10 Horror Movie Romances That Make Love Terrifying

Maybe you're safer on your own.

The Fly
20th Century Fox

Isn't being in love great? Nothing fills a person's heart with as much joy and sunshine than being with their favourite guy or gal. Romance. Happiness. All you need is love.

But what about the dark underbelly of love? Heartbreak. Obsession. Grief. We all fear these just as much as loneliness, and horror films sure know this.

This list will look at films where romance becomes something utterly terrifying. The dark places that love can take people. Forbidden love with those whom we should avoid. And relationships that become living nightmares.

It is worth noting that this list could have been filled exclusively with vampire films, since all of them play on taboos of love, sex, and death, and always end up being super mushy.

But, fear not, there are more than enough other horror films out there that will make you think twice before looking for love.

10. Beyond The Darkness (1979)

Beyond The Darkness
Shriek Show

“Death has no power to separate us” promises Frank (Kieran Canter), our blue-eyed protagonist, as his girlfriend Anna (Cinzia Monreale) lays dying on a hospital bed. So far, so romantic.

Soon after this, Frank digs up her body from the graveyard, plonks her naked cadaver on his taxidermy table and, in a lengthy and graphic sequence, carves her open, removes her guts, sucks her brains out of her nose with a tube, sticks new eyes in the empty sockets…

Frank’s sure making good on his promise. Perhaps this is still romantic? Frank holds his dead girlfriend's heart in his hands like a lover from a Jacobean tragedy - then he bites into it and blood spurts everywhere. Gross.

It turns out Frank is a sexually deranged psychopath. He keeps Anna’s stuffed corpse tucked up in a bed, seemingly to cope with his grief, but also as a means of sexual arousal when he’s with other women.

If the necrophilic overtones weren’t enough for you, Frank also engages in quasi-Oedipal acts of sexual deviancy with his spooky housekeeper/wet-nurse, Iris (Franca Stoppi - looking like the wife from the American Gothic painting). That’s when the two of them aren’t chopping up and disposing of murdered women, of course.

Oh, and Iris is actually responsible for Anna’s death at the start of the film, killing her via voodoo curse so that she can try to marry Frank. It’s that age old love triangle between two murderous perverts and a corpse!


9. Candyman (1992)

Candyman movie
TriStar Pictures

“It was always you Helen” says Candyman (Tony Todd) in his trademark sexy voice, as we are shown the same phrase scrawled on the wall of his hideout. There’s a painted mural too, depicting Candyman and Helen (Virginia Madsen) but in nineteenth century attire.

Were Helen and Candyman lovers over a hundred years ago before his murder? Is this why he spends half the movie trying to convince Helen to join him in his afterlife dimension?

Candyman is a film that examines the nature of urban legends, asking whether they can become true by simply having enough people believe in them. As Helen probes deeper into the Candyman legend the Candyman himself soon appears, framing her for a series of grisly murders in the hopes that she will become his ghostly lover and partner in hook-based slaughter.

Does Helen will Candyman into existence by fuelling the fires of the legend? Or does Helen become so subsumed in these stories that she takes on the mantle of the Candyman and commits these crimes herself? “It was always you Helen”.

Whether you believe that Helen becomes Candyman or not, the pair leave a trail of bloodshed.

Their ambiguous relationship is another tantalizing part of the Candyman mythos, kept alive by the re-telling of the legend.


8. Cat People (1942)

Cat People Irene
RKO

In Cat People, a man and a woman meet, go on several dates, fall in love, and even get married despite never having kissed. This is because the lady in question, Irena (Simone Simon), believes she is descended from the cat people of a medieval Serbian village, and that she will turn into a violent panther if aroused.

Since kissing his wife is out of the question, husband Oliver (Kent Smith) begins spending more and more time with his female friend Alice (Jane Randolph). But wait, another trigger for feline transformation is - jealousy!

It’s a fairly doomed marriage truth be told. And the only person who believes Irena is her rival in love, Alice, after she is stalked by an unseen wildcat in two wonderfully tense sequences.

