't commonly used is... it makes everything look a bit crap, especially in the first film. In Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone, Harry and Ron get in a scuffle with a troll in a bathroom. Because this is the first monstrous creature we see up close, this should feel like a magical and scary moment for the viewer.

But because of the ogre's janky movements and blurred animations, he looks downright shoddy. To add insult to injury, Harry is blatantly replaced with a CG image in certain shots, making the whole scene less believable.

Some viewers justify the troll's appearance, since visual artists still hadn't mastered fully-rendered CG characters. However, the troll in The Lord of the Rings looks dramatically better, even though the film was released only a month later.


8. Spider-Man

Green Goblin
Sony

Sam Raimi's Spider-Man was the first movie in history to earn $100 million in its opening weekend. Even though the trilogy ended on a bit of a downer, there are legions of fans who prefer this incarnation of Spidey over the MCU version.

But the biggest lovers of the first film can't deny the fact the visual effects are sub-par. Ironically, most of the worst CGI moments come from Peter Parker being... y'know... Spider-Man. When the webslinger leaps from building to building, he looks like a rubber man with Tobey Maguire's face stitched on. When Green Goblin is terrorising the citizens, his unnatural movements make him resemble a cartoon character. Even though we should be in awe watching the wallcrawler soaring through the sky, most viewers are wondering why Spider-Man looks more like his video game counterpart than the ACTUAL video game equivalent!

Although there are a couple of solid shots of the webhead swinging through the city, the bad far outweighs the good. Even though the special effects in the sequel are lightyears ahead in quality, this just makes the CGI in this film look more underwhelming.


7. Rogue One: A Star Wars Story

Rogue One A Star Wars Story Moff Tarkin
Lucasfilm

Star Wars fanatics were so psyched to see Darth Vader in Rogue One, they never considered the possibility the prequel would contain other iconic figures from the beloved franchise. So, when Moff Tarkin revealed himself, viewers were blown away.

No one expected to see the architect of the Death Star since the actor portraying him, Peter Cushing, was suffering from a severe case of being dead for 22 years. But thanks to the wonders of CGI and motion-capture, the VFX efforts resurrected the legendary British actor, allowing him to portray his most famous role.

But with the benefit of hindsight, it seems fans originally watched this scene with rose-tinted glasses. Viewers got so caught up on seeing the deceased actor on the big screen again, they didn't realise the special effects aren't as mesmerising as they initially thought. Although Tarkin's facial ticks and voice is spot-on, his mouth is... weird. Not only does it move unnaturally, his lips don't move in accordance with his voice, making him look like he's being dubbed.

You have to commend the visual crew for pushing the effects as far as they could, but the scenes with Tarkin proved the technology isn't quite there yet.


6. The Social Network

Social Network
Sony

Nobody exemplifies this philosophy that "the best visual effects are the ones we don't notice" better than David Fincher. In The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo, most viewers didn't notice green-screen was used to heighten the harsh weather. In Gone Girl, you could never tell everything outside the house of Ben Affleck's character was CGI. Viewers of The Social Network were baffled when they learned digital trickery was used to make Armie Hammer depict the Winklevoss twins.

However, there's one visual in The Social Network that doesn't work. While Mark Zuckerberg and Eduardo Saverin are speaking outside a party, their breath is digital! Although this visual was inserted to illustrate how cold it is, it looks like Zuckerberg and Saverin have freeze breath like Superman or Iceman.

What's worse is this visual is completely inconsequential. We can see the characters are shivering so we know it's chilly. Why did the visual team have to force an unconvincing effect to hammer this fact in? The sad thing is that once you notice the CGI breath, it becomes so distracting, you don't listen to a word either character is saying.


5. The Hobbit Trilogy

Battle of the Five Armies
New Line Cinema

The Hobbit did not live up to Peter Jackson's The Lord of the Rings. Nobody is going to deny that, nor did anyone think that could reasonably happen. But it doesn't change the fact Jackson crafted a satisfying trilogy in its own right. The action sequences in The Hobbit are innovative, the battle sequences are epic, and the performances are astounding, (especially Martin Freeman who feels like he was born to play Bilbo Baggins).

Even though LOTR set the bar unnaturally high in terms of special effects, you'd expect The Hobbit's visuals surpass it. Since technology had advanced over ten years and the prequels had over double the budget of its predecessor, how could The Hobbit's CGI not be out of this world?

Ironically, the visuals are the trilogy's biggest detriment. Everything looks so artificial, you can practically see the green-screen. Instead of using CGI to add to the spectacle, Jackson's crew here relied on the technology like a crutch, swashing every shot with a smorgasbord of cartoonish VFX.

