10 Huge Sequels That Were Announced (And Then Just Disappeared)

From the possible to the improbable to the extremely ambitious...

It's no secret that movie sequels have been a source of tension in the entertainment industry; one has only to look as far as the Star Wars franchise to see the damaging effects a sequel can have on the original content, not to mention the coexistence of the fans. If there's anything we learned from The Phantom Menace, it's that bringing characters back for a second, third, or even fourth go-round can be a touchy subject. Ultimately it all comes down to a cautious optimism and sense of trust harbored by fans that takes a special kind of magic not to betray. Some sequels are able to capture that magic, a prime example being Spider-Man 2, but movies like Spider-Man 3 can leave franchises in a state of disrepair. Unfortunately, most sequels are made not for the enhancement of the original, but to snag over eager moviegoers - and their hard-earned dollar - by giving them what they want; a chance to see their favorite characters grace the screens once more. Admittedly, some sequels execute this concept extremely well, and have managed to become classics in their own right; the Back to the Future trilogy, Indiana Jones installments (sans Kingdom of the Crystal Skull), and Nolan's Batman Trilogy, to name a few. But there's a third breed of sequel that has us breathing a sigh of relief while simultaneously wondering if we've been robbed of a cinematic masterpiece. Over the years a number of sequels have been officially announced or considered, and yet were left by the wayside, offering nothing more than inspiration for your next piece of fanfiction. Here is a list of 10 sequels that were announced and just disappeared...

10. E.T. 2

We all know that E.T. : The Extra-Terrestrial is a Steven Spielberg classic, and has long been considered a staple in any movie lover's personal collection. One can hardly forget the first time they experienced the heartfelt story about a homesick alien, his bond with a young boy, and their subsequent quest to return E.T. to his rightful home. The movie was a huge success, having earned 9 Oscar nominations and the title "Highest Grossing Film of 1982". Even now it sits on the list of highest grossing films of all time, comfortably placed at #42, among movies such as The Avengers, The Titanic, and several of the Harry Potter installments. The success of E.T. naturally sparked talks of a sequel, one that would see Elliot dealing with the loss of his friend, the divorce of his parents, and the eventual threat of alien invasion. The working title was E.T. II: Nocturnal Fears, and it had all the ingredients to make an interesting and exciting sequel, but the film never made its way past the 9-page pitch, which has since been made available to the public. So what was stopping this feature from taking off? It's likely a multitude of factors were taken into consideration when deciding whether or not to give Nocturnal Fears a chance, but in the end, Spielberg explained that it was partially due to the unstable and unpredictable nature that is inherent in the realm of sequels. When asked by the American Film Institute about the film, he said, "Sequels can be very dangerous because they compromise your truth as an artist. I think a sequel to E.T. would do nothing but rob the original of its virginity. People only remember the latest episode, while the pilot tarnishes." Perhaps if more filmmakers took these profound words to heart, society would have been saved from several cinematic disasters, but alas.

9. Gump And Co.

You know the films that seem to be in a perpetual state of limbo? The ones that are promised to be finished by producers and writers alike, but never actually gain any solid ground? Gump and Co. is one of those films. This movie was to be based on a novel of the same name, which had been written by Winston Groom and published the year after Forrest Gump had made it's movie debut. The book itself received mixed reviews, partially due to the combining of Groom's original character and Tom Hanks' Forrest Gump in an attempt to appeal to the novel and film fans alike. Naturally the well-intentioned plan backfired, and we were left with a weak character who had been written into an even weaker plot. Nevertheless, Hollywood seemed determined that they would have the book adapted for film and finished by 2002, but when the attacks of September 11 occurred in 2001, the project was placed on hold with no return date in sight. The last we've heard of the adaptation was a 2007 announcement by Paramount that claimed they were still looking to move forward with the film. The premise of the film would have stayed true to the novel itself; with Jenny gone and Forrest now a single father, his shrimp business €“ Bubba Gump Shrimp Company €“ would eventually take a nosedive, subsequently causing the Gump boys to struggle through life. In the novel, Forrest's story had indeed been made into a film, and the attention it had garnered him has started to affect his life. What ensues is a whirlwind through history that is rife with real events and celebrity "cameos"; Forrest helps tear down the Berlin Wall, fights in Operation Desert Storm, meets Bill and Hillary Clinton, and even has the opportunity to come in contact with Tom Hanks himself. While the film could have been a recipe for disaster, there's nothing to say that it couldn't have been a huge success like its predecessor. Unfortunately €“ or thankfully, depending on how you choose to believe it would have fared €“ it doesn't seem like we'll get the chance to experience this sequel any time soon.

