10 Harry Potter Plot-Holes That Are Actually Aren't

Annoyed at Potter critics poking fun at your favourite series? Prepare to fight back.

Harry Potter Goblet
Warner Bros.

Harry Potter is a beast, a near epoch-defining work of fiction so entrenched in our culture that it is near impossible to imagine our world without it (almost like Frozen, but without the singing).

With that kind of influence it should came as no surprise that it is one of the most heavily scrutinized series in history, and with fans combing the books with the keen eyes of Sherlock Holmes it should also come as even less of a surprise that mistakes have been found.

Some are valid, such as when, during the Priori Incantatum incident in Goblet of Fire, the echo of Lily Potter appeared before James Potter despite the fact that James was killed first. But a great many are not and while seeming to be iron-clad, bonafide plot-holes, are in fact easily explained with only a little careful thought.

Normally this type of list demands a fair bit of, how shall we say? out-of-the-box creative licence (*cough* Unapologetic BS *cough*). But with Harry Potter there is no need. Because such is JK Rowling’s attention to that detail that, channel your inner Sherlock hard enough and you’ll find the evidence you’re looking for.

So, let’s dive into some of the mistakes and find out why the mystery lies not in the mistake, but in the reason why it was considered a mistake in the first place.

10. Why Did No Other Nation Stand With Britain Against Voldemort?

Harry Potter Deathly Hallows Neville Longbottom
Warner Bros.

The Plot-Hole

The British were left to fight Voldemort entirely on their own. But with the threat he poses why did other nations not send forces to help?

But Wait...

Simple, the answer here is Dumbledore.

Dumbledore was internationally recognized as the only wizard Voldemort feared. It is logical, then, to go one step further and assume that only Dumbledore could defeat him. With Dumbledore dead resistance against Voldemort would be seen as pointless, as would be sending wizards to help fight him.

Instead many nations would see to their own defence, hoping to make one last defiant stand on their home ground. Many others would probably wait to see how the war progressed in order to decide whether to spin at least a passable excuse for their inaction or just how quickly to grovel at Voldemort’s feet. Some had likely already sent envoys suing for peace.

Rather than being a plot-hole the absence of the wider world is a perfectly understandable response to an extremely difficult situation. Cause when you're staring down the barrel, it's awful hard not to cower.


9. The Trace Is A Nightmare For Parents?

Dobby House Elf
Warner Bros.

The Plot-Hole

The logic behind The Trace is a touch wonky. If it detects magic cast around under age wizards should it not be a constant source of frustration for parents?

But Wait...

Make an addendum to the established lore and the solution to the conundrum is simple. That the Trace does not activate in the case of parents’ spell-casting indicates that the Trace can differentiate between those who do – and do not – have a Trace on them. Ergo, as far as the Trace is concerned, as long as magic is cast in the presence of someone who does not have a Trace on them then that person must, by definition, be of appropriate age.

A definition as basic as this leads to inevitable loopholes, one of which brings us to the question of Dobby. Prejudice against House Elves is characteristic of even the pre-Voldemort era, with the House Elves being seen as little more than menial servants. That a House Elf would act on their own initiative outside of the will of their master is something that likely never occurred to the wizards who created the Trace. Dobby, being the unusual Elf that he is, knew of the loophole and was smart enough to exploit it.

What of the Muggle-born Hermione? The Ministry must have notified the Grangers that their daughter was a Witch and, to help them cope, would have added a bit of magic to prevent false alarms.

As for Tom Riddle killing his father? Well, you don’t send a reprimand to a murderer – you send the police, and Tom was obviously long gone by the time the Aurors arrived.


8. Why Did The Death Eater's Not Remove Harry's Glasses When Duelling Voldemort?

Harry Potter Goblet Of Fire
Warner Bros. Pictures

The Plot-Hole

The claim is that, had Voldermort removed Harry’s glasses during their duel in Goblet of Fire the now visually-impaired Harry he would have been easily beaten.

But Wait...

Harry is not blind: his eyesight may be poor enough to require glasses but he can still see without them. Even should his vision be little more than a watery blur, if the blur is moving and talking with Voldemort’s voice then that is where the danger lies.

More importantly, this is The Boy Who Lived, the wizard who had ostensibly defeated him as a mere baby. Voldemort needed to dispel any notion that Harry was special: handicap him in any way and Voldemort sows doubt as to his own supremacy, doubt that, at that moment, could have shaken the faith of his supporters.

