10 Horror Movie Theories That Change Everything

What really happened when Heather went into that basement?...

The Blair Witch Project
Artisan Entertainment

You've toughed it out for ninety minutes and the credits are rolling. You can turn on the light, stick the kettle on and calm yourself down. You've done it, you've braved yet another horror film.

It'll take a few minutes, but that feeling of dread will soon dissipate and you'll no longer have to keep your mind invested in the spooky shenanigans you've just witnessed.

But what if the events you just witnessed weren't as they seemed?...

All of a sudden you find yourself thinking back on the menagerie of horrors and a wider picture begins to form, changing your entire perception and understanding of the film entirely.

Whilst it's true that most horror films can be taken on face value, with simplistic plots often being secondary to the scares, in some instances a little digging can unearth a whole host of unanswered questions and theories as to what really transpired. This can often completely change the tone and themes of the film in ways you never thought possible.

As the old saying goes, it's what you don't see that scares you the most, and in this instance that may very well be the case.

WARNING: Spoilers Ahead!

10. Cloverfield - There Were Two Monsters Attacking The City

TERMINATOR DARK FATE
Paramount Pictures

Long before The Cloverfield Paradox made us all collectively scratch our heads, several theories regarding the original film had circulated online. The most interesting, and potentially true, theory is that during the events of Cloverfield, there are in fact two monsters running amok.

Director Matt Reeves revealed in an interview that at the tail end of the movie, you can see a satellite fall into the ocean, which supposedly awoke the monster and started the chain of destruction.

There is then further speculation that the creature we see throughout the movie is in fact a baby, which would explain its confused and destructive nature.

Throughout the film, we scarcely see the monster in full view, only catching small glimpses here and there, but more often than not, the size and appearance of the creature seems to vary. In some scenes its taller than buildings and in others it can easily hide itself away, which can lead to some confusion.

Could it be that the creature's mother is also running rampage?

The changing appearance and its ability to be in seemingly two places at once certainly alludes to this, but until we get a proper sequel, we may never know for sure.


9. The Texas Chainsaw Massacre - The Film Is Vegetarian Propaganda

texas chainsaw massacre original
Bryanston Pictures

This theory doesn't stretch the imagination too much, given the film's nasty subject matter and emphasis on barbaric slaughter, but it does make you look at it in a different light.

The film follows a group of college students who, like literal lambs to the slaughter, stumble into an unassuming Texas country house that also doubles as the murder capital of the state. One by one, they fall victim to the deranged family who live there, whose methods include bludgeoning with hammers, carving up with sharp objects and suspending from meat hooks.

All of which were common methods utilised in slaughterhouses.

If that was too subtle, then the constant motifs of butchery, animal carcasses and the consumption of human flesh more than hammer home the message. The use of animalistic squeals that accompany many of the murders also plays into this, highlighting the sheer terror that animals confined in slaughterhouses must feel.

Sure, the film can be viewed purely on a surface level as just another horror film, but when taking these factors into the account, it does add to the film's already queasy feel and might even make you think twice about that fat, juicy steak in your fridge.


8. Drag Me To Hell - The Hauntings Are Manifestations Of Christine's Eating Disorder

Drag Me To Hell
Universal Pictures

After taking some time out direct all three original Spider-Man films, Sam Raimi finally made his triumphant return to the world of horror with wonderfully silly Drag Me to Hell.

Telling the story of young banker Christine, who after denying an elderly gypsy lady a mortgage extension, is haunted by a dark spirit that plans to take her to hell. A simple and effective premise for a horror film.

When looking at the film a little closer however, a more tragic picture begins to form. Early in the film, Christine briefly talks about how she was overweight during her teenage years, leading to a lot of bullying and ridicule from the people around her.

However, this seemingly throwaway anecdote seems to manifest itself in the hauntings. Most of the attacks have something either going in or coming out of Christine's mouth or the mouths of others. Furthermore, a lot of these also attacks happen whilst she is in the kitchen and some of them even relate directly to the food she's eating.

