10 Huge What Ifs That Could Have Changed The MCU Forever
What if Ed Norton's Hulk had stayed in the MCU?
The Marvel Cinematic Universe is well and truly established as the biggest, most lucrative and popular franchise that the industry has ever seen, and in the eyes of many fans the series has never put a single foot wrong in well over a decade.
Being absorbed into Disney's multimedia empire has only seen the MCU go from strength to strength, with a raft of upcoming shows exclusive to the company's in-house streaming service only set to expand the scope and scale of the shared universe.
One of those shows is What If...?, based on the comic book title of the same name that imagines alternate realities for some of Marvel's most iconic heroes. The animated series looks set to paint some familiar faces in an entirely new light, but what if the Marvel Cinematic Universe itself had turned out completely different?
No franchise of this size manages to go off without a single hitch, and there are countless scenarios that could have resulted in the MCU turning out in a vastly different way from the all-conquering cultural behemoth that we know it as today.
10. What If The Inhumans Had Actually Been Made?
Inhumans holds the unwanted distinction of being the only Marvel Studios project to be announced and given a release date that was never actually made, and based on how the short-lived TV show turned out it was probably for the best.
James Gunn's Guardians of the Galaxy marked the MCU's first venture into full-blown cosmic territory, but Inhumans had been in development for a year longer, and just weeks after the Guardians' debut feature had arrived in cinemas it was confirmed that graduate of their writers' program and future Black Panther scribe Joe Robert Cole would be handling the script.
From there, things just sort of fell apart despite Vin Diesel being attached to lead the team as Black Bolt, and two and a half years before the intended November 2018 release date Inhumans was quietly removed from the schedule, never to be spoken of again.
Given that the eventual small screen series was widely panned by critics and fans before getting canceled after just eight episodes, Marvel Studios likely dodged a bullet here.
Guardians of the Galaxy had filled the cosmic void that Kevin Feige was keen to fill, and looking at the how the characters ultimately fared in live-action there was every chance that Inhumans could have bombed hard, and even set the MCU's expansion back by years.
9. What If The Netflix Shows Became Canon?
For a while it seemed like the roster of Netflix shows based on the Defenders existed as part of the wider Marvel Cinematic Universe, given the fleeting but never direct references to events that had happened in the movies.
Once Netflix had canceled their entire slate of Marvel projects, along with the reveal that Disney Plus was set to be established as the official home of the MCU's small screen expansion, Kevin Feige publicly admitted that none of the previous Marvel shows were considered canon anymore, with The Falcon and the Winter Soldier set to mark the genuine kick-off point.
This means that the Defenders will inevitably be rebooted at some point in the future, but if Marvel had embraced them as a part of the shared continuity instead, they would have had a handful of ready-made shows with a built-in fanbase at their disposal.
Iron Fist may have been terrible and the Defenders miniseries itself was a letdown, but viewership numbers and the general critical consensus proved that Charlie Cox's Daredevil, Krysten Ritter's Jessica Jones, Mike Colter's Iron Fist and Jon Bernthal's Punisher had plenty more to offer.
While there's been rumors that some of them might eventually reprise their roles under the Disney banner, if they'd just been accepted as official canon then the cast, crew and creative teams were all ready to for more adventures.
8. What If Edgar Wright Directed Ant-Man?
Marvel Studios have never exactly been lauded for the amount of creative control that they hand over to their directors, and while the men behind the camera invariably get the job done, the vast majority of the movies don't tend to bear any unique visual or stylistic fingerprints, and fall back into the MCU's overly-safe established in-house style.
Edgar Wright hit the nail on the head when he said that he wanted to make a Marvel movie, but they didn't want to make an Edgar Wright movie, and as a result Ant-Man turned out to be one of the least interesting installments in the franchise from a technical perspective in the sound yet workmanlike hands of Peyton Reed.
If Kevin Feige and his team had just bitten the bullet and given Wright free rein over Ant-Man, it could have led to an increase in the amount of authority and imprint that the directors hold over the MCU. Instead, most of the movies opt for the serviceable over the spectacular, and functionality over freshness.
The Russo brothers are Marvel's favorite filmmakers because they're the best at the in-house style, and with the exception of Taika Waititi's Thor: Ragnarok and Ryan Coogler's Black Panther, the vast majority of these movies could have been made by just about anyone.
