10 Great Performances That Were Overshadowed By Their Co-Stars

Not that we're trying to guilt trip you into feeling bad or anything.

It's something akin to an unwritten law that, coming out of the theatre, movie-goers focus all their attention on the "one performance" that stood out. Of course, when a performance manages to mesmerise audiences in their masses - to the point that they can't think about anything else that happened in the movie - it's obviously worthy of the acclaim. But it also sometimes means that other great performances get lost in the wake and don't necessarily get the praise they deserve. That's to say, a great acting performance has the potential to overshadow other great acting performances if they happen to be a little louder, outrageous, or are given more screen time. That's not to suggest that actors purposely dominate movies and overshadow their fellow actors - it's just that certain movies have come to be so associated with certain performances, that all the other great performances in said movie might not have been met with the appropriate acclaim. So join us as we take a look through 10 great performances that were overshadowed by other great performances - in all of the cases assembled here, both were great, but one got way more attention than the other, and maybe didn't find itself met with the accolade that was warranted...

Honourable Mention: Woody Harrelson - True Detective

Overshadowed By: Matthew McConaughey This performance doesn't get a place on the main list for two reasons. Firstly, it's a TV show and the main list is strictly film-based. Secondly, the series isn't finished yet, so we can't judge it properly. So HBO's latest show - which has been hailed a masterpiece by many - follows two troubled detectives as they try and solve a series of serial murders over the course of 17 years in backwater Louisiana. It's dark, complex, narratively innovative, and addictive as hell. The detectives, Martin Hart and Rustin Cohle, are played by Woody Harrelson and Matthew McConaughey, respectively... and though they're both putting in some of the best acting of their careers, it's McConaughey's complicated, troubled and existential Cohle who is getting all the attention, presumably because... well, who knew that McConaughey had it in him to act like that? Still, all the focus on McConaughey has taken a lot of attention off of Harrelson's equally brilliant performance. And in a lot of ways, he has a much harder role as the semi-straight man.

10. Ethan Hawke - Training Day

Overshadowed By: Denzel Washington When anybody talks about Training Day, they will always almost bring up Denzel Washington's terrifying performance as Detective Alonzo Harris, a corrupt and deranged LAPD officer who escorts Ethan Hawke's inexperienced rookie, Jake Hoyt, on his first day on the job, where trouble ensues. The fact that Washington was going against his established character type meant that he eventually won acclaim (and the Oscar for Best Actor) for his turn here, but it also meant that a lot of the limelight was shifted away from Ethan Hawke, who's work here is equally impressive. Hawke might just be one of the most underrated actors working today as it is, and his role in Training Day - Oscar-nominated as it was - stands out as one of the great unsung performances of recent years. After all, we put ourselves in Jake's shoes for the sum of the picture, and we have to believe in him in order to believe in Harris. The problem is that it's easy to miss the great subtle nuances and moments of sublime acting on Hawke's part when Alonzo Harris is raving on the screen. So both performances are great; but none more so than the other.

9. Jeremy Renner - American Hustle

Overshadowed By: Jennifer Lawrence, Christian Bale, Amy Adams, Bradley Cooper Jeremy Renner had one of the most difficult parts to play in American Hustle - he wasn't one of the "main four," his character was out of the loop for much of the movie, and he had to settle for less screen time than Jennifer Lawrence, Christian Bale, Amy Adams and Bradley Cooper. So although all the awards glory and attention has fixated on those actors, it's important to remember that Renner's turn as the Mayor of New Jersey, Carmine Polito, is one of his best roles in years. It just happens he had to share the screen with some of the best actors going when it happened. Watch the careful facial expressions that Renner provides his character with all throughout David O. Russell's crime caper - unlike the rest of the cast (who are really going for it), Renner decides to play things subtle, and makes no attempt to hijack scenes. Instead, he provides a gentle, innocent and brilliant portrait of naivety - so much so, that he gives us a place to ground ourselves, away from all the cons and the commotion. In his willingness to be less, Renner gives us more. So we should remember American Hustle as having five great performances, not four.

