10 Horror Remakes To Avoid This Halloween

Freddy's back....again....for more.

Anyone who doubts that the movies are a gold rush business need only look at the clones that come out in the wake of a major hit, all of which are competing to be the first to do something for the second time. From the moment someone yells, €œStrike!€, you can expect a steady diet of more of the same from now until the next score. When the late 90s horror boom produced several successful remakes (House On Haunted Hill, The Ring etc), Hollywood took note and began snapping up remake rights to every second and third rate title available. The formula was simple: pretty teen stars from a popular TV show, a budget low enough to ensure profitability and enough action to make sure the target demographic didn€™t get bored. Rupert Wainright€™s The Fog (2005) is a perfect example of the contempt shown for audiences. Rushed into production to capitalize on the craze, the movie was written, shot and in theatres within a year, and the producers even had the gall to promote it as €œFrom the makers of Halloween.€ While John Carpenter and Debra Hill are credited as producers, it€™s safe to assume neither had much control over the final product €“ Hill died 7 months before the film€™s release. When settling in to watch a scary movie this Halloween, you might want to give the following a wide berth. After all, there are plenty of other films competing for your attention.

10. The Haunting (1999)

This is the tawdry, illogical, monotonous, never-ending, pointless, lame, ridiculous, underwhelming, needless, stupid, patience-testing, senseless, unnecessary, time-stealing, joyless, obnoxious, oh-God-oh-God-I€™m-going-to-die-in-here Jan de Bont movie that isn€™t Speed 2: Cruise Control, but if you enjoy watching good actors run away from special effects for 2 hours, knock yourself out. Note to gullible idiots: you should never trust a doctor who conducts an €œinsomnia study€ in a haunted house, even if he is played by Liam Neeson. After statues come to life and staircases collapse, he€™ll reveal he really lured you there for a study of group fear and hysteria. Most critics wondered what Shirley Jackson€™s novel (or Robert Wise€™s 1963 adaptation) had done to deserve such treatment. The Austin Chronicle called it €œabout as tantalizing as a desicated Gummi Bear€, while James Berardinelli, writing for Reel Views, noted that €œthe only thing disturbing about The Haunting is how discouraging the end product is.€

9. Carnival Of Souls (1998)

Okay, gang: what happens when you watch a remake from the director of Sometimes They Come Back€.Again, produced by the director of Warlock: The Armageddon, with Wes Craven€™s name attached to draw an audience? Here€™s a hint: the villain is played by Larry Miller, who was anally raped by a hamster in The Nutty Professor 2: The Klumps. Carnival Of Souls has ambitions similar to that hamster, except it wants to spray itself with shellac, put spikes through its feet and gorge itself until it€™s the size of a pineapple before donning a miner€™s helmet and taking that trip up yonder. But it either overate or is a lazy sumbitch because instead it just sits there spitting at you until it dies of a cerebral oedema and begins reeking up the joint. Craven might€™ve had nothing to do with Souls (he €œpresents€ the film), but it€™s ironic that the film€™s antagonist €“ played by director Herk Harvey in the 1962 original €“ here becomes a Freddy Krueger-ish bogeyman who wears clown make-up, appears at will and possesses powers that don€™t require an explanation. In other words, they threw out Harvey€™s movie and made Elm Street-lite. Shame on you, guys.

8. Day Of The Dead (2008)

Sensibly dumped on DVD by its distributor, this Day follows neither 2004€™s Dawn Of The Dead (which also starred Ving Rhames) nor 2006€™s Night Of The Living Dead 3D, it€™s just another stand-alone rip-off hiding behind a famous title. And what a rip-off. Gone is the briskness of George Romero€™s original set-up and in, courtesy of screenwriter JeffreyReddick (Final Destination), comes lots of running around as a bunch of boring, interchangeable nobodies behave in stupid ways. If our last line of defence against the living dead consists of Mena Suvari, AnnaLynne McCord and Nick Cannon (later a judge on America€™s Got Talent), we really are in trouble. The director is Steve Miner, who also helmed Friday The 13th Part 2 & 3, House and Halloween H20, so he knows how to squeeze thrills out of limited budgets (and ideas), but Day looks and plays like a TV movie. Rushed and poorly staged, with indifferent make-up effects, it€™s enough to make you nostalgic for Flight of the Living Dead.