8. The Breakfast Club 2

Just typing this title out seems like a horrible affront to the original film. The fact that John Hughes even considered going forward with this sequel is astounding to me, but apparently it had been on his mind ever since the groundbreaking success of the first film. Set and filmed 10 years after the events of The Breakfast Club, the sequel would have caught up with Bender, Claire, Andrew, Brian, and Allison to see where their lives had taken them. While this isn't a completely horrid premise for a second film, it is a terribly cliche one. In the end, one of the most substantial reasons for halting the production was the volatile relationship between John Hughes and Judd Nelson, as well as Molly Ringwald's decision to move on to more mature films in an attempt to break out of the teen genre. With two of his star actors out of the picture, details failed to fall into place and The Breakfast Club 2 was added to the long list of movies that could have been but never were. Which is probably for the best. Part of the genius of The Breakfast Club was the perfect ambiguity that the story held; while we saw glimpses into the lives of the characters, we were only given them in small doses and sporadic instances. The audience learned to love the characters in the moments we saw and not the moments we were told about, as is so often the case. This allowed us to make our own assumptions about the characters' lives and personalities, and ultimately decide where the gang would have found themselves the next morning, let alone 10 years down the road. A sequel would have robbed the original film of that magic, devaluing it of the beautiful simplicity that it had achieved.

7. Gladiator 2

Though the first Gladiator film saw the heroic death of Russell Crowe's Maximus, that wouldn't stop Australian jack-of-all-trades Nick Cave from reviving the character for a subsequent action packed blockbuster. He even wrote a full script for the film €“ which he had titled "Christ Killer" €“ but that's about as far as the movie progressed. Initially, Crowe had been the one to call Cave and put in the request for a second go-round for Maximus, which raises questions as to why the film was never actually completed; a lead actor so gung-ho for a sequel should have spelled success. Perhaps the premise of the film itself was what gave the other key players pause, an answer that seems most viable when reading through Cave's script. Since Russell Crowe was the one commissioning the writer in the first place, Cave's biggest challenge would be discovering a way to bring Maximus back from the dead, which apparently isn't a difficult thing to do when your film is set in ancient Rome. The gladiator is raised to life immortal by the gods, and is naturally given a hefty quest to make up for all that expended godly power €“ kill Christ and all his followers. The gods of the heavens were quickly wasting away, their power being stolen believer by believer every time a new Christian convert appeared, and Maximus would be the solution to their problem. The film would have followed Maximus' journey through the ages to effectively wipe Christianity from the face of the earth. It's a risky and somewhat controversial plot, to be sure, and is probably the reason the film never saw the light of day.

6. The Vega Brothers

Vega Brothers Speaking of risks, if there's anyone willing to take a few, it's Quentin Tarantino. It's long been a speculation that Vic Vega of Reservoir Dogs and Vincent Vega of Pulp Fiction are in fact brothers, which isn't exactly an implausible theory; we've since learned that there's no relation between them at all, and that there was never intended to be. "But what's this about the Vega Brothers? Are they brothers or not?" you ask. After the success of both Reservoir Dogs and Pulp Fiction, there were talks of a potential spinoff including both Michael Madsen and Jon Travolta as the twin brothers of Vic and Vincent, respectively. Not only would this solve the dilemma of both of the original characters' deaths, but also the issue of the the actors' ages in relation to their previous roles. The idea was that Madsen and Travolta would find themselves on a flight to LA with the intent of avenging their respective twin's murder. The premise itself is a tad lacking, sure, but it also could have been a fun homage to Tarantino's earlier work, and would have served as a great cult favorite for fans. Unfortunately, the likeliness of seeing this film on the silver screen dwindles every year, as the actors get older and the screenwriter moves on to bigger things.

5. Back To The Future 4 & 5

I want you to take a moment to envision your first experience with Marty McFly and Doc Brown. Close your eyes, and picture that time traveling Delorean, burning it's way over the asphalt or taking to the sky. Now picture a UFO crashing to earth, Doc Brown and his new female assistant powerless to stop it. In fact, the Doc has inadvertently caused the crash, so now it's Rule 63 Marty's job to clean up the mess. Alright, please stop imagining now. Please. Believe it or not, this is precisely the plot that was considered for a fourth and fifth installment to the series, even if it was only for a brief period of time. The rumor was that Ed Solomon had been commissioned to write those treatments, which he did in fact do, and that the films would have seen the departure of Michael J. Fox and the heralding in of a new star; there had even been talks of casting Sarah Michelle Gellar as the plucky lead. I think we can all agree that the Back to the Future franchise would have been ill-served by abandoning the actor that carried at least 50% of the weight in order to make the trilogy a classic in it's own right. Perhaps it's the implementation of a new main character, or maybe it's the whole "UFO crashing to earth" trope, but something about the sequel treatments just seems slightly different from the feel of the first three films, and it's probably for the best that they never became more than briefly considered concepts.

