10 Horror Movies That Never Left You

You'll remember these films forever... whether you want to or not.

Censor 2021
Film4

Let's be honest - a horror movie isn't a real horror movie unless it arouses true fear. If a slasher, sci-fi flick, or a found-footage doc has no authentic scares, the majority of people will forget it within a week, even if they thoroughly enjoyed it at the time.

But if a film makes you clutch your heart, hide behind a blanket, or gasp in legitimate terror, you know it's staying with you for a long, long time. While looking back at The Exorcist, Poltergeist, or The Texas Chain Saw Massacre, moviegoers don't just remember the scary scenes, but the haunting feeling they experienced while watching them for the first time.

Even though it's fascinating how horror can harbour such a hold on viewers, some go too far. There are certain movies that are so chilling, unnerving, or sickening, viewers may regret watching them.

Now, that's not suggesting the films on this list should be avoided. However, caution is advised before checking out these entries, since there's a good chance the depraved and unsettling content they harbour will effect viewers for the rest of their life.

10. Society

Society 1992 150446 Fli 1386303507
Society Productions Inc. Wild Street Pictures

There are plenty of stories which explore the dangers of being pressurised into an affluent but corrupt clique, including The Firm, The Wolf of Wall Street, and even Mean Girls. But few films delve into this concept more imaginatively than 1989's Society.

Brian Yuzna's horror flick follows Billy Whitney - a teen who feels like he doesn't belong in his upper-class family. When he sees people in the neighbourhood contorting their bodies in an inhumane manner, Billy suspects there's something seriously wrong, not just with his family, but his entire community.

Because Society boasts astounding practical effects, the film could've thrown in some grotesque visuals every now and again to stop viewers getting bored.

Instead, the special effects are often quick and understated, so viewers second-guess what they saw. Not only do subtle scares like this effectively build tension and paranoia, it allows the climax to have a more profound impact, since the most gruesome visuals are saved for the end.

Society is often simplified as "the movie with the butt-head guy" but its biting social commentary on elitism and conformity has allowed it to maintain its relevance for decades.


9. Smile

Smile 2022
Paramount

In Smile, a psychiatrist, Rosie Cotter (Sosie Bacon), finds she's being hunted by a nebulous shapeshifter. Although this creature takes many forms, each of its identities share one trait - they smile.

But it's not just any smile. This malevolent being leers at Rosie with a sickly grin that would unsettle anyone. Within a matter of days, Rosie's life has turned upside down by the Smile Entity, compelling her to do all she can to destroy it before she loses her mind.

Although being smiled at doesn't sound too bad, viewers believe this form of torment would drive a person insane, thanks to Sosie Bacon's career-defining performance and Parker Finn's top-notch script and direction.

But what makes Smile so much more than a generic monster movie is how realistically it explores mental health. The way Rosie is shunned and stigmatised for a problem no one can see hits deep for anyone who's struggled with depression. Watching Rosie breathe a sigh of relief when she believes she's faced her demons, only for them to come back stronger is a pain many people know all too well.

Even though Smile has the traditional jump-scares and wince-inducing gore, it's the disturbingly accurate and relatable themes that hit hardest.


8. Audition

Audition 1999
Vitagraph Film

Most horror films open with a haunting prologue that gets viewers' attention immediately. Because many scary movies take their time setting up characters, dynamics, and sub-plots, this is a clever method to ensure the audience is invested from the beginning.

However, Audition does away with this strategy entirely as the movie opens with widowed teacher, Shigeharu, organising a fake audition in the hopes to find a new partner, first-timers may think they're watching a rom-com!

Half an hour in, Audition suddenly subverts all expectations. After meeting a shy girl called Asami during the "audition," Shigeharu believes she'll be a worthy bride. When he calls her, there's a shot of Asami in a barren apartment. Her phone rings, and a sack in the background suddenly contorts, while the unseen entity inside starts squealing in terror. In this moment, everyone realises they're watching something well and truly screwed up.

