10 Incredible CGI Scenes You Won't Believe Aren't Real

A Beautiful Mind

As advanced as digital imagery in movies has become over the last 10 years, film buffs generally like to think that they're one step ahead of the curve, and readily able to spot even the most superbly-realised visual effect. After all, when dealing with elements like fire and water, and the physics of human beings, computer simulations still struggle to live up to reality, and so can (normally) be easily told apart. However, these 10 movies boast startling visual effects that, for the most part, you wouldn't even think to look for. It is often said that the best effects are the ones that you don't notice, and going by these subtly-employed ones, that just might be right. Here are 10 incredible CGI scenes you won't believe are real...

10. Spartan Abs - 300

While it's widely known - not to mention clear as day - that Zack Snyder's epic action film is almost completely CGI except for the human element, it seems that even that isn't as real as we thought, because the Spartan soldiers themselves have had a little airbrushing in order for them to seem all the more buff and capable of holding off a million Persians. While we're assured that the men portraying the 300 all worked extremely hard to achieve their chiseled physiques, apparently it wasn't enough for Snyder, because he ended up just painting over their abs anyway in post-production. Though the results are impressively seamless, it does beg the question - why make the actors bother working out in the first place? As long as they have an acceptable muscle tone and don't have flab jiggling around, why put them through a rigorous regime only to correct it with a copy and paste?

9. Jessica Alba Nude - Machete

Machete To be fair, the fact that Jessica Alba is notoriously averse to stripping off for films - cuing a lot of nerd outrage when she wouldn't re-robe for the bar scenes in Sin City - should have been a good indication that something wasn't quite right here, yet the shot on the right, of Alba stood naked, strategically framed to cover her modesty, seemed so realistic that there didn't seem to be any doubt. However, it was in fact an extremely photo-realistic airbrushing, with Alba's underwear having been painted out. Given that the final result presumably gives a pretty photo-realistic depiction of what Alba looks like naked, one has to ask, why didn't she just strip off anyway? If she's consenting for her image to be used that way, does it really matter if there's a barrier of CGI in the way?

8. Personal Microphones Removed Throughout The Entire Movie - Les Miserables

Tom Hooper directed the Hell out of Les Miserables, and one of the biggest reasons for its success was the decision for the actors to sing live rather than dub their performances in post-production. The result was a more visceral array of performances that were affected by the environments around them and seemed more naturalistic, if perhaps slightly at the expense of the singing itself. Nevertheless, this required each actor to be fitted out with a radio microphone which could not be concealed within the costumes, and for this sort of assignment, a boom mic towering overhead wasn't really an option either. As such, CGI was cleverly used to paint out the mikes, and though this sort of practise has been done for years with wires during action scenes, it's rarely been employed in this way, and naturally, is totally freaking seamless.

7. Spider-Man Dodging Razor-Bats - Spider-Man

Much like 300, this is one that slips in under the radar because it appears within an image that is composed almost entirely of CGI. When Spidey leaps into a burning building to save a woman and her baby, he soon enough discovers that the Green Goblin has been waiting for him, and a fight ensues. Goblin hurls some razor-bats, and Raimi cuts to the iconic slow-motion shot of Spidey leaping about to avoid being cut to shreds. While the razor-bats are themselves obviously CGI, one would readily assume that the raw image was of a stunt actor in the Spidey suit leaping about, but alas, that is not the case. In actual fact, Spidey here is a 100% CGI model, impressive because back in the early 2000s these sorts of things were easy to distinguish from the real thing, given that animators had not yet properly grasped the subtle tics and inflections in muscle that define movement. However, this is perfectly weighted and looks indistinguishable from the real deal.

6. Jennifer Connelly's Tear - Blood Diamond

This one's a bit weird and kinda insulting if you're Jennifer Connelly, I guess. It's as though director Edward Zwick was filming this emotional scene between DiCaprio and Connelly, thought he had everything he needed, then got to the edit bay and decided it needed some weeping just to convey the fact that, if you hadn't guessed already, this is supposed to be a sad scene. I have no doubts that Connelly could have brought the tears if asked, so why was this not just sorted out on set, especially given that Connelly was clearly making the whimpering noises already. Could she really not cry? Whatever the reason, it sets a disturbing precedent as far as performances go; if an actor can't act, it can now be fixed in post-production, which is great for filmmakers, though not so good for audiences (if they can ever tell the difference), and actors (who are slowly being phased out of a job).

