10 Groundbreaking Films That Are Actually Terrible

This is probably not what ‘bad influence’ is supposed to mean.

Avatar Jake
20th Century Fox

When something’s pioneering, hugely influential, perhaps even trailblazing, people tend to put it on a pedestal. They’re not always wrong to do so - after all, influential, gamechanging movies are bound to be classics of their genre, right?

Well, no. The only maxim in Hollywood that’s ever been proven 100% true 100% of the time is screenwriting legend William Goldman’s motto: nobody knows anything. No one in the movie industry has any clue what’s going to work and what isn’t, and they never have: so which means that when something does work, it tends to get slavishly copied until everyone’s sick of it.

So sometimes ‘hugely influential’ is just shorthand for ‘hugely commercially successful’ - and you can’t ever guarantee that a movie’s success is going to be inextricably linked to its quality.

However, in other cases these monumental films of the past simply haven't weathered well. Perhaps events since their release have coloured the way we look at them and the attitudes that gave birth to them. Perhaps they’ve lost a lot of their lustre in the intervening years - or perhaps, stripped of the weight of so much accrued cultural baggage and held up on their own, they were never especially good films to begin with.

Here are ten examples - ten influential but terrible movies that inspired, and continue to inspire the moviemakers that followed it despite their shortcomings. Time to make burgers out of those sacred cows...

10. The Blair Witch Project (1999)

Blair Witch Project
Artisan Entertainment

There were cheapass found footage horror movies long before The Blair Witch Project, of course - the notorious Cannibal Holocaust immediately springs to mind.

However, Eduardo Sanchez and Daniel Myrick's no-budget superhit created a tsunami of imitators, some actually rather good, some DTV-terrible. As far as its influence goes, the film’s place in cinema history is inarguable.

Here’s the thing, though - take away the hype, the legacy and that innovative immersive marketing campaign, and The Blair Witch Project is not a good or even entertaining movie. For about seventy minutes, very little happens while the camera focuses - because it has no choice - on the only three actors in it.

Actually, the camera barely even does that. The found footage conceit and the dodgy production concept mean that we’re treated to some of the hammiest improvised acting ever seen - only out of shot, off-frame or out of focus, which is what happens when you get three inexperienced actors to shoot your movie themselves.

In fairness to Sanchez and Myrick, their canny marketing transformed this bug into a feature… but perhaps it would have been better as a taut, nail-biting thirty-minute short. We’ll never know, because the whole thing clocks in at a turgid eighty-one minutes of nothing at all, shot and cut like cr*p.


9. Love Actually (2003)

alan rickman love actually
Universal Pictures

You’ll probably already be familiar with the scornful feminist deconstruction of Love Actually that’s become prevalent over the last decade. It’s totally on the money.

The runaway success of Love Actually inspired so many other mediocre ensemble comedies - often also set around a Hallmark holiday - that listing them feels like padding the word count. Unfortunately, the women in this film get short shrift. Love Actually is a movie about men, and boys, and men acting like boys, who treat women as property that they deserve to own.

Almost none of the women in Love Actually have personality, agency or (let’s face it) dialogue. They’re there for men to perve over, pine over, angst over and, in the slapstick sense, fall over. You could replace 90% of the female characters with cartoon cardboard cutouts and not only would no one would notice, but you wouldn’t need to change the blocking.

There are two exceptions to that male-focused rule. There’s Emma Thompson’s gabby and fun Karen, positioned as a best friend and wife (not as a person, god no) who is punished for having both opinions and dialogue by being cheated on and humiliated. Meanwhile, Laura Linney’s office sad sack Sarah is inevitably c*ckblocked by her disabled brother for wanting something other than just to look after a man.

Love Actually was Richard Curtis’ directorial debut after establishing himself as the king of the sh*t-Brit-rom-com screenplay. Directors are supposed to reveal something about themselves with their movies… but not like this, Richard. Not like this.


8. The Birth Of A Nation (1915)

The Birth of a Nation
D.W Griffith

D.W. Griffiths’ magnum opus is one of the most groundbreaking movies ever made, a landmark in cinematic history.

This epic silent drama was the first twelve-reel film ever made - and also the longest ever made at that point in cinema history, some cuts exceeding three hours long. Detailing the assassination of Abraham Lincoln and American society through the Civil War and Reconstruction eras, it was incredibly ambitious for the time, the first film to have a musical score, introducing techniques like close-ups and fade-outs that would become part of the vocabulary of the cinema.

It’s also horribly, horribly racist, portraying black men as dumb, sexually aggressive animals who posed a threat to white women and based on a book - The Clansman - by a white supremacist, Thomas Dixon Jr.

This is not a modern interpretation of the film: there were widespread protests from African-American activists across America when it was first released, and the National Association For The Advancement Of Coloured People attempted (unsuccessfully) to have it banned for inciting hatred against the whole race.