Over time, Shigeharu learns Asami is a deeply disturbed individual, who'll stop at nothing to be with him. When she discovers the audition was a sham, Asami vows to punish Shigeharu, by performing an act with razor wire that's not for the faint-hearted.

Because so many horror films focus on grossing out the audience straight away, it's refreshing how Audition is patient with the set-up. Not only does it give viewers more time to get to know the characters, it makes it more shocking when things get... messy.


7. Lake Mungo

Lake Mungo
Arclight Films

Lake Mungo is a found-footage doc that analyses the mysterious death of drowned teenager, Alice Palmer. When the Palmer family are contacted by Alice's spirit, they learn she harboured a secret double life, which may have led to her demise.

It's a pity Lake Mungo is the only film Joel Anderson directed, since the underrated filmmaker has an unmistakable talent for storytelling. This "documentary" is unsettling, not just because of the subject matter or gruesome visuals, but the way it makes viewers routinely doubt themselves.

When it looks like the mystery has been solved, another detail is found which puts everything back to square one. Just as the film crew feel like they've figured everything out, there's a revelation that makes them challenge everything they ever believed. Viewers change their mind on what's real and what isn't with such regularity, the whole experience can be quite disorienting.

Also, the rug-pull during the film's closing moments is so unexpected, it encourages viewers to watch Lake Mungo all over again, now they have a greater sense of the tragedy that befell Alice Palmer.


6. Apostle

Apostle Film
Netflix

In Apostle, an ex-missionary called Thomas Richardson (Dan Stevens,) infiltrates a cult to rescue his kidnapped sister, Jennifer. At first, Thomas assumes the commune leader, Malcolm Howe, is using his disciples for his own personal gain. But over time, he realises there might be some truth to Howe's dogmatic beliefs.

The main reason Apostle is chilling is because it ironically doesn't focus on the horror elements. For the most part, the film plays out like a period drama or detective thriller. As such, viewers aren't ready when it turns into a medieval slasher, depicting fingers being hacked off, heads being drilled, and a woman being force-fed the blood of a dead rodent.

Apostle sets itself apart from other horror with its ability to create a sense of unease through atmospheric music and meticulous pacing, rather than cheap jump-scares. Yes, there is gore galore, but it always serve the narrative, and never comes across as gimmicky.

Although Apostle is longer than the average horror flick, it never feels lengthy, since the ever-present tension is sure to leave viewers engaged until the final frame.


5. The Human Centipede Part II

Human Centipede 2
Six Entertainment Company

In The Human Centipede, a mad scientist surgically attaches three people together "ass-to-mouth," creating the most disturbing conga line possible. Although the film developed a cult following, it feels like a concept that could only work once.

But not only does The Human Centipede Part II work (for the most part,) it leaves a far greater impression. The meta-sequel centres around a disturbed security guard called Martin. Martin is utterly obsessed with The Human Centipede, despite the fact it is, in the words of his victims, "only a movie". As his obsession grows, Martin starts kidnapping people, hoping to create a twelve-person centipede.

Even though The Human Centipede was billed as "the movie you'll struggle to watch," many hardcore horror fans didn't find it as gruesome as they expected. The sequel, on the other hand, is guaranteed to leave the most hardened viewers feeling squeamish.

When Martin's creation is assembled during the climax, it feels like the gross factor has peaked. That's when the movie unleashes a multitude of haunting images (especially one involving a newborn baby,) that'll leave viewers rattled for years.


4. Censor

Censor Niamh Algar
Film4

This British mind-bender follows a film censor called Enid, who's tasked with rating obscene horror movies. While reviewing Don't Go in the Church, Enid notices one scene is suspiciously similar to the night her sister, Nina, went missing.

While watching a movie made by the same director, she notices the lead actress resembles Nina. Convinced Nina was kidnapped at a young age so she could be exploited in the film industry, Enid does everything in her power to save her sibling.

