10 Huge Mistakes In Marvel's Cinematic Universe
10. Ed Norton As Bruce Banner (The Incredible Hulk)
When Ed Norton was cast as Bruce Banner in Louis Leterrier's The Incredible Hulk, I was overjoyed, and having seen the film, he certainly gave a stirring portrayal of the character, far outdoing Eric Bana's turn in Ang Lee's Hulk. However, things took a turn for the worse when Norton's relationship with Marvel broke down, reportedly as a result of the actor wanting to have creative control over his performance and how the character was portrayed; on the set of The Incredible Hulk, he went about assembling his own cut of the film in the way that he envisioned it, which rubbed just about everyone the wrong way. Also, due to the editing dispute, Norton refused to do publicity for the film. Banner was recast for The Avengers with Mark Ruffalo taking the helm, and given that Ruffalo managed to top Norton, giving easily the best screen portrayal of the character to date - in large part due to Joss Whedon's electrifying script - it makes the Norton Hulk seem incongruous and awkward. Nobody can predict the future, but this is a regrettable aspect of the MCU nevertheless.
9. One-Dimensional Villains (Iron Man 2)
Expectations were high for Iron Man 2, yet the consensus on the whole seems to be that it didn't meet them, and this was in large part because of the pretty mediocre villains on display. When it was announced that Mickey Rourke was cast as Whiplash, the net nerds were overjoyed; Rourke is a superb actor, and would no doubt be able to bring the appropriate level of menace. As his partner in crime Justin Hammer, Sam Rockwell seemed like a fine fit for the slimy bureaucrat also. In the end, though, the villains seem curiously one-note and dull. Rourke looks the part, but has a simple revenge back-story that's not very well developed, and Rockwell's Hammer is similarly a very simplistic villain without much in the way of complexity or intrigue, just a rival to Stark. Though Rourke especially tries hard to impart his role with some gravitas, even he notes that he didn't have a whole lot to work with.
8. Forced Romance (Thor)
I wasn't a huge fan of Thor as it stands, and one of the big reasons was because of the laughably cynical central "romance" between the titular Asgardian and Dr. Jane Foster, which is utterly superfluous to the grander narrative, and is woefully underdeveloped. Even ignoring the fact that Thor and Jane don't have a whole lot of screen time together - given that Thor finds himself dividing his time between Asgard and Earth - does every superhero movie need a romance thrown in higgledy-piggledy? Not much more than a few seconds of thought are devoted to establishing this connection, such that when they end up kissing, who really gives a damn? If this relationship is going to work, more screen time needs to be focused on their relationship in Thor: The Dark World, because I don't care at all at the moment.
7. Black Widow & Hawkeye (The Avengers)
Though The Avengers was a fantastic film, there's one area that felt really malnourished and underdeveloped, and that's the two "lesser" Avengers, Black Widow and Hawkeye. Though some screen time is devoted to their past, on the whole they just feel like superfluous characters who don't really have a whole lot to do. The fact that they are so obviously under-powered - and, you know, human - compared to their team-mates makes them seem like second-string Avengers members; while The Hulk, Thor, Iron Man and Captain America all get moments to shine, it's hard to say the same for these two. Even Jeremy Renner himself said he was disappointed with the little he was given to do, so hopefully with The Avengers 2 - and the films leading into it - Joss Whedon will find a way to make them seem a little more interesting.
6. Messy Plot (Iron Man 2)
We've already established that Iron Man 2 was a disappointment, and apart from the boring villains, a lot of the reason was that it was just so simplistically plotted; it girds along the typical three act structure with exactly the beats you expect, with a cursory attempt made to start tying it to the MCU as well. Jon Favreau even admitted that Marvel Studios wanted him to force MCU elements into the film, which was essentially why he didn't return for IM3 or direct The Avengers, and stars Downey Jr. and Rourke also came out admitting that it's the weak link in the series. It just never felt like it had a clear direction - it wanted to introduce MCU characters like Black Widow, but the standalone story suffered as a result, feeling piecemeal and ineffective. The worst thing I can about IM2 is that, aside from its final set-piece, there's just not a whole lot about it that's particularly memorable.
