10 Horror Movie Nightmares WITHIN Nightmares

Is your totem still spinning? Here are ten horror movie nightmares WITHIN nightmares...

AMERICAN WEREWOLF in London
Universal Pictures

The nightmare sequence holds limitless possibilities for the horror film - dream scapes can be as abstract and imaginative as the writer wants, including the nightmare within a nightmare trope. Also known as the 'false awakening,' this is a weird form of lucid dreaming that means you wake from one nightmare straight into another. It's also one of the sneakiest jump scare set ups around.

Some movies base the entire concept on dreams within dreams (Inception, Waking Life) to great effect, this trope however, is for pure shock factor. Our sleeper wakes from a horrific nightmare and breathes a sigh of relief and suddenly... BOOM! Straight into a second nightmare we didn't even know we were in.

Some of the films on this list are of questionable merit; even Nicholas Cage can't fix the most cynical of remakes but don't worry, there's plenty of top notch horror here too. Brutal revenge thrillers, classic 90s slashers, modern internet urban legends and yes, how could we forget - the purveyor of slumber slaughter himself, Mr. Freddy Krueger makes an appearance too.

Beware of heavy spoilers throughout and keep one eye on your totem - you may very well still be in a nightmare...

10. Jen's Cave Nightmare - Revenge (2017)

Revenge 2017
Shudder/Neon

Revenge does exactly what it says on the tin - this is Mad Max meets I Spit On Your Grave, and is not for the easily shocked. In fact, the opening act is so uncomfortable to watch, it almost strays into a different genre altogether.

Jen is invited to her rich boyfriend's weekend hunting getaway in a remote luxury home overlooking an expanse of desert. When Richard leaves on an errand, his friend Stan viciously sexually assaults Jen, as Dimitri does nothing to intervene. Richard returns to the scene and instead of doing the right thing, he tries to persuade Jen to forget the whole incident. She flees but Richard pursues her, pushing Jen from a cliff and impaling her on the limb of a dead tree. Amazingly, she survives.

She finds refuge in a cave and using some peyote as anaesthetic, cauterises her wounds. She wakes and prepares to leave the cave when Richard suddenly appears and blows her head off with a shotgun, forcing her awake from a drug induced nightmare. She leaves again, Richard shows up with the shotgun, and bang, another nightmare. As she continues to dream, this time it's trippy; lizards, flashbacks, revenge fantasies and once again, she wakes in the cave. That's two fake outs in a row.

By the time she finally leaves the cave for real, the scene is set for her vengeance and you're with her the whole way - Jen deserves every drop of blood she squeezes from these three scumbags.


9. Annie And The Ants - Hereditary (2018)

Hereditary thumb
A24

Ari Aster's 2018 occult horror has been a Marmite movie since release; a series of swish horror cliches or a surreal slow burn tragedy? Whatever. This entry is just about that gnarly nightmare within a nightmare scene - and this one is nasty.

Annie (Toni Collette) greives the death of her weird, secretive mother. In fact, her family is plagued with tragedy; her brother committed suicide some years previously, alleging their mother was in some way responsible. Days later, her daughter Charlie is decapitated in a devastating accident and Annie begins to inwardly blame her son Peter, who was driving the car Charlie was leaning from.

She wakes one night and watches a series of ants crawling over her bedroom walls and traces them to Peter's room, watching in horror as they spew from his sleeping mouth. Peter sits up, ants now gone, staring at his presumably sleepwalking mother. She seems fully awake, yet the scene becomes increasingly menacing as she explains to the terrified Peter that she tried to have him aborted. As the argument escalates, they are suddenly both dripping wet, and in a moment, the liquid ignites and Annie wakes up for the second time.

A classic nightmare within a nightmare, as Aster piles on horror after horror. An essay in grief or Rosemary's Baby's baby? That's up to the viewer but one has to commend Aster on his attention to detail and his ability to wring every ounce of tension from a scene.


8. Cage Falls Asleep On A Bench - The Wicker Man (2006)

The Wicker Man 2006 Nicholas Cage
Warner Bros

OK, yeah, alright, we know. If ever there was one film to be committed to Room 101 it is Neil LaBute's catastrophic disaster that DARES to call itself The Wicker Man. The original is a bonafide masterpiece, so really don't bother too much with this one, apart from this nightmare sequence, which is actually genius, just not for the reasons you think.

Cage plays Edward, a traumatised cop who's asked by his ex to find her missing daughter. She lives on Summersisle, a rural matriarchal community off the coast of New England and before long, Edward finds himself at the centre of a conspiracy. Why do people who are planning to murder a cop behave so suspiciously? Is that really Aaron Eckhart in the diner at the beginning for all of two seconds? How do you un-see this film?

Anyway, Cage manages to fall asleep on a bench by the harbour (we know how he feels) and dreams of seeing Rowan floating lifelessly in the water. He removes his jacket and performing one of the strangest 45 degree angle dives into the water ever put on film, he swims toward the floating corpse. All of a sudden, he wakes from the nightmare, still on the harbour and looks down to see the sopping body is now on his lap and wakes for a second time - a clear as day, a nightmare within nightmare.