8. Melanie Laurent - Inglourious Basterds

Overshadowed By: Christoph Waltz Christoph Waltz is, to put it bluntly, a bonafide scene-stealer. It's not his fault - he was gifted with the ability to deliver Quentin Tarantino's dialogue like some mystical, silver-tongued devil and it's delicious to watch each and every time he opens his mouth. The moment he first appeared in Inglourious Basterds as milk-chugging, pipe-smoking Nazi Colonel Hans Landa, movie-goers knew that Tarantino had found somebody special. So although his role in Inglorious became everyone's favourite subject, it also meant that another brilliant performance went unsung. Melanie Laurent, quite simply, is amazing here, though - given that she was a female and that the rest of the movie found itself dominated by strong male types - she received nowhere near the levels of acclaim that she deserved for her performance. As Shosanna Dreyfuss, she's the real star of the picture - Laurent makes her character bold, brave and sexy all at once, though not a second of acting feels forced or fake or hammy in the way that some Tarantino performances do. It's cool, collected and perfectly weighed: the movie just wouldn't have worked without her.

7. Sean Bean - The Lord Of The Rings: The Fellowship Of The Ring

Overshadowed By: Ian McKellen, Viggo Mortensen There are those who say that Sean Bean cannot act to save his life, and there are those who say: "What? Sean Bean's a great actor! You're talkin' crazy - now get outta here!" The jury's still out on which team is right, but if there was a movie to help the former sway the later, it might be the first installment in Peter Jackson's brilliant Lord of the Rings trilogy, subtitled The Fellowship of the Ring. Of course, most people remember Elijah Wood, Ian McKellen and Viggo Mortensen (the first because he's the main character, the last because they're brilliant) over Bean. As Gondorian soldier Boromir, however, Bean has what is arguably the most interesting part in the original movie - he is consumed by the One Ring before anyone else, of course, but he's also brave and noble, whilst remaining flawed. Bean showcases every aspect of his acting ability as he plunges himself into this role - so much so, that it's a shame the most interesting character is killed off at the end of the film. So whereas McKellen and Mortensen received the most acclaim for their performances as Gandalf and Aragorn, Sean Bean gave us the most complex character.

6. Paul Dano - There Will Be Blood

Overshadowed By: Daniel Day-Lewis When you go up against Daniel Day-Lewis, you're asking for trouble... and yet Paul Dano, who was brave enough to do so in There Will Be Blood (and in a Paul Thomas Anderson film, no less) manages to hold his own for the sum of two and a half hours. As preacher Eli Sunday, Dano is the antagonist to Day-Lewis' ruthless oil man Daniel Plainview - a constant weight on his shoulders, and - in a way - his nemesis. Dano plays Eli with a strange but grating self-righteousness. He gets on Daniel's nerves as he gets on our own. But Dano knows what he's doing. So whereas it was Day-Lewis who received the Academy Award for Best Actor and near enough every other accolade available, there were very few nominations thrown at Dano. What we have to remember here is that this young actor successfully managed to create a character who was meek and nebbish but also capable of providing Daniel Plainview with a genuinely disorienting rival. It's a masterful performance, totally underrated in every way, and one that was ingloriously pushed aside whilst the world chose to gush at Daniel Day-Lewis' instead.

5. Tom Cruise - Rain Man

Overshadowed By: Dustin Hoffman The film is called "Rain Man," Dustin Hoffman played the eponymous character, and he won an Oscar for playing that character, too... no wonder nobody really thinks about Tom Cruise when it comes to this motion picture. So although Rain Main was undoubtably Dustin Hoffman's triumph, you would have least thought that Cruise would have received some accolade for what is - without a doubt - one of his finest performances. As Charlie Babbitt, brother of the titular Rain Man, Cruise offers up another one of his cocky characters who learns there's more to life. And yet there's something sincere and genuine about this performance that allows it to ring far truer than any of the other times that Tom Cruise has played a character of this type (and let's face it, he has played said type a lot). Still, the drama between Charlie and Raymond would not have worked without Cruise's surprisingly acute work, and it's a shame that he was totally ignored by the Academy - and a lot of movie-goers, in fact, as it's fair to say this performance feels buried beneath Hoffman's. Which is greater, though? All these years later, it's still not entirely clear.

