10 Hilariously Awful Cry-Faces That Ruined Moving Scenes

Even the finest actors struggle when it comes to convincingly bawling.

Being capable of leaking out tears on cue is a great skill for any actor to have in their arsenal. It can sell a scene, make a movie more memorable, and in certain cases even pave the way towards a golden statue at the Academy Awards. However, it's not enough to simply produce gallons of snot and tears when a critical moment arrives, because the act of crying does not guarantee an emotional reaction in an audience. Sometimes an actor's crying technique can be counter-productive - so terrible or distracting that it becomes the main attraction, superseding the emotions that should be the central focus. Even worse, sometimes an actor's crying can be so jarring that it deflates a scene entirely.Through a combination of inhuman mouth shapes, disturbing lip quivers, wild, bulging eyes and high volume shrieking a surprising number of actors have managed to turn what should have been a moment of mournful reflection into something inappropriately laughable, and in the process ruined the entire scene. And frankly, these actors need to be held accountable for their actions...

10. Elijah Wood - LOTR: The Fellowship Of The Ring

During the memorable Mines Of Moria sequence in the first LOTR film, fans were forced to endure easily the most emotionally loaded moment in the entire epic trilogy. Sacrificing himself so that the Fellowship may advance further, Gandalf - unofficial leader, guide and generally useful guy to have around, plunges (seemingly) to his death on The Bridge of Khazad-dûm, which sends the Fellowship into a emotional tailspin. While most of the Fellowship opt for the stiff upper lip, the feckless, curly-haired Frodo (played by Elijah Wood) engages in his typical buffoonery. What's unfortunate about this is that so much about the scene does work, from Howard Shore's touching, lyrical score through Sir Ian McKellen's awesome command of "Fly you fools!" to Viggo Mortensen's quiet look of total devastation. It is an almost perfect scene. But then Wood's acting choices compromise these elements. Not only does he immediately scream out "NOOO!!!" with somewhat inevitable obviousness, but he surges towards the fallen wizard in such a wild, infantile fashion that one would think he was a little boy and that someone had just snatched away his favourite rattle. There is not a shred of nuance here; it's all big eyes and gaping mouth, which are captured in a tight, jarring close-up by Peter Jackson's camera. Maybe the effects of this moment would have been lessened by Wood portraying Frodo as a bit more competent in earlier scenes, but his character is all thumbs throughout Fellowship, tripping over his own feet and being both a physical and emotional burden on the group. Thus, this reaction to Gandalf's death only further highlighted that and unfortunately stymied the scene's considerable power.

9. Harvey Keitel - Bad Lieutenant

Between Harvey Keitel's repulsive albeit powerful performance and Abel Ferrara's grimy, lurid direction, 1992's Bad Lieutenant became so emotionally overwhelming that one might feel the need to take multiple showers after first viewing and then go give their friends and family a reassuring hug. It's a particularly potent effect. Still, there are a few sparse moments that do prove to be unintentionally hilarious, and distract from the film's propulsive force, one of which is undoubtedly a crying scene by Keitel, whose facial expressions and whiny, animalistic moaning make him look more like he is passing a kidney stone than experiencing existential despair. The scene in question sees Keitel's Lieutenant character repent to a vision of Jesus Christ, along side some mind-bendingly bizarre "crying" (if you want to call it that). The result is that you're left wondering if you were supposed to laugh uproariously or cry along with him. In a way it almost works: Keitel's visceral bleating pairs well with his admonishing screams (directed at the vision of Christ). However, when the actor periodically stops haranguing the Lamb of God, and when his face crumbles into that inimitable mixture of beady eyes and elongated mouth, one is hard-pressed not to chuckle.

8. Anne Hathaway - Les Miserables

To some it may seem crazy to criticize Anne Hathaway's lauded rendition of "I Dreamed a Dream" considering how showered with praise she was in its wake. But this isn't intended to denigrate Hathaway per se; the actress clearly went all out to capture the nadir of her character Fantine's existence with the song. But while Anne gets an A for effort, her cry-face is still problematic. Filmed unmercifully by director Tom Hooper in a series of bruising close-ups, Anne's waterfalls of tears, uncontrollable gasping, and the stuttered belting she does to hit all of the requisite notes becomes gradually overwhelming - and not in a good way. The paean inexorably slides from being a shattering depiction of grief and regret to a shattering depiction of an actor's exertions. Essentially, due to the severity of her cry-face, Fantine's emotional journey becomes lost in the bombast of Hathaway's technique.

