10 Horror Movie Sequels That Started In Surprising Ways

Those horror sequels whose opening moments shocked audiences.

The Grudge 2 Karen Davis Kyako Sarah Michelle Gellar
Columbia Pictures

No genre of cinema is more synonymous with sequels than the murky realm of horror.

Given the relatively cheap cost of putting a horror movie together - which in turn makes it possible to turn an extremely healthy profit - we've seen time and time again how an initial idea is revisited. For so many films, they end up being spun into a multi-movie franchise, with some franchises even getting into double figures when it comes to how many entries they consist of.

While certain sequels often retread the same plot points as their predecessor(s), in turn bringing a predictability to them, there are those follow-ups that manage to do something different, something eye-grabbing, and something surprising. And it's on those particular sequels that the attention is on here.

With our recent 10 Movie Sequels That Started In Surprising Ways having covered Jaws: The Revenge, Scream 2, The Texas Chainsaw Massacre 2, and Alien 3, those pictures are off the table here. Still, there are so many other sequels to choose from when it comes those which began by shocking us all.

Keeping that in mind, then, here are ten such horror follow-ups which immediately caught audiences off guard with their opening moments.

10. Slumber Party Massacre II

Slumber Party Massacre II
New Concorde

Slumber Party Massacre is everything you'd expect from a slasher film released in 1982. Overflowing with the cliches of the subgenre, this Amy Holden Jones-helmed offering presents a group of disposable teens, a drill-wielding killer, and the sort of chaos and carnage one automatically associates with the slashers of that time.

While Russ Thorn, the villain of Slumber Party Massacre, is offed at the end of the movie, that didn't stop him from technically returning for the 1987 follow-up picture.

Rather than the middle-aged mass murderer seen in the first film, the big surprise of Slumber Party Massacre II is how Russ is presented upon being resurrected for another dose of bloodshed. As shown in the opening moments of SPM2, this rogue is now a hip 'n' cool 1950s greaser, decked out in leather and sporting a guitar that's fitted with a drill bit. Oh, and he sings. Like, a lot. So much so, Slumber Party Massacre II borders on being an all-out musical at times.

For better or worse, Slumber Party Massacre II's first 15 minutes sets out to make you fully aware that this is very much a different film to its predecessor.


9. Lost Boys: The Thirst

Lost Boys The Thirst Alan Frog
Warner Bros.

With fans having waited 21 years for a Lost Boys sequel, they were eventually served up two such movies with 2008's Lost Boys: The Tribe and 2010's Lost Boys: The Thirst. To be blunt, neither of these follow-ups were particularly good, though there was a certain charm to revisiting some of the characters from Joel Schumacher's iconic 1987 effort.

Pivotal parts of Schumacher's movie were Edgar and Alan Frog, two young warriors looking to fight the good fight against the "goddamn sh*t-sucking vampires" of Santa Carla, California. Played by Corey Feldman and Jamison Newlander, respectively, in that picture, the two actors were set to reprise those roles for The Tribe. Unfortunately for Newlander, he ended up being part of an alternate ending that didn't make the final cut of that offering.

Still, Jamison did get to be a significant part of Lost Boys: The Thirst alongside Feldman's Edgar Frog.

What was surprising about the opening of The Thirst, though, is that Newlander's Alan ends up becoming a half-vampire after being forced to drink vampire blood. From there, the film jumps ahead five years to find a depressed, reclused Alan living out his days surviving on animal blood.


8. House IV: The Repossession

House IV The Repossession
New Line Cinema

Steve Miner's House is a (relatively) family-friendly horror with just the right amount of humour to go along with its terror and tension. Unfortunately, the two subsequent follow-ups to Miner's 1982 effort veered in vastly different directions to that first House, with House II: The Second Story leaning way too much into slapstick comedy, and House III: The Horror Show veering too much towards excessive gore and violence for the sake of excessive gore and violence.

Still, 1992's House IV: The Repossession ending up being a fitting end for the franchise, managing to recapture the same balance of horror and humour as the original movie. The Repossession also brought back the first film's lead character, William Katt's Roger.

In House, Roger is spooked by plentiful bumps in the night at his deceased aunt's old house. That picture also sees him separated from his wife, and puts Katt's character on the hunt for his missing young son, Jimmy. For the audience, House IV: The Repossession has quite the surprise where Roger is concerned.

When we pick things up with Rog, his prior wife and son are completely ignored by the film. Instead, he's now married to someone else, Kelly, with whom he has a daughter, Laurel. Also, while the events of House IV are meant to take place in the same house as, well, House, it's clearly a totally different building.

If all of that wasn't surprising enough, the biggest shocker of The Repossession's opening is how it opts to kill off Roger in an explosive car crash.


7. The Devil's Rejects

The Devil's Rejects Baby Mother Firefly
Lionsgate

What was surprising about the start of Rob Zombie's The Devil's Rejects, is how it immediately put the Firefly clan on the back foot.

