10 Incredible Fan Films That Totally Succeeded Where Hollywood Failed
Who says the studios know best?

Somewhere between fanbases that can't be pleased and studios that can't be reasoned with, it must be pretty nightmarish being a director in Hollywood at present. Imagine it, one minute you've just been put at the helm of one of the world's most beloved franchises, and the next thing you know your script is getting torn up by the money men while the whole internet is writing about how it's going to be terrible anyway.
As the saying goes, you can please some of the people some of the time, but you can't please all of the people all of the time. Or, to put it another way, if you make something for the fans it probably won't make any money, but if you do something for the money it'll only alienate the fans. You can't win. But, down as much to the ingenuity of folks in the 21st century as the ease at which they can get their hands on studio-quality recording equipment, there exists a third solution: simply let the fans do it!
Thanks to the wonders of websites like Kickstarter fans are now free of the burly financial might of big studios and can simply have a massive whip-round to finance the cinematic spectacles they've always dreamed off. Where Hollywood has stuffed up some iconic stories in the last few years, these beauties have been waiting to tell the tales the way they were destined to be told.
10. Darth Maul Apprentice
Going to start here just to give you an idea of the sort of standard we’re talking here. Darth Maul: Apprentice is a 17 minute fan film about the Phantom Menace’s antagonist that is arguably better than the Phantom Menace itself.
The tone, score, direction, all of it are legimtately amazing, and it’s got some of the best lightsaber action seen in any star wars outing. T7Pro, the team behind it, spent two years on this entirely original story and, just, yeah, it’s incredible.
At the time of me recording this it’s just about to top some 20 million views on Youtube, which isn’t bad for two young filmmakers from Germany with a few cameras and a desire to see one of the franchise’s best villains get the screen time he deserved.
9. Left 4 Dead: Impulse 76
The almost overnight explosion of the zombie genre from "occasional B-movie novelty" to "mainstream entertainment real estate" is littered with the corpses of so many dreadful game adaptations. The Resident Evil franchise has pumped out some truly awful offerings, House Of The Dead went straight to DVD, and the bar is currently set so low that very little is expected of the upcoming The Last of Us film.
Which is odd because Northern Five Entertainment proved, with their Left 4 Dead adaptation, that it isn't actually that hard to do. Opening in fairly understated scenes, the 9 minute short then explodes into life in precisely the sort of way that made the games so enjoyable. There's gore-a-plenty as the characters from the game fight their way through the zombie hordes, and the actors involved give fantastic performances as Zoey, Bill, Wade, Louis, and Francis.
There's over 60 zombie extras, which requires impressive organisational nous for a fan film, and there's even some outlandish cameos from the rest of the gaming world. All of which manages to equal more enjoyment in under 10 minutes than most other adaptations have mustered in their entire running time.
8. Spider-Man: Eclipse
Barring a wonderfully managed role in the upcoming Marvel films, it's fair to say that Spider-Man's appearances on the big screen have been really, really disappointing. The original trilogy went from average popcorn flick to complete disaster in only the time it took Toby Maguire to swan dive off an American flag, and the Andrew Garfield reboot didn't even come close to matching its big-screen superhero contemporaries.
Opening with Peter Parker bloodied, bruised and unmasked, Spider-Man: Eclipse is Bokeh Pictures attempt to portray the character in a "darker, more visceral, and more realistic fashion". They've succeeded too. Making his escape through a warehouse, the film features some incredible CGI, fight scenes and free-running that really belies the small budget and crew involved.
Although it lacks the huge eye-dropping moments of its Hollywood incarnations, it does more to open up the persona of Peter Parker than any film has previously. If Marvel still have any decisions to make over which way to take Spidey in the next generation of movies, there's plenty they could learn from his portrayal here.
7. Pokémon: Apokélypse
It's a notion long since agreed upon that, if the Call Of Duty franchise is something designed for adults but mostly popular with children, then Pokémon is the spiritual opposite; a game designed almost exclusively for children, but with a fanbase that's now well into its late '20s and early '30s. Not that they'd ever admit it, but the game's core audience has been crying out for years now for something that they wouldn't feel guilty about enjoying.
Something a little darker, something a little rougher, something a little more, well, grown up. There's been nothing forthcoming from Nintendo, for obvious reasons, but there was a brilliantly put together fan film that went some way to scratching this particular itch. Taking the notion of Pokémon to its logical real-world conclusion, Apokélypse sets the game up as little more than outlawed animal brutality that's being used by the world's evilest factions to further their own gritty aims.
The story sees Ash embroiled with bribery, murder and gang warfare, with Jessie, James, Brock, Misty, Oak and Giovanni all making appearances. Visually speaking the whole thing looks incredible, even if a few of the monster approximations are a little bit off.
6. The Punisher: Dirty Laundry
There can surely be nothing sweeter to fans of a franchise than finding out that the person who portrays your hero on the big screen is as big a geek over the subject matter as you are. After reading the initial scripts and plans for the followup to 2004's The Punisher movie, actor Thomas Jane wrestled with himself and decided he couldn't betray the character he loved so much by playing him in what he thought would be a terrible sequel.
So instead he set about researching his source materials and keeping himself in peak physical condition so he could give Frank Castle the sort of screen return he deserved. Whipping together sufficient money for a short film, and the help of his good pal Ron Perlman (y'know, Hellboy), Jane produced a "love letter to the fans" that he would screen at conventions and other Punisher related events. In the end though, the consensus was that this was too good to keep locked up, and it was released on YouTube as well.