In the end the point is moot as Harry, even with perfect eyesight, would never defeat Voldemort in a fair duel, something that all fans know. And so, this is not a plot-hole, or even a plot convenience, but a case of fans doing as we do and, bless our little hearts, being characteristically pedantic.


7. Why Does Harry Rush To The Ministry Without Contacting Sirius?

Harry Potter Order Of The Phoenix
Warner Bros.

The Plot-Hole

Upon receiving a vision of Sirius in Voldemort’s hands Harry turns full maniac and charges off to the Ministry without ever thinking to check in at Grimmauld Place.

But Wait...

This is a classic case of those who proclaim the plot-hole forgetting what was written in the books, because Harry did attempt to contact Sirius.

Recall that the sole reason why Harry broke into Umbridge’s office was to use her fireplace, this being the only one still connected to the Floo Network. Harry succeeded in contacting Grimmauld Place but found only Kreacher, who deceived him by implying that Sirius had been captured. With all available evidence pointing to the truth of the vision what reason did Harry have to believe otherwise?

Harry is reckless and impulsive and, let’s be honest, not the smartest hero to ever grace the pages of a novel. But in this case he showed admirable and uncharacteristic restraint, and was simply outplayed by forces that understood him better than he understood himself.


6. Why Does Voldemort Not Force The Death Eaters To Take An Unbreakable Vow Of Loyalty?

Lord voldemort
Warner Bros.

The Plot-Hole

Voldemort is not the most trusting of people. Why then does he not demand that the Death Eaters make an Unbreakable Vow of loyalty to him?

But Wait...

Well, it's because loyalty does not work that way.

Voldemort’s ideology revolves around the belief in pure blood supremacy, where a perfect, unblemished race rules over lesser specimens by right of inherent superiority. The Death Eaters follow him because they share that ideology, leaving little need to compel them into a vow of obedience.

Also, Voldemort does not portray himself as a dictator but a visionary, a first among equals. Compelling loyalty through threat of death, as would be the case with the Unbreakable Vow, would undermine his vision of an elite pure-blood utopia by setting him up as tyrant. Far from making his followers loyal this would breed resentment, even lead to a to reluctance to join his crusade.

Voldemert may not the best strategist but he understands the merits of offering the carrot rather than brandishing the stick, and inviting his followers to share in the spoils is better than holding a gun to their heads.


5. The Portkey In Goblet Of Fire Makes No Sense?

Harry Potter Portkey
Warner Bros.

The Plot-Hole

By activating through touch and then transporting Harry back to Hogwarts, the Portkey in Goblet of Fire breaks all of the established rules.

But Wait...

That's true, but that does not mean that this is a plot-hole.

In Philosopher’s Stone Dumbledore modifies the Mirror of Erised – a powerful magical object – to function in a manner it was never designed to, and if the rules of the Mirror could be broken by a skilled wizard then so too can the rules of a Portkey. Thus, for Barty Crouch Jr, masquerading as Mad-Eye Moody, modifying the Triwizard Cup to act as a Portkey that could activate by touch would have been simple.

What of the two-way nature?

Well, who’s to say that Crouch Jr was the only one to have modified the cup? Recall that in Philosopher’s Stone Dumbedlore allowed Harry, an untrained eleven-year-old, to face the dangers of the Forbidden Forest, a monstrous three-headed dog, five deadly challenges, and the most dangerous wizard alive.

Taking the infamous gleam of triumph into account, it is quite possible that it was Dumbledore who modified the Portkety to act as two-way device, intending for Harry to be captured specifically in order for Voldemort to use Harry’s blood in his resurrection. It is that blood, let us remember, that allows Harry to survive his final confrontation with Voldemort.

While it may seem to be a blind roll of the dice this is in fact the kind of calculated risk that brought Dumbledore great success, and ultimately, victory.


4. Why Did Harry Not Use The Time-Turner To Prevent His Parents' Deaths?

time turner
Warner Bros.

The Plot-Hole

The Time Turner is able to take a person back in time. It should be easy for Harry to go back and, if not beat Voldemort, at least warn them. That way his parents will be alive in the future.

But Wait...

Thing is, this is not Star Trek. Despite the fact that JK Rowling has stated that the Time Turner only allows travel six hours into the past, thus rendering this plot-hole moot, the Time Turner does not allow travel back to the present. Should Harry somehow manage to succeed in thwarting Voldemort he would be trapped in the past, forced to watch his infant self grow up alongside his – the infant self’s – parents.

