10 Horror Movies That Got Too Silly To Be Scary
Swapping nightmares for humour doesn't always work out...
New Line CinemaHorror is one of cinemas most diverse genres. Both slasher movies and haunted house tales fit under its umbrella, but the two couldn't be more different. It's a genre that branches off in many directions, but it bears so much fruit that some of it has to be rotten. The genre is also unique for its absolutely stunning commitment to sequels. Few genres are so keen on spinning an idea out for as long as humanly possible. The three most famous horror franchises - Halloween, A Nightmare On Elm Street and Friday the 13th - add up to more than 30 movies. Outside of Marvel's Avengers universe, it's tough to find a franchise that even stands a chance of running that long. Unfortunately, with that longevity, there's a lot of pressure on each installment of a franchise to get better, which leads to some truly bizarre risk-taking. The same is true of stand-alone films that are attempting to position themselves into a crowded sub-genre, such as the recent obsession with demonic home invasion tales (Sinister, Dark Skies, Insidious, The Purge). One of the easiest traps for a horror movie - especially a long-running franchise - to fall into is that of excessive silliness. Scary movies often try to bring in aspects of fantasy and comedy to spice up their storytelling and mark them out as original. Sometimes this works like a charm, but occasionally the film can become too silly to scare anyone.
10. Cabin In The Woods (2012)
LionsgateJoss Whedon and Drew Goddard's witty, well-observed horror with a twist is a great movie. There are shocks and surprises at every turn, creating something that is a veritable feast for fans of horror movies. However, the one thing it struggles to do is actually scare the audience. Cabin in the Woods is a thoroughly silly movie, with its wry take on the formula of the eponymous sub-genre running throughout. But it's in the third act that things really turn unhinged, with a single press of a button unleashing a tonne of silliness into a crowded environment. When someone gets gored by a unicorn, the film is probably too silly to scare anyone. Goddard and Whedon are clearly huge fans of the genre and so are well aware of the huge glut of films that are essentially exactly the same. Embracing silliness was a perfect way for Cabin in the Woods to stand out as something different, even if it didn't really give audiences the willies.9. Freddy vs. Jason (2003)
New Line CinemaIt was billed as the clash that would define horror cinema for the new millennium. New Line Cinema's enormous 2003 crossover pitted two of the genres biggest icons against each other in a clash for supernatural supremacy. To start with, it holds together pretty well. Robert Englund's well-honed performance as Freddy Krueger and Jason's inventive kills are enough to hold together the first hour or so. Then, however, a worm with Freddy's face appears and smokes weed, in what is presumably an homage to the hookah-smoking Caterpillar in Lewis Carroll's Alice in Wonderland. From there, it's pretty much downhill in the logic stakes. By the time the two monsters finally battle it out, the film has become so stupid that it's impossible to get excited. Freddy's dreamscapes were always bizarre, but it really devalues Jason's prowess when he is pinging around a boiler room like it's some kind of pinball machine. And the less said about that final scene the better. It's the very definition of a cop out.
8. Switchblade Romance (2003)
LionsgateAlexandre Aja's Switchblade Romance (aka Haute Tension or High Tension) is a very intriguing example of a slasher film that attempts to transcend the basic conventions of the genre. It builds as a generic, but entertaining, slasher with some delightfully inventive gore before taking a drastic and head-scratching turn in the third act. It is this twist that both makes and breaks the film. Without it, Switchblade Romance would be a basic (if well-executed) slasher movie. With it, it's an interesting slasher movie that reaches a bit too far in order to craft an interesting twist. On paper, the idea of Marie (Cécile de France) perpetrating all of the movie's violence as a result of her deep, unrequited love for her friend is an interesting one. Unfortunately, it is revealed in a ham-fisted fashion that means it comes across as rather silly. This silliness undercuts the punch of the story and means that the finale feels like a gorefest rather than a passionate fight for survival.
7. Texas Chainsaw 3D (2013)
LionsgateThere wasn't a lot of love from critics or audiences for last year's reboot of the horror franchise that began with 1974s brutal independent film The Texas Chainsaw Massacre. It leant heavily on its 3D gimmick, focusing more on chucking chainsaws, body parts and just about everything else at the audience than on providing a coherent narrative or real scares. Every plot development in Texas Chainsaw 3D comes as a result of a succession of ridiculous contrivances. Leatherface is cast as a sympathetic anti-hero in a hilariously misguided attempt to convert his brutish character into a modern horror icon. There is silliness at every turn, whether it's the over-amplified gore or the clumsy references to the original movie franchise. The film is actually passably entertaining, but as a horror film, it utterly fails to conjure up anything other than generic jump scares.
6. Final Destination (2000)
New Line CinemaIf ever a film franchise prioritised silliness over scares, it's the Final Destination series. Devotees of the films watch mostly for the increasingly ludicrous death sequences. They know they're unlikely to be scared, but that doesn't matter. There's little reason to care about the characters, but a certain dark thrill to seeing how Death is able to catch up with them. They'd rather see someone fall off some gymnastics apparatus and snap in half. The first Final Destination film does feel like a genuine attempt at crafting a creepy horror movie. Whilst Tony Todd's mortician is legitimately scary, everything else is just a little too silly. The early deaths are harrowing, but things take a downward spiral when Amanda Detmer is hit by a bus and Stifler from American Pie gets his head cut off by a flying piece of metal. Final Destination is mainly on this list because of its sequels, but the first film certainly sets the general tone of silliness that prevents the franchise from ever being properly scary.