7. The Texas Chainsaw Massacre (2003)

The Texas Chainsaw Massacre was made for the lowest budget ($9m) of Michael Bay€™s career, but don€™t go thinking that this is a €˜little€™ movie struggling to compete against the studio big guns. That label could€™ve been applied to the 16mm Drive-in movie Tobe Hooper shot in his backyard in 1973, but the remake is an exploitation picture for the modern era. It€™s bigger, faster and has more of everything €“ but it isn€™t necessarily better. Chainsaw €™03 is all about suffering, mostly the audience€™s, but whereas other films that set out to make a quick buck from over-the-top brutality, from Last House On The Left to Chaos, usually have the kind of production values found in hardcore pornography or amateur snuff films, debuting commercials director Marcus Nispel, probably under orders from Bay, gives us Torture Porn: The Music Video. Intercutting close-ups of open wounds and lopped-off limbs with the sort of visuals you€™d expect to see in a Pepsi ad, this is the Spinal Tap of reboots, constantly going up to eleven, which because it€™s irresponsible, shameless and slow on the uptake, it considers an impressive feat.

6. Black Christmas (2006)

This is the seasonal horror opus that isn€™t Bloody Christmas, Christmas Evil, Christmas With The Dead, The Christmas Season Massacre, A Cadaver Christmas, Deadly Little Christmas, Don€™t Open Till Christmas, Bikini Blood Bath Christmas, One Hell Of A Christmas, The 13th Day Of Christmas, Santa Claws, Satan Claus, Santa€™s Slay, Slayer Santa, Psycho Santa, Hate€™s Haunted Slay Ride, Silent Night, Silent Night Bloody Night, Silent Night Deadly Night, Silent Night Zombie Night, Violent Night: The Movie, Tinsel or Jack Frost. There are no murdering mutant snowmen in this remake and the villain doesn€™t make wisecracks or kill anyone while dressed as Santa but otherwise it offers pretty much what you€™d expect. It€™s supposedly a remake of Bob Clark€™s 1974 film, but the tone, pacing and intent are very different. Working with limited resources, Clark still pulled off a seminal, atmospheric movie, whose plot device of a killer calling from inside the house would be ripped off countless times in countless movies. The nicest thing you can say about this reboot is that the cast is comprised of great screamers.

5. Friday The 13th (2009)

Brace yourselves, for this may come as a surprise, but do you think there is just the slightest chance that a character who has been drowned, axed, macheted, killed by Corey Feldman, cremated, aped by a copycat, resurrected by lightning/ telekinesis/ possession/an underwater power surge, melted by toxic waste, blown up by an FBI task force, sent to hell, sent into space and returned to the present for a grudge match with Freddy might€™ve become€you know€a tad over-familiar? Have, dare we say it, outstayed his welcome? When characters with no surnames sit around the campfire and retell the story of Mrs Voorhees and her boy moments before the big fella turns up, machete in hand, it€™s hard not to be reminded of all those parodies€.including Scooby Doo! Camp Scare. In fact, all that€™s missing are a few cries of €œHe€™s behind you, Scooby!€ Because Jason usually is. For almost every kill.

4. Thir13en Ghosts (2001)

In the same year Michael Bay co-founded Platinum Dunes, Dark Castle unleashed their second redux (following 1999€™s House On Haunted Hill) and they could€™ve chosen better because 13 Ghosts (as it was called in those days) wasn€™t even that great when William Castle did it in 1960. Those who remember it at all remember it for the gimmick of €œIllusion-O€, where €œGhost Viewers€ (actually 3D glasses) allowed audience members to see the spirits. Here, 12 ghosts held in 12 cages in the basement of an isolated mansion are unwittingly released, causing The Damsel In Distress, The Cute Kid and The Comic Relief to run around screaming for the rest of the movie. And before you ask, yes, they do decide to split up inside the haunted house. It€™s that lame. Ah, but what of the 13th ghost, you say? Glad you asked. Turns out F Murray Abraham lured Tony Shalhoub to the house under false pretences, stashed the ghost of his dead wife in a closet and hoped her appearance would make Shalhoub kill himself out of love, thus completing the baker€™s dozen and making Abraham the most powerful person in the world€.somehow.

