10 Greatest Ever Oscar Shocks
The Academy doesn't always play it safe...
The Oscars are an opportunity for the movie biz to throw itself a party, to celebrate another year of important work and to dole out prizes for the great and good alike. It is also, more often than not, about as predictable an evening as you can hope to see.
As soon as the nominations come out, most years you can pinpoint who’ll win what, right down to the nature of speech the recipient will make (self-deprecating, gushingly gracious, and political being the three main flavours). The Oscar bait pictures roll out in the winter, the stars go on the charm offensive, and the show goes on as it must.
Every once in a while, though, the system gets a shock. A rank outsider wins a big prize; a hot favourite is hit with a snub. Some would suggest that the ceremony is nothing but a big backslapping festival, and that awards for art are basically pointless. For better or for worse, though, the Oscars are still capable of doling out a grand shock, of making themselves the centre of another debate.
10. How Green Was My Valley Beats Citizen Kane
There are plenty of smaller films that have overcome the odds to beat cinematic behemoths - Annie Hall and Rocky winning in the years of Star Wars and Jaws, for example. Only How Green Was My Valley, though, has beaten what is often considered the greatest film of all time.
Orson Welles, one of the business’ true geniuses and innovators, won a grand total of one Oscar - best screenplay for 1941’s Citizen Kane.
The best picture gong went to How Green Was My Valley, the story of troubled times in a Welsh mining town. In fairness, this was hardly a no-name indie picture - it was directed by the great John Ford, and has serious studio heft behind it. From a modern perspective, though, it seems bizarre that the academy didn’t recognise something as genuinely game changing as Citizen Kane (along with the equally forward thinking Maltese Falcon).
In the end, Citizen Kane’s lack of academy recognition has only added to its mystique, a film outside of its own time. And as for Orson Welles, going home without a statuette for his directing prowess hardly did him any harm.
9. The Marisa Tomei Conspiracy
A 1992 comedy starring Joe Pesci as a live wire lawyer is near enough the opposite of Oscar bait, which is why Marisa Tomei’s Mona Lisa taking the prize for best supporting actress remains such a shocking choice. That she beat the likes of Vanessa Redgrave and Judy Davis makes the moment all the more astonishing.
What’s disappointing, if unsurprising, is that folk ever since have been unable to simply be happy for Tomei, instead crying conspiracy (the theory being that elderly host Jack Palance struggled to read the card, shooting out the only name he could remember in a panic).
Not only is that mean, it’s completely missing the joy of Tomei’s performance. Comedy frequently gets a hard time at the Oscars, and it seems here that critics have deemed Tomei unworthy of recognition on the basis the film was of a lighter weight than the others.
To take that position, quite frankly, is to be an enemy of fun. Tomei lights up the screen in her every scene in My Cousin Vinny, and has proven ever since that she is a quality actress (with a further two Oscar nominations in the ‘00s). There’s more to life than period dramas.
8. Forrest... Gump
1994 was a great year for cinema. Pulp Fiction showed the world what Tarantino could do with a budget. Four Weddings And A Funeral mastered the rom com. The Shawshank Redemption engraved itself into the pantheon, and the underrated Quiz Show spun a black web of American media scandal.
Naturally, the best picture went to Tom Hanks doing a funny voice over clips of important historical events for two hours. A tasteless spectacle in less gifted hands and pretty much the same in Hanks’, Forrest Gump is a schmaltzy and troubling saga which remains mystifyingly popular today.
Hanks won back to back Oscars after deservedly triumphing for his heart breaking turn in AIDS drama Philadelphia. Morgan Freeman (career best in Shawshank), especially, must have been aggrieved. Gump won fans as well as detractors and it’s a film of bravura and ambition, but the sweetness and slush drips off every frame. It’s celluloid diabetes.
The ‘90s are often heralded as an era of bold and original filmmaking, when the old rules went out the window and the new generation turned things on their head. Forrest Gump is a saccharin Zelig imitation which has only gotten worse with age.
7. The Moonlight Debacle
The Oscars ceremony is a whirlwind of moving parts, with hundreds of participants, performers, and awards recipients. As such, it is stage managed to within an inch of its life. Still, sometimes things go wrong, and they don’t go much more wrong than Faye Dunaway reading out the wrong best picture winner at the end of the 2017 ceremony.
It’s a car crash moment, as the erroneously announced cast and crew of La La Land joyously swarm the stage, only for the film’s producer to curtail the festivities. With commendable grace and restraint, he corrects the error, and Moonlight gets the gong.
A colossal and hilarious blunder which no doubt caused panic behind the scenes, the best film certainly won here, with Moonlight, a gorgeous coming of age story, far more deserving than the serviceable but safe La La Land. The Moonlight crew are delighted but too staggered for long speeches - never a bad thing.
A great night for director Barry Jenkins and co, a bitter pill for the losers, and a surefire striking off the invitations list for Faye Dunaway (and co-presenter Warren Beatty who, in handing her the fateful envelope, sells her right down the river).
6. Parasite!
The first foreign language film to scoop best picture, the first winner of Canne’s prestigious Palme D’or to do so since 1965 - the 2020 Oscars were good to South Korean cinema and for Bong Joon-ho. Trumping more traditional Oscar fare like 1917, Parasite was the shock of the night, and the best decision the academy has made in many a year.
The acerbic class comedy was, admittedly, second favourite to take the prize, but the coronation of 1917 seemed nailed on. While it’s not traditional Oscar bait, it boasts many academy friendly qualities - it’s based on true events, has an acclaimed director, is somewhat worthy. Parasite, meanwhile, is an oddball of a film, uproariously entertaining but with a dark and cynical edge. It asks uncomfortable questions about our class systems, and offers none of the easy answers the academy voters tend to gobble up.
