10 Great Sci-Fi Movies With Terrible Concepts

"A dream within a dream within a dream within a dream" didn't sound like blockbuster perfection...

Arrival Aliens
Paramount Pictures

Sometimes the greatest films can unexpectedly come from the most head-scratching ideas, and what sounds like a laughable premise can turn out to be an instant classic of its genre.

Just look at 1996's Scream, which managed to turn "smug teens comment on slasher film cliches whilst living through a slasher movie" into an instant classic.

More recently, horror fans were surprised to see that 2016's edgy indie home invasion thriller Better Watch Out managed to wring some blackly comic scares out of (serious spoilers for the uninitiated) a killer spoiled suburban twelve year old.

As evidenced in WhatCulture’s recent rundown of horror movies whose seemingly doomed concepts turned out to be unexpected classics, this phenomenon appears throughout cinema history.

Another genre whose high concepts can result in some successes no one saw coming is sci-fi, where ambitious conceits can either be total flops or unexpectedly effective pieces of cinema depending on the director’s vision.

Often, the best sci-fi movies can come from conceits that sound terrible on paper, as evidenced in these ten classics of the genre which sound more than a little flawed when all you’ve heard is their premise.

10. The Truman Show

The Truman Show Jim Carrey
Paramount Pictures

Released in 1998, The Truman Show is one of the most poignant and prescient pieces of sci-fi satire from the last few decades.

Following a superb Jim Carrey as the titular hero, who is unaware that his entire life has been an elaborately staged TV show, the movie interrogates why audiences enjoy the voyeurism of watching real people’s everyday lives. Its twisty plot takes apart reality TV’s constructed “reality”, deconstructing the idea of the genre before it was anywhere near as successful with viewers as it is today.

But this doesn’t change the fact that The Truman Show’s premise, on a bare bones technical level, doesn’t really work.

Who is the target audience for this presumably deeply boring, incredibly expensive show in its first few years, when Truman is still an infant incapable of any agency of his own? Hell, even after that what's the contingency plan if this sheltered person turns out, well, sheltered and uninteresting as a protagonist? Also, why did the producers let our hero even find out about Fiji when they need him to never leave?

If Peter Weir’s famous satire had lingered for a moment longer on the logistics of how the eponymous show functions, everything would fall apart. Without a reason for viewers to watch, it's impossible to see how the show would become a phenomenon and maintain its massively expensive conceit in the first place, so it's just as well that a great script and superb performances hold this one together.


9. The Platform

The Platform
Netflix

Released earlier this year, Netflix’s blackly comic sci-fi horror The Platform has an undeniably effective, simple premise. It's also a premise whose metaphorical message is as unsubtle as a high school freshman's attempt to write for The Twilight Zone.

Set in a strange sort-of-prison, the film sees its hero wake up in a cell where he and his cellmate must fight over the meagre food given to them by a platform which works its slow, cyclical way down through this jail. There's enough food on the platform to feed every prisoner when it's at the top but, surprise surprise, the upper echelons take far too much. Thus everyone else is forced to fight to the death for their scraps.

It's about class and capital, folks, and that's it.

No explanation of how the platform works, who's running the show, or anything beyond a set up so simple that Black Mirror's own Charlie Brooker would greet it with "little on-the-nose, don't you think?"

In a conceit which makes Parasite's condemnation of capitalism look subtle, The Platform prides itself on how simplistic its central thesis is. But what sounds like an obnoxiously over-obvious metaphor is actually a biting bit of satire in this dark dystopian sci-fi horror.

Released at a time of unprecedented income inequality, the film's decision to forego backstory allows it to hit all the harder, and without any distracting world building, this blatant but brilliant film can make its statement all the more forcefully.


8. Species

Species Alfred Molina
MGM

If you left the cinema after seeing Ridley Scott's classic "haunted house in space sci-fi horror" Alien and thought, "that would have been better if the alien tried to have sex with its victims before killing them off", then congratulations, you could have come up with the premise for 1995's Roger Donaldson film, Species!

Following the murderous trail of a shape-shifting alien human hybrid who is searching for a human male to mate with and then consume, the film's corny conceit sounds laughable. After all, the monstrous villain of John Carpenter's The Thing would probably not be as threatening if it was slinking around in an evening dress.

But...

