10 Infamous Times Actors Refused To Break Character

There’s acting and then there’s Jim Carrey's method acting.

Jim Carrey Man On The Moon
Netflix

Back in 1976 when Dustin Hoffman was making Marathon Man he had a scene in which his character hadn’t slept for three days. To properly portray his character’s exhaustion, Hoffman also stayed awake for 72 hours and showed up on set looking suitably fatigued and weary.

Famously, his co-star and British thespian Laurence Olivier quizzed Hoffman on his technique and asked him, “My dear boy, why don’t you just try acting?” Meows aside, Olivier’s remark to Hoffman’s approach shows there is two kinds of actors.

Some are happier hopping into their character when needed but able to shake them off after a long, hard day’s filming. Other actors, however, prefer to take the method acting route – learning all they can about their characters and immersing themselves so much that they practically become them.

Often, this involves taking some pretty drastic measures, like literally staying in character for the entire shoot of a movie...

10. Jared Leto – Suicide Squad

Suicide Squad Joker.jpg
Warner Bros.

Prior to his role as the Joker in Suicide Squad, Jared Leto was no stranger to diving deep into his characters. He’s done the extreme weight loss and gain shtick, gaining over four stone to play overweight Beatle assassin Mark David Chapman in Chapter 27 and getting gout for his troubles.

He later lost over two stone to play an HIV-positive trans woman in Dallas Buyers Club, though was rewarded with an Oscar for Best Supporting Actor that time rather than gout. While extreme, these processes Leto went through weren’t really hurting anybody but himself.

On the set of Suicide Squad, however, everybody felt the full effects of Jared in Joker mode. Throughout filming Leto never broke character prompting his co-star Will Smith to say, "I’ve never actually met Jared Leto. We worked together for six months and we’ve never exchanged a word outside of ‘Action’ and ‘Cut!’”

That’s par for the course with method acting but Leto’s technique of staying character involved some pretty weird behaviour including sending his castmates some questionable ‘gifts’ in keeping with the Joker’s personality.

Will Smith got bullets and Adewale Akinnuoye-Agbaje got a “sticky Playboy magazine” while Margot Robbie was given a live rat. Amongst the other bizarre and creepy gifts Leto bestowed upon cast and crew were condoms (unused contrary to rumours), anal beads and a dead pig. Charming.

In the end, it turned out most of Leto’s scenes in Suicide Squad ended up on the cutting room floor and all that unhinged effort was for naught.


9. Forest Whitaker – The Last King Of Scotland

last king of scotland
Fox Searchlight Pictures

Even before Forest Whitaker started filming The Last King of Scotland, Ugandan dictator Idi Amin was encroaching on the actor’s life. In the months preceding production Whitaker dedicated himself to learning all he could about his onscreen persona, becoming fluent in Amin’s native language Kiswahili and spending time with Amin’s family and friends to better understand and humanise the charismatic but ruthless leader.

He also put on over 50 pounds to pull off Amin’s rotund physique and learned to play accordion just as the despot had. Whitaker nailed his mannerisms so perfectly that while shooting a scene set in a remote village, local extras were so convinced by his performance that they thought he really was Idi Amin despite the dictator dying a few years previously.

For three whole months of shooting, Whitaker never once broke character which proved quite unnerving for his co-stars. Kerry Washington, who played one of Amin’s many wives in the movie, noted “He totally embraced the character, and for me it was terrifying. He was scary to be around because he was Idi all the time."

It took its toll on Whitaker too who later described the experience of getting into the mind of a dictator and staying there as all-consuming. He did, however, sweep the boards on the awards circuit with his performance winning Best Actor at the Oscars, Golden Globes, BAFTAs and Screen Actors Guild Awards so at least it was worth it.


8. Christian Bale – Terminator Salvation

Terminator Salvation
Warner Bros.

Although Christian Bale has insisted that method acting isn’t his thing, he’s certainly taken a rather extreme approach to his work at times. While playing a disturbed insomniac in the 2004 psychological thriller The Machinist, Bale shed 63 pounds only to put it all back on again plus a few extra pounds shortly after to bulk up for his role as Bruce Wayne in Batman Begins.

Perhaps more infamous than his yo-yo weight was when Bale’s commitment to his character resulted in an angry tirade launched at director of photography Shane Hurlbut after he distracted the actor during a particularly intense scene on the set of Terminator Salvation.

So dedicated was Bale to his role as John Connor that he delivered the four-minute-long diatribe (which contained an impressive 37 F-bombs) completely in character, never once dropping his affected American accent and even throwing in a few typically American cuss words like ‘ass’ and ‘trash’.

You could even say that Bale is so in character that it isn’t even really him ranting away effing and blinding but John Connor. Or at least that’s the excuse Bale went with, claiming “that guy who was yelling was at least half John Connor, and the rest was Christian Bale”. Okay, we believe you.


