10 Horror Remakes Everyone Expected To Suck (But Didn't)
These horror movie remakes totally over-delivered.
A lot of people really, really don't like remakes, and considering how often they're cynical, listless exercises in brand reinforcement, it's easy to appreciate why.
They're often indicative of Hollywood's craven lack of imagination, to simply rehash a prior success for another go-around, and no genre is more prone to this than horror.
But not all remakes are created equal, and though we're usually right to be skeptical of them, every so often one comes along that performs far above and beyond reasonable expectations.
And that's absolutely the case with these 10 horror remakes, each of which avoided obvious pitfalls, defied our understandably low expectations and actually delivered a rock-solid result.
Everything we knew about these remakes pre-release suggested they wouldn't work, yet the filmmakers took their clear love for the original and offered up something that managed to respect what came before while, in most cases, doing something laudably different.
While few of us want to see horror remakes clogging up our multiplexes any time soon, these ones are proof perfect that "remake" need not be a dirty word when a committed cast and crew are behind it...
10. The Texas Chainsaw Massacre
When 2003's remake of The Texas Chain Saw Massacre was first announced, fans were irate, and though it ultimately performed well at the box office, critics of the era largely dismissed it as a pointless rehash of Tobe Hooper's unassailable genre classic.
And yet, time has been incredibly kind to Marcus Nispel's gorgeously grimy retelling, which while hardly "necessary" as remakes go, packs a surprisingly mighty punch amid a sea of anodyne, listless horror remakes also produced by Platinum Dunes.
Indeed, it doesn't get close to touching the 1974 original, but this remake nevertheless boasts appreciably gross visuals as shot by the original's own cinematographer Daniel Pearl, a solid cast - especially final girl Jessica Biel and a scene-stealing R. Lee Ermey - and some unique set-pieces which set it apart from its predecessor.
In an era where sanitised horror remakes were speedily churned out for a new generation every couple of months, The Texas Chainsaw Massacre at least understood the essence of its inspiration and delivered a fitting redo.
9. Night of the Living Dead
Back in 1990, it was nothing short of sacrilege to consider remaking George A. Romero's legendary zombie film Night of the Living Dead, and so it's little surprise that reviews of the era were largely negative, in addition to it flopping at the box office.
But watch the movie today and it's tough not to get swept up by both director Tom Savini's peerless makeup effects and the film's smart reimagining of the original text, at once reverent to the original - having been also penned by Romero - and unafraid to make contemporary changes.
Most praise-worthy is the remake's reinvention of female lead Barbara (Patricia Tallman), who is lent considerably more agency in this newer take, while Tony Todd gives a superb performance as protagonist Ben.
Look past the fact that Night of the Living Dead 1990 doesn't "need" to exist - does any film? - and it's a rare remake crafted with real respect for what came before, while also feeling empowered to bring fresh ideas to the table.
8. Let Me In
There were eyerolls a-plenty when 2008's masterful Swedish vampire film Let the Right One In was confirmed for a glossy Hollywood remake with a budget almost five times that of the original.
It was simply expected, quite understandably given Hollywood's track record, that producers would massively water down the original's more unsavory and challenging elements to be more palatable to a multiplex audience that wants to be anything but challenged.
And on top of this, there was much hand-wringing about the remake being written and directed by Matt Reeves, whose most prominent credit at the time was Cloverfield - hardly a project that'd immediately qualify him to tackle this more pared-down, moody vampire film.
Though Let Me In doesn't reach the heights of the original, it does offer up an impressively well-wrought retelling, elevated by Reeves' stylish direction and strong performances from Kodi Smit-McPhee, Chloë Grace Moretz, and Richard Jenkins.
7. The Ring
Gore Verbinski's The Ring kickstarted Hollywood's run of J-horror remakes throughout the 2000s, and arguably remains the standard bearer for glossy American remakes of international horror hits.
First and foremost, Verbinski and his cinematographer Bojan Bazelli did a fantastic job giving The Ring a distinct visual identity from both 1998's Ringu and Hollywood horror as a whole, the sickly green tint present throughout the film making it immediately recognisable from just a second's glance.
This speaks to the film's wider atmospheric achievements, relying less on gore and obnoxious jump scares and more on skin-crawling vibes and slow-building suspense.
It doesn't hurt that Naomi Watts gives a terrific performance in the lead role either.
Ignore the thoroughly naff sequels that followed, but for a remake that seemed primed to be nothing more than a hollow, style-over-substance rehash, it's impressively effortful filmmaking from start to finish.
6. Friday the 13th
After successfully remaking The Texas Chain Saw Massacre against the odds, director Marcus Nispel proved it was far from a fluke by doing it again for Friday the 13th.
But his 2009 remake was far from a straightforward redo - it instead offered up a retelling of the original Friday trilogy, telling a streamlined origin story for Jason that made some impressively bold and unexpected choices.
Right from its scintillating prologue, this is a ferocious horror that doesn't skimp on the gore but also occasionally takes a breath for some goofy humour. Who among us can forget Travis Van Winkle's irrepressible horndog dudebro Trent?