This theory is something of a stretch, given that Christine isn't the only person we succumb to the demon, but all of the evidence presented does add up.


7. The Thing - There Were Two Aliens, One Of Which Was MacReady

Thing Head Stretch
Universal Pictures

Much like the aforementioned Cloverfield, 1982's The Thing may also be concealing another creature amongst all the bloodshed. Fuelled by the film's bleak and ambiguous ending, the internet has been abuzz with theories regarding this film for the longest time.

The most popular theory is that there are in fact two creatures inside the base, one of which is housed inside MacReady after he drinks from an infected bottle of scotch. If this is to be believed, then the supposed protagonist we've been rooting for this entire time was in fact the antagonist and the journey we've gone on with this character is all a lie.

Interestingly, it would also appear that the two aliens are actually at odds with one another, as opposed to working together to wipe out the crew. This is evidenced by MacReady's continued efforts to expose and destroy the alien, which could all be a facade to avoid suspicion.

MacReady's laughter at the end of the film has often been viewed as a nihilistic acceptance of their fate, but what if by offering Childs the (now infected) scotch bottle, he was declaring his victory over the other alien that had since been destroyed.


6. The Mist - Mrs Carmody Was Right, A Sacrifice Was Needed

The Mist Ending
MGM

If you've seen The Mist, then there's no doubt that it's ending is permanently seared into your brain, but what if there was a hidden meaning amongst the nihilistic gut-puncher?

Towards the film's climax, religious fanatic Mrs Carmody suggests that a sacrifice must be made in order to appease God and end their suffering, offering up protagonist David's young son Billy and his friend Amanda as the tributes.

So what if Mrs Carmody was right?

She was unsuccessful in her bid for a blood sacrifice as David killed her and escaped with Billy, Amanda and two others in tow. The group soon find themselves stranded in the middle of the mist and with very few options, David agrees to euthanise everyone but himself, before offering himself up to the creatures outside. Moments later, the army arrives to save the day, making David's act of mercy pointless.

Or was it?

Could it have been that David killing Billy and Amanda did in fact trigger an act of God and saved humanity, but leaving David to bare this horrific burden for the rest of his life?


5. Halloween (2018) - Laurie Caused The Bus Crash That Allowed Michael To Escape

Halloween 2018
Universal Pictures

David Gordon Green's 2018 reboot of the Halloween series was a pitch-perfect return to form for a franchise that had long since ran out of steam. Trimming away the fat and excising every sequel prior, this new tale was a continuation of the original film and followed Laurie Strode's troubled existence forty years later.

The trauma Laurie experienced in the original film has never truly gone away, with her paranoia approaching dangerous levels. Perhaps dangerous enough to willingly free to Michael from captivity so she can take revenge?

Prior to Michael's escape we see a clearly intoxicated Laurie watching him being loaded onto the prison bus. The next time we see her she has a public meltdown in front of her family and Michael has escaped. The exact nature of how the bus crashed is never explained either, adding further fuel to the fire.

We're drip-fed a lot of information throughout the film that indicates that Laurie is more mentally unstable than she lets on. She's previously had her child taken away from her due to endangerment and the sheer amount of weapons and booby-traps she has strewn around her house is alarming.

Maybe we'll get our answer in the upcoming Halloween Kills.


4. Friday The 13th Series - Each Film's Jason Is A Different Person

Friday The 13th
Paramount

Whilst on the surface this one sounds a little ludicrous, given that Jason Voorhees is such an emblematic character for the franchise, it begins to make sense when you peel back the layers.

Aside from the original film and Part 5, Jason has always been the masked maniac cutting up horny teenagers. Or so we thought, as this theory suggests that every Jason we've seen across the series is a different axe-wielding maniac.