4. Elf 2

In a world where so many actors leap at the chance for another sequel and a bigger paycheck (see: Russell Crowe), Will Ferrell steps in to save the day! Even though he was offered quite a large sum to don the tights and pointy-toed shoes once more, Ferrell turned down the request because of the fear of compromising his ethics, and receiving the inevitable blame if the sequel turned out to be a farce. Due to Ferrell's prompt response and subsequent obliteration of sequel plans, no plot details were released to the public. Perhaps the filmmakers themselves were unsure of what direction the comedy would have taken, but I think it's safe to say it wouldn't have received high marks. As a rule, the majority of comedy sequels lack a certain something to make them fan favorites, simply because their predecessors are not likely to leave the audience wanting more out of the story. For Elf, the plot was pretty much wrapped up with a shiny bow by the end credits; a sequel would have seemed forced, at best. Thank you once again, Will Ferrell. You're an inspiration to us all.

3. Napoleon Dynamite 2

Back in 2006, there were a number of rumors circulating about a sequel to the quirky comedy, which led to star Efren Ramirez (Pedro) confirming that there were in fact talks of a sequel. Of course, that was seven years ago, and it's doubtful that those talks ever came to fruition. The closest the franchise came to continuing the story was a 2 month stint as a cartoon on Fox in 2012. The characters were even voiced by the original actors, but how can a cartoon compete with the genius of the on-screen persona given to Napoleon by Jon Heder? Obviously it can't as proven by the failed animated follow-up. It's another case of a comedy film's catch 22. The question we need to ask ourselves is this: did there need to be a Napoleon Dynamite 2? The safe answer is no, in every sense of the word. The film left us with a shot of Napoleon and Deb playing a casual game of tetherball, which was a simple and sweet ending to a simple and sweet movie, but we can all agree that it's not exactly sequel material. Napoleon Dynamite remains a solitary gem in the independent film genre, and that's the way it should be.

2. YA Book-To-Screen Series

Golden Compass When filmmakers began adapting novels for the big screen, we all knew that there were going to be some wonderful classics and some...less than favorable flops. The latter category seems to be dominated by a plethora of Young Adult series, though there are a few exceptions - most notably Harry Potter, Twilight, and The Hunger Games. However, the majority of adapted YA series have been unable to garner the success of their paperback predecessors. Book series like His Dark Materials (Phillip Pullman), The Inkworld Trilogy (Cornelia Funke), The Inheritance Cycle (Christopher Paolini), and A Series of Unfortunate Events (Lemony Snicket) €“ all widely popular series written for children and young adults €“ are prime examples of one-off films that denied their sequels the chance of ever seeing the silver screen. This can mainly be attributed to poor decisions in the film making process that led to bad reviews from the general public, but lazy plot holes and unnecessary rewriting of original scripts more than likely played their own parts in the films' downfalls. The films mentioned above took more than their fare share of liberties in the adaptation processes, which ultimately only lead to disappointed fans and disillusioned critics. Of course, we know it's nearly impossible to stay completely true to a story's original material, especially when that material is a 60 chapter novel like Eragon; transforming that monster into a 1 1/2 hour film was a bold undertaking, to say the least. Perhaps it is for this reason that books should stay books, and films should bring something new and exciting to the table instead of rehashing old plots tried and true.

1. Ferris Bueller's Day Off 2

John Hughes just couldn't let go of his desire for Brat Pack sequels, and who can blame him really? The films were all extremely popular, and it would've been a shame to let that popularity go to waste, from a purely monetary standpoint, of course. Much like his plans for The Breakfast Club 2, Hughes wanted to take a look at how Matthew Broderick's character was faring down the road. Hughes and Broderick had kept in touch over the years, and even passed a few ideas back and forth; Ferris Bueller in college, Ferris Bueller in the workplace, Ferris Bueller breaking Cameron out of a nursing home, etc. Over 20 years later, with no further rumors to speak of, it's probably safe to say that Ferris Bueller will not be getting another day off anytime soon. That's not to say we didn't all get a little scare. In 2012, a ten-second trailer was released, showing Broderick opening the curtains at his hotel window and uttering the line, "How can I handle work on a day like today?" Fans were left with the promise that all would be announced during the 2012 Superbowl, and so they waited in anticipation... or was it dread? Either way, the promo was finally revealed as a Honda CR-V television spot, proving that car companies do indeed subject the general public to cruel and unusual punishment. Regardless, the commercial is a fun little tip of the hat to the '80s classic, and we can all rest easy in the knowledge that no plans of an actual Bueller sequel are currently being discussed. So what do you think? Did any of these potential sequels catch your eye, or are you happy that they were given the axe? Let us know what you think by commenting below.

In this post: 
E.T. E.T. 2
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Currently living in Orlando, Florida, Riley is a 19 year old Journalism major with her sights set on film and television review.