10 Incredibly Dark Comedies That Dare You To Laugh

Comedies that squeeze their laughs from the least likely sources...

For some people, a good comedy needs nothing more than some silly costumes, catchphrases and a couple of well-aimed custard pies. But for others, this barely even tickles the funnybone. What they need is a little edgier, a little more risqué. And so they turn to the dark side of comedy, the type of film where you don't know whether to laugh or cry. The type of film that you know you probably shouldn't be watching. The type of film that'll make you smile and then, almost immediately, make you feel guilty about it. It seems like an easy task - take subjects that we're not supposed to talk about and make jokes about them- and yet very few manage to find the right balance between proper comedy and needless provocation. Too often they revel in their own filth, swap sight gags for shock tactics, punchlines for poor taste. When done correctly, the dark comedy should challenge, trouble and even offend you. It should also, however, make you pee your pants. Below are ten films that despite (or rather, due to) tackling difficult subject matter, squeeze their laughs from the least likely sources... Contains spoilers

10. Chopper (2000)

It's never easy to ask an audience to empathise with a killer, and especially difficult when they're based on a real life career criminal. And yet, for his directorial debut, Andrew Dominik adapted the autobiographical works of Mark ''Chopper'' Read to bring a riveting character study packed full of violence and edgy, uncomfortable humour. In an incredible, breakthrough role (and at the suggestion of the man himself, no less) Eric Bana plays Read not so much as the villain of the piece but more as a charming rogue, albeit one with a hair-trigger temper. As a result, the film has been accused of glorifying Chopper, making him the main attraction of Pentridge Prison. Certainly, the early scenes in which he brawls and bickers with his fellow inmates convicts do have a persuasive sort of swagger but when this aggression spills out into his domestic life, seeing the funny side becomes something of a struggle. Darkest Comedy Moment: When Chopper is stabbed repeatedly in the stomach by Jimmy, own of his gang members, he seems more concerned about his friend than his own health. As the blood dribbles from his mouth, he looks at Jimmy and asks, softly ''What's got into you?'' He then hugs Jimmy, who has now burst into tears and cannot apologise enough. ''It's alright'', replies Chopper, clearly not letting the gaping wounds get the better of him,''Always give credit where credit is due, Jimmy. I'll give ya top marks for treachery, mate.''

9. Harold And Maude (1971)

Harold (Bud Cort) is a death-obsessed young man who regularly stages his own suicide (see above) and, as a hobby, enjoys going to strangers' funerals. Maude (Ruth Gordon) is a septuagenarian free spirit who lives in a converted railway carriage and, as a hobby, also enjoys attending funerals. Naturally, it is here that the two meet - and an unlikely relationship is formed. Despite Maude's joie de vivre proving just the cure for Harold's morbid outlook, his mother (Vivian Pickles), annoyed by Harold's incessant attention-seeking, is determined to find him a wife. However, taking the disastrous first date to its extreme, Harold has a variety of escape plans: seppuku, self-immolation, slicing off his hand... Needless to say, his prospective partners don't call back. Although the film can be a little preachy in places, and its final scenes seem to send a mixed message, Hal Ashby's second feature has lost precious little of its ability to shock. Darkest Comedy Moment: Although Harold appears to 'die' around eight times in the film, the scene in which he points a shotgun at his mother, who is too busy filling out a dating service survey on his behalf to notice, before turning it on himself is surely the most awkward.

8. Fight Club (1999)

As Fight Club punched its way through cinema screens and into the public consciousness, it was easy to dismiss the film as a series of shock tactics desperate to get a reaction like a boy prodding a beehive with a stick. After all, everything about it seemed purpose-built to provoke: a man who fakes his way into support groups, another man who creates soap from the leftover fat found outside liposuction clinics, a terrorist organisation blowing smiley faces into the sides of buildings, and of course, the idea that a bunch of blokes beating the hell out of each other for the best of two hours constitutes a story. But Fight Club was much more than that. Through our nameless narrator (Ed Norton) and the twisted philosophy of ubermensch Tyler Durden (Brad Pitt), the film took the masculinity crisis, a growing sense of millennial angst and some good old fashioned social satire and turned them into a modern masterpiece. What's more, it was pretty funny in the process. After all, who said self-destruction had to be serious? Darkest Comedy Moment: Although the 'Raymond K. Hessel' scene takes some dark detours before its oddly enlightening twist, the film's funniest (and filthiest) lines come from the smoky mouth of Marla Singer (Helena Bonham Carter). Slumping to her pillow after having sex with Tyler, she tells him ''I haven't been f**ked like that since grade school''- a line that even he shudders at. On the DVD commentary Bonham Carter admits that the impact of that line had only recently hit home; she thought that 'grade school' was what Americans called high school. Erm...still, it could have been worse: her line was originally ''I want to have your abortion''.