7. Daniel Day-Lewis – My Left Foot

my left foot
Ferndale Films

As the undisputed king of plunging elbow-deep into his characters, Daniel Day-Lewis is so method that the lengths he’ll go to in the process of becoming one with his role are legendary.

To prepare for his role in The Last of the Mohicans he lived in the wild for six months, built himself a canoe and learned how to trap and skin animals while for The Crucible he built his character’s 17th century-style house using only the kind of old-timey tools that would’ve been available back then.

Some of the most extreme tactics Day-Lewis has used to stay in character came with 1989’s biographical drama My Left Foot in which he played the Irish painter and writer Christy Brown who was born with cerebral palsy, wheelchair-bound and only had control over his left foot.

During the shoot, Day-Lewis confined himself to his character’s wheelchair almost entirely and even when the cameras weren’t rolling the actor insisted crew members carry him around if he wasn’t in his chair and even had them spoon-feed him too. As a result of being hunched over for weeks on end, Day-Lewis ending up breaking two of his ribs.

There was method to his madness, though. His dedication to staying in character on the set of My Left Foot scored him the first of his three Best Actor Oscars. Whether the unfortunate cast members tasked with lugging the six foot two-inch-tall actor around the set were rewarded for their efforts remains to be seen.


6. James Franco – The Disaster Artist

The Disaster Artist James Franco
A24

Tommy Wiseau – the enigmatic legend behind the best worst movie of all time, The Room – is quite a curious character. Nobody is sure where he came from, where he got the $6 million he used to make The Room or even if Tommy Wiseau is his real name. All we really know is that he’s pretty peculiar and thinks that his film is a masterpiece.

So, when James Franco directed The Disaster Artist – a comedy-drama about the making of The Room in which Franco also stars as Wiseau – he decided to go as meta as the movie itself and as weird as Wiseau by never breaking character throughout the shoot.

Essentially, that meant Franco was directing a movie about directing a movie that Tommy Wiseau both directed and starred in while staying in character as Wiseau the whole time. Confused? So were Franco’s cast and crew, apparently.

His brother Dave Franco, who played Wiseau’s BFF Greg Sestero in the film, would prep newcomers to the set by telling them that Tommy and not James would be directing that day. Co-star Seth Rogen claims Franco’s constantly staying in character was so convincing that people would ask him where James was. Even Rogen’s grandmother, who visited the set one day, was hoodwinked by Franco’s act and asked her grandson “I thought James was in the movie?”

Deceiving cast, crew and Rogen’s grandma worked, however, and Franco received a tonne of critical acclaim for his spot-on portrayal of Wiseau.


5. Hilary Swank – Boys Don’t Cry

hilary swank boys don't cry
Fox Searchlight Pictures

When actress Hilary Swank nabbed the role of trans man Brandon Teena in director Kimberly Peirce’s biographical drama Boys Don’t Cry, she began staying in character even before filming commenced.

At the insistence of Peirce, Swank fully transformed into a boy and lived as a male for a month in the lead up to filming. To do so Swank employed many of tactics Teena himself had used to pass as male including cutting her hair short and ‘strapping and packing’ –that is, binding her breasts and stuffing socks in her pants to look manly in all the right places.

Swank’s new look was so convincing that even her neighbours didn’t recognise her and assumed the ‘young man’ hanging around her home was her visiting brother. She remained in character once she arrived on set too and was introduced to her fellow cast members in character and as a male and never let them see her out of costume during the shoot.

According to the crew, Swank was so absorbed by the role that she practically lost herself. Producer Eva Kolodner even went so far as to say she felt she never really met the actress while filming: “She was immersed in this boyness. She left everything of Hilary somewhere else.”

Losing herself so deeply did prove to have an upside, however, when Swank was rewarded for her efforts with a Best Actress win at the Oscars.


4. Val Kilmer – The Doors

The Doors Movie
TriStar Pictures

To say Val Kilmer got slightly obsessive in his approach to playing rock legend Jim Morrison in Oliver Stone’s biopic The Doors is probably putting it mildly. In the year leading up to filming, Kilmer dressed like Morrison and hung out at his old L.A. haunts alongside spending hour after hour badgering The Doors’ producer Paul Rothchild to learn all about Morrison’s vocal mannerisms.

He ended up memorizing 50 Doors songs (even though only 15 were actually used in the film) and did such a convincing job of mimicking Morrison’s singing that even his fellow band members had trouble telling their voices apart.

As dedicated as Kilmer was to the role, his behaviour on set soon took a diva-like turn. While staying in character during filming is perfectly understandable, the way Kilmer went about establishing this probably wasn’t the best way to curry favour with cast and crew.