Most notably, though, it’s not in English, which shouldn’t be - but until now always has been - the great stumbling block for Oscar voters. Whether this opens the floodgates or just speeds up the inevitable US remake remains to be seen, but it can only be a good thing when the best picture actually wins Best Picture.
5. Bob Fosse: Best Director
The first two instalments of the Godfather trilogy are as Oscar laden as they come. Two of the decade’s defining films, each snagged the best picture award, with Brando and De Niro (but not Pacino, on which more later) recognised for their shared role as Vito Corleone. Surprisingly, though, the first film did not garner a best director award for Francis Ford Coppola. This instead went to Bob Fosse, for musical masterpiece Cabaret.
This was a bold move on the part of the academy, and while Coppola would of course have been a worthy winner of the gold, Fosse was the right choice. A bleak and bawdy musical about Nazis, the film is all moving parts and breathtaking set pieces.
It took a certain type of singular creative talent to bring something like this together - frankly it could only have been genius control freak Fosse. That’s not to say that what Coppola achieved was in any way easy, but as far as bringing a vision to the screen, Cabaret could have been made only by someone with the nous and the brash confidence of Fosse.
Coppola would go on the scoop the statuette for Part II, and rightly so. Fosse would sadly die at age 60 in 1980. It’s heartening that a talent so singular received such recognition before then.
4. Crash
Taken in isolation, Crash is a mediocre movie. There are some strong performances and an admirable sense of ambition, but it’s heavy handed in its message, and simplistic with it. As a Best Picture winner? It’s nothing short of crazy.
Writer/director Paul Haggis clearly had his heart in the right place in trying to make a major movie about racism, but he misses the mark badly. Crash has very little insight to offer on the subject of racism, other than that it takes many forms and is bad. None of the individual strands of the anthology piece would be too bad on their own, but they come together to form something worse than the sum of their parts as a multitude of bigoted characters have their broadly racist views challenged in the city of Angels.
Making matters worse, far better films – most notably Brokeback Mountain – were up for the big prize that year. Hollywood dinosaurs Tony Curtis and Ernest Borgnine refused to watch Ang Lee’s powerful drama out of rank homophobia, making it all the more disappointing that this bland morality piece scooped the top gong.
3. Art Carney Beats The Greats
Albert Finney, Jack Nicholson, Dustin Hoffman, Al Pacino, and Art Carney. One of those is not like the others. It was a surprise in 1975 when Carney took home the best actor prize for Harry And Tonto, in which he plays a widower travelling across America with his pet cat. In 2020, it seems frankly mad.
Carney is brilliant in the somewhat-forgotten road movie, bringing a lifetime of experience to a wonderfully written role. But to say he’s up against some heavyweights is to seriously undersell the situation. Not only are the actors giants, some of the roles are humongous, too.
Nicholson at a then-career best as Jake Gittes in Chinatown. Pacino reprising - and bettering - his performance as Michael Corleone. Finney and Hoffman play Hercule Poirot and Lenny Bruce respectively. It’s not a knock on Carney, but perhaps the Serious Actor In An Important Role vote was split, allowing the veteran to sneak in with his gentle and warm turn.
Harry And Tonto has not stood the test of time like some of the other films mentioned, and the other actors (save Finney, outrageously) would eventually taste Oscar gold. It’s a good thing, then, that Art Carney got his moment, even if it still seems very, very odd.
2. The Snubbing Of Martin Scorsese
On the surface, Dances With Wolves and Ordinary People don’t seem to have much in common. One is an epic, elegiac western; the other a taught family melodrama. What links them is that both are directed by all American actors who successfully migrated behind the camera – and both kept Martin Scorsese from getting his hands on an Oscar.
Kevin Costner and Robert Redford are certainly worthy of awards recognition, but at the expense of two of Scorsese’s finest pictures – 1980’s Raging Bull and 1990’s Goodfellas? Something doesn’t add up. Whether it’s an aversion to darkness and violence from the elder statesmen of the academy panel or rewarding two long term actors for stepping out of their comfort zone, for a long while Marty was always the bridesmaid, never the bride when it came to the Oscars.
Scorsese finally won a best director award in 2006 for The Departed, a good film if not a great one. And while no one will begrudge one of Hollywood’s true masters, it’s a shame he wasn’t rewarded for one of his true classics.
1. Green Book
In what will likely remain the most bizarre academy decision until the next one, no one expected the co-director of Dumb and Dumber to be picking up an award for best picture. Green Book, not unlike Crash, wants to be on the side of the angels. It wants to give us a thoughtful look at bigotry and remind us that it’s really not OK! Instead, it’s a pretty middling drama that somehow sealed its place as 2018’s best film out of all the films.
Admittedly, this wasn’t a bumper year for nominations. Films like BlackKklansman and The Favourite are perfectly good films, better than Green Book, but wouldn’t be in with a shout at most Oscars. Still, this ham fisted (if well acted by Viggo Mortensen and, especially, Mahershala Ali) story of a black jazz musician teaching his white driver to be less bigoted was a shocking choice. The film came under criticism for leaning on the white saviour trope, and for bizarrely neglecting the chance to speak to the subject’s living family.
Green Book could easily have faded into obscurity, a run of the mill, nicely acted picture with little to stick in the mind. Instead, it became an outstanding piece of Oscar lore, though not for the right reasons.