The remake also dares to expand the lore of Jason in some fascinating ways, namely explaining his ability to so effortlessly get the drop on his victims without it feeling like a mythology expansion nobody asked for.
Despite grossing almost $100 million worldwide, though, it didn't lead to the expected glut of sequels due to legal issues regarding the franchise's rights.
And over 15 years later, we're still waiting for a new Friday the 13th. What the hell, man?
5. Cat People
When a 40-years-later remake of RKO's beloved 1942 horror film Cat People was announced, there was a lot of skepticism about the prospect of remaking a bonafide genre classic.
But leave it to the great Paul Schrader to deliver a totally singular and unexpected remix of the original erotic horror story, taking the implication and innuendo of the '42 film and turning it inside out.
The Cat People remake is explicit and very, very grim in ways that its predecessor simply couldn't realise on screen due to the restrictions of the Hays Code at the time.
By comparison, Schrader's take is an untamed beast not unlike its central character.
In addition to its more permissive content, its gorgeous, colourful visuals stand in stark contrast to the original's monochrome style, and Nastassja Kinski's performance as the titular cat person is a sensual, unforgettable delight.
While Cat People '82 is far from universally liked, it is a remake that fully justifies its existence by going so much harder than its inspiration was ever able to.
4. Evil Dead
Evil Dead is one of those sacrosanct horror films that many fans felt shouldn't ever be remade - beyond Evil Dead II being a quasi-remake of the original, of course.
And it was incredibly easy to have through-the-floor expectations for 2013's remake given that Bruce Campbell wasn't the lead and it was being helmed by a virtually unknown filmmaker, Fede Álvarez, in his feature debut.
Even with original director Sam Raimi producing the remake under his Ghost House banner, what was the point in rehashing perfection?
Though Álvarez's remake absolutely wears its bigger budget on its sleeve - having been produced for $17 million compared to the original's $375,000 - and takes a more serious, less-camp approach, it nevertheless delivers an appreciably nasty, extremely bloody reimagining.
Much of the credit goes to not only Álvarez's visually creative direction, but also Jane Levy's superb performance in the lead role, ensuring it was easier than expected to forget about Ash and just enjoy the gnarly ride.
3. The Hills Have Eyes
There wasn't much interest in 2006's remake of The Hills Have Eyes when it was first announced, because as if remaking a Wes Craven classic wasn't bad enough, it was being directed by Alexandre Aja, whose previous film High Tension tripped over itself so spectacularly in the third act.
But there's honestly a solid argument to be made that Aja's film is superior to Craven's, or at least comes within a mouse hair of it.
With its gnarlier gore, creepier setting, and an intriguing post-9/11 thematic which takes American exceptionalism to task, this is a remake that updates the original in all the right ways.
Also, shoutout to the ever-underappreciated Aaron Stanford for his terrific central performance as protagonist Doug.
While there's a low-fi grottiness to the original that this remake can't replicate, in terms of violence, intensity, and character development, the 2006 film is a vast improvement.
And much like Marcus Nispel, Aja pulled off another coup remake a few years later when he helmed the shockingly entertaining Piranha 3D.
2. Speak No Evil
When savage Danish horror Speak No Evil premiered at Sundance in 2022, critics immediately began counting down the time before this deliciously premised chamber piece would get an inevitable English-language remake.
And indeed, many horror fans groaned when it was confirmed the very next year that Blumhouse were developing the remake, no matter that it touted a talented cast led by James McAvoy and Mackenzie Davis.
While the recent Speak No Evil remake undeniably planes away the sharper edges of its more vicious original - particularly in its more crowd-pleasing third act - it still captures the awkward tension of its inspiration, and benefits massively from James McAvoy's swinging-for-the-fences performance as the central villain.
This is a remake that does the rarest of things - it "sanitises" the decidedly meaner source material, albeit in a manner entertaining enough to inexplicably get away with it.
It doesn't replace the original but serves as a rock solid companion piece, which is pretty much a best case scenario for a rushed-into-production remake few fans of the original were asking for.
However Christian Tafdrup, who directed the original, didn't have much kind to say about the remake after watching it.
1. Quarantine
Another horror remake that genre fans saw coming a mile off now, with 2008's Quarantine - an ultra-faithful English-language retelling of acclaimed Spanish found footage film [REC].
Impressively, Quarantine rolled cameras just two months after [REC] was released, though that certainly didn't provide much hope it'd be a considered or particularly effort-filled remake.
But honestly, the worst thing that can really be said about Quarantine is that it's reverent to a fault, offering up a beat-for-beat retelling that, to anyone happy enough to read subtitles, is basically "pointless."
Yet it's well-made, Jennifer Carpenter gives a solid lead performance, and it actually makes one smart change from the original - while [REC]'s chilling ending is immediately followed up by jarring rock music throughout its end credits, Quarantine leaves the audience to soak it all in with eerie ambient sounds.
Surprisingly despite Quarantine performing well at the box office relative to its low budget, the filmmakers never bothered remaking the other two direct sequels to [REC], opting instead to produce one standalone sequel which came and went without making a dent.