The Birth Of A Nation was also responsible for the resurgence of the Ku Klux Klan only months after its release, given that it presented the then-defunct outfit as a heroic force for America.

Technically brilliant, hugely ambitious, unbelievably influential? Absolutely - but what an awful, awful shadow legacy this awful, awful movie has.


7. Pulp Fiction (1994)

Pulp Fiction John Travolta Uma Thurman
Miramax Films

As a pop culture phenomenon, 1994 belonged to Pulp Fiction. The soundtrack, the performances, the unutterable cool of the movie - it changed the game for badass, slinky cinema, not to mention the fortunes of many of the cast. But divorce the film from the cultural context, and how does it hold up?

Like a house of cards in a high wind, unfortunately. Pulp Fiction has no real story, no narrative direction. As a result, it has no protagonist, no one to follow over two and a half hours of weary meandering - it’s just a collection of cool scenes featuring cool people being cool. There’s plenty of rhyme, but no reason for any of it.

It’s also where we first see warning signs of QT’s worrying fetishisation of black men and black culture, with his overuse of the n-word - and there’s an even more worrying homophobic issue with the film that’s never been explained or resolved. A quarter of a century on, it’s a film clearly made by an arrested adolescent with little in the way of emotional intelligence.

After Pulp Fiction, Tarantino was at a fork in the road. He could grow up, follow Reservoir Dogs and deliver on his stellar talent… or he could plunge down the Pulp Fiction rabbit hole and spend his career making cartoons in his own weird, self-indulgent, hyperreal Wonderland, saying nothing about real people in the real world.

The impeccable Jackie Brown shows the road not taken - but everyone knows what path Tarantino chose.


6. Avatar (2009)

Avatar Sam Worthington
20th Century Fox

Even without that box office world record, Avatar's position in film history is unassailable. After decades of 3D being treated as a gimmicky fad, it's a permanent fixture in the cinema - and it works, thanks to Avatar.

Sadly, the film itself is dreadful. James Cameron's filmmaking obsession has always been with emerging technology, not storytelling, and his 'white saviour' plot - a Good White Dude joins an indigneous community to become the best of them all, saving them from the Bad White Dudes and getting the girl - is derivative, predictable and cringeworthy.

It's not just the plot, though. The disconnect between the human protagonists and their avatars is massive, so everything we learn about Jake Sully becomes irrelevant once he goes native.

Unfortunately, any attempts to get to know this new Jake or the People he's befriending fall utterly flat. The Na'avi may be amazing technical advances in performance capture and animation, but Cameron and his cast and crew have no idea how to blend the two to create a character: the performances aren't big enough for animation and the animation isn't nuanced enough for performance. The result? Deathly dull cartoons.

Avatar is a VR theme park ride riddled with patronising, boring bullsh*t. If you're into that kind of thing, you can turn your brain off and go "wooooooo!" a lot for about half of this long, awful movie... but, like everyone else, you'll forget about that 'unforgettable experience' as soon as the credits roll.


5. Breathless (1960)

Breathless (1960)
StudioCanal

Jean-Luc Godard is one of the most influential and important writer/directors in cinema: an icon in the industry whose contributions to the French New Wave have rippled out across the world. You can argue that he’s the wellspring from which our modern understanding of film editing gushes forth, if you want to be fancy about it.

Breathless, his first feature-length project, is the story of a criminal and the girlfriend he hides with while on the run for killing a cop. Its influence can’t be underestimated: it’s been the precursor for so many sophisticated crime dramas over the intervening sixty years that to excise it would leave the history of film with more holes than a fishing net.

And it’s a woeful film. Strip away the influence, the hype, the cool and you’ve got an outlaw country song updated for French hipsters. That’s a three-minute song about a boy and his fifteen minutes of fame, but it’s not a narrative worth ninety minutes of anyone’s time.

Godard’s reinterpretation of structure in shooting a script helped to bust myths about what could and couldn’t be done in cinema… but it makes for a dreary, formless film, all style and no substance, as shallow as a puddle.

The one thing that made Breathless compulsive viewing was its radical nature, but this is 2020, and we see a little clearer now. Sixty years on, it’s not new or exciting, and what’s left isn’t remotely interesting and has nothing to say.


4. The Curious Case Of Benjamin Button (2008)

Benjamin Button Brad Pitt
Warner Bros.

TCCOBB (as all the groovy kids are calling it) is a film that succeeds in its vaulting technical ambitions and fails absolutely everywhere else.

TCCOBB received thirteen Oscar nominations, including the nod for all the top awards except Best Lead Actress - yet all it won was make-up, visual effects and art direction. Damned with faint praise - you have to rate David Fincher’s accomplishment, but dear god you don’t want to ever have to sit through it again.

It’s certainly something to hold up as an example of what can be done - but it’s a terrible film, meaningless and callow. Fincher is not the man to direct a slow-moving drama about epoch-defining love: his best movies are merciless, highly crafted slices of high-concept cinema, arch and cold, and unfortunately so is this.