7. What If Robert Downey Jr. Left After Iron Man 3?
The vast majority of the events that took place throughout the entire Infinity Saga can all be traced back to Tony Stark in some way, which isn't surprising given his status as the MCU's marquee name for over a decade.
However, the complexion of the franchise could have looked entirely different had Robert Downey Jr. opted to walk away from Iron Man after the third installment marked his final contractual obligation to the studio.
Kevin Feige even hinted at a Bond-like recasting in 2012, and in interviews around that time the actor certainly didn't shy away from the speculation that he was done playing a superhero. However, money always talks the loudest in the end, and Downey Jr. eventually re-negotiated his contract several times over the next few years to become the highest-paid supporting player the business had ever seen.
The ending of Iron Man 3 seemed to deliberately hint that Tony was hanging up the armor for good just in case RDJ didn't show any interest in signing up for more adventures, and if he'd walked away from the role that shot him to a permanent residence at the top of the A-list, it would have blown a massive hole in the studio's plans for the next half a decade that would have left them scrambling to come up with a solution.
6. What If It Hadn't Been Sold To Disney?
Disney don't exactly make movies on a small scale, and the monolithic corporation's insistence that almost the entirety of their output be mega-budget blockbusters has virtually eliminated the mid-budget movie from their repertoire.
Ant-Man is the only Marvel Studios movie since Phase One that cost less than $150m to produce, but before Disney stepped in to purchase the company there had been talk about the franchise narrowing its scope and testing the waters with some lower-budget efforts that focused on more obscure characters.
Kevin Feige confirmed in 2010 that they were in the process of developing $20-40m projects based on Doctor Strange, Ka-Zar, Luke Cage and Power Pack, and while the Sorcerer Supreme did eventually land on the big screen six years later, it was as the star of a $165m epic.
Even the upcoming slate of shows exclusive to Disney Plus are reported to be costing up to $150m, which is an eye-watering chunk of change for what will only amount to six or eight episodes of television per season.
Before Disney got into the Marvel business, the studio were keen to expand and diversify their portfolio of comic book adventures, but once Disney came calling the business model shifted entirely to gigantic budgets designed entirely to maximize profits and nothing else.
5. What If Joss Whedon Hadn't Jumped Ship?
After shepherding The Avengers to widespread critical acclaim and one of the biggest box office hauls in history, Joss Whedon firmly announced himself as the MCU's golden boy. This led to an exclusive three-year deal with the studio, where he held a huge amount of creative influence over Phase Two.
Whedon polished some of Thor: The Dark World's dialogue, directed Captain America: The Winter Soldier's mid-credits scene and even encouraged James Gunn to make his early draft of the Guardians of the Galaxy script a whole lot weirder.
Despite holding a level of control that no filmmaker had ever been awarded as part of the MCU before, Whedon still walked away after finding himself caving in to the studio's demands more often than he would have liked when making Age of Ultron.
Had he enjoyed his experience enough to stick around after the Avengers sequel, then it wouldn't just be the MCU that could look markedly different today. No director before or since has even come close to the level of autonomy that the Firefly creator had as part of his contract with Marvel, as they reverted to their preference towards candidates that can fit their style to the material instead of the other way around.
And then there's Justice Leauge, with Whedon's contributions to the DCEU's troubled team-up epic directly leading to the #ReleaseTheSnyderCut campaign that rolled on for over two and a half years before it was finally confirmed as a reality.
Had Whedon not abandoned the Marvel Cinematic Universe when his stock was at an all-time high, it could have had a seismic impact on both of Hollywood's premiere shared comic book franchises.
4. What If Chris Evans Turned Down Captain America For A Third Time?
In Chris Evans' capable hands, he turned a character that's arguably the least-interesting of the Avengers on paper into the beating heart and soul of the Marvel Cinematic Universe. Tony Stark might have been the flashy and impulsive star of the show, but Steve Rogers was the glue that held it all together.
Things could have turned out completely different had the actor stuck to his guns and turned down the role for a third time, having knocked it back twice already given his concerns of committing to a multi-picture deal, and fears about being typecast for the rest of his career.