5. The Mandarin (Iron Man 3)

SPOILER WARNING FOR IRON MAN 3. I've already spoken at length about this, but the twist in Iron Man 3 really hampered the experience for me; I enjoyed the first act, but the mid-film reveal that The Mandarin was, in fact, a decoy, seemed like a total waste of the character.
Ben Kingsley has the likeness of the character, but it is completely pawned off as a postmodern joke, while Guy Pearce's Aldrich Killian instead plays the main antagonist, professing to be the "real" Mandarin despite looking nothing like the comic book counterpart.
Though the critical reception has been very strong, the fan backlash has been equally vocal, noting a certain degree of disrespect for the very fans who have allowed these films to have huge box office grosses. It seems like a po-faced move to try and surprise viewers rather than just focusing on satisfyingly portraying a beloved villain from the comics. Though not everyone will be bothered by it, for me it really distracted from the good things the film did (the action and the humour).
4. Lack of Spider-Man
Well, this one's just a pipe dream and there's no getting around that, but wouldn't it be amazing to see Spider-Man show up as part of The Avengers? Depressingly, the Oscorp building was originally planned to show up in the New York skyline in The Avengers, but they couldn't get the render finished in time, so it was left out. It's a shame, as this at least suggests that Sony and Marvel Studios are on the same page in some capacity, despite protestations that they are not. The problem is that cutting through all of the bureaucratic nonsense and having the two studios agree on terms is just a legal minefield; neither studio wants to be seen as conceding to the other, and as a result we'll almost definitely never see Spidey join Iron Man and friends.
3. Keeping Pepper Potts Alive (Iron Man 3)
Prior to its release, one major expectation of Iron Man 3 was that either Pepper Potts or Happy Hogan would die, and given how much Pepper means to Tony, it seemed fair to assume that it would be her. After all, what better way is there to cement a villain than to have them murder the hero's love? However, Shane Black basically wimped out at the last minute, having Pepper be dropped into a smoldering fire, only to survive because of the Extremis virus she was infected with. If Pepper had instead been killed in The Mandarin's attack on Tony's home, it would have accentuated the gritty tone Black was shooting for, and also made Tony's quest for revenge that much more poignant. Instead, it really comes down to the bad guy blowing up his house and putting the comic relief sidekick in hospital, which isn't fantastic motivation for an epic action film like this. I can see why they didn't kill Pepper off, but it would have helped keep things interesting, and no doubt left us a very different Tony Stark for The Avengers 2.
2. Characterisation (Thor)
Aside from the fact that the plot is incredibly thin, there are plenty of issues with Thor - the disconnect between Asgard and Earth is never satisfyingly realised for me, and as I've already said, the Jane Foster-Thor romance is just terrible. There's one thing that really strikes me as disappointing, though, and that's the characterisation of Thor himself; every other Marvel hero can be related to in one way or another, yet not Thor. Though those of us trying to seek familial approval might get a giggle out of it, I just never cared about whether Thor became King or not. The film didn't rouse the emotions like so many other Marvel films (namely Spider-Man), and just feels cold and disconnected. Perhaps that's the point given that Thor is an alien, but it doesn't exactly make for the most gratifying viewing experience.
1. Failing To Set Up Phase Two (Iron Man 3)
IRON MAN 3 SPOILER WARNING (AGAIN). Perhaps the most surprising thing about Iron Man 3 is that it did practically nothing to propel Phase Two of the MCU forward. Though that can be left for Captain America: The Winter Soldier and Thor: The Dark World, Iron Man 3 didn't give us anything. The film ends with Tony having the arc reactor removed, blowing up his suits but still attesting that he is Iron Man; while that might be satisfying from a character perspective, there was always the expectation that IM3 would leave us wanting more which, to be honest, it didn't at all. I came out of IM3 feeling like it was a closed-off end-point to the character, and that he's finally found a way to reconcile his issues and balance the two sides of his persona. If Shane Black wanted me to be excited about Tony Stark's next adventure (presumably The Avengers 2), we should have at least seen Tony re-building his home and basically re-restablishing himself having now gotten rid of his post-Avengers trauma. Instead, we got nothing. Which MCU moments make you cringe the most? Let us know in the comments below.