The biggest indication as to this theory's validity is that Jason's height, build and general appearance changes quite drastically between films. The most obvious of which being his transition from long-haired, backwoods hermit in Part 2, to a muscular bald man in Part 3. That change wouldn't seem so drastic if the two films weren't suppose to happen over the course of two days.

It's possible that the woods surrounding Crystal Lake are home to more than one deranged killer, or that there is something inherently supernatural that drives people to madness.

Whilst this can be hastily explained away by the Friday the 13th series' complete disregard for concrete continuity, it does add an interesting dimension to what is otherwise a fairly straightforward set of slasher films.


3. Evil Dead Series - Ash Loses His Mind Mid-way Through The Evil Dead 2

The Evil Dead Evil Dead 2 Bruce Campbell
New Line & Rosebud Releasing

Being trapped in a cabin with malevolent spirits and the reanimated corpses of your now deceased best friends is nobody's idea of a quaint summer break.

Understandably, the loveable Ash Williams goes a little crazy during the events of Evil Dead 2. I suppose you'd feel the same if you had to chainsaw your own girlfriend to death after watching all of your other friends be slaughtered, but I digress.

Halfway through the film, Ash stops dead before having a mental breakdown. His maniacal laughing is accompanied by all manner of furniture moving and joining in with him, laughing along to a sick joke that nobody ever said.

Ash quickly brings it to a halt and snaps himself back to reality, or did he?

Throughout the rest of its run-time, Evil Dead 2 gets progressively nuttier and stranger, even culminating in an ending where Ash is thrown back in time to the Middle Ages. This ending did lead to the wonderfully bonkers Army of Darkness, but that being said, could this all just be the fabrication of a man who had simply snapped?


2. The Blair Witch Project - Michael And Josh Lured Heather Into The Woods To Murder Her

Heather Donahue Blair Witch
Haxan Films

The Blair Witch Project is no stranger to bizarre fan theories, ranging from ideas of time travel to group psychosis, but the most interesting (and plausible) of these theories though, is rooted in reality.

Throughout the course of the film, tensions between Michael, Joshua and Heather escalate to near physical levels. Insults are hurled and references to past events between them are brought to the surface, leading to fractures in their dynamic. Whilst this is never fully explained in the film itself, earlier drafts of the script (as well as Heather's online diary) allude to Heather and Josh being romantically involved at one point, but the whole affair turned ugly.

The fact that we never see anything truly supernatural occur in the film also makes you wonder whether all of the supposed spooky shenanigans were actually real or just fabrications by Micheal and Josh to scare Heather.

The infamous final shot of the film supports this theory too, did Josh stand in the corner to distract Heather whilst Michael attacked her from behind? These questions are never answered and there's plenty of evidence to support that maybe the whole set-up was simply an elaborate set-up to kill Heather.


1. The Witch - There Was No Witch, The Family Were Driven Crazy By Spoilt Crops

The Witch
A24

Robert Egger's folk tale creep-fest The Witch is one of last decade's best and most celebrated horror films. Partly due to its dense atmosphere and excellent character studies found throughout.

After William and his family are banished from a Puritan colony over a religious dispute, they begin a new life on a small patch of farmland, surrounded by some foreboding woods. It's not long before their newborn child vanishes and the family begin to suspect that a witch resides in the woods who means to bring them harm.

Whilst it's easy to just accept the supernatural goings on, there may be something else causing all the intense paranoia. Early in the film, it's referenced that the crops the family grow are of poor quality and infested with fungus.

If the family were to be consuming the fungus, then the chances are that they may be under the influence of psychedelics, causing them to be believe that there was a witch plaguing them. Instead, this theory suggests that all of the death, destruction and tragedy, was caused by a shared psychosis brought on by the fungus.

This is certainly up for debate, but it feels very natural given the film's grounded approach to its subject matter.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

UK based screenwriter, actor and one-half of the always-irreverent Kino Inferno podcast. Purveyor of cult cinema, survival horror games and low-rent slasher films.