This issue is extra noticeable when characters are substituted for CG doppelgängers. Because their bodies don't move in a natural way, you never believe they are really there for a second.


4. Forrest Gump

Forrest Gump Tom Hanks JFK
Paramount Pictures

For the most part, the special effects in Forrest Gump look breathtaking. Most viewers didn't have an inkling that the feather in the opening shot was computer-generated. People are gobsmacked when they learn every ping pong ball that Forrest plays with is digital. The greenscreen used to depict Lieutenant Dan without legs looks just as good now as it did back then.

But there was one special effect that looked bad, even when the film was released. Throughout the movie, Forrest rubs shoulders with many famous people throughout history including John Lennon, John F. Kennedy, Lyndon B. Johnson, and Richard Nixon. Instead of relying on body doubles, the film digitally inserted Tom Hanks' character into archival footage to make it look like he was meeting these historic figures.

Although these scenes look convincing at first, the VFX is all over the place when it comes to each character's mouth. If you analyse the lips of Nixon, Johnson, or Kennedy's in these moments, they clearly don't match with what they're saying.

Sometimes, digital trickery is used to make the lips move a certain way, which makes it look all the more superficial.


3. I Am Legend

I Am Legend Will Smith
Warner Bros.

I Am Legend takes place in a post-apocalyptic world where a retro-virus has either killed humans or turned them into vampiric mutants called Darkseekers. The story follows a virologist called Robert Neville who does everything in his power to find a cure for the creatures to save what's left of humanity.

It's common knowledge that this adaptation is quite a departure from Richard Matheson's novel of the same name. Nevertheless, the 2007 movie's long shots and slow build up helps to keep the viewer on edge. Unfortunately, all the tension disappears the moment you see the Darkseekers. Their movements and facial expressions are exaggerated to the point where they'd feel more at home in a comedy than a sci-fi horror.

These visual effects are so heinous, viewers couldn't understand why the film crew didn't bring the creatures to life with actors wearing prosthetics instead of CGI.

Well, that was the original plan. But during the screen test, the director worried the Darkseekers resembled "angry mimes", so switched to CGI in the eleventh hour. But upon watching the screen test, there's no question the original design of the monsters is vastly superior.


2. Black Panther

Black Panther Killmonger
Marvel Studios

Black Panther was an unprecedented success on every level. It was the first film with a Black director to earn a billion dollars, and ushered in a new age for Marvel. Although Michael B. Jordan's Fantastic Four tanked, the young star redeemed himself in the eyes of Marvel fans by playing one of the best villains in the franchise. All in all, there is a lot to love about Black Panther.

But one thing that stops the film from being among the MCU greats is the atrocious special effects. This is ironic since Marvel has always prided itself with pushing visual technology as far as it can go. After all, it was the first studio that pretty much perfected de-aging. But in Black Panther, the VFX are astonishingly shabby, especially in the final battle.

Because the visual team only had six weeks to animate the fight with T'Challa and Killmonger, simple things like shadows and textures were compromised. Also, it's nearly impossible to know what's happening since the scene is really dark.

Black Panther has become so infamous for its shameful CGI, visual effects channel, Corridor Crew, did a breakdown on why the showdown doesn't visually work.


1. The Irishman

The Irishman Robert De Niro
Netflix

In terms of acting, directing, story structure, and editing, The Irishman is almost perfect. Sadly, the de-aging effects used for Robert De Niro, Joe Pesci, and Al Pacino never stop getting in the way of Martin Scorsese's remarkable movie.

To make these actors look up to 50 years younger, each of them wore motion-capture sensors on their face and body. However, the final results look so awful, you'd swear the characters on screen are pure CG creations. Even when the effects look impressive, the characters don't move correctly. When we see De Niro's character in his thirties, you don't buy it since he still moves like a man in his seventies.

If this special effect was an issue in only one or two scenes, viewers would be more forgiving. But since the de-aging is noticeable throughout the entire 219 minute runtime, it stops The Irishman from being better than it should be.

The fact that there are YouTubers and freelance VFX artists who were able to create more convincing de-aging effects for these scenes without a $200 million budget makes The Irishman all the more disappointing.


Watch Next


Contributor

James Egan has been with Whatculture for five years and prominently works on Horror, Film, and Video Games. He's written over 80 books including 1000 Facts about Horror Movies Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts about The Greatest Films Ever Made Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts about Video Games Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts About James Bond 1000 Facts About TV Shows