10 Ingenious Ways Film Directors Beat The Studio

You gotta do what you gotta do to get your movie made.

Zack Snyder's Justice League.jpg
Warner Bros.

Even the smoothest movie production is a creative tug-of-war between the director and the studio, typically resulting in a series of compromises in order to keep both sides at least somewhat happy.

There are of course many examples where the studio simply steamrolls a filmmaker with all of their might, but every so often, there are occasional instances of a director using their business nous to get one over on those pesky executives.

These 10 directors, from venerated icons and Oscar winners to more niche up-and-comers, all pulled off absurdly smart games of 4D chess with the bigwigs at the studio who attempted to mess with their vision.

If you give the studio an inch they'll gladly take a mile, so these directors' well-laid plans ensured that wasn't really possible. They may have had to lie and scheme their way there, but in most cases the final movie proved superior as a result.

It's always nice to see the little guy score a win, especially when they're an artist competing against a commercial goliath whose primary interest is money at any cost...

10. John Ford Only Shot The Material He Needed To Avoid Studio Meddling - Most Of His Movies

John Wayne John Ford
Paramount Pictures

It's no secret that even the most organised filmmaker shoots far more footage than actually ends up in the movie, and that's become ever-more true in the age of digital filmmaking, without the need to consider the expense of shooting on film stock.

Mad Max: Fury Road, for instance, had a shooting ratio of 240:1, capturing roughly 480 hours of footage for the two-hour final movie.

But even back in the Golden Age of Hollywood (1930-1959), it was extremely common for films to be shot at a ratio as high as 10:1.

Yet a select circle of filmmakers realised that they could minimise the shooting ratio in order to help them maintain creative control. Alfred Hitchcock famously shot at a 3:1 ratio most of the time, and the legendary John Ford was reportedly even stricter.

Ford would shoot minimal takes and only the bare minimum coverage to protect himself in the editing room, but otherwise shot little extraneous material so that the studio couldn't interfere with the end product.

This is allegedly why Ford worked with so many cast members time and time again, because their professional familiarity allowed him to get what he wanted in just a few takes. Ford himself even spoke of his stingy shooting style:

"I don't give 'em a lot of film to play with...I do cut in the camera. Otherwise, if you give them a lot of film 'the committee' takes over. They start juggling scenes around and taking out this and putting in that. They can't do it with my pictures. I cut in the camera and that's it. There's not a lot of film left on the floor when I'm finished."

Genius.


9. Michael Cimino Lied About The Length Of The Wedding Scene - The Deer Hunter

The Deer Hunter Wedding
United Artists

If all else fails, just flat-out lie to the studio and hope for the best. That was the bold strategy employed by the late, great Michael Cimino while shooting his Oscar-winning opus The Deer Hunter.

The film is famous - or some might say, infamous - for its lengthy wedding sequence before the central characters head off to war, totalling a stonking 51 minutes in length.

Hilariously, though, Cimino initially claimed to producers that the scene would only take up a mere 21 minutes of screen time, so one can imagine their surprise when it was a whole half-hour longer, extending the runtime out to 184 bladder-busting minutes.

Producer Michael Deeley later said of Cimino's sneaky trick, "the plan was to be advanced by stealth rather than straight dealing." He wasn't wrong.

Cimino even went as far as to fire editor Peter Zinner from the movie when he found him cutting the wedding scene down, and though Cimino insisted he more-or-less cut the movie himself, Zinner still won a Best Film Editing Oscar for his work.

Ultimately the outcome was a happy one for all involved, as The Deer Hunter won four of its nine Oscars - for Best Picture, Director, Supporting Actor (Christopher Walken), and Film Editing - and performed well at the box office.

Yet the film's unlikely success nevertheless led to Cimino's career-ending, hubris-filled, studio-destroying follow-up, the grandiose 1980 flop Heaven's Gate.


8. David Fincher Changed The Movie's Most Offensive Line...To Something MORE Offensive - Fight Club

Fight Club Brad Pitt Helena Bonham Carter
Fox

David Fincher may be one of the most respected filmmakers working today, but he is himself no stranger to feuding with studios, suffering through the traumatic production of Alien 3 amid constantly meddling from Fox.

Production on Fight Club was no picnic either, especially as studio executives had little faith in the movie, effectively wanting to plane the edges off the film and turn it into something more outwardly commercial.

The studio particularly balked at the brief post-coital exchange between Marla Singer (Helen Bonham) and Tyler Durden (Brad Pitt), where she was originally supposed to say, "I want to have your abortion."

Because Fincher didn't have final cut privilege, Fox insisted that he change the line to something else, yet Fincher somehow convinced the executives to agree to a deal that he'd change the line once and only once.

