10 Greatest Actors Turned Directors

The stars equally comfortable on either side of the lens!

Ben Affleck Live By Night
Warner Bros.

All actors, secretly or otherwise, want to direct. In the cutthroat movie business, anything you can do to get ahead is a boon, and once you’re calling the shots, you’re set up for life with endless movie roles and no one to tell you to do things differently. Alternatively you can remain behind the camera and exert a little power over your former peers - a tempting proposition.

It’s not always as easy as many performers imagine, though. Many an actor has made the jump only to find themselves accused of making vanity projects, lacking the critical eye required to occupy the hot seat.

When it goes well, though, you can find yourself with a whole new career, which sometimes exceeds your achievements as a performer. The critics love an actor-turned-director, and the rewards are great.

We’ll be looking here solely at those who worked primarily as actors before making the transition, so the likes of Woody Allen or Orson Welles, whose vision and or ego meant that they wore both hats from the off, won’t be included. These are the rare actors who decided they had something more to offer and could actually back it up.

10. Olivia Wilde

Olivia Wilde The Longest Week
Gravitas Ventures

She has thus far directed only one feature film, but what a film it is. Olivia Wilde’s career up to 2019 had been solid if perhaps unspectacular - after bursting onto the scene with a recurring role in The O.C, she had found a few decent film roles as well as some less interesting ones, and a lead part in HBO drama Vinyl which, despite input from Martin Scorsese and Mick Jagger, promptly bombed.

Then, she directed Booksmart. One of the sharpest, funniest, and generally most delightful films in recent memory, the comedy quickly changed Wilde’s status, and most likely her career going forward.

An unflinching look at friendship, young adulthood, self confidence and sexuality, Booksmart was starmaking not just for its lead actors Kaitlyn Denver and Beanie Feldstein but for its director too. A sleeper hit and a critical smash, it left audiences and studios alike eager for Wilde’s next effort.

She has also recently been involved in documentaries, producing and directing shorts with heavy subjects like war and natural disasters. While they may not have the mass appeal of a coming of age comedy, she is evidently a director to watch in future.


9. Kevin Costner

Oscars 1991 Kevin Costner
ABC & AMPAS

A victim of his own success, Kevin Costner had the misfortune to release his directorial debut the same year as Martin Scorsese’s Goodfellas, and the even greater misfortune to win the Oscar over the veteran, leading to much clucking from critics and Scorsese fans alike.

While it was and is a shock that Dances With Wolves triumphed that year, it shouldn’t be taken as a criticism of Coster’s film, which is magnificent. An incredibly bold debut, the neo-western pushes the three hour mark and is sweeping in scope and is clearly a true passion project for the director. In spite of its length and much of the dialogue being in a Sioux dialect, it was a box office hit.

Follow up The Postman was not so good, but Costner went back to the west with Open Range in 2003. It’s a genre he can do as well as about anyone, and this is another elegiac and spacious picture with glorious performances from Robert Duvall and Annette Bening.

Coster hasn’t stepped behind the camera since then, but with the right project, the guy clearly has a lot to say.


8. Ben Affleck

IMAGE DISTRIBUTED FOR FIJI WATER - Actor Ben Affleck arrives at the premiere of
Matt Sayles/AP

Now with four hit movies and a Best Picture Oscar under his belt, it’s hard to remember that, around 15 years ago, Ben Affleck was pretty much a punchline. Ridiculed on South Park and late night shows for his terrible movie choices and wide open personal life, it didn’t seem like there was any way back for the formerly acclaimed screenwriter and actor.

Then came Gone Baby Gone, a hardboiled and distinctive thriller that shut critics up with remarkable efficiency. Affleck made the smart choice to stay strictly behind the camera here, allowing Casey Affleck, Michelle Monaghan, and Amy Ryan to shine.

He’d show no such restraint for his next films, but not to their detriment - he turns in some of his best performances in The Town and Argo, showing subtlety that seemed to have deserted him. It was an impressive triple bill, with Affleck exhibiting greater ambition and confidence in his skills with each subsequent film.

