10 Harry Potter Characters Who Were Sorted Into The Wrong House

The Hogwarts Sorting Hat made a number of significant errors over the years...

Hermione young
Warner Bros.

Every Hogwarts student has been sorted into one of the four houses. For the most part, the Sorting Hat has made the correct choice. However, that does not mean that the famous hat has not made some mistakes over the years.

Due to the fact that the Harry Potter series was focused on Harry, Ron and Hermione, there was always an overemphasis upon Gryffindor. Crucially, there were a significant number of Gryffindors who – upon closer inspection – were sorted into the wrong house. Though this was partly true in regard to the other houses as well, Gryffindor was undoubtedly the house with the highest number of wrongly-sorted students.

In this sense, J.K. Rowling missed an opportunity to enrich the other houses with more prominent individuals. Even some of the most important characters in her story did not necessarily fit the criteria of the house she put them in…

10. James Potter

Lily Potter Harry Potter James Potter
Warner Bros.

Sorted House: Gryffindor

Correct House: Slytherin

James Potter was not heavily featured throughout the series because the bulk of the story took place long after his death. The information that was offered, however, suggested that he should not have been in Gryffindor.

In The Order of the Phoenix, Harry experienced some of the actions of his father via the Pensieve, and said actions were far from brave or noble. Purely for entertainment, James humiliated Snape without warning in front of a number of onlookers. He also had an irritating habit of showing off his Quidditch skills by playing with a recently caught Snitch.

In this sense, James was more like a Slytherin than a Gryffindor. In particular, his unprovoked attack on Snape was pure cowardice, and his constant desire to show off and be noticed suggested that he was someone who enjoyed the spotlight.

Granted, this moment was only a small snippet of James’s life, but there was little evidence to indicate that he belonged in Gryffindor based on Harry’s experience in the Pensieve.


9. Neville Longbottom

Neville Longbottom
Warner Bros.

Sorted House: Gryffindor

Correct House: Hufflepuff

Neville was occasionally brave throughout the Harry Potter series, but he was also very cowardly at times as well.

He was always terrified of Professor Snape during his time at Hogwarts, and he was not the best at standing up to bullies such as Malfoy.

On the other hand, Neville did exemplify many of the traits of Hufflepuff. As a member of Dumbledore’s Army, he worked harder than anyone else to improve his magical ability under Harry’s tuition, and he was one of the few to go to the Ministry of Magic in the finale of The Order of the Phoenix.

Said actions indicate how Neville was more hardworking and loyal than he was brave, and as a result, Hufflepuff would seem the more obvious house to put him in.


8. Cormac McLaggen

Harry Potter Cormac McLaggen
Warner Bros.

Sorted House: Gryffindor

Correct House: Slytherin

Cormac McLaggen was only featured in The Half-Blood Prince, and there was nothing at all within this sixth volume of the series to suggest that he should be in Gryffindor.

McLaggen’s main relevance to the plot was to act as Ron’s rival for Gryffindor Keeper. After losing out at the try-outs, McLaggen was bitterly resentful, arguing that Ginny had given Ron an ‘easy save’.

His unpleasant actions were further exemplified when he was required to play Keeper when Ron was in the Hospital Wing. Rather than doing his job, he insisted on telling the other players what to do, believing that he knew better than they did.

This big-headed attitude ultimately led to him knocking out Harry with a Beater’s bat when he was trying to demonstrate how to use it properly.

Such self-centred behaviour had no connection to the qualities of Gryffindor. Had McLaggen been a Slytherin, on the other hand, this behaviour would not have been surprising.


7. Quirinus Quirrell

Snape And Quirrell Harry Potter
Warner Bros.

Sorted House: Ravenclaw

Correct House: Slytherin

Professor Quirrell’s house was never actually revealed in The Philosopher’s Stone. Thanks to Pottermore, however, fans of the series were able to learn more about Harry’s first Defence Against the Darks Arts teacher.

Due to his actions in The Philosopher’s Stone, Slytherin seemed the obvious house for Quirrell. Surprisingly, he was actually sorted into Ravenclaw.

As a student, Quirrell was often bullied at school due to his nervous demeanour. This neglect led him to pursue power in the hope of feeling a greater sense of pride and importance, which by extent drew him to Voldemort.

Quirrell may well have been clever, but he was clearly more interested in power than wisdom.


6. Fred And George Weasley

Fred And George Weasley
Warner Bros.

Sorted House: Gryffindor

Correct House: Ravenclaw

Fred and George only obtained three OWLs each, and such an academic record certainly does not suggest that the famous Weasley twins should have been in Ravenclaw. Outside of their school studies, however, they demonstrated a remarkable level of intelligence.

Their knack for creating both amusing and useful magical items was unmatched, and even Hermione complemented their abilities on more than one occasion. Indeed, she described their Patented Daydream Charms as ‘extraordinary magic’.

The twins were also intelligent in regard to business acumen. They knew precisely how to market and sell their products, as well as how to bring in huge profits for their work.