But Fincher never specified the change would be for the "better," and so replaced the original line with the even more horrifying quip, "I haven't been f**ked like that since grade school."


7. Miramax Challenged Peter Jackson To Find Another Willing Studio (And He Did) - The Lord Of The Rings

The Lord of the Rings Peter Jackson
New Line Cinema

Peter Jackson knew full well he'd have a hard time convincing any studio to make his desired Lord of the Rings trilogy, and so pitched to Miramax a two-film series instead.

But Miramax's then-parent company Disney ultimately presented a counter-offer, feeling that a duology was just too financially risky.

They instead suggested adapting the three books into a single abridged film, ditching Saruman (Christopher Lee), combining numerous characters and locations, cutting two of the Hobbits, and even using exposition dumps rather than actually, you know, filming crucial scenes from the book.

Jackson naturally wasn't too keen on these compromises, so Miramax responded by giving him a month to find another studio who would get onboard with his ambitious vision, or they'd just replace him with another director.

Miramax was clearly and understandably confident that Jackson, who had no experience in blockbuster fare and whose last film was a major box office bomb, wouldn't find a studio willing to give him hundreds of millions of dollars.

But Jackson stuck to his guns and lucked out, as New Line Cinema ended up giving him a $281 million budget to make his entire envisioned trilogy.

It goes without saying that The Lord of the Rings trilogy was a phenomenal success for all involved, while Miramax and the Weinsteins were left kicking rocks.


6. Orson Welles Told The Studio He Was "Rehearsing" While Shooting The Movie - Citizen Kane

Citizen Kane Orson Welles
RKO

Orson Welles was a trailblazer and a maverick like no other - a prodigiously talented filmmaker whose perfectionism and ego ensured he clashed constantly with studios.

Welles was just 25 years old when he co-write, directed, and starred in both his directorial debut and magnum opus Citizen Kane, and though Hollywood is littered with stories of studios bending young filmmakers to their will, Welles was evidently savvy beyond his years.

Beyond having an unprecedented level of creative control in his contract - namely final cut privilege and the right to withhold dailies from studio RKO - Welles also schemed to keep executives in the dark as much as possible.

During the first few days of the shoot, Welles told the RKO stuffed shirts that he and the rest of the cast were "rehearsing," when in fact the film was already in full production.

This allowed Welles to get started free of any unwanted set visits or executive micro-management, and the studio didn't catch on for a few days.

Presumably by this point Welles had some impressive dailies in the can in case he needed to keep the executives further at bay.


5. George Lucas Took A Low Directing Fee To Keep Merchandising & Sequel Rights - Star Wars: A New Hope

Star Wars A New Hope George Lucas Alec Guinness
Lucasfilm

As much as Star Wars fans may have a love-hate relationship with George Lucas, there's no denying that the man made one of the shrewdest decisions in Hollywood history when assembling the original Star Wars.

After numerous studios passed on Lucas' pitch, he finally struck gold with Fox, who agreed to finance Star Wars for $8 million in order to foster a working relationship with Lucas, whose previous film American Graffiti was nominated for five Oscars (including Best Director and Best Original Screenplay for Lucas).

Considering the phenomenal box office success of American Graffiti, Lucas was advised to re-negotiate his Star Wars directing fee from $150,000 to $500,000, but he instead suggested a deal to Fox: he'd stick to $150,000 if he retained the full merchandising and sequel rights.

Fox agreed, and were soon enough left kicking themselves when Star Wars became a box office and merchandising goliath.

Lucas bet on himself and it paid off dividends, enough that practises with regard to merchandising and sequel negotiations changed drastically in the years that followed.

Lucas ended up selling the entirety of the Star Wars IP, merch and all, to Disney for $4 billion in 2012, confirming just how thoroughly he outsmarted a studio who assumed his film had only limited commercial appeal.


4. Michael Patrick Jann Refused To Re-Cut The Film (And Let It Become A Cult Hit) - Drop Dead Gorgeous

Drop Dead Gorgeous
New Line Cinema

Cult classic mockumentary Drop Dead Gorgeous didn't move the needle critically or commercially upon its initial 1999 release, its subversive, darkly comic riff on teen movies of the era proving rather ahead of its time.

And New Line Cinema were seemingly equally puzzled by the movie, as while the studio had largely left director Michael Patrick Jann alone during principal photography, they began to panic in post-production when the film's box office tracking turned out troublingly low.

Executives asked Jann to create a new, softer cut which was closer in tone to teen sensation Clueless, in the hope of elevating the film's box office prospects.