Nearly three hours long, TCCOBB moves like treacle, as though every moment was designed to be weighty - but because it’s so inconsequential, going for sentimentality or artifice over depth every time, that slowness becomes torpor, pompous and self-indulgent.

You don’t ever get the impression that Fincher is as interested in the story or the people in it as he is the cunning way he’s telling it, which would be fine for a thriller or a horror movie, but not at all for the ethereal drama he’s aiming for. There are no grace notes despite the technical beauty of the visuals, no breathless moments that might make you want to come back. What a waste of time.


3. Triumph Of The Will (1935)

Triumph of the Will
Universum Film AG

A companion piece to The Birth Of A Nation? Unfortunately, yes.

Leni Riefenstahl was an astonishing, undeniable talent in cinema, the German Orson Welles: a fêted female producer, writer and director at a time when women had no agency in the industry at all. Triumph Of The Will is a remarkable example of propaganda in cinema, technically pioneering and innovative, a globally award-winning film whose influence is still being seen in documentaries and advertising to this day.

That propaganda, though. The theme of the film is Germany’s return to prominence under Der Führer and the Nazi Party following the Night Of The Long Knives, and Adolf Hitler’s presence haunts it even when he’s not lovingly framed on camera - he was heavily involved in commissioning it and making it, as much as any strong-arm Hollywood producer would be today.

Trimuph Of The Will is Nazi propaganda from the very first frame, and Riefenstahl, for all her arresting gifts, made her most career-defining work for the Nazis and specifically for Hitler.

That context alone makes that Triumph Of The Will a ghastly piece of work, one which history has deservedly cr*pped on from a great height.


2. Manhattan (1979)

Manhattan Woody Allen
United Artists

Woody Allen practically invented the wry, not-quite-funny, romantic comedy with this, his wry, not-quite-funny ode to New York and the mid-life crisis, soaked in Gershwin and angsty whimsy. Manhattan is a beautiful looking movie, a beautiful sounding movie. The problem with Manhattan? It’s Woody Allen.

Regardless of your opinion of the more serious allegations against him, it’s a matter of record that Woody Allen has always been predatory towards teenage girls. According to journalists who’ve read Allen’s private papers collected at Princeton University, the auteur’s predilections are heavily, creepily documented. He’s literally spent decades writing obsessively about older men obsessing over teenage girls.

For all its surface beauty, Manhattan is just another example. In fact it may be the worst, given that one of those teenage girls Allen obsessed over was Mariel Hemingway, the actor who he cast, at 16 years old, to play Tracy, the 17-year-old girlfriend of his 42-year-old character Isaac in the movie.

‘Tracy’ was reportedly a composite version of at least two of Allen’s past teenage girlfriends, and Hemingway found herself nearly becoming one herself when, after the film’s release, he invited her to Paris with the aim of seducing her. The kiss they share in the film was Hemingway’s actual first kiss ever: he insisted upon it, and she begged not to have to do it again.

Nothing about this is okay, and it’s sickening to see people raving about a movie in which a middle-aged man dramatises his real-life sexual relationships with teenagers, starring a 16-year-old he wanted to sleep with.


1. Batman (1989)

Tim Burton Batman
Warner Bros

The impact from Tim Burton's Batman was seismic: it paved the way for the superhero revolution in the cinema in the 21st century.

Seminal grim n' gritty comic book stories like Batman: Year One and The Dark Knight Returns had persuaded Tim Burton to sign onto the long-running Batman movie project, having initially balked at a retread of the camp sixties-style Batman.

There was only one real snag with that: Burton wasn't a superhero fan, or an action movie director. He didn’t make blockbuster movies and he had no idea how to handle studio interference. Okay, that’s a lot of snags.

A little distance from the film's massive cultural impact reveals all the cracks. Almost entirely lacking in plot, its inconsistent tone the consequence of dozens of piecemeal rewrites during the shoot, Batman is a mess - no more so than at the end.

The original ending called for the Joker - Jack Nicholson, doing a vaudevillian version of his usual schtick - to murder Kim Basinger’s Vicki Vale, but producer Jon Peters had begun sleeping with Basinger during the shoot and changed the finish without telling Burton, so that the Joker kidnapped her instead. The inexperienced director, who’d completely lost control of the production by that point, began shooting the new ending with no idea where it was going, essentially making it up as he went along.

The confused, slapdash film that emerged from that godawful shoot is far camper than Burton ever intended: a cautionary tale in how not to let a studio run rings around you.


In this post: 
Avatar
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Professional writer, punk werewolf and nesting place for starfish. Obsessed with squid, spirals and story. I publish short weird fiction online at desincarne.com, and tweet nonsense under the name Jack The Bodiless. You can follow me all you like, just don't touch my stuff.