His fourth, Live By Night, was a setback - not a bad film by any means, but a notable box office flop. Still, Affleck’s directorial career is yet young, and at this point you’d bet on his next movie to be a belter.


7. Julie Delpy

Julie Delpy
Sony Pictures

The enormously versatile Jule Delpy is good at just about anything. She is perhaps best known for the Before series (Sunrise, Sunset, Midnight), the latter two of which she also wrote. Aside from these, she has made a career in directing highly accomplished, ever so European relationship movies, for which she often composes the score as well just to put the rest of us to shame.

Best known are 2 Days In Paris, and its similarly titled sequel set in New York. Delpy coaxes great performances out of her American co-stars (Adam Goldberg, Chris Rock) and paints a sensitive and funny portrait of motherhood and finding romance. The films are somewhat autobiographical, but unlike other artists writing about themselves she has an interest in the world around her, too, with sexual politics and race being key themes.

2009’s The Countess saw Delpy tackle historical drama (again pulling a quadruple shift as director, star, writer, and composer), and her latest, My Zoe, is an often heartbreaking look at motherhood. While she’s yet to have a hit on the level of the Before films, it seems there’s nothing she can’t do.


6. Robert Redford

Truth Robert Redford
Sony Pictures Classics

The ‘70s icon was an understated actor of rare grace and elegance, and it stands to reason that he’d follow suit as a director. Like Kevin Coster after him, he would fall afoul of an unfortunate curse: directing a film that won the Oscars over a Martin Scorsese masterpiece.

Ordinary People is, admittedly, not as good as Raging Bull (few films are), but its reputation as a schlocky melodrama is unfounded. In fact it’s a well observed and beautifully acted family tragedy, with a barnstorming performance by Mary Tyler Moore. Redford’s approach is a restrained one, letting the story breathe.

Better still is Quiz Show, his 1994 true story about a 1950s scandal on the titular TV format. Ralph Fiennes and John Turturro put in two of their best ever performances. The film was overshadowed by the year’s blockbusters and critical darlings (Gump, Shawshank, Pulp), but it’s better than most if not all of them, a dark and acidic drama that subtly hits on some serious class issues.

He hasn’t reached these heights since but has continued to put out solid films about the matters that interest him most - American history and politics. Now retired, he is one of Hollywood’s class acts.


5. Sofia Coppola

Jury member Sofia Coppola poses for photographers as she arrives for the screening of Foxcatcher at the 67th international film festival, Cannes, southern France, Monday, May 19, 2014. (AP Photo/Thibault Camus)
Thibault Camus/AP

The Godfather Part III isn’t the unmitigated disaster many would have you believe, but one thing’s for sure: the performance of Sophia Coppola was not very good. Thankfully, no one understood that better than Coppola herself, and she quickly made the move behind the lens.

It turned out that, like her old man, she is very good at directing. Starting with The Virgin Suicides, Coppola demonstrated her fully formed visual style, vibrant, high energy, always with a great soundtrack.

Her next was even better - Lost In Translation. A bittersweet tale of two Americans at loose ends in Japan, she helped put Scarlett Johansson on the map, and reminded the world of just how great an actor Bill Murray is (she’s one of the few directors the reclusive star will always turn up for).

Her latest, The Beguiled, was a departure for her but proved one of her most fascinating projects yet. She’s a real actors’ director - Kirsten Dunst, particularly, is never better than when working with Coppola. This was a career change that paid dividends and then some.


4. Rob Reiner

Rob Reiner Wolf Of Wall Street
Universal Studios

Before a stellar directing career, Rob Reiner spent seven years as a sitcom actor. As the combative liberal voice on All In The Family, Reiner spent 182 episodes sparring with Archie Bunker, chipping in with four scripts along the way.

With his father, the late Carl, a hugely successful director, it was always likely Rob would go the same way, and he debuted in some style with 1984’s This Is Spinal Tap.

Reiner can claim a classic in most genres - horror (Misery), coming of age (Stand By Me), courtroom (All The President’s Men), fantasy (The Princess Bride), romcom (When Harry Met Sally).