7. Laura Dern - Blue Velvet

For a majority of David Lynch's Blue Velvet the character of Sandy Williams (played by Laura Dern) is rather forgettable, but this changes dramatically during a scene late in the film when star Isabella Rossellini shows up (battered, bruised and totally nude) at the door of the character played by Kyle MacLachlan. Clearly disturbed, Dern's Sandy soon erupts into a violent crying jag, which unquestionably contains one of the most classic cry-faces in modern cinema. When one watches Dern's face during this scene it's hard not to be distracted, not least because her acting choices are astoundingly over the top. Dern's mouth turns downward into a distressingly inhumane shape, almost like an inverted banana. This, paired with her character's guttural spasms of horror (not to mention that 80s fright wig), imbues the scene with an unfortunately comedic element, something which does partially inhibit the power of Rossellini's brave performance.

6. Natalie Portman - Garden State

It is a well known axiom that Natalie Portman cries in movies, but the image of the actress wracked with sobs has never felt all that convincing. Every time her face starts scrunching up, and every time she bares those pearly whites before letting loose a wail of grief, one gets the powerful, overwhelming feeling that this is an actor acting, not a character feeling something. Never has this been more evident than in Zach Braff's Garden State, especially when Portman's character Sam stages a funeral for her pet hamster. This scene is a rare moment in Garden State where some of the emotions don't seem forced. Braff underplays his character beautifully here, especially when Andrew admits to Sam that his mother has just passed away. Portman on the other hand immediately begins to blubber, sprouting off profound reflections like: "It's so tragic. Isn't it? It's like real life tragedy or something." The vapid nature of these lines is then enhanced by Portman's bizarre crying expressions, which feature characteristically leaky eyes and outrageous eyebrows that look like check marks. It's all just frankly unnecessary: the scene is supposed to be about Andrew's emotional disconnect, which could have still been conveyed without turning Portman's Sam into a hammy caricature of emotional "free-spirited-ness." Yet, Braff went with what was easy, capitalizing on Portman's perpetually tearful face to produce the required contrast between the characters. Unfortunately and ironically though, this made the scene significantly less involving. It revealed Braff's intentions to use the actress for her ability to cry first, and for her ability to build a character second. It would have been a more mature and rewarding scene if Portman could have toned the crying down, or just scrapped it all together.

5. Toby Maguire - Spiderman

Superheroes in general are a moody bunch, but never has anyone sniveled so much in spandex as this particular incarnation of the Web Head, played far too emotionally by Tobey Maguire. Now, there are scores of scenes that were ruined by Maguire's endless sobbing and rubber-faced mugging, but one which towers over the rest occurs in the first film where Maguire's clueless nerd stumbles across his dying Uncle Ben after testing his new Spider-mettle in a wrestling match. To be fair, this scene is probably more detrimental when viewed in the present day. At the time nobody knew how frequently the tears would be rolling for Maguire's Peter Parker; we all figured that it was a one time display of emotional weakness at a crucial point in his origin. How wrong we were. But then, even twelve years ago this cry-face felt a tad ridiculous, especially with the tear drops that look strategically placed, and with his features taking on an even dopier appearance than before. It set the mold for what would gratingly become the actor's trademark as the series progressed.

4. Claire Danes - Romeo and Juliet

Claire Danes is probably the undisputed queen of the ridiculous cry-face. There has rarely been someone so lampooned, disparaged, and occasionally celebrated for this particular facet of their acting. Hell, there is even an official "Claire Danes Cry Face Project" page on Tumblr; her tear-stained mug is that infamous. One of Danes' early roles illuminates the reasons behind this rabid following. During the climax of Baz Luhrmann's opulent adaptation of Romeo & Juliet, which of course features the two youths offing themselves, Danes' cry-face makes a brief but memorable appearance, all but ruining the finale in the process. As Juliet wakes up to find that Romeo has poisoned himself next to her, Danes lets loose with a jarring, volcanic sob, which rips out of her in the way similar to a tot being awoken early from a much needed nap. Now, to her credit, Danes is actually a good actress, whose expressive face has often served her well. Yet, there is such a thing as being too expressive at times. This moment, which sees her face look like it's about to literally explode, is a great example of this.