In 2003's House of 1000 Corpses, the Fireflies were introduced as a family who operated under their own grizzly, grimey rules of murder and mayhem, and who were always one step ahead of the law. That motus operandi was perfectly showcased in how Mother Firefly, Otis, Baby, Captain Spaulding and Co. duped and brutally slaughtered a group of police officers who visited their abode as part of a missing persons' hunt.

Surprisingly, the opening sequence of The Devil's Rejects turns the tables on the Fireflies.

For this 2005 sequel, it opens with a hefty, armed bunch of state troopers ambushing the Firefly household while the family sleeps. Said ambush results in the death of Rufus Firefly, the incarceration of Mother Firefly, and puts Otis, Baby and Spaulding 'on the run' as they look to evade the law and plot the rescue of Leslie Easterbrook's Mother; a rescue that doesn't happen, with Easterbrook's character murdered by the vengeance-seeking Sheriff Wydell.

Of course, 3 from Hell - the third entry in this series - likewise opened in surprising fashion, killing off Sid Haig's Spaulding. Unfortunately, that was a decision made by Zombie after it became apparent that Haig's poor health would restrict his involvement - with the actor sadly passing away in September 2019 just days after 3 from Hell premiered.


6. A Nightmare On Elm Street 4: The Dream Master

A Nightmare on Elm Street 4 The Dream Master Jason Dog
New Line Cinema

With A Nightmare on Elm Street 3: Dream Warriors seeing franchise fave Nancy use her last breaths to help kill off Freddy Krueger, many pondered just how Krueger would resurface once it was announced that Renny Harlin would be bringing a fourth Elm Street picture to the silver screen in 1988. After all, you couldn't do an Elm Street offering and not feature Robert Englund's fedora-adorned child killer, right?

Freddy would indeed (obviously) return for A Nightmare on Elm Street 4: The Dream Master - and Elm Street 5: The Dream Child... and Freddy's Dead: The Final Nightmare... and kind of for Wes Craven's New Nightmare... plus Freddy vs. Jason... and even the awful 2010 remake - but the more shocking matter was how Englund's character was reintroduced in The Dream Master.

When Elm Street 3 survivor Kincaid finds himself joined by his dog Jason in a dream, it soon becomes apparent that the duo are near the remains of Freddy Krueger. In one of the most baffling, bizarre moments in mainstream horror history, the pooch takes a literal flaming piss on Krueger's bones, which somehow resurrects the villain and allows him to carry on with his vendetta against the children of Springwood.


5. Hellbound: Hellraiser II

Hellbound Hellraiser II Elliot Spencer Doug Bradley
New World Pictures

Having won plentiful praise for its sinister visuals, unnerving atmosphere, and ominous dialogue, 1987's Hellraiser introduced moviegoers to Pinhead and his Cenobites. Presenting these sinister sorts as an otherworldly force - after all, they do reside in Hell - Clive Barker's directorial debut set these pleasure 'n' pain-obsessed figures up as something totally foreign to the real world.

Catching many a horror hound off guard, follow-up Hellbound: Hellraiser II opened by surprisingly humanising Pinhead.

Released just a year after its predecessor, this sequel started by showcasing Pinhead before he was Pinhead. Rather than forever being some pseudo supernatural being that's only ever called the murky depths of Hell home, Hellbound's opening teased that Pinhead was previously a human soldier who was ultimately corrupted by the infamous Lament Configuration.

The film would later identify this man as Elliot Spencer, a British army captain during World War I. And with that, Pinhead now had a backstory; a backstory which itself would be further elaborated on and fleshed out in 1992's Hellraiser III: Hell on Earth. In fact, that threequel went in the bold direction of utilising Pinhead and Spencer as two entirely separate entities who had been unbonded following the events of Hellbound's finale.


4. Hostel: Part II

hostel 2 paxton.jpg
Lionsgate

Oh, Paxton...

Having survived a whole bunch of Achilles-slicing, eye-popping, finger-chopping antics in 2005's Hostel, Jay Hernandez's Paxton had been put through quite the wringer. Of course, such an experience will leave one traumatised, and that's clearly the case for our sole Hostel survivor by the time we pick things up with him at the start of Hostel: Part II.

Living in seclusion with his girlfriend, we find a Paxton who is dealing with severe PTSD. It also doesn't help Hernandez's character that his beau believes he's exaggerating his trauma, with her feeling that a) Paxton's time in Slovakia can't have been that bad, and b) there's absolutely zero chance of the nefarious Elite Hunting Group being able to track Paxton down.

How wrong was she? In a jarring move, Hostel: Part II's opening sequence ends with Paxton's girlfriend finding his headless corpse in the pair's kitchen. From there, we see Paxton's decapitated head couriered to the waiting hands of Sasha, the big boss of the aforementioned Elite Hunting Group.

With that, this first Hostel sequel switches its attention to a trio of new female characters who soon find themselves in the sinister clutches of Sasha's organisation.