Though they had their moments of bravery, their unique talents would suggest that the Sorting Hat should have put Fred and George into Ravenclaw rather than Gryffindor.


5. Gilderoy Lockhart

Gilderoy Lockhart Harry Potter
Warner Bros.

Sorted House: Ravenclaw

Correct House: Slytherin

Professor Lockhart was a fraud. For no other reason than the desire for fame and money, he published a number of books that were false accounts of his magical abilities.

In reality, the only spell he was any good at was the Memory Charm. Armed with such a spell, Lockhart had tracked down many heroic witches and wizards, questioned them about their honourable and challenging deeds, before then wiping their memories and claiming all the glory for himself.

In this sense, Lockhart was clearly someone who sought power and influence rather than wisdom. The desire to maintain his reputation even led him to threaten Harry and Ron with a Memory Charm whilst down in the Chamber of Secrets.

Though the method he used to become famous was a smart idea, Lockhart’s actions and ambitions were clearly that of a Slytherin.


4. Percy Weasley

Percy Weasley  Harry Potter
Warner Bros.

Sorted House: Gryffindor

Correct House: Slytherin

Percy was another member of the Weasley family who should not have been in Gryffindor. There was little to suggest within Rowling’s seven Harry Potter novels that he was a particularly brave person.

He was, however, very ambitious. Even whilst he was at Hogwarts, Percy was a little too proud of being both a prefect and head boy.

After leaving school, his desire for power only intensified. Following Voldemort’s revival at the end of The Goblet of Fire, Percy denied the Dark Lord’s return and also neglected his family. Before leaving the Burrow, he claimed that Mr Weasley had no ambition, which was why the family had never been particularly wealthy.

He then remained loyal to the Ministry of Magic until the finale of The Deathly Hallows, during which he apologised for his behaviour. Despite this act of redemption, Percy was undoubtedly a wizard who valued ambition above bravery, loyalty, or wisdom.


3. Hermione Granger

Hermione Harry Potter
Warner Bros.

Sorted House: Gryffindor

Correct House: Ravenclaw

Practically speaking, it would have complicated the story to have put Hermione in a different house to Harry and Ron, yet there’s no denying she was more suited to Ravenclaw than Gryffindor.

Throughout the series, Hermione was always willing to accompany Harry on his numerous adventures at Hogwarts and beyond. This willingness to face danger was certainly strong evidence that Hermione was a genuine Gryffindor.

Nevertheless, Hermione’s intelligence was always more prominent than her bravery. She continuously outperformed her fellow classmates, including those in Ravenclaw. Indeed, with the exception of Quidditch, there was no part of her magical education that she did not excel at.

Hermione was also a highly pragmatic person. Harry’s quest to find and destroy Voldemort’s Horcruxes would have resulted in failure had it not been for her magical skills out in the wilderness.

Consequently, Ravenclaw House were robbed of an outstanding student when Hermione was sorted into Gryffindor.


2. Peter Pettigrew

Peter Pettigrew Harry Potter
Warner Bros.

Sorted House: Gryffindor

Correct House: Slytherin

Why the Sorting Hat believed Gryffindor to be the right house for Wormtail will always be a mystery.

Though he was a friend of James, Sirius and Remus, his admiration for them stemmed from his desire to be around those with power and influence rather than because he felt any genuine affection for them.

Indeed, he was a spy for Voldemort during the First Wizarding War, and upon becoming the Potters' Secret-Keeper, he immediatley betrayed their location to his master.

Despite the fact that he was loyal to Voldemort, he was also terrified whenever he was in his master’s presence. Whereas most Death Eaters admired and respected the Dark Lord, Pettigrew seemed to act out of fear rather than loyalty.

Given such factors, the Sorting Hat’s decision was completely nonsensical.


1. Albus Dumbledore

Albus Dumbledore Richard Harris
Warner Bros.

Sorted House: Gryffindor

Correct House: Ravenclaw

Professor Dumbledore was the epitome of wisdom. Few characters in fiction have ever possessed such a powerful aura of intelligence and knowledge.

Like Hermione, Dumbledore was undoubtedly brave. He always dominated any conversation he was involved in due to his effortless wit and confidence, and his ability to remain calm in the face of danger was incredibly courageous.

Nevertheless, the reason why he was able to be so brave was because of his intelligence and wisdom. Indeed, throughout his life Dumbledore achieved some truly remarkable feats, the best of which was his defeat of Grindelwald in 1945.

Dumbledore’s dialogue was also a delight to experience. He had far more quotable lines than any other character due to the vast amount of wisdom he obtained during his long life.

As brave as Dumbledore was, there is no denying that this great wizard should have been a Ravenclaw.

Which Harry Potter character do you think was sorted into the wrong house? Share your thoughts below in the comments thread.


Harry Potter Book Quiz: How Well Do You Know The Chamber Of Secrets?

Dobby House Elf
Warner Bros.

1. After Dobby Uses A Hover Charm, Harry Is Sent A Letter From Which Ministry Official?

In this post: 
Harry Potter
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

Love to read and write. Have an unhealthy obsession with Harry Potter. Enjoy running up hills.