10 Henchman Movie Roles Made Epic By Casting
Jonathan Banks was always an imposing hitman.
Actors love to talk about playing the villain. It's a favourite topic that often comes up in interviews, particularly in certain episodes of Inside the Actor's Studio. The key, actors say, is to never play it as though your motives are impure, but lean into it fully and play the part as if convinced your actions are just. It's a wise piece of advice, and it's evident in some of the best villain roles in history.
Where those actor's tips become more complex is when you're not the lead, when you have to invent more of an M.O. for the character. This is true when you're cast as a second-fiddle henchman. When you're role is often little more than standing around and looking imposing, your mind tends to go places.
Many films have utilized the henchman or lackey role ingeniously, turning narrative contrivances on their head or using them as blunt instruments of masterminds. On other occasions, they're the hidden masterminds themselves.
The role of the henchman should never be underwritten or ignored, as they can always strengthen an action picture, particularly when there's an action beat missing. But here are some that just by casting alone made the part something a little more than just an obstacle for the hero to overcome.
10. Bokeem Woodbine - The Rock
From The Rock's opening moments, you know you aren't in for your typical action film - a bit of a surprise from Michael Bay. General Francis X. Hummel he lays out his motive and logic for taking over Alcatraz with hostages and chemical weapons. And they're the only reasons for terrorism a movie audience will accept: America betrayed he and his fellow soldiers for fighting honourably. The solution, in his warped mind, is to fight dishonourably.
That's enough to make everyone's veteran father in the crowd tear up. Unfortunately, Hummel hired bloodthirsty mercenaries (hiring Candyman and Melvyn from Renaissance Man wasn't ideal), and they betray him the moment he has a change of heart.
The cast is stacked with a veritable who's who of character actors, from the aforementioned Tony Todd to old reliables like David Morse and John C. McGinley.
But of the impressive crew of villains, a young Bokeem Woodbine seems out of place. Woodbine, then unknown, plays Gunnery Sergeant Crisp, who wears his inexperience on his face throughout the movie. Woodbine doesn't have many lines, making it all the more impressive. He mostly stands around in the background, but his uncertainty about what they're doing is obvious.
That's what makes it all the more heartbreaking when he's ordered to pull a gun on his commanding officer. The doubt, the concern is so obvious right up until he takes a bullet to the chest. The look of shock on his face is palpable.
9. Kurtwood Smith - Robocop
Someone at FOX saw the dynamic between the band of rouge criminals in Paul Verhoeven's Robocop and thought they had terrific chemistry, because nearly 20 years after its debut, cast members starting showing up randomly as guests on 24.
While it was a nice nod toward the film's legacy, it did make the crucial mistake in breaking up the band. Its leader, Kurtwood Smith, was now a crusading Senator.
Nevertheless, Verhoeven's original brings a kind of manic energy to the action genre that was already jacked on cocaine, and his sharp satiric tongue turns downright acidic whenever he points it toward America.
A lot of the energy relies on the cast, headed by Kurtwood Smith on the villain side. As Clarence J. Boddicker, Smith is the kind of quotable crazy most other eighties villains aspire to. He's unpredictable, coked to the gills and remorseless. Using his short stature to his advantage, he plays a cagey, fast-talking sociopath with absolutely no charm.
There's even a moment in which he tries to flirt with a secretary, only to be rebuffed. He'd perfectly fit in a Frank Miller comic - ironic considering the writer worked on the franchise one film later. All of this is in service of the film's big reveal, that Smith is just a pawn of OCP corporate criminal Dick Jones. It's not meant to be played as much of a shock, but it wouldn't have worked at all if Smith weren't so intimidating for the film's first half.
8. William H. Macy - The Lincoln Lawyer
Not all henchmen are playing on the wrong team, but they're often underused. Brad Furman's The Lincoln Lawyer seems to exist as a movie out of time. It would have been a blockbuster if it were made in the heyday of John Grisham adaptations, where Mathew McConaughey reigned supreme. But by 2011, the actor had already re-invented himself, further embracing his offscreen stoner persona. Seeing him back in the shoes of a lawyer, even one whose scruples were less laudable than those from his Grisham days, was discombobulating.
It was far from a flop, but it's not a particularly memorable film. Which is a bit of a shame, because The Lincoln lawyer is a brisk, serviceable courtroom picture that just happens to contain one of the best performances to come out of a nothing part.
William H. Macy's hard drinking private investigator Frank Levin works for McConaughey, and he's every bit the cliche he sounds like. The role could best be likened to Donald Sutherland's in A Time to Kill, a wise, drunk elder character who's seen everything and is more than a little jaded. They serve the same purpose as a henchman, doing the busywork. But few people play world-weary drunks as well as Macy, with his sallow, tired eyes saying far more than words.