The best part, however, is Cage shouting "GODAMM!T!" as he recovers. Unintentionally, utterly hilarious.


7. Demonic Babe In The Woods - Brightburn (2019)

Brightburn Brandon
Sony

Brightburn is a nice change of tone from the average kid-with-powers movie and while perhaps not terribly well executed, the horror approach is welcome, albeit familiar.

Tori and Kyle Breyer long for a child of their own. When a spacecraft containing a baby crashes into their farm land, they decide to raise him as their own. Some years later, the kid, now Brandon, is an adolescent with more than acne and girls on his mind - he's alien with some nifty X-Men style powers (he can throw lawnmowers really far). He also a psychopath and before long, he's too much for mum and dad to handle. Just think of a young Clark Kent - if he was the Antichrist.

This nightmare within a nightmare is different here but still counts; it's just in reverse. Here the short sharp shock comes first, as dad Kyle dreams of kissing Tori, before she screams in reaction to something. As Kyle wakes up in bed, he steadies himself and glances to his left; the wall has merged into a forest - Kyle is still in a nightmare.

This is where the slow burn comes in, usually reserved for the first nightmare. He walks through the forest at night and find Tori nursing a baby at the alien craft crash-site. Peering closer, he sees the baby begin to ooze blood and finally looking at its face, the eyes begin to glow red.

A nice sequence in a half-way decent serial killer sci-fi horror movie.


6. Teenage Pregnancy - Slender Man (2018)

Slender Man
Sony

The Slender Man urban legend began life as an online photoshop competition hosted by the site Something Awful, which posted two cleverly doctored photos depicting a strange, tall, thin, faceless man wearing a black suit lurking in the background of some seemingly innocuous shots. The result was nothing short of a viral sensation with a fully fledged narrative - it wasn't long before a movie was developed and tragically, an attempted murder case in the US was 'blamed' on The Slender Man. Despite the controversy, the movie went ahead, with mixed results.

Four pals hear of the legend of Slender Man and decide to invoke the myth himself, so when Katie goes missing, Wren, Hallie and Chloe must find a way to stop him before they all end up as a statistic of alleged Slender Man victims.

In this nightmare sequence, Hallie wanders into the woods behind her house at night, hearing the voice of her missing friend Katie calling her name from the darkness. When he finally appears, reaching out with his breadstick fingers, she wakes suddenly, back in her bedroom. Making her way to the bathroom mirror, she suddenly appears to be full-term pregnant and tendrils burst from her stomach, prompting the second, screaming true awakening - she is still dreaming.

The film is a pretty worn out retread of teen horror scream-fests, but it's the appeal of Slender Man as a villain that makes this fun-but-formulaic horror worth a glance up from your phone.


5. A Nightmare On Syd's Street - Scream 3 (2000)

Scream 3 Cast
Dimension

Wes Craven movies were never likely to win any Oscars but then again, he really understood the genre, inventing some of the most popular franchises we have today. Aside from the Nightmare On Elm Street series, Craven gave us the meta-horror delights of Scream, a slasher flick that was practically interactive.

By the time we got to the third movie, the whodunnit shtick was getting a bit tired (there's soon to be a soft reboot, let's hope that brings some fresh meat) so Craven strayed back to his playpen of old - nightmares.

Sydney Prescott, the series protagonist, has retreated, unsurprisingly, to a life of seclusion. But all the locks in the world can't prevent Ghostface from making a comeback. Syd receives a warning early on in the film in the form of a dream. Whilst asleep on the sofa, she dreams of her mother Maureen, the perceived catalyst of the Woodsboro murders. She wakes up with a jolt and before she has a chance to recover, Maureen appears at her window, issuing a warning; "Everything you touch DIES! You're just like me Syd... "

Is this an actual ghost in the Scream series? 'Fraid not - Sydney is still in a nightmare. Seconds later, as she creeps closer to the apparition, Maureen suddenly morphs into Ghostface, who lunges with a knife, waking Syd once and for all.

Craven had a knack for a jump-scare - let's see how director Matt Bettinelli-Olpin fairs with the fifth entry in 2022.


4. Bud's Blood Bath - It Comes At Night (2017)

It Comes At Night
A24

A24 have a knack for releasing imaginative, cerebral horror movies. Hereditary, A Ghost Story, Under The Skin and The VVitch use the prism of horror to reflect societal fears. They're also bloody scary and It Comes At Night is dripping with tension from the opening act.

The world has been infected with a fatal, highly contagious disease. Paul, his wife Sarah and their son Travis live in a house in the woods with a strict security regime. In the opening sequence, Paul and Travis, wrapped in protective clothing and gas masks, euthanise Sarah's father, Bud. They even burn the body to ensure no one else becomes infected by his oozing sores. This film is strictly show, don't tell and it's immensely effective.

Travis' fears are easy to imagine: to die from disease before he has even had a chance to outgrow adolescence is reflected in his increasingly graphic nightmares. This is where the false awakening makes an appearance:

Travis wanders the woods at night, searching for his lost dog. As the barking gets louder, he wakes with a start, just a nightmare. He sits upright and begins to vomit blood, his arms covered in welts from the disease. To make matters worse, his dead grandfather, his mouth dripping with blood, stares at him from the darkness, until he suddenly wakes for a second time.