4. Josh Brolin - No Country For Old Men

Overshadowed By: Javier Bardem No Country For Old Men nabbed the prestigious Best Picture Academy Award back in 2007, beating out Paul Thomas Anderson's There Will Be Blood - a movie we've already mentioned on this list - in the process. Both pictures were excellent, of course, though No Country For Old Men presumably had the edge because it was slightly more mainstream (yes, slightly) - it was also propelled to victory by way of Javier Bardem's iconic performance as a terrifying hitman with an awful haircut who would stop at absolutely nothing to get the job done. Still, the movie's central character is one Llewelyn Moss, who Josh Brolin plays with skill and hard-assed determination, in a great and masterful performance that was greatly overlooked by movie-goers (and the Academy) who were too fixated on Bardem's baddy to take notice. Brolin successfully manages to make Moss quiet and broody but not in way so that we don't side with him during his attempts to dodge death. You might even argue the same happened with Tommy Lee Jones, who was great here also, but found himself obscured beneath Chigurh's shadow similarly.

3. Brendan Fraser - The Quiet American

Overshadowed By: Michael Caine The words "Brendan Fraser" and "great performance" don't usually wind up appearing together in the same sentence, but we're here to break that tradition: Brendan Fraser's performance in the 2002 adaptation of Graham Greene's novel, The Quiet American, is great. Genuinely. In fact, it's probably the best performance of his career - and going by the sort of thing he stars in these days, it looks like it might stay that way. Co-starring Michael Caine, The Quiet American tells the story of a reporter and his friendship with an idealistic American in 1950s Saigon. Michael Caine was nominated for an Academy Award for his turn here, of course - rightly so, in fact, given that it's one of the strongest performances. But Fraser, who clearly has an affinity for the source material and puts everything he has into his own performance as Pyle, was completely ignored by pretty much everyone who laid eyes on this picture - what they don't seem to have realised is that the entire movie hinges on our belief that Caine's journalist, Fowler, could be enamoured with Fraser's character. For Fraser haters, this will change your mind.

2. Andrew Garfield - The Social Network

Overshadowed By: Jesse Eisenberg Jesse Eisenberg received a well-earned Oscar nomination for his performance in David Fincher's surprisingly brilliant and gripping movie about the founding of Facebook - he played cold, calculating computer genius Mark Zuckerberg, of course, and that's the performance that everyone went home talking about, saying things like: "Oh, maybe he's not a second rate Michael Cera after all." Much credit - also due, mind - was given to Armie Hammer, too, who played the identical twins who rally against Zuckerberg and sue him for rights to the company. But it was British actor Andrew Garfield who might have put in the best performance in the whole movie. As Zuckerberg's wronged friend and co-founder Eduardo Saverin, whose plight gives the movie its moral edge, Garfield is mesmerising, poised as the movie's closest thing to a "hero," and the one character who genuinely seems to have more than one emotion. The scene where he breaks down - "You better lawyer up asshole, because I'm not coming back for 30%... I'm coming back for everything!" - is also the movie's best and most heartbreaking scene.

1. Aaron Eckhart - The Dark Knight

Overshadowed By: Heath Ledger The one thing on near enough everybody's mind having just sat down to The Dark Knight wasn't "great cinematography" or "awesome set-pieces," but was basically: "Heath Ledger - MY GOD... did we just witness one of the greatest movie performances of all time there?" Yes, Ledger literally left people speechless when he exploded all over the screen with an unexpected, creepy and frankly hilarious portrayal of Batman's greatest nemesis - so much so, that people failed to notice that there was another rather unexpected and expertly-honed performance going on. That's right: had Aaron Eckhart's Harvey Dent been a part of another movie - one where Two-Face had been the only villain, perhaps - we might have been singing him similar praises. You can see the actor is totally and utterly committed to his role at every moment... even when his face is destroyed and he looks like a walking nightmare, Eckhart lets us feel Harvey's pain, bitterness and anger. Simply put, Heath Ledger left no room for another "star" to shine in The Dark Knight - rightly so, even - but Eckhart was also noticeably transformative and brilliant, too. Like this article? Let us know in the comments section below.

Contributor
Contributor

Articles published under the WhatCulture name denote collective efforts of a number of our writers, both past and present.