What makes Censor stand out is how effectively it pays homage to the video nasty sub-genre. The grainy and atmospheric cinematography is so reminiscent of 1980s horror, it feels like Censor was made during that era. The director's choice to incorporate real video nasties adds a chilling authenticity to the story (and is a real treat for veterans of the genre).

Although viewers are rooting for Enid to reunite with her sister, it's obvious her job and childhood has traumatised her, making her an unreliable narrator. As Enid's sanity is pushed more and more, it's impossible to tell what's real until the final twist, which hits viewers like a train.


3. Suicide Club

Suicide Club WC Image
Earthrise

Suicide Club opens with 54 school girls in a subway station inexplicably jumping in front of a train, squishing them flat.

As utterly gruesome as this prologue is, it's crucial, since it lets viewers know what's in store for them. If they can't stomach visuals like this, this is their chance to back out. This is a fair warning since, as hard as it is to believe, Suicide Club rapidly delves into more unsettling territories.

However, it's nearly impossible to stop watching after witnessing this show-stopping opener. As grotesque as this scene is, it piques one's interests with immediate effect.

And when people across the city start taking their lives in a similar fashion, viewers will be inclined to stick through it, to learn what force could possibly compel people to act this way en masse.

Rather than using suicide as a manipulative plot device, the film explores key factors in society, including conformity, individuality, and the pressure which the youth is under. Even though Suicide Club is astoundingly violent, its focuses on more complex elements makes it far more thought-provoking than expected.


2. Eraserhead

eraserhead lynch
Libra Films

After nearly 50 years, David Lynch's directorial debut, Eraserhead, is still what the coiffed filmmaker is best-known for. Despite Lynch's vastly diverse career, nothing comes close to exemplifying the esteemed director's eccentric manner of storytelling as his first full-length feature.

Even though Lynch's passion project has been analysed to death, it's hard to explain what happens in Eraserhead, and it's more difficult to understand what it's about. Yes, the film deals with the pressures of being a new parent, but that barely scratches the surface.

Because of the experimental filmmaking and steam-of-consciousness narrative, Eraserhead isn't easy to follow or understand. (I mean, it does start with a sperm cell shooting out of the protagonist's mouth.) Considering it contains surreal visuals, including a puffy-cheeked woman living in a radiator and a deformed chicken baby gushing blood, it's not going to be everyone's cup of tea.

But there's no question Eraserhead leaves an everlasting impact. It may have no conventional scares, but the creep factor that germinates throughout every frame will spook anyone. Whether you thinks Eraserhead is high art or a meaningless affair, it's a one-of-a-kind experience, guaranteed to make all viewers think, "What the hell did I just watch?"


1. Martyrs

Martyrs 2008
Wild Bunch

Even though aliens, monsters, demons, and ghosts get hearts racing and teeth chattering, there's one entity far, far scarier.

People. History has repeatedly shown that humans are capable of committing the most unspeakable atrocities.

And few movies demonstrates this fact more than Pascal Laugier's Martyrs. The psychological horror opens with a young girl, Lucie, escaping from a slaughterhouse where she was daily tortured. After befriending another abused girl called Anna, the pair promises to punish the people who made Lucie's life a living hell.

Going into Martyrs, viewers expect to be horrified by the themes of child abuse and torture. (And yes, those qualities are explored in spades.)

However, nobody is ready for how unbearably depressing Martyrs is. There are few things more soul-destroying than watching people perform inconceivable deeds on the innocent for what they believe to be the greater good. And just as it look like things can't get any darker, Martyrs opens up a whole new dimension of terror.

Even though the film is phenomenal, no one watches it without feeling violated. Much like the lead characters, Martyrs bombards viewers with unimaginable horror, leaving them feeling deadened and empty.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Horror Martyrs
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

James Egan has been with Whatculture for five years and prominently works on Horror, Film, and Video Games. He's written over 80 books including 1000 Facts about Horror Movies Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts about The Greatest Films Ever Made Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts about Video Games Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts About James Bond 1000 Facts About TV Shows