The metaphor is obvious but powerful - Travis is surrounded by death and disease, the fear of which drives the family to some horrific levels of desperation. A great film for those who appreciate a slow-burn horror.


3. Freddy Vs Kristen - A Nightmare On Elm Street Part 3: The Dream Warriors (1987)

Nightmare on Elm Street Robert Englund Freddy Krueger
New Line Cinema/Warner Bros

By 1987, the Nightmare franchise had been through some teething problems but was considered a lucrative bet for New Line studios. The first movie was a hit and had the makings of a genre classic, the second was enjoyably camp trash but was dragged down by haste, so by the time part three came round, producer Bob Shaye invested heavily in its conceptual stages.

Wes Craven was back for writing duties, now teamed with Shawshank's Frank Darabont and the star of the original, Heather Langenkamp, was returning as the plucky Nancy. A bigger budget, a surprisingly effective structure and a confident tone gave us the best Freddy sequel to date.

Kristen (Patricia Arquette) and the last of the Elm Street kids are unaware of Freddy's murder at the hands of their own parents. He is now killing them in their sleep and Kristen, plagued by nightmares, finds herself in Nancy's dilapidated Elm Street house in the film's opening dream sequence.

She attempts to rescue a little girl from Freddy's razors and wakes in a cold sweat. Making her way to the bathroom to wash off the experience, Kristen reaches for the tap, which suddenly sprouts blades and slashes both her wrists. Freddy himself laughs at her from inside the mirror; Kristen is still trapped in the nightmare.

There are, as one would expect, several false awakenings in the series but this one is perhaps the slickest, serving as a suitably flashy intro to the most polished of the Elm Street nightmares.


2. Nazi Mutants - An American Werewolf In London (1981)

An American Werewolf In London Nazi Mutant Zombies
Polygram Pictures

An American werewolf In London could very well be the first, and certainly the most infamous, use of the nightmare within a nightmare trope. It's also perhaps the most effective; no one saw this one coming on initial viewing (OK clever clogs, maybe you did).

David and Jack, two backpacking Americans, find themselves lost on the English moors late one night when they are attacked by a werewolf. Jack is killed and David wakes in a hospital in London, injured from a bite but alive nonetheless. David begins to experience visions and it soon becomes clear is becoming a werewolf himself; this is where things begin to get wonderfully weird...

One night whilst still in hospital, David dreams he is home, surrounded by his family and enjoying an episode of The Muppet Show, when the door bell rings. Nope it's not the postman, it's a cohort of Nazi-mutants armed with automatic weapons. His family is slaughtered and David has his throat cut, waking from the nightmare at the pivotal moment, to the sedate surroundings of his hospital bed and the unique charms of nurse Alex Price. Phew, says the audience collectively.

Alex has "just the thing" and heads to the window to let the morning light in. She whips the curtains open and BANG! She's stabbed in the chest by another Nazi-mutant thingy who's hiding behind the curtains. David screams out, only to awaken for a second time, still in a nightmare.

It's a superlative jump-scare; thoroughly unexpected, audibly assaulting and appropriately violent.


1. Catherine's Return - Prince Of Darkness (1987)

prince of darkness
Universal Pictures

John Carpenter's 1987 science-meets-religion horror Prince Of Darkness was conceived as part two of his 'Apocalypse' trilogy, along with 1982s The Thing and 1994s In The Mouth Of Madness. While perhaps the weakest of the three, Carpenter's imagination is enough to draw in the most cynical of viewers.

A priest (Donald Pleasence) calls upon the big brains of Professor Howard Birack (Victor Wong) to investigate the findings of a secret society, The Brotherhood of Sleep. In the crypt of a church in LA, the Brotherhood guard a large vial, containing a swirling green substance, which is essentially liquid Satan. When a member of the group becomes infected by the green stuff, she begins killing the others, now possessed. To make matters worse, the church is becoming besieged by sinister vagrants (including Alice Cooper in a great cameo), now willing recruits, intent on bringing Satan to the realm of men...

The nightmare within a nightmare comes right at the climax, as Brian grieves for his lover Catherine, who sacrifices herself to essentially save humanity. He sees her emerge from the church in the reoccurring nightmare (a warning from the Brotherhood of the incoming apocalypse) and like all intense movie nightmares, wakes in sheer panic. He turns over to see... Catherine is actually lying in bed with him, minus her face. Is she trying to communicate from beyond the grave? Who knows, but it's a great jump-scare.

There must be many other examples of false awakenings in horror movies, so please leave these in the comments and have fun spotting this elusive yet wonderfully effective gotcha' gag of the genre.


Watch Next


The Hardest A Nightmare On Elm Street Franchise Quiz On The Internet

Wes Craven
New Line Cinema

1. After The First Nightmare Movie, Wes Craven Only Directed One More, Which One?

Contributor
Contributor

A lifelong aficionado of horror films and Gothic novels with literary delusions of grandeur...