7. Heathers (1988)

Despite having joined the three Heathers (played by Shannen Doherty, Kim Walker and Lisanne Falk) as the most powerful clique at Westerberg High School,Veronica (Winona Ryder) cannot stand their snobbish self-importance and so, with the help of boyfriend J.D ( Christian Slater), plans to murder them and disguise the deaths as suicide. Things quickly get out of hand, however, when this leads to a spate of copycat suicide attempts throughout the school. Realising that they have gone a step too far, Veronica breaks up with J.D - who takes his revenge by first attempting to kill her before rigging the school boiler room with explosives. By now it's too late to question just where, if anywhere, director Michael Lehmann plans to draw the line. Darkest Comedy Moment: After shooting jocks Kurt and Ram, Veronica and J.D plant a note along with 'gay materials' (a photo of Joan Crawford and, erm, a bottle of mineral water) beside their bodies to suggest they were victims of a suicide pact. At Kurt's funeral, his father proudly announces ''My son's a homosexual. I love my dead gay son''. Admittedly, this has become a different sort of awkward over the last twenty-five years...

6. Kill Me Please (2010)

A Belgian farce set within the grounds of an euthanasia clinic, Kill Me Please performs a fine tightrope act between tragedy and comedy before throwing itself head-first into the latter. Despite it seeming like a bad business model, Dr Krueger (Aurélien Recoing) isn't always forthcoming with his little cup of cyanide. Instead, he tries to talk his patients out of it. Failing that, he prides himself on being able to fulfil their last wishes - providing they've got the cash, of course. But, during a particularly hectic run, not every patient can have the death that they'd like...and so they start to take matters into their own hands. Although 'quirky' may be a slight exaggeration, our guests are not necessarily the forlorn no-hopers you'd expect. Among our clients looking for a quick exit are Virgile, who, at the age of seven, claimed to have "the youngest suicide attempt in France's history", Sylvie, a transgendered singer and Mr. Breiman,whose family believes that he is in fact on holiday. Each is more alive than their disposition may let on. Darkest Comedy Moment: As you may have guessed, the whole film is pretty bleak; with each scene given extra gravitas by its stark, black and white, almost documentary aesthetic. But there's also a steady flow of ironic gags to keep us entertained. For example, the guests often argue about who should die first (suffice it to say it doesn't quite work that way). But perhaps the darkest joke comes when, after witnessing a man burn to death, one of the patients turns to Krueger and says, his voice full of hope: ''I didn't know you could die from burns. Well, I'd like to if I could sign up for that...''

5. Super (2010)

Armed with a budget of $2.5 million and a few buckets of blood, director James Gunn grabbed the superhero genre and subjected it to some very bad things indeed. Its story- what if the average Joe suddenly became a superhero?- may sound familiar, but sadsack Frank D'Arbo (Rainn Wilson) is no Peter Parker. After a rather disturbing spot of what he believes to be divine intervention, Frank becomes the Crimson Bolt; crimefighter extraordinaire. Maybe now he'll get the respect he deserves. Maybe now he'll find his true calling. And maybe now he'll win back his wife (Liv Tyler) from sleazeball Jacques (a brilliant Kevin Bacon)... Along the way, he creates a cheap costume, comes up with a catchphrase (''Shut up, crime!'') and bashes a couple of queuejumpers' brains out with a pipe wrench. Don't forget, this guy's the hero. Darkest Comedy Moment: In hindsight, the insanely violent animated intro should've told us that this wasn't a superhero film from the mould of Christopher Nolan. No conflicted alter egos, moral dilemmas and moody rooftop posturing here. Instead, this is the kind of a film where our protagonist is raped by his hyperactive and gleefully sadistic sidekick Boltie (Ellen Page).

4. Four Lions (2010)

Arriving only five years after the 7/7 bombings in London, it's safe to say that a comedy about home-grown terrorists wasn't exactly the most sought-after script in British cinema. But then, if anyone could persuade us to find the 'fun' in Islamic fundamentalism it's provocateur par excellence, Chris Morris. In his hands, a group of aspiring suicide bombers becomes far more amusing than it has any right to be. This is largely because, for all their misplaced idealism, our ragtag radicals are so gloriously inept. For example, after struggling to even put together a video threat, they unwittingly fire a rocket launcher at their own base camp, try to train crows to carry bombs and lose one of their team while lugging explosives across a field. Only Omar (Riz Ahmed), their de facto leader, is knowledgeable and passionate enough to die for their cause; his buddies are too concerned with hiding their beards, blowing up mosques and, erm, Mini Babybels. Darkest Comedy Moment: If Omar openly discussing his plans for martyrdom with his wife and young son doesn't make you feel queasy, then the scene in which the police shoot the wrong man - or rather, shoot a Wookie instead of a Honey Monster- certainly will. Why? It isn't difficult to see it as a response to the real-life tragedy of Jean Charles de Menezes, a Brazilian man who was mistaken for a terror suspect and shot dead by the London Metropolitan police in 2005.