Having embodied Captain America for the best part of decade, it seems impossible to imagine anyone else as the star-spangled superhero, vindicating Evans' decision to finally accept the part after much soul-searching. Not only is he the leader of the Avengers, he's the star of the MCU's best trilogy thanks to the actor's perfectly-pitched performances.
Ryan Phillipe, John Krasinski, Sam Worthington, Garrett Hedlund, Chad Michael Murray, Jensen Ackles, Alexander Skarsgard, Kellan Lutz and Channing Tatum were all on the final shortlist to play Captain America, and you simply can't see any of those names playing the role even half as well as Chris Evans ultimately did.
3. What If Edward Norton Fulfilled His Contract?
Whether it be for better or worse, Edward Norton has always had a reputation as an actor that likes to become involved in the creative process of the movies that he works on, even if it happens to be a $150m comic book blockbuster.
Like American History X and Red Dragon before it, The Incredible Hulk was subjected to Norton's interference, with the Academy Award-nominated star refusing to do the promotional rounds after falling out with Marvel over both the final cut of the movie and his contributions to the script.
It might have arrived in theaters just six weeks after Iron Man, but The Incredible Hulk has since been completely ignored by the Marvel Cinematic Universe, and if it wasn't for the recent return of William Hurt's Thaddeus Ross then everything that happened in the movie could be wiped from canon and it wouldn't change a thing about the current makeup of the franchise.
Norton was contracted for a sequel, but a combination of his confrontational behavior and the fact the rights to solo outings for the Hulk still belong to Universal meant that Mark Ruffalo was eventually announced as his replacement, with Bruce Banner now one of the MCU's most integral supporting players.
Had Norton stayed on there's every chance he would have ended up getting fired anyway given that Kevin Feige is the undisputed man in charge of the shared universe, but with the franchise going from strength to strength in the decade since and the plot threads left hanging in The Incredible Hulk never picked up again, it could have signaled an entirely different trajectory for the MCU's future if they'd been determined to keep the big green guy at the forefront.
2. What If Sony Made The Amazing Spider-Man 3?
Tom Holland's MCU debut in Captain America: Civil War might have seen him become the third different actor to appear as Spider-Man in a live-action movie in just nine years, but he's already played the character the same number of times as Tobey Maguire and Andrew Garfield combined.
Jealously watching the success of Marvel Studios, Sony decided to try and will their own cinematic universe into existence with The Amazing Spider-Man 2, sowing the seeds for multiple sequels and spinoffs. When the sequel disappointed both critically and commercially, they were forced to admit defeat and can their second Spidey franchise in seven years, before striking their unprecedented agreement with Marvel.
The MCU's Spider-Man has already been established as a key part of the series, and with his father figure Tony Stark out of the way it seems almost guaranteed that the web-slinger will continue to be positioned as one of the studio's figureheads, which is a far cry from how the character's future looked just half a decade ago.
The Amazing Spider-Man 3 and 4 had been announced and dated for 2016 and 2018 respectively, while spinoffs for the Sinister Six, Venom, Black Cat, Silver Sable and Spider-Man 2099 were all in various stages of development.
Sony might finally crack the formula for success with their wonderfully-titled SPUoMC, but if they hadn't ceded control of their most marketable name,then both comic book franchises would have turned out completely differently.
1. What If Iron Man Had Bombed?
Having never experienced a single box office disappointment despite being twenty-three movies deep, the Marvel Cinematic Universe has long since established dominance at the head of the blockbuster totem pole. The power of the brand alone is enough to guarantee success these days, but things weren't quite so clear cut in the build-up to Iron Man's release.
A new and unproven studio sinking $150m into their first-ever feature, directed by the guy who had just seen Zathura flop and was best known for Elf, headlined by a star that was still trying to rehabilitate his reputation in the industry after some highly-publicized personal issues, based on a B-level comic book characters that a lot of general audiences weren't exactly familiar with. What could possibly go wrong?
Obviously the answer is nothing, but hindsight is always 20/20. From the outside looking in, Iron Man was an incredibly risky gamble that could have backfired spectacularly. Had it failed, then the landscape of the entire entertainment industry would be unrecognizable from how it looks today, given how deeply the MCU has embedded itself into the very fabric of popular culture.