10 Greatest Directorial Film Debuts

Directors have got to start somewhere! Here are ten of the greatest directorial debuts!

Reservoir Dogs Tim Roth Mr Orange
Miramax

Over the course of 120 years of motion pictures, the radical evolution of filmmaking could never truly have been envisioned by even most ambitious of cinema’s early innovators.

Sound, colour and CGI are just a few of the thousands of developments and techniques that have ultimately transformed the film industry into the world’s most celebrated artform. However, more than a century on from the early classics of Georges Méliès and Charlie Chaplin, one component of the filmmaking process remains at the heart of any production: the director.

Critical to the visual style and creative direction of the film, a director’s responsibility to dictate the actors and crew has predominantly stayed the same, whether it be the studio productions of “Hollywood’s Golden Era” or the Blockbuster Epics of “Modern Cinema”.

The art of directing is one that requires a multitude of skills, which in most cases takes years of training and practice to expertise. Regardless, directors have to start somewhere and as shown by the films on this list, directing can be just as much of a gift than a skill that can be mastered. This list will look at ten of the most impressive directorial debuts.

10. Mel Brooks – The Producers (1967)

The Producers
Embassy Pictures

Comedy great Mel Brooks began a stellar career as one of the genre's greatest personalities with the groundbreaking and controversial black comedy, The Producers. Brooks' story revolves around a theatre producer's efforts to create the worst Broadway musical of all time.

The concept is simplistic and innocent on paper, but never afraid to push the boundaries, Brooks decided to make said musical a love letter to Adolf Hitler!

Written by a deranged former Nazi, "Springtime for Hitler: A Gay Romp with Adolf and Eva at Berchtesgaden" is a sincere romanticized depiction of Nazi Germany in a musical format.

As the first slapstick comedic depiction of the evil Nazi regime would inevitably be slammed by some critics as tasteless and vulgar. Overtime these mixed reviews were eventually squashed by the film's prolonged legacy, with the musical gaining cult status and later becoming a real show on Broadway!

Brooks would win his only Academy Award for the musical, winning Best Screenplay in what was a rare triumph for the comedy genre at the Oscars. The Producers was also the first of a series of collaborations with close friend Gene Wilder, with Blazing Saddles (1974) and Young Frankenstein (1974) also gaining a cult following.


9. Charles Laughton – Night Of The Hunter (1955)

Night Of The Hunter
United Artists

Whilst Charles Laughton may not be a household name, his one and only directorial contribution to cinema is today regarded as one of the greatest films of all time. His flick, The Night of the Hunter, is a wicked trailblazing thriller about a minister-turned-serial killer planning to steal $10,000 dollars from a naive widow.

Starring Robert Mitchum as the cruel and deceiving Reverend Harry Powell, the character is regarded as one of cinema's greatest villains, with Powell's cold hearted demeanor frightening audiences for generations.

Unlike most thrillers of its era, The Night of the Hunter has aged particularly well in regards to both the story's content and visual appeal. This can largely be credited to Laughton, who successfully conveyed the dark and morbid content of the original novel into a suspenseful cinematic classic.

Despite the film's legacy and influence on the thriller genre, the film was initially both a critical and commercial failure. The movie's early struggles ended any hopes that Laughton had regarding any further directorial opportunities and so he swiftly returned to the stage and film studios to continue his impressive acting career.


8. Greta Gerwig – Lady Bird (2017)

Saoirse Ronan lady bird
A24

Whilst Greta Gerwig technically co-directed a successful Independent film in 2008, for the purpose of this article, I will consider her first solo directorial picture that was released more than nine years later.

The gender barriers of the film production system is an ongoing problem that continue to plague film studios across the world. With Lady Bird, not only was Gerwig able to break through the many obstacles that female directors face, she was also able to create one of the best coming-of-age dramas of the past decade.

Featuring a career defining performance by Oscar favourite Saoirse Ronan as the "girl on the wrong side of the tracks", Lady Bird was a hit with audiences and critics alike. The film was nominated in five categories, including Best Director with Gerwig becoming just the fifth woman in the ceremony's ninety years to be nominated for the award.