Then there’s the sleazy psychiatrist who, after planting a kiss on Irena, gets mauled to bits.

It may not be as horrifying as other entries on this list, but Cat People plays on male attitudes towards female sexuality: it is as desirable as it is threatening.


7. A Girl Walks Home Alone At Night (2014)

A Girl Walks Home Alone At Night Sheila Vand Vampire
Vice Films

Vampire stories are always steeped in romance. Vampires are sexy because they tempt us with immortality in exchange for our lives. They are powerful, predatory creatures that reject God and revel in blood, sex, and death. They’re also inherently tragic because as much as we want to be dead like them, we wish to humanise them too.

This combination makes them the perfect figures for a taboo romance.

Speaking of taboo, let’s look at the story of a female, chador-wearing vampire (Sheila Vand) who preys on men, set in Iran.

One night our vampire - The Girl - bumps into Arash (Arash Marandi), a young chap returning home from a Halloween party dressed as Dracula. They end up going back to her place where they listen to dream-pop in what must be the coolest scene in any vampire film.

What makes this romance frightening is that we know that The Girl has killed and will kill again, despite resisting the urge to bite Arash. At the end of the film as the two run away together, Arash realises that The Girl has killed his own father. Yet, after a brief moment of turmoil, he still decides to go away with her.

Arash fulfils the fantasy of many by eloping with a murderous vampire. The danger is all part of the thrill.


6. Let The Right One In (2008)

Let The Right One In Eli
Magnet Releasing

Speaking of eloping with murderous vampires, Let the Right One In is the coming-of-story where young Oskar (Kåre Hedebrant) meets young-looking but ageless vampire Eli (Lina Leandersson).

Tomas Alfredson’s film deals with two male relationships formed with a vampire. At the start of the film Eli’s blood supply is taken care of by Håkan (Per Ragnar), a middle aged man who kills innocent locals and collects their blood for Eli to consume. When caught in the act by police he attempts suicide to protect Eli. For his efforts, Eli kills Håkan in hospital and feeds on him.

The lengths Håkan goes to for Eli are terrifying, killing others and ultimately sacrificing himself for her.

Eli goes to similarly terrifying lengths to protect Oskar. In the film’s grand finale sequence she dismembers Oskar’s school bullies at the swimming pool. The perks of dating a vampire.

The film ends with a young Oskar boarding a train out of town with Eli hidden in a trunk. Just like at the end of A Girl Walks Home Alone At Night, the assumption is that they will escape their grim pasts for a blissful future.

Or is Oskar simply Eli’s next Håkan?


5. Bram Stoker's Dracula (1992)

Gary Oldman Winona Ryder Dracula
Columbia Pictures

The final vampire film on this list, and by far the soppiest one, Francis Ford Coppola’s adaptation of Dracula is an overblown romance tale that spans hundreds of years.

In the year 1462 Dracula’s (Gary Oldman) beloved Elisbatha (Winona Ryder) commits suicide, sending him into a heartbroken fury. He promises to avenge Elisbatha and stabs a big stone cross, drinking the blood that spurts forth from it, becoming a vampire!

We all know the story here - after centuries of pining and harem-building, it is 1897 and Dracula discovers that Elisabetha is reincarnated as Mina and now lives in London. Thus begins Dracula’s journey across land and sea to be reunited with her, leaving plenty of exsanguinated corpses in his lovelorn wake.

It may half-pretend to be a horror film, but Bram Stoker’s Dracula is ultimately the grandaddy of gothic erotica.

Most of the film is lit like a brothel, bathed in red (the colour of love and blood!), and it doesn’t skimp on either the sex or the gore, with raunchy scenes involving vampire brides and a big hairy wolf-monster clear standouts.

There’s a reason this film is such an enduring guilty pleasure.