3. Piranha 3D (2010)

In common with her day job, porn star Riley Steele isn€™t required to act or say anything in Piranha 3D, just wander around in a bikini and go skinny dipping, and if her presence doesn€™t make clear the film€™s attitude towards women, then constant shouts of €œnaked bitches€ will remind you. The film€™s attitude to its audience can be deduced from the fact that this remake of a Jaws rip-off was French filmmaker Alexandre Aja€™s third redux, brought to the screen by Dimension Films, who also remade Black Christmas, Pulse and Halloween. Calling it shallow, pointless and casually sexist is to risk one of those €œIt wasn€™t supposed to be Hamlet€ arguments, which begs the question€.what was it supposed to be? Because if you were thinking Guilty Pleasure, bad news €“ Roger Corman did it better, thirty years earlier, with Humanoids From The Deep. Excising the wit and film buff in jokes of Joe Dante€™s original, Piranha 3D plays like Humanoids€™ third act stretched to feature length, only with porn stars and wet t-shirt contests. Which is fine for a while, but when you realize it has nothing else to offer and there€™s another hour left, the film creeps around guiltily, like an old man in a raincoat.

2. The Wicker Man (2006)

No list of unnecessary remakes is complete without The Wicker Man, which courtesy of its leading man€™s histrionics has a shot at being the funniest bad movie of the last decade. Whether dropping the F-bomb in front of small children, stealing a teacher€™s bicycle at gunpoint or knocking out a woman while dressed as a bear (don€™t ask), Nicolas Cage is the whole show here and his over-the-top-and-through-the-woods shenanigans elevate an otherwise uninteresting failure to Bad Movie Heaven. In order to convey his character€™s frustration, Nic shouts his lines, says everything three times and, when the going gets weird, eventually resorts to Kung-Fu. According to director Neil Labutte€™s commentary, the star demanded daily rewrites so that his character would be more believable, martial arts apparently being common among motorcycle cops. Had the movie been played for intentional laughs, with our indomitable hero investigating weird goings on at the settlement depicted in The Village (2004), Nic would€™ve been in his element. He could€™ve overplayed to his heart€™s content, worn an ostrich costume and joked about partying like it€™s 1899. Come the big finale, he fights Bryce Dallas Howard€™s blind samurai warrior and punches out M Night Shyamalan. He still gets barbecued, though. They were running low on roast ham.

1. A Nightmare On Elm Street (2010)

Remember when the surviving Beatles regrouped in the mid-90s and released Free As A Bird, a €˜new€™ song that was really one of John Lennon€™s unreleased demos? Glam, punk, new wave and grunge had been and gone, the Sixties counter-culture had become The Establishment etc, but if you closed your eyes and listened€.Free As A Bird still sounded like a cash-in. Well, Freddy must be the Paul McCartney of serial killers, because after appearing in music videos and on lunch boxes, after cameoing in South Park and being a €˜nostalgic€™ gag in The Wedding Singer, he€™s Establishment to the core. Elm Street 2010 is his Free As A Bird. One reason why we see Messrs Krueger and Voorhees so often, and Bruce The Shark or Father Merrin so seldom, is that unlike Jaws and The Exorcist, an excursion to Springwood or Crystal Lake doesn€™t require name actors or expensive effects. You can knock one out for little more than the cost of a DVD movie, so it doesn€™t matter if there€™s no story worth telling or vision worth seeing €“ there€™s no financial risk, either. You could produce a sluggish, awkward film that nobody claims to like, saddle it with a stupid ending, and it will still open bank vaults for you.

Contributor

Ian Watson is the author of 'Midnight Movie Madness', a 600+ page guide to "bad" movies from 'Reefer Madness' to 'Poultrygeist: Night of the Chicken Dead.'