According to movie legend, Kilmer sent a memo around requesting that people refer to him as ‘Jim’ (fair enough) but also forbade people to approach him without good reason or to stare at him on set (not so fair) and then had the audacity to wonder why he was being largely ignored on set. He basically insisted everyone treat him like a brattish, entitled rock star and was then bewildered when they did exactly that. Actor logic, eh?

Mind, some say that Morrison was a bit of a d**k so perhaps it was all part of Kilmer’s method acting masterplan.


3. Bill Murray – Where The Buffalo Roam

Where The Buffalo Roam
Universal

Playing the late, great and slightly insane gonzo journalist Hunter S. Thompson in 1980’s Where the Buffalo Roam had quite the effect on Bill Murray. After spending enough time with Thompson to perfectly nail his mannerisms – even going so far as to live together at points during production – it seemed his persona started overtaking Murray.

While staying at Thompson’s Aspen, Colorado home during filming the pair embroiled themselves in a rather risky game of one-upmanship that culminated in an alcohol-fuelled Murray – seemingly still in gonzo journalist mode – daring an equally drunk Thompson to tie him to a chair and chuck him in his swimming pool. Thompson obliged and Murray almost drowned before the former pulled him out.

Filming of Where the Buffalo Roam also happened to coincide with Murray’s other work commitments including the fifth season of Saturday Night Live. According to SNL crew members, Murray showed up on set in his Hunter S. Thompson costume apparently unable to shake his persona. One unnamed SNL writer said even said, “Billy was not Bill Murray, he was Hunter Thompson. You couldn’t talk to him without talking to Hunter Thompson.”

Even more than a decade after playing Thompson, Murray was still feeling the effects of basically becoming his doppelganger: “I took on another persona and that was tough to shake. I still have Hunter in me”, he said in a 1993 interview. Hopefully now 15 years later he’s managed to finally give Thompson the slip.


2. Jim Carrey – Man On The Moon

Jim Carrey Man On The Moon.jpg
Universal Pictures

Jim Carrey nabbed his second Golden Globe for Best Actor for his performance as legendary funny man Andy Kaufman in Milos Forman’s biopic Man on the Moon but the rather extreme lengths he took to get inside the mind of Kaufman didn’t exactly earn many new friends on set.

Carrey dove headlong into Kaufman’s quirky personality and stayed in character 24/7 during the shoot either as Kaufman himself or his vulgar alter ego, lounge singer Tony Clifton. His act was apparently so convincing and consistent that according to co-stars, crew and even Kaufman’s own family and friends it was difficult to tell where Kaufman ended and Carrey began.

Carrey’s commitment to ‘the Method’ even spawned a documentary – Jim & Andy: The Great Beyond – compiled from hours of behind-the-scenes footage that captured his on-set antics.

Alongside refusing to respond to any name but Andy or Tony, Carrey got up to some pretty bizarre stuff including barging into Steven Spielberg office demanding to see the shark from Jaws (as Tony Clifton) and speaking to Ron Howard about their forthcoming project How the Grinch Stole Christmas in character as Kaufman.

He took it a bit too far, however, when he picked a fight with wrestler Jerry Lawler – a friend of Kaufman’s who’d had a famously faux feud with him in the early 80s. While recreating a wrestling match between Lawler and Kaufman, Carrey tried to goad Lawler into hitting him for real by spitting on him to which the wrestler responded by putting him in a reverse chin lock and sending him to hospital.

Ouch, but understandable.


1. Joaquin Phoenix – I’m Still Here

im still here
Magnolia Pictures

Joaquin has had some successful dalliances with The Method during his movie career. His insistence on being referred to by Johnny Cash’s real name J.R. during the making of biopic Walk the Line and his staying in character for three months as a disturbed WWII veteran during the making of The Master both resulted in Best Actor nominations at the Oscars.

Between those films, however, Phoenix conducted a not so successful experiment with method acting when in late 2008 he announced he would be retiring from acting to concentrate on a career as a hip-hop artist instead.

For the next two years Phoenix kept up the act appearing in public unshaved and unkempt. He once showed up on the Late Show with David Letterman to promote his last ever movie in character as Joaquin Phoenix the possibly unhinged actor who gave up an acclaimed acting career to become a rapper and proceeded to mumble his way through the interview.

He even went so far as to perform a few live shows in hip-hop artist mode during which he rapped unintelligibly and got booed off stage. The second-hand cringe must’ve been unbearable.

Eventually it turned out it was all an elaborate hoax part of he and Casey Affleck’s mockumentary I’m Still Here. Unfortunately for Phoenix, nobody else really got the joke and the film flopped harder than a fish out of water.a

Still though, you’ve got to admire his dedication. Staying in character while shooting a movie is one thing but staying in character – as a messed-up version of yourself, no less – for two whole years of your public life is a whole other level of commitment.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Jim-Carrey
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

Helen Jones hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.