5. Saw III (2006)
LionsgateJames Wan and Leigh Whannell's horror juggernaut Saw is one of the most bafflingly popular franchises of all time. Its low-budget, simplistic origins are virtually indistinguishable from the glossy, blood-splattered mess that the series became once Wan and Whannell left it in the hands of others. Saw III was a real turning point for the series, marking the moment when the inherent silliness of the traps - similar to the death sequences in the Final Destination films - became more significant than the scares. The torture Angus Macfadyen's central character goes through is utterly ridiculous and the plotline around Jigsaw's medical condition is laughable. Any film that features DIY brain surgery is probably too silly to properly function. Saw IV may have been the first to have a truly stupid chronological twist, but Saw III was definitely the beginning of the end in terms of logic.
4. Evil Dead II (1987)
Paramount PicturesSam Raimi's sequel Evil Dead II is quite rightly considered a genre classic. Bruce Campbell's committed performance as Ash and the innovative practical effects are enough to make it one of the most entertaining horror films of the last 30 years. Few would, however, be able to argue with the notion that it is also probably the silliest horror movie ever made. The first Evil Dead movie, which was made for almost no money, was genuinely terrifying. The effects were gruesome and the grubbiness of the whole thing really helped Raimi to create some genuinely alarming moments alongside his trademark dark humour. In Evil Dead II, he pretty much ditches the scares and just goes as zany as possible. Evil Dead II is a prime example of a horror movie that succeeds without being scary. Like Cabin in the Woods, it's aiming to achieve something different. Something that is, as Ash would say, groovy.
3. Funny Games (1997)
Madman EntertainmentPeople who have seen Funny Games - Michael Haneke's meditation on cinematic violence and torture - fall into two specific camps. There are those who think that Haneke has produced something masterful, satirical and witty and there are others who think that the film is pretentious, pseudo-intellectual rubbish. Both camps, however, would be forced to admit that the film sacrifices much of its scare value in order to make its point. Whilst the early instances of wry breaking of the fourth wall help add to the suspense of the home invasion setup, this is not the case later on. As the fourth wall is completely demolished, it becomes far too much not to be alienating. It might make the audience consider their love of fictional violence, but it's certainly going to ensure that they're not scared. At times, Funny Games is more of a lecture than a movie as villainous protagonist Paul discusses the unfolding events with the audience. By the time he whips out a remote control to "rewind" an unwanted plot development, the film has completely abandoned the idea of ever scaring anyone. However, without these flourishes, Funny Games is just a generic home invasion horror. Like Switchblade Romance, it's a film that is both defined and derailed by its own silliness.
2. Insidious (2010)
FilmDistrictJames Wan appears on this list again, with his haunted house chiller Insidious. It's one of the more frustrating films featured because it spends around two thirds of its running time on the right side of the silliness line. It's as the film prepares to venture into its third act that the concept of "the Further" is introduced. It takes the form of a separate dimension, inhabited by malevolent demons who are willing to use the body of a gifted child to gain access to the world. Unfortunately, the Further is simply ridiculous and completely undermines the solid chills of the rest of the film. The supposedly demonic entities that wander the Further look as if they have purchased their clothes from Poundland and the central demon character resembles a cheap knock-off of Darth Maul from Star Wars. Wan and writer Leigh Whannell should receive some credit for being willing to take his film somewhere risky, but the execution of his offbeat idea is seriously lacking. With that in mind, it was a bizarre choice for Wan to base his 2013 sequel to Insidious almost entirely in its silly astral realm. Asking Patrick Wilson to impersonate Jack Nicholson from The Shining wasn't too wise either.
1. The Wicker Man (2006)
Sony PicturesWhere to start with this one... Neil LaBute's 2006 remake of British horror The Wicker Man is dominated by one of the biggest screen presences in cinema: Nicolas Cage in full-on crazy mode. It is seen by many people as the perfect example of a film that's so bad it's good and is now a cult classic in the same vein as other awful films such as Troll 2 and The Room. Cage's performance is utterly bizarre. Even outside of the now legendary sacrifice scene ("not the bees... they're in my eyes" etc), every movement and line of dialogue is turned up to eleven. It's a performance completely free of control, subtlety or sanity. Only in The Wicker Man will you see a man punch a woman in a bear suit. Seriously. There must have been something in the water during the creative process for this film. Neither Cage, nor LaBute, seems to have any grip on reality or notion of how a horror film should be made. It's difficult to conceive of anyone ever thinking that this was going to be something worthwhile. There's silliness... and then there's The Wicker Man. Cage himself has acknowledged in interviews that the movie is "absurd". That's probably the understatement of the century. Do you agree with the films on this list? Are there any other horror films that you think are ruined by their unnecessary silliness. Let us know in the comments section.