3. Ewan McGregor - Moulin Rouge!

Much like the film itself, Ewan McGregor's big crying scene during the end of Moulin Rouge! is highly divisive. Some - especially those who buy into the frenzied hyperactivity and garish aplomb of Luhrmann's vision - find the moment shattering, as we see the character's heart flayed open by the death of his love. But there are others who are turned off, considering this yet another moment where the film's bombast is to its detriment. Now, even those who like the scene and the film can probably understand its polarizing effect. In this scene McGregor doesn't just sob, he SOBS. So many things jump out about his acting, from the painful and almost frightening pause he has before the first bout of crying escapes him, to the heavily dramatic way his face is lit during the scene. It all contributes to a moment that can be involving if one has surrendered to the film's huge and wild spirit, but crucially it also detracts for someone who is looking for something with greater emotional specificity and nuance.

2. Edward Norton - American History X

It may seem heretical to speak pejoratively about Edward Norton, especially when he was in his acting heyday back in the late 1990s and early 2000s. Norton was (and still is) a powerhouse actor, capable of delivering intense and believable performances. Still, if there has ever been a weak spot in his acting it has to do with his crying scenes, which for the most part have never felt entirely convincing. Consider the finale of his classic film American History X, where his younger brother, Edward Furlong's Danny has been gunned down in the bathroom of his high school. Everything seems fine at first, especially as Derek runs towards his fallen brother, hoarsely screaming "No!" over and over again. Then things becomes a little less powerful. Derek pulls Danny onto his lap, cradling his head against his chest. He begins to "cry," so to speak, but no tears are in sight. All that we are left with are his expressions, which look surprisingly simulated for an actor of Norton's caliber. Thankfully, the scene is relatively brief, and the impact of Danny's horrific death is only partially ruined.

1. Liam Neeson - Schindler's List

Ever the bleeding heart sentimentalist, it was a great surprise in 1993 when Steven Spielberg released Schindler's List. Finally, Mr. Peter Pan was going to broach difficult subject matter without the crutch of melodrama. For the most part this proved to be the case, but one of the film's final sequences showcases Spielberg indulging in his most fundamental instincts as a filmmaker, and features Liam Neeson's Schindler crumbling into a pitiful bucket of syrupy slop. The scene of course starts strong, with Schindler saying goodbye to his Jews while appearing somewhat shaken due to the sheer emotional weight of the situation. Then everything goes straight to hell, with Spielberg having Neeson collapse into the stoic, supportive arms of Ben Kingsley and then become mobbed by the comforting bodies of the Jews surrounding him. The problem here is two-fold: first, this scene undercuts the rest of the film, which largely refrained from this type of hero worship or emotional manipulation. Second, the way that Neeson plays this moment amplifies its preexisting, problematic nature. Up until this point Neeson had essentially offered a staggering portrait of complex humanism, a highly effective and restrained depiction of an intriguing historical figure. His face and body movements here deflate this. His uncontrollable crying, and especially his huge facial expressions, don't really tell us anything interesting about Schindler's post-war relationship to his actions. They instead speak to Spielberg's proclivity for easy emotional accessibility, which, try as he might, just couldn't be avoided. Do you agree or disagree with the problems with these cry-faces? What do you think should have made the list? Let us know in the comments section below.

Contributor
Contributor

Adam Mohrbacher has been afflicted with an obession for film since his earliest memories. In addition to his work with WhatCulture, Adam has been a contributor with Filmophilia.com, FilmMonthly.com and Examiner.com. You can also check out his personal blog here: adammohrbacher@wordpress.com. A devoted fan of all film genres and styles, Adam gets equally giddy over the sensitive, existential musings of Ingmar Bergman, and the brawny brilliance of Arnold Schwartzenegger. He loves fish tacos and misses the work of Heath Ledger and Jack Lemmon on a daily basis.