3. Jason Goes To Hell: The Final Friday

Jason Goes to Hell: The Final Friday Jason Voorhees
New Line Cinema

With any long-standing horror franchise that has a particular villain constantly at its core, the big question of any sequel tends to revolve around how exactly this bad guy or gal will be brought back after having been stopped at the end of the previous picture.

In the case of Jason Goes to Hell: The Final Friday, the big opening moment surprise wasn't how Jason Voorhees was resurrected, but more how he was shockingly killed off. Well, sort of.

Having ended Friday the 13th Part VIII: Jason Takes Manhattan in the form of a young boy following a run in with some New York toxic waste - yep, it makes zero sense - 1993's The Final Friday opens up with Jason very much alive as a hulking adult who's stalking an unsuspecting female in a Camp Crystal Lake cabin.

While there's zero explanation as to how Jason reverted to his adult self and departed the bright lights of NYC following Part VIII, even more surprising is how Voorhees is blown to smithereens mere minutes into Jason Goes to Hell.

You see, the aforementioned unsuspecting female was really an FBI agent who was tasked with luring Jason into an ambush from a SWAT team that shoot the sh*t out of the serial killer and blow him up. From here, The Final Friday devolved into an odd movie about the spirit of Jason - which looked like a turd - being passed from person to person, with the physical form of Voorhees absent for the vast majority of the film.


2. The Grudge 2

The Grudge 2 Karen Davis Kyako Sarah Michelle Gellar
Columbia Pictures

Having survived plentiful supernatural chicanery in 2004's The Grudge, Sarah Michelle Gellar's Karen Davis was back for another round of spooky shenanigans for that movie's 2006 follow-up.

As The Grudge 2 begins, we come to learn that Karen is laid up in a Japanese hospital following the fiery finale of the first film. When Karen's sister Aubrey heads to Tokyo to retrieve her elder sibling, things immediately take a turn for the worse during the picture's opening moments.

When Karen panics after seeing the sinister Kayako spirit which plagued her in The Grudge, she bolts from her hospital bed and winds up on the building's roof. Convinced that the visage of Kayako is merely her own mind playing tricks on her, SMG's character finds out the hard way that that's not the case, with Kayako flinging Karen to her death from the hospital rooftop.

In a surprise move, it then becomes clear that The Grudge 2 will instead follow the story of Amber Tamblyn's Aubrey as she takes centre-stage and has to deal with her own supernatural chicanery in this so-so sequel.


1. Halloween: Resurrection

Halloween Resurrection Laurie Dead
Trancas International

In terms of shocking horror sequel opening, it doesn't get more jarring than seeing the greatest franchise protagonist in horror history being brutally killed off in the first few minutes. For the oft-lambasted Halloween: Resurrection, that's exactly what it ended up doing.

Picking things up after Laurie Strode had beheaded Michael Myers after the conclusion of Halloween H20, Resurrection finds Jamie Lee Curtis' Laurie locked up in a mental institution. There, it's detailed how Michael had pulled a switcheroo in H20, putting his famed mask on a poor paramedic, who Strode then decapitated. Thus, Laurie was traumatised and left as an institutionalised mute.

Of course, Curtis' character was really playing possum here, for yes, while she was locked up, she was merely biding her time for Michael to come and find her. In typical Myers fashion, the Shape does indeed turn up at the facility housing Laurie, with a rooftop battle between the two actually seeing Strode get the better of her long-time rival.

When Laurie hesitates in killing her then-canon brother - for fear of it being another innocent under the mask - Michael seizes the moment to stab his sibling and throw her body to its death. And with that, Halloween: Resurrection peaked, as the film then descends into a farce that culminates with Busta Rhymes busting out some kung fu moves on Michael Myers.


Watch Next


Senior Writer
Senior Writer

Once described as the Swiss Army Knife of WhatCulture, Andrew can usually be found writing, editing, or presenting on a wide range of topics. As a lifelong wrestling fan, horror obsessive, and comic book nerd, he's been covering those topics professionally as far back as 2010. In addition to his current WhatCulture role of Senior Content Producer and Presenter, Andrew previously spent nearly a decade as Online Editor and Lead Writer for the world's longest-running genre publication, Starburst Magazine, and his work has also been featured on BBC, TechRadar, Tom's Guide, WhatToWatch, Sportkskeeda, and various other outlets, in addition to being a Rotten Tomatoes-approved film critic. Between his main day job, his role as lead panel host of Wales Comic Con, and his gig as a pre-match host for Wrexham AFC games, Andrew has also carried out a hugely varied amount of interviews, from the likes of Robert Englund and Eli Roth to Kevin Smith and the Russo Brothers, to Kevin Conroy and Frank Miller, to Bret Hart and Sting, to Mickey Thomas, Joey Jones, Phil Parkinson, and Brian Flynn, to many, many more. Where his beloved Wrexham AFC is concerned, Andrew is a long-standing season ticket holder and an FSA Award-winner for his time co-hosting the Fearless in Devotion podcast.