Whilst the premise of "Alien, if the Xenormorph had some added sex appeal" isn’t a film anyone was asking for, the film is surprisingly tense, scary good fun.

After all, it just takes some basic audience psychology to note that characters are never more vulnerable than when they're in the nip and ready to get down and dirty. As such, making this film's victims a bunch of clueless would-be Romeos rather than hardy space truckers or Antarctic explorers leaves them more exposed and more likely to be picked off, resulting in a creepy, fun sci-fi horror.


7. Face/Off

john travolta face off
Buena Vista

Okay, so this one seems like a real “come up with the title pun and then work backwards to fill in silly smaller details like plot, characters, etc”.

After all, a sci-fi action thriller where two men swap faces via some convoluted (and presumably completely impossible) surgery is a terrible idea for a film.

But if said film is titled Face/Off? Well, now you've got the sort of insane over-the-top nineties action film conceit that The Simpsons would have joked about.

But John Woo's 1998 hit succeeds solely because it opts to lean in to this absurdity, foregoing any attempts at self seriousness in favour of some broad and self-aware theatrics. The film's action is spectacular, but its premise of a cop and a criminal literally swapping faces with each other is both ludicrous and fun in an agreeably silly way as soon as the film makes it clear that it has no truck with believability.

Woo may have taken this approach too far with the later, pointlessly silly and tension-free Mission Impossible 2, but this film saw his kinetic action and silly sense of humour married perfectly through an idiotic idea which is weirdly ingenious in its unashamed willingness to go totally over the top.


6. Arrival

Arrival Aliens
Paramount Pictures

Is there anything more gripping and intense than watching translators work?

Okay, so interpreting one language into another isn't necessarily the most glamorous or fascinating job on Earth. But speaking of Earth, aliens are fun, right?

Sure, but mostly only if they don't come in peace. Viewers love to watch Roland Emmerich's alien spaceships demolish the White House and get demolished in return, but lengthy attempts at mediation? Boring!

Watching a linguist attempt to establish contact with alien life forms via carefully managed mediated attempts at communication should not be as gripping as Dennis Villeneuve’s thoughtful sci-fi Arrival proves to be. So it's no surprise that sci-fi fans are excited to see the visionary director rebooting Frank Herbert's epic doorstopper Dune. After all, Villeneuve salvaged the promise hidden in this seemingly terrible premise.

The director took an innovative approach to time travel and used it to make this story of Amy Adams' linguist and her attempts to translate alien communication into an intense and involving sci-fi thriller. A stand out genre effort from 2016, this thoughtful and mature piece of sci-fi proved almost any idea can work with the right angle.


5. A Clockwork Orange

A Clockwork Orange
Warner Bros.

Never seen Stanley Kubrick's critically adored, deeply controversial sci-fi dystopia A Clockwork Orange?

Here's what you need to know.

Like many other Kubrick characters, our protagonist is severely disturbed. However unlike, say, The Shining's Jack Torrance or Full Metal Jacket's Joker, this hero doesn't start off normal.

He doesn't even start off likeable, as right off the bat our audience insertion persona is a violent murderer and rapist who thinks nothing of beating a vagrant for fun. But don't worry, he's soon caught and his crime sprees are stopped.

Oops, sorry. Actually, it turns out that the state’s attempts to curb his sick behaviour amounts to little more than pointless torture. So our protagonist ends up a barely conscious sentient corpse by the film’s close.

Also, he doesn’t have the spiritual epiphany of his novel counterpart.

By this stage of the summary, it sounds sarcastic to claim that the film is a masterpiece and you’ve got to see it. But the bracing brutality of A Clockwork Orange and its unsparing worldview are what make it so vital, as the film refuses to offer any easy answers and instead forces the viewer to interrogate their own ideas of fairness, law, retribution, and rehabilitation.


4. The World’s End

The Worlds End
Universal

Okay, so you're critically acclaimed British comedy director/ genre mash-up mastermind Edgar Wright.

It's 2012, and after the one-two punch mega-successes of the first two Cornetto trilogy instalments Shaun of the Dead and Hot Fuzz, you've hit a snag. Those two films saw Simon Pegg and Nick Frost play a pair of slackers stuck in a zombie horror and an uptight city cop and his over-enthusiastic partner stuck in a twisty mystery, respectively. In both cases, these instantly likeable characters won them a lot of love.