Gerwig would be recognised for her achievements by being named on Time magazine's most influential people list of 2018. She has since followed up her solo-debut film with a successful adaptation of the classic novel Little Women and is quickly developing into one of cinema's rising talents.


7. Kevin Costner – Dances With Wolves (1990)

Dances With Wolves Kevin Costner
Orion Pictures

The nineties was a special decade for Kevin Costner, with actor soon becoming one of the most recognisable men in Hollywood. Building on his early strong performances in The Untouchables (1987) and Field of Dreams (1989), Costner used his rising profile in Hollywood to form his own production company with producer Jim Wilson.

The company's first produced film was Dances with Wolves, with Costner simultaneously producing, directing and acting in the three-hour Western epic. He had come a long way from that field in Iowa!

The film was both a commercial and critical success. Making $424 million worldwide, Dances with Wolves was nominated for twelve Academy Awards, winning seven. Costner would be awarded with the Best Director Oscar and the film would become the first Western to win Best Picture since Cimarron won all the way back in 1931!

Credited with relaunching the genre, the epic would be followed by another Western Best Picture in Clint Eastwood's Unforgiven (1992), with many more classics of the genre to follow in the decades since.

Costner would not return to directing for several years, deciding instead to pursue more acting roles. Whilst Costner has yet to replicate the success of his first directed film, Dances with Wolves remains one of the most critically acclaimed portrayals of American Indian culture in film history.


6. John Singleton – Boyz N The Hood (1991)

Boyz N The Hood
Columbia Pictures

A Los Angeles native, John Singleton used his real life experiences from his younger years as an inspiration in his debut film Boyz n' the Hood.

Initially writing the screenplay for a film school application, Singleton eventually directed the film in 1991 for Colombia pictures, who trusted that the young filmmaker would be able to pull off the project. The coming-of-age drama follows a young Cuba Gooding Jr, who is forced to live with his father in the gang hotbed of South Central Los Angeles.

The studio's faith in Singleton was rewarded, with Boyz n' the Hood proving to be both a commercial and critical success. Despite having a low budget, the film made $65 million at the box office and Singleton would become the first African American director to be nominated for the Best Director award.

The film was part of a new era of African American cinema with Singleton and fellow filmmaker Spike Lee leading the movement.

Boyz n the Hood also proved to be the breakout movie for various Hollywood stars. In addition to the aforementioned Gooding Jr, rapper turned actor Ice Cube, Angela Bassett and Regina King all benefited from the success of the film.

Singleton would go on to have a successful and memorable career in Hollywood, before his unexpected death in 2019.


5. Dennis Hopper – Easy Rider (1969)

Easy Rider
Columbia Pictures

A landmark film for not only its cultural significance, but also its influence on Hollywood, Dennis Hopper's Easy Rider captures the counterculture movement of the 1960s.

Featuring one of the best film soundtracks of all time, the road drama follows bikers Hopper and his close friend Peter Fonda's journey across the American South. Fueled by drugs, sex and rock n' roll, the movie is a psychedelic adventure into the communal and free living lifestyle of the hippie generation.

Easy Rider is one of the key influential films that changed the landscape in Hollywood. Alongside Bonnie and Clyde (1967), The Graduate (1967) and various others, Easy Rider was critical to the transfer of power in the film industry, with young ambitious filmmakers taking creative control away from the studios.

Challenging traditional cinema with a fresh style and adherence to realism, New Hollywood would dominate the box office for the duration of the 1970s.

Hopper's groundbreaking first contribution to this movement would be awarded with two Oscar nominations and in 1998, the film was selected for preservation at the US National Film Registry.


4. John Huston – The Maltese Falcon (1941)

Bogart The Maltese Falcon
Warner Bros.

Considered my many to be Hollywood's first major noir film, The Maltese Falcon is often credited with transforming American cinema into a golden era of morally flawed detectives and femme fatales.

For main actor Humphrery Bogart, the movie was instrumental in his sudden rise to the top of Hollywood in the 1940s and the same can be said for the actor's close friend and Maltese Falcon director, John Huston.