3. God Bless America (2011)

If you mixed together the brash, biting satire of Falling Down, Network, Black Mirror and the Grand Theft Auto series, threw in an arsenal of semi-automatics, and then removed anything that could pass for good taste, you'd probably end up with something resembling God Bless America. It really is a film that takes no prisoners. Joel Murray plays Frank Murdoch, a man driven to despair by all of modern life's irritations. Noisy neighbours, a dead-end job, the endless sludge of reality TV being pumped into his living room... But help comes from the least likely of sources: being diagnosed with a brain tumour gives him the perfect excuse to seize the day. And by that I mean shoot everything -and everyone- in sight. Somewhat appropriately, the film's relentless spray of vitriol has its share of hits and misses, with everything from the death of manners to Diablo Cody in the firing line. And while taking potshots at US gun and celebrity culture is hardly original, few films would have the audacity to show a man shooting a schoolgirl at point blank range, for example. Fewer still would play it as a punchline. Much like Super (what is it with Franks and cock-eyed vigilantism, by the way?), our 'hero' soon finds himself upstaged by a sadistic teenage sidekick, Roxy (Lynne Barr), who is responsible for dragging the film into some really dark corners. Of course, rampant misanthropy has practically become the trademark of director Bobcat Goldthwait; his 2009 film World's Greatest Dad mined comedy gold from suicide notes and autoerotic asphyxiation. God knows what he'll set his sights on next... Darkest Comedy Moment: What the film lacks in subtlety it gains in sheer offensiveness. For example, less than five minutes in we're treated to a fantasy sequence in which Frank bursts through his neighbours' door with a shotgun. As the woman throws her baby into the air, Frank lifts the gun, fires and splatters the entire room. The fact that the man screaming ''f**k you'' to the entire world is Mad Men's Freddy Rumsen really doesn't help, either.

2. Happiness (1994)

As with a handful of other entries on this list, the irony of the film's title becomes immediately apparent. Every character we meet is miserable, pathetic, desperate, lonely and unfulfilled. In short, they're not the kind of people that you'd choose to spend two hours with. So why is it that you can't look away? To say that Todd Solondz's second feature is a bit controversial would be a giant understatement; each scene revels in making light of such taboo subjects as suicide, rape and paedophilia. Amongst a cast of grotesques there's Allen (the late, great Philip Seymour Hoffman), who masturbates while making obscene calls to strangers. There's Helen (Lara Flynn Boyle), the woman he's calling, who is only too glad of the attention.And then there's Bill (Dylan Baker), Allen's therapist and arguably one of the most disturbing characters you'll ever see. After Bill develops an obsession for his eleven-year-old son's classmate, Johnny, he arranges for the boys to have a sleepover. It is here that he drugs and sodomises Johnny. He then preys on another of his son's friends. But it isn't long before the secret is out. Which leads us to... Darkest Comedy Moment: The conversation between Bill and his son Billy is truly, thankfully, one of a kind. It's the type of dialogue you hear once and never forget. It's the sort of jet-black, unbearably inappropriate humour that even Chris Morris' Jam might shy away from. And it goes like this:
Billy: Dad, did you, um... with Johnny Grasso and Ronald Farber? Bill: Yes. Billy: Would you... would you do it again? Bill: Yes. Billy: Would you ever f**k me? Bill: No. I'd jerk off instead.

1. Man Bites Dog (1992)

The fact that this film comes from the same production team as Kill Me Please should tell you everything you need to know. It's another black and white documentary-style study into the darker recesses of the human mind- only more so. The story follows a film crew as they document a day in the life of Benoit (Benoît Poelvoorde). Although he begins as a witty and articulate host, his thoughts soon stray into more uncomfortable territory, revealing a misogynistic and xenophobic streak before the camera. What's more, Benoit is a serial killer. But he isn't necessarily the film's true heart of evil. No, what makes the film so unique, so perverse and yet so compelling is how the crew becomes increasingly implicit in Benoit's crimes. For example, after he breaks into a house and kills an entire family, they help him to smother a small boy. As a result, we too become accomplices. And it's a horribly unnerving experience; like a rabid version of Peeping Tom let off its lead. Remember how the antagonists in Funny Games claimed to be torturing an innocent family for our mere entertainment? Here it's a hundred times worse. Darkest Comedy Moment: Take your pick, but the scene in which Benoit and the filmmakers interview an old lady in her living room (above) certainly takes some time to be scrubbed from your mind. After asking the woman if she receives regular visitors, Benoit suddenly shoves his gun in her face and screams so loudly that she suffers an immediate heart attack. ''I just freaked her out,'' smiles Ben as the woman slumps in her sofa, ''Which saves me a bullet''. Like this article? Are there any other dark comedies that keep you awake at night? Let us know in the comments box below.

In this post: 
Four Lions
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Yorkshireman (hence the surname). Often spotted sacrificing sleep and sanity for the annual Leeds International Film Festival. For a sample of (fairly) recent film reviews, please visit whatsnottoblog.wordpress.com.