4. Hellraiser (1987)

Claire Higgins Hellraiser
Film Futures

So iconic are Pinhead and the Cenobites that the actual plot of Hellraiser is often overlooked. Based on Clive Barker’s short story The Hellbound Heart, it is one of damning infidelity that carries on beyond the grave.

Julia (Claire Higgins) moves into the house of the recently deceased Frank (Sean Chapman), the brother of her husband, with whom she was having an affair. But Frank is still in the house as a skinless corpse thirsty for blood. Julia, still in love with Frank, agrees to quench his thirst, and begins bringing men back to house for sex before murdering them with a hammer.

Frank and Julia make a frightening couple. Frank is a monstrous sadomasochist driven only by sexual depravity. Julia is a murderer willing to kill her own husband to resurrect Frank and renew their affair. The gruesome tragedy is that she ultimately dies at the hands of Frank, and that Frank is killed by the Hooks from Hell that so seduced him in the first place.

Hellraiser explores the dark corners of our desires where pleasure and pain converge, as do love and lust, sex and death, heaven and hell.


3. Antichrist (2009)

Antichrist Shower
IFC Films

Lars von Trier’s exploration of a married couple’s grief after the death of their son garnered a lot of controversy for its extreme violence, particularly for its depictions of battered and mutilated genitals.

There’s a lot you can try to infer from Antichrist’s onslaught of gruesome and allegorical imagery. For the purposes of this list, we shall read it as - Lars von Trier Presents: Marriage, a Cautionary Tale!

The unnamed wife (Charlotte Gainsbourg) is suffering from severe depression after the death of the couple’s child, so she and her husband (Willem Dafoe) retreat into the woods. Whilst there she is also writing a thesis on gynocide and witch hunts, which leads to her believing that all women are evil.

Soon, she goes utterly insane, and subjects her husband to horrific sexual violence, and from then on it becomes a bloody fight for survival in the woods between husband and wife.

It is also revealed that she deliberately allowed the death of their son to occur, so it actually turns out she was evil long. Poor Willem Dafoe sure picked a wrong’un.

It’s no surprise that Antichrist got labelled misogynistic by some critics, because if this is how von Trier sees women and marriage then no wonder he’s been divorced twice.


2. The Fly (1986)

The Fly
20th Century Fox

David Cronenberg is best known for body horror, of which The Fly might be his most horrific. What makes this film terrifying on an emotional level is the romantic tragedy of someone watching their beloved change before their very eyes.

Then having to blow their head off.

Ronnie (Geena Davis) is dating scientist Seth (Jeff Goldblum), who manages to fuse his DNA with a fly during a teleportation experiment. His body gradually becomes less human, but most devastatingly for Ronnie, so does his mind. Cronenberg doesn’t limit body horror purely to Seth’s transformation, with Ronnie having a nightmare about giving birth to a gigantic maggot.

Ronnie’s nightmares become reality in the film’s finale. Ronnie watches in horror as the man she once loved has a monstrous fly creature explode from his decayed human shell. She then, screaming, has to shoot it with a shotgun.

In The Fly, Cronenberg takes romantic conventions of the happy couple and childbirth and destroys them with monstrous body horror, made all the more heart-wrenching by the slow breakdown of a couple’s love.


1. Audition (1999)

Audition Asami
Omega Project

A lonely windower decides to find new love by auditioning several young ladies to find his perfect match.

It’s an unorthodox method, but he finds his dream gal, and the first two thirds of Audition are a jolly pleasant romantic drama.

When Audition decides to become a horror film, there is no turning back.

The violence is extreme. It is far more horrifying than the gratuitous goings-on in Antichrist because Audition takes its time to tell a story that makes us care about its characters.

The final ten minutes of Audition could well be the most nightmarish minutes in cinema.

Audition is a cautionary tale for men whose idea of love is objectifying women. Here, misogynist tropes of “dream girl” and “crazy chick” converge into a bloody finale of female vengeance.


Watch Next


Contributor

Born in Essex, lives in South London. MA in Film & Literature, actor, and playwright.