How do you create iconic characters for their third outing?

Well, how about addressing those two cornerstones of comedy: depression and alcoholism?

Not just in a throwaway gag, either. Look at the premise of The World’s End: A depressed alcoholic, desperate to relive his glory days when he peaked in high school, marshals his reluctant middle aged friends together for a poignant, embarrassing pub crawl.

Then they realise their town is overrun by robots.

As far as genre mash-ups go, it sounds messy, ill-conceived, and tonally disastrous. But the thing is, by putting this film's darker moments in the beginning where Shaun of the Dead took the opposite approach, the robot-smashing third act of The World's End becomes an unexpected and gleeful blast.

The film tackles its heavy themes early on when the audience are most patient, then cleverly lightens its tone near the close when the depressing content could easily have become overbearing.


3. Monsters

Gareth Edwards Monsters Aliens
Vertigo

It’s not easy to make a giant monster movie whose entire conceit is based around not really focusing on the monsters at all.

But it's no wonder that Gareth Edwards went on to direct 2014's long-awaited Godzilla reboot, as his 2010 indie Monsters pulled off this seemingly impossible trick handsomely.

By focusing on a pair of survivors manoeuvring their slow way through a country devastated by kaiju attacks, the film depicted the reality of what most monster movies would look like from the perspective of an average civilian. Less flashy and bleak than the comparable Cloverfield, this film's occasional glimpses of its monsters provided some truly beautiful and fascinating designs.

This strange and innovative creature design is mirrored in the film's unusual perspective, with the action focusing on a photographer escorting his boss's daughter across the country rather than the military or scientists and experts.

The monsters look like none that creature feature fans have ever encountered before because the viewer is seeing them with the fresh eyes, not as a threat to be neutralised or a problem to be overcome but just as a new, surreal fact of life for the people on the ground.


2. Inception

Leonardo DiCaprio, dapper as Nolan, in Inception
Warner Bros. Pictures

Okay, so anyone who has seen legendary blockbuster director Christopher Nolan's 2010 hit Inception will have a hard time imagining what they would have thought of the film's premise if they'd never seen the innovative heist thriller.

But there's a reason Nolan was so tight-lipped about details of the film's story before its release, and it's more than just his general secrecy.

“It was all just a dream” is usually a phrase which destroys any tension and stakes instead of raising them. It's an easy way to say "see? It was all pretend, no harm done", and audiences generally presume that anything which happens in dreams has no real effect on the reality of the movie.

Characters can be eaten alive in a dream and then walk to school minutes later. So how would a heist that takes place entirely in dreams build or maintain any modicum of tension?

Well, by writing in the ingenious twist that characters always run the risk of becoming trapped in the dreams and languishing there. It's a seemingly small detail which grounds this otherwise weightless premise and gives it real, life-or-death stakes, even in a dream within a dream.


1. Her

her 2013 movie
Warner Bros.

“What if you fell in love with Siri?” is not, it’s fair to say, the most promising premise.

And yet 2013's Her, like The Truman Show before it, managed to not only overcome the potentially silly sounding nature of its central conceit, but actually wring some pretty moving satire out of the idea.

It's down to a pair of superb performances that this one succeeds.

First, an unrecognisable Joaquin Phoenix as the nebbish protagonist managed to convince the viewer that many modern lovelorn people are removed enough from human contact to consider their operating systems a replacement for human, let alone, romantic, relationships.

Then Scarlett Johansson's sultry and animated voice-only role as said operating system infuses what could have been a creepy, robotic monotone with real heart. It's still a strange premise, and one which not every viewer fell for.

But Her undeniably succeeds for the vast majority of moviegoers by focusing on the growing rapport between its central characters rather than dwelling on the more-than-a-little unconventional nature of their romance. By refuse to treat its own premise as outlandish, the film grounds its far-fetched story in what feels like a recognisable reality and avoids genre cliches as a result.

There's no fear of A.I. here, nor any hoary "get off your cell phone" anti-tech moral. Instead, the film tells a touching love story by focusing on character over conceit.


Watch Next


The Ultimate Christopher Nolan Movie Quiz

Christopher Nolan shooting Interstellar
Warner Bros.

1. What Is The Title Of Nolan's First Feature Film?

Contributor

Cathal Gunning hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.