Unfortunately, Levin is also a character clearly written to die, with his death being telegraphed early in the film as a key motivator for McConaghey. In a better world, he'd had a spin-off.
7. Harry Morgan - The Big Clock
You've likely seen a version of John Farrow's The Big Clock and don't realize it, as Kenneth Fearing's 1946 novel about a newspaper writer trying to solve a murder for which he's about to be framed was adapted with an upgraded Pentagon setting as No Way Out with Kevin Costner and Gene Hackman.
Morgan, best known for his work as Sgt. Potter on M*A*S*H and Bill Gannon on Dragnet, shows up about halfway through the picture. As the actual murderer of his mistress, the editor (Charles Laughton) turns to some unsavory types to handle his mark (Ray Milland) once he is revealed.
Morgan doesn't have a lot of lines, mostly just lumbers around intimidating the lead through the newspaper offices. But Morgan, who only stood at 5'5, was hardly an imposing figure. He always had the wiry frame audiences knew as the elder Sergeant.
Nevertheless, he manages to add a legitimate air of menace, stalking the halls of a newspaper office alongside George Macready. Farrow's decision to dress a character in all black in a black and white film paid off. And it's retroactively unnerving to see a man who was primarily known for his grandfatherly roles or no-nonsense law and order figures play someone who, at a moment's notice, will throw you down an elevator shaft.
6. Martin Landau - North By Northwest
It's still surprising that Mel Brooks' send-up of Hitchcock films, High Anxiety, isn't as well-received as the rest of his seventies output. The Master of Suspense himself reportedly loved it, but critics considered it uneven at best.
Perhaps the disconnect is not any fault of Brooks' film, which is genuinely funny, but that Hitchcock's work required no parody. He had, perhaps even intentionally given his reputation, sent up himself when he made North by Northwest with screenwriter Ernest Lehman whose goal was to write "the Hitchcock picture to end all Hitchcock pictures."
Every trope is there, from his favourite Wrong Man set-up, to perfectly staged moments of suspense that work despite their ludicrous set pieces and a healthy strain of morbid humour. And, in perhaps one of Hitchcock's most common subversive turns, the film's heavy (James Mason) has a henchman with a clear infatuation with his employer.
It's unclear how noticeable it was to audiences in 1950 that Martin Laundau's Leonard was homosexual, but it's obvious now. And he had all the stereotypically over-the-top signifigiers fifties audiences deemed as gay: he was keenly interested in fashion and soft-spoken.
You can't help but feel a little sorry for Leonard when he realizes the love of his life was abandoning him for an undercover spy - and a woman, no less. Landau plays it all-out heartbroken, and his devotion is sympathetic up until the point when our heroes' lives are at his whim.
5. Will Patton - No Way Out
North by Northwest's Leonard was subtle in the sense that he didn't have a coming out scene, but Scott Pritchard's was much clearer in No Way Out.
Taking its cues from Fearing's novel, director Roger Spottiswoode uses his Pentagon setting to maximum effectiveness, ramping up the tension with new technological developments that make Costner's hunt for himself nerve-wrackingly easy. Were it not for a dumbfoundedly silly third-act twist, it'd almost be on par with The Big Clock's pulse-pounding suspense.
And as the ringleader of havoc, willing to do anything to cover up his boss Hackman's murder, Will Patton is downright scary. He's still playing up the same signifiers as Landau, particularly the sycophancy, but its Patton's unpredictable streak make him a legitimate threat.
We know he's a danger to Costner, but by the film's climax it's unclear just how he'll react to betrayal. Hackman is good, but underwritten as the Secretary of Defense with a temper. He's too much of a politician to be frightening. The real power lies in his aide, Patton's gay Stephen Miller-esque prototype.
4. Benicio Del Toro - License To Kill
Audiences have finally come around on Timothy Dalton's tenure as 007, however the films themselves are still not beloved. While he was arguably the first Bond to bring the blunt instrument of Ian Fleming's novels to screen with any faith to the source material, his two entries stand out as, if nothing else, exceptionally weird Bond entries. The Living Daylights at least kept the action within Cold War politics.
License to Kill makes no such effort. It's more like a cop with a grudge picture than a spy movie, and it didn't ingratiate itself with loyalists when it mauled series regular Felix Leiter in the film's first act.
Nevertheless, despite its drenched-in-eighties aesthetic, it's an especially fun Bond film, never losing pace and piling on the levels of absurdity with each plot development.