In typical Punisher style, the story follows the vigilante simply trying to get his laundry done. However when some street crime breaks out across the road the now-retired enforcer decides he can't stand idly by and allow it to happen. What follows is some of the most breathtakingly gory action ever seen in a fan film, as well as some of the most creative use of a bottle of Jack Daniels ever captured on screen.
5. Judge Minty
Karl Urban's Dredd film went someway to repairing the damage of the catastrophic mess created by Sylvester Stallone in 1995, but still left a lot to be desired for the $50,000,000 that was invested in it.
It took Judge Minty, an impossibly polished and fiercely gripping fan adaptation, to really show how the 2000AD universe could be best realised though. As a story it's superb, as a spectacle is breathtaking, and as a piece of cinema it stands head and shoulders about both of Hollywood's laboured attempts to bring these characters onto the big screen. At the heart of it is an incredible performance by Edmund Dehn in the title role.
Finding the perfectly compelling balance between his human nature and the brutality of a Judge, the film's only main drawback is that its 25 minute running time is a lot less than both he and the story deserve.
4. Super Mario Indie Film
There's some debate as to where the notion of adapting video games for cinema originated, but for most people their first experience was with 1993's Super Mario Bros film. It promised to be dark, it promised to be gritty, but in the end it was a critical and financial disaster. Allegedly hamstrung by not being able to find a middle-ground between the game's mythology and a story that would work for cinema audiences, it completely shelved any future plans Nintendo had for live-action adaptations of their properties - something they've still yet to reconsider.
However Austin-based filmmaker Joe Nicolosi managed, with only $400, to show exactly how a Mario film could work. Created as a short for SXSW, the indie Mario Bros gives us a hefty dose of reality, but combines it beautifully with the bright and fun vibrancy of the game's characters. Depicting Mario as a jaded and lovesick plumber, the story starts with him learning that his princess (figuratively speaking) is going out with some creep called Koopa. The solution? Take some mushrooms and jump on his head, obviously.
Although only 2 minutes long, the idea here is so rich and well thought out that it's a crime against both films and movies that it hasn't been realised as feature-length film yet. Where's a Kickstarter when you need one?
3. Power Rangers
In what is almost certain to be taken down again at some point, the recent adaptation of the Mighty Morphin' Power Rangers franchise has been seen as something of a watershed moment in the battle between fans and rights holders. Released only a few weeks ago to huge critical acclaim, Power/Rangers has quickly become a viral hit for its brutality, inventiveness, production values and all-star cast.
Opening with an interrogation, then moving onto murder, drugs, and threesomes before the Black Ranger slaughters an entire room of gangsters, the 12 minute epic is about as far removed from the flashy kids show as it's possible to be. Starring James Van Der Beek and Katee Sackhoff (Rules Of Attraction and Battlestar Galactica respectively), the short was created by Joseph Kahn as a love-letter to the series and its legacy.
The show's original cast members have all praised it as brilliant, and it stands on a par with Nolan's Batman as a lesson on how to take a franchise to a new audience. Naturally though it raised the eyebrows of Haim Saban, who still hold the intellectual copyright, almost clean off their faces. Despite having as many disclaimers about its unofficial nature as it's possible to have, the film was immediately met with legal challenges and removed from circulation. It's back online now, but with an official series reboot scheduled for 2016 it remains to be seen for how long.
2. The Hunt For Gollum
Debuting at the London International Festival of Science Fiction, The Hunt For Gollum is the creation of an entire team of amateur British filmmakers. Done for only £3000, the film runs for an impressive 38 minutes and manages to create an impressive vision on Middle Earth using Tolkien's own appendices.
Picking up between Bilbo returning from his adventures in the The Hobbit, but before Frodo leaves in The Lord Of The Rings - ironically the only bit of the story unmolested by Peter Jackson - the story centres around Aragorn's quest to stop Gollum revealing information about the One Ring. Dispatched at the behest of Gandalf, the film features impressive performances from those charged with filling the boots of Viggo Mortensen, Sir Ian McKellen and Liv Tyler.
Since its release it's racked up well over 1.5 million views on YouTube, with the creators claiming that the total surpasses 12 million when factoring in the other sites, streams and downloads. Richly deserved as well, as it looks fantastic and more than does justice to the richness of the world it's set in. In fact so impressive is the film that the Tolkien estate, notorious for clamping down hard on any violations of copyright, have allowed it to remain online for over 5 years now.
1. Lego Jurassic Park
By far and away the most ambitious entry in this list also happens to be the most heartwarming. Earlier this year, a father and daughter team released a three-minute recreation of Jurassic Park, made using nothing more than stop-motion animation, $100,000 worth of Lego bricks, and a lot of time and patience.
Since its release in 1993, Hollywood has tried and failed to recapture the magic of Spielberg's original. Two direct sequels have been widely panned, and every other movie that's featured history's favourite overgrown lizards has seemed cheap and tacky by comparison, but something about this adaptation reminds you exactly how exciting it all was as a child.
Faithfully recreating some of the best scenes from the film, the short manages to capture all the enchantment of the original whilst adding a lot of the toytronic charm that made The Lego Movie so popular. It really is a triumph of filmmaking, and all the more so when you consider that a 9-year-old was at the helm.
What's your favourite fan film? Share a link for others to check out down in the comments.