5. Bathtub Water - A Beautiful Mind

Talk to any animator and they'll tell you that the hardest thing to create other than a photo-realistic human being is either fire or water; the elements are so dynamic that bringing them to the screen without a single imperfection is extremely challenging. However, the geniuses who worked on A Beautiful Mind struck gold by rendering some wholly convincing CGI water after the fact, even if it was likely a digital composite rather than an outright rendering from scratch. The scene is a pivotal one, as John Nash is in the thrall of his mental illness and almost ends up drowning his own child by placing it in the bathtub with the taps turned on full. Jennifer Connelly - this time fully expressing her distress - pulls the baby out, but not before we get a decent look in at the tub, with the baby almost completely submerged in water. While this could have been achieved practically, the risk of putting the child under unnecessary stress seemed too great, so they opted for the more expensive approach instead! Still, the end result is completely seamless.

4. Landscapes & Sheep...Lots Of Sheep - Brokeback Mountain

When I discovered a five-minute video breakdown of all the visual effects in Brokeback Mountain, I couldn't quite believe it, given that the film by its nature appeared to have practically zero necessity for visual effects, and yet, there it is. The above video demonstrates how much of the rural landscape was digitally altered to accommodate the look Ang Lee wanted, from shifting entire regions in the background to adding in weather elements, the moon and so on. Perhaps the most amusing addition, though, was sheep...lots and lots of sheep, namely when Ennis is herding them early on. The raw image shows Heath Ledger and just a few sheep, but this was digitally duplicated to absolute perfection for the final product.

3. Tobey Maguire's Hair - Fear & Loathing In Las Vegas

When Johnny Depp and Benicio Del Toro pick up Tobey Maguire and we see the ridiculous haircut that he's sporting for the first time, 99.9% of people would simply assume that it was a hair-piece, because why not? It's the standard way to film a scene like that, but Terry Gilliam, ever shying away from convention, had a slightly different idea, to use CGI, given that the tendency for even a well-screwed-on hairpiece to flail out the back end of an open-top car was pretty high. So yes, the end result is computer-generated, and given the difficulty of rendering objects with lots of strands like hair (as so many video games told us about in the early 2000s), it's impressively seamless, and not once does this draw attention itself.

2. Lindsay Lohan's Breast Reduction - Herbie: Fully Loaded

After screening Herbie: Fully Loaded for test audiences, a concern emerged - and it must have been mothers complaining - that Lindsay Lohan's 18-year-old breasts were too large, and were distracting from everything else the film had to offer (read: not a lot). This sounds like a joke, but yes, Disney reportedly digitally reduced the size of Lohan's breasts to a less invasive stature so as not to draw everyone's attention away from the film's other digital creation. It's unfathomable, both because it's so well-integrated into the film, and also because...um...Ms. Lohan's natural gifts still appear to be relatively well-sized and distracting, as evidenced by the utterly lecherous montage compiled above.

1. Kee's Baby - Children of Men

Alfonso Cuaron's Children of Men is a technical marvel in every sense, and so perhaps it shouldn't be a surprise that he snuck such a fantastic work of CGI past us during a climactic scene in which the answer to Earth's extinction problem, Kee, gives birth to hope in actual human form. Would you know, however, that the baby entering the world is in fact a CGI creation rather than a clever blend of doll and actual human? The entire thing, from when it emerges limp to when it begins moving, is digital, and startlingly lifelike in this stead. Granted, poor lighting helps the scene be convincing, but still, every single tic and movement of the baby is exactly as a real baby would perform it; this is a CGI scene that is staggering in its ambition and utterly flawless in execution. Which CGI scenes did you think were real? Let us know in the comments below.

Contributor
Contributor

Frequently sleep-deprived film addict and video game obsessive who spends more time than is healthy in darkened London screening rooms. Follow his twitter on @ShaunMunroFilm or e-mail him at shaneo632 [at] gmail.com.