Indeed there can be few directors with a more successful ‘80s than Reiner, with some of the above mentioned films ranking among the most enduring, not to mention the most influential, of their genre. The sheer number of film and TV show creators who owe a debt of gratitude to him and his collaborators is staggering.

Reiner’s latest, more dramatic movies haven’t been at quite this standard, but he has made smart shift back to acting, with his performance in The Wolf Of Wall Street an unexpected delight. His resume can stand up there with the best.


3. Mel Gibson

Daddy S Home 2 Mel Gibson
Paramount

Say what you will about Mel Gibson - and there are, most assuredly, things that need to be said about Mel Gibson - but the man can direct a film. While Gibson’s career wasn’t ailing at the time he made Braveheart, he certainly wasn’t the force he once was. His sophomore effort put him right back on the map, and changed his fortunes entirely.

Follow up The Passion Of The Christ is unsurprisingly a divisive one, but for sheer moxy you’ve got to give him some credit (it was also an incredible money spinner - the man knows business).

His next, Apocalypto, was more like it. An epic tale of the dying days of Mayan civilization, this was pure cinematic Mel. It’s violent, it’s raucous, it’s unbelievable fun. It is based on - but not bogged down by the details of - true historical events. No one else could have made Apocalypto - it takes a man of true bonkers vision and bloodlust.

His latest, Hacksaw Ridge, is a little closer to standard Hollywood fare (though with more guts ‘n’ gore than most films) but serves to solidify his status as an Oscar favourite.


2. Sarah Polley

Stories We Tell Sarah Polley
Roadside Attractions

Polley has made two impressive jumps - first from child actor to successful adult star, and from there to one of the most acclaimed young directors of her generation. After roles in The Sweet Hereafter and Go, Polley directed her first feature at age 27.

2006’s Away From Her would be a commendable movie from anyone, but for someone so young, it was all the more impressive, dealing so heartbreakingly with topics of dementia and infidelity. Polley, whose script was Oscar nominated, coaxed a career best performance from veteran actress Julie Christie, who also gained well deserved Academy attention for her work.

Her next film, Take This Waltz, was a similarly honest and unsparing look at marriage and lust, with Michelle Williams typically superb and rare serious turns from comedians Seth Rogen and Sarah Silverman. Polley’s films are free from cliche and approach well worn topics with totally fresh approaches.

Best of all, though, is her 2012 documentary Stories We Tell. It’s best viewed without knowing too much but suffice to say it’s a bold exploration of Polley’s own family past, with home movies, interviews, and reenactments used to tell a difficult tale.


1. Clint Eastwood

The Dead Pool Clint Eastwood
Warner Bros.

Even without his directorial work, the erstwhile man with no name has a resume to be proud of, with a classic in every genre. Add in his second life as an auteur, though, and Clint Eastwood has arguably one of the best careers the movie business has ever seen.

Known for his remarkable work ethic, Eastwood churned out films from his first screen appearance, and learned at the feet of directors Don Seigel and Sergio Leone. He first stepped behind the camera with Play Misty For Me, but moved onto the genre for which he’s most famous, westerns. Few can have had such an impact on a single genre - Eastwood has reinvented it repeatedly, culminating in 1992 Oscar triumph Unforgiven.

He casts himself a lot, but he’s able to do so with precious little vanity, giving choice roles to the likes of Morgan Freeman, Hilary Swank, and Kevin Costner, and leading many performers to awards glory.

Now 90 years old, he shows no signs of slowing down, and is still making fascinating and varied movies. He sings, too, but he’s not quite so good at that.


Watch Next


Famous Film Directors And Their Works Quiz!

The French Connection Gene Hackman
20th Century Fox

1. Which Film Director Earned An Academy Award For Best Picture For "The French Connection?"

In this post: 
Argo
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Yorkshire-based writer of screenplays, essays, and fiction. Big fan of having a laugh. Read more of my stuff @ www.twotownsover.com (if you want!)