And therein lies the rub. While past Lily and James would do their utmost to care for the deeply traumatized future-Harry they would never be his parents: future-Harry was an infant when his parents were murdered – he never knew them and they never knew him. Worse, even should he be able to return to the present he would find parents who had never lost their son: the Harry they know would be completely different to the person time-travelling Harry is.

Harsh though it is, even should he succeed the people Harry wants so desperately to save would always be strangers to him. Heartbreakingly, the echoes Harry sees of them will forever be the closest thing he gets to ever meeting his parents.


3. Wizard Schools Are Rubbish?

Hogwarts Great Hall
Warner Bros.

The Plot-Hole

Wizard children may be able to count to ten but when they go to school all they learn is magic. What about engineering and science and advanced mathematics?

But Wait...

This is not so much a plot-hole but an inevitable consequence of using magic.

Because wizards have no need of the Muggle sciences. For us, building something even as simple as a house involves a great deal of time and effort. For wizards, as seen in Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them, putting a devastated neighbourhood back together is the task of only a few minutes.

Hagrid exemplifies this attitude when he states that the reason why wizards remain hidden is due to Muggles inevitably wanting magic solutions to their problems. Ergo, we Muggles are inferior.

Except we are not.

Consider another ‘plot-hole.’ Why can wizards do nothing about Harry’s poor eyesight? To solve the problem we Muggles have to form a deep understanding of physiology and the genetics involved in order to determine the root cause. This can take decades. But once the cause is determined tools such as CRISPR promise to provide us with the means of rectifying the problem at the genetic level. Wizards have no such knowledge and no such tools.

Magic works quickly and can easily solve most problems. But, without the need to go any further it becomes a crutch, a self-imposed ceiling born of convenience. Wizarding schools are letting their students down, but due to understandable and myopic reasons rather than the result of a plot-hole.


2. Why Weren't Lily And James Their Own Secret-Keepers?

Lily And James Potter
Warner Bros.

The Plot-Hole

The Fidelius Charm functions by hiding a secret within a human soul. As long as that human doesn’t spill the beans the secret remains safe. For Lily and James, being their own secret-keepers should have been the obvious choice.

But Wait...

What we have here is a classic case of thinking with the benefit of hindsight. We, the reader, know that Peter Pettigrew was corrupted because we are told that he is, but Lily and James had no such secret insight. Remember, James had no reason to distrust Peter: Peter had kept the secret of Lupin’s lycanthropy for decades and had been one of the architects of the Marauder’s Map. He was in James’ inner circle and as trustworthy as he could possibly be.

It is also a tragic case of idealism trumping sense. Dumbeldore himself offered to be the Potter’s secret-keeper, a choice we can all agree would have been ideal. However, Lily and James refused, preferring to put their faith in their friends. With how rife enmity and distrust were at the time of the First Wizarding War this belief in trust was a practical – and powerfully symbolic – means by which to resist Voldemort’s poisonous influence.

Unfortunately, noble as the ideal was, they were mistaken.

As a silver lining the lesson was learned and come the Second Wizarding War Bill and Arthur Weasley functioned as their own secret keepers. A hard price to pay, but at least the loss was not in vain.


1. Ollivander Should Be Broke?

Ollivander and Harry Potter
Warner Brothers

The Plot-Hole:

In Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince Slughorn states that the price of Unicorn hair is ten galleons, yet Olivander sells his Unicorn hair wands for seven. Wizards clearly don’t understand economics.

But Wait...

Except, they do.

Ollivander collects his wand core materials personally: in Goblet of Fire he mentions nearly being gored by a Unicorn after plucking a hair from its tail. We also know that Fawkes gifted the feather that forms the core of Harry’s wand. Seeing that Ollivander procures these materials for free he can hardly be operating at a loss.

Consider also that we are dealing with retail. It is quite possible that Ollivander leverages his reputation as a legendary wand maker into a discount from wholesalers, something his lesser competitors cannot do. Even slyer, with wands being a compulsory item on the school shopping list Ollivander can afford to charge less - thus making him the preferred source for exclusive and cash-strapped parents alike - and still turn a handsome profit. Far from being ignorant, Ollivander is one properly canny businessman.

Or, as is most likely, the ten galleon price is a case capitalism at work and the poor customers were simply being ripped off. Even in the wizarding world some things never change.


In this post: 
Harry Potter
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Marcellus Huisamen hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.