During his time in Hollywood, Huston did it all! Screenwriter, actor, producer, director, the filmmaker was a titan of the film industry and with The Maltese Falcon he directed his first all-time classic film.

Based on a novel of the same name, the film follows a private detective who stumbles across a hunt for the treasured Maltese Falcon statue. One of the most recognisable props in film history, the deadly competition for the statue is classic noir, with deceit and suspicion around every corner.

The Maltese Falcon would be nominated for three Oscars and in 1988, the noir classic was one of twenty-five classic American films to be preserved at the inaugural National Film Registry.


3. Sidney Lumet – 12 Angry Men (1957)

12 Angry Men
United Artists

Sidney Lumet had a noteworthy fifty-year career in Hollywood. The director earned himself four Best Director Oscar nominations for films such as Dog Day Afternoon (1975), Network (1976) and the Paul Newman legal drama The Verdict (1982).

But it would a different courtroom drama that immortalized the director in cinema history, 12 Angry Men. Making the transition from television to the silver screen, Lumet would be awarded with his first nomination and more than sixty years on from its release, the film is still regarded as one of the greatest films of all time.

With the exception of the opening and closing scene, the entire story is filmed in the jury room. Henry Fonda is cast as the story's hero as the only holdout of the twelve man jury. Unwilling to sentence the defendant on the evidence provided, Fonda and the other jurors debate if the crime committed is beyond reasonable doubt.

Over the course of the next hour and half, Lumet captures the infighting, conflicts and underlying disputes of a hung jury, making for a captivating watch. The classic movie's interpretation of racism and legal ethics have aged extraordinarily well and it remains essential viewing for any law student.


2. Quentin Tarantino – Reservoir Dogs (1992)

Reservoir Dogs Trunk
Miramax

Quentin Tarantino introduced himself to audiences the only way he knew how with blood, violence and a lot of profanity! Produced on a small budget, Reservoir Dogs is regarded as one of best independent films of all time.

Despite the film's limited budget, the cast is an impressive mix of future stars and cinema veterans. Tim Roth, Steve Buscemi and Michael Madsen were all examples of good casting choices, but the pickup of cinema legend Harvey Keitel was a sign of what was too come. So impressed by the original script, Keitel agreed to both co-produce and star in the ambitious filmmaker's debut movie!

The follows a group of thieves involved in a heist gone wrong and as the non-linear story slowly unravels, all is revealed. Tense and brutal throughout, Reservoir Dogs continues to captivate audiences almost thirty years after its release.

The movie did not make the biggest splash at the box office, barely making a profit from its initial release. However, following the release of Pulp Fiction (1994) the crime drama found new audiences across the world and is now regarded as a cult classic. Tarantino continues to produce twisted and overtly violent films to this day, not that anyone is complaining of course.


1. Orson Welles – Citizen Kane (1941)

Citizen Kane Orson Welles
Warner Bros. Pictures

Was this ever really up for debate? Regarded by many to be the greatest film of all time, it was inevitable that Orson Welles' legendary tale about wealth and power would be number one on this list.

Exempt from the control of the studios, Welles was a visionary whose production of Citizen Kane has become developed into Hollywood legend. Whether it be Welles' war with media mogul William Randolph Hearst or the controversial history regarding the authorship of the screenplay, the mystery drama continues to be appreciated, more than 80 years after its release.

As for the film itself, Citizen Kane changed cinema forever. Featuring dozens of innovative camera and editing techniques, the movie is an impressive cinematic experience for a film made in 1941, overcoming the typical issues that usually limited studio productions during that era.

Welles' vision is enhanced by an excellent screenplay and story, that provided audiences with some of the best lines in cinema history and an underlying message that resonates to this day.

Some suggest that having Citizen Kane as his debut film was a curse on Welles, with expectations for his future films being almost impossible to beat.

Asked years later whether he thought his first film was the greatest of all time, Welles replied "No certainly not, my next one is". That question is up for debate. But when it comes to debut films, Welles' Citizen Kane is undoubtedly the greatest.


Contributor
Contributor

Film and history enthusiast, writing articles about some of cinema's best from both the past and present. Find me on Twitter @JThurstance