The film reaches the height of crazy when it winds up on drug lord Franz Sanchez' private drug island, which has its very own Wayne Newton. Throughout his career, 007 has had a habit of collecting a vast array of character actors, from Joe Don Baker to Kill's Everett McGill, but most notable is the mostly silent Benicio Del Toro as Sanchez's mostly wordless henchman.
Del Toro famously turned his dialogue into gibberish in The Usual Suspects after realizing his character didn't add anything to the plot, and he's just as effective here, wordlessly intimidating Bond with nothing but a switchblade.
He also receives a fitting Bond death going through factory machinery.
3. Jonathan Banks - Beverly Hills Cop
Mike Erhmantraut was always a menace.
It's no surprise that Jonathan Banks made a name for himself playing tightly-wound heavies on either side of the law throughout the eighties, but his first two major appearances are: his now-famous short Linda's Film on Menstruation and an early part in Airplane!
But Banks settled into the law enforcement/criminal dynamic pretty early, appearing in Gremlins, Armed and Dangerous, and earning his first Emmy nomination during his four-year run on Wiseguy.
Banks would also pull the cop/criminal duo for Eddie Murphy, first as a cop gunned down in 48 Hrs. and later as the trigger man who kills Murphy's friend in Beverly Hills Cop.
The moment Banks shows up in Cop, it's clear who's in charge. And while he's not the main villain, Banks' quiet menace is far more intimidating than that of the effete Victor Maitland.
Maitland is almost intentionally a weak villain, written to be the polar opposite of Murphy's loudmouth Detroit cop. He's boring by design. Banks, on the other hand, gives the film a villain that will gladly meet Murphy on his terms.
It would be 22 years before Hollywood started nominating him again. He still hasn't won an Emmy.
2. Elisha Cook Jr. - Rosemary's Baby
To understand the importance of Elisha Cook Jr.'s appearance as the landlord of the Satanists' apartment complex in Rosemary's Baby, we first must go back to William Castle.
Castle had become something of a shock-jock version of Alfred Hitchcock, a horror producer and director who became as well-known as the films he put out. Like Hitch, he often appeared in his film's trailers, warning audiences of the dangers of seeing his films.
The dangers were parlour tricks. For The Tingler, a film about a spinal parasite that feeds on people's fears, he had randomly placed electric charges in certain seats in theatres across the country.
But his signature work was House On Haunted Hill, the Vincent Price-led 3D haunter shot at Frank Lloyd Wright's Ennis House. Cook appears as the house's owner, suffering from PTSD having suffered the horrors of the building all his life.
Castle's wanted to adapt Ira Levin's Rosemary's Baby before it had even been published, rushing to producer Robert Evan's office with the galleys. But his B-movie reputation didn't impress Evans, who insisted on his first choice, Roman Polanski.
Nevertheless, Polanski offered Castle a cameo. He's the man waiting for the phone booth.
Cook's role is an extension of that cameo, and he plays the frazzled landlord with the same, harried intensity he brought to House. It's even more effective when you recognize him, as the role is the exact opposite of what he played before - instead of warning Rosemary away, he invites her in.
1. The Entire Crew(s) That Took Pelham 123
Telling a young person today that Walter Mathauu was once a credible action star is a fairly daunting task. The actor, best known for his grandfatherly parts or as Jack Lemmon's schlub foil, had a solid run in the seventies as a more hard-boiled figure, appearing in The Laughing Policeman, Charley Varrick and most notably The Taking of Pelham 123.
From Morton Freedgood's novel, Joseph Sargeant (of Jaws: The Revenge) directed a fairly legendary crew of terrorists who hijack a New York subway car for a ransom of one million dollars. The hijackers call signs - Mr. Green, Mr. Blue, Mr. Brown - would show up in Reservoir Dogs years later.
Mathauu was the wisecracking NYC transit cop tasked with negotiating the ransom.
No great band of criminals would be complete without a great ringleader, and Sargeant had one in Robert Shaw, who played the role with an icy coolness that nicely worked against Mathauu's schlubby cop.
But the crew is rounded out by a gang of mostly name actors - Martin Balsam, Hector Elizondo and Earl Hindman. Balsam is the real standout here, with an eccentricity that winds up being his downfall, but each member brings their own unique brand of menace or incompetence to their role.
The film would see two severely inferior remakes, a TV film in 1998 and Tony Scott's brutally loud 2009 film. But even those manage to round out their cast with character actors - first with Vincent D'Onofrio and Richard Schiff, and then later with Luis Guzman and John Turturro.
Watch Next
90s Action Movie Quiz: How Did The Villain Die?