Jann, frustrated at the studio's 180 in attitude to the project - having previously been effusively supportive - ultimately elected not to compromise his vision. In his own words, "It's too late. It's not like that. This is for the girls who went to Clueless and were like, 'F**k them.'"

Because there wasn't much time to fix the film and New Line had already pre-sold international rights, they decided to simply release the film as-is, having mostly mitigated their financial exposure before it hit cinemas thanks to its low $15 million budget.

Jann got the last laugh by standing his ground and refusing to contrive a sanitised, Frankensteined re-edit of the movie, though, as it found a second life on streaming in recent years, resulting in a critical re-evaluation of its entertaining deconstruction of the teen comedy.


3. The Iconic Propeller Gag Was Created Due To Studio Interference - Airplane

Airplane Zero Hour
Paramount Pictures

Iconic parody film Airplane! probably isn't a movie most people associate with executive meddling and galaxy brain filmmaker scheming, but a frustrating stipulation from Paramount inadvertently led to one of the film's best gags.

Originally, directors David and Jerry Zucker and Jim Abrahams wanted to heighten the absurdity of the comedy by having the titular vehicle be an old-fashioned propeller plane.

However, Paramount insisted that it be switched out for a commercial jet airliner as to better connect with contemporary audiences. The filmmakers agreed and in turn were allowed to cast a slew of serious actors in deadpan roles rather than recognisable comedians.

But the Zuckers and Abrahams didn't simply let the propeller fight go: they decided to have some fun with it by dubbing propeller sound effects over all exterior shots of the plane throughout the movie.

Better still, the sound effect is taken from the 1957 drama Zero Hour!, which Airplane! itself is a parody of. Talk about a brilliantly petty way to get back at the studio.


2. Zack Snyder Harnessed Social Media To Get His Cut Released - Zack Snyder's Justice League

Zack Snyder's Justice League Superman
Warner Bros.

Let's face it - we're all fed up of talking about Zack Snyder's Justice League at this point, but the film's mere existence is nevertheless an extremely fascinating sign of the times.

Justice League was of course originally released in 2017, with Joss Whedon re-shooting a large percentage of the film after Snyder stepped away to deal with a family tragedy, in turn transforming Snyder's ambitious vision into a more bland, "commercial," Avengers-esque tentpole.

The so-called "Whedon Cut" was a critical and commercial disappointment, and in the years that followed Snyder continually talked-up the existence of his own "Snyder Cut," which had already been cut together but still required extensive post-production work.

For years the Snyder Cut seemed like nothing more than a pipe dream, an intriguing "what if?" but not something Warner Bros. would ever entertain bankrolling.

But the power of the #ReleaseTheSnyderCut hashtag was undeniable, fans passionately campaigning for the film in ways both creative and troublingly obsessive, alongside most of the focal cast members such as Ben Affleck and Gal Gadot.

Last year, Warner Bros. made fans' dreams come true by confirming the Snyder Cut would indeed be completed, with Snyder being given $70 million to complete visual effects work and even shoot a small additional sequence.

To the surprise of just about everyone, the end result was surprisingly solid, if undeniably messy and excessive.

But more than the movie itself, it crowbarred open a discussion about not only the future of both film and streaming, but also the ability for an online "movement" to actually get what it wants.

This isn't to say that Snyder wanted things to turn out this way back in 2017, but Zack Snyder's Justice League is still an undeniable, belated "win" for Snyder over executive meddlers who felt compelled to sanitise his vision into generic slop.


1. Alfred Hitchcock Shot The Film On A Rival Studio Lot With His Own Money - Psycho

Psycho Janet Leigh
Paramount Pictures

Alfred Hitchcock is one of the shrewdest filmmakers the industry has ever seen, but his most brilliantly Machiavellian achievement might well be how he ingeniously schemed Psycho into existence.

It's no secret that Paramount didn't want Hitchcock to make the film in the first place, feeling the source novel was "too repulsive."

Hitchcock bought the rights to the book anyway, but Paramount held firm, refusing to stump up the usual $3-4 million budget Hitch's films commanded.

Never one to be deterred, Hitch fought back, making a series of concessions which ultimately ended up elevating the film: he agreed to shoot in black-and-white and self-finance the project on a budget of just $806,947.

Even then, Paramount still tried to talk the director out of it, insisting that they didn't have any spare soundstages where Psycho could be filmed.

And at this point Hitch pulled out his masterstroke: he agreed to shoot the film on a lot owned by rival studio Universal-International, in turn only requiring Paramount to distribute the film.

Hitch also waived his $250,000 director's fee, instead agreeing to receive a 60% stake in the film negative, which naturally proved far more lucrative soon enough.

Hitch just kept trivialising Paramount's risk and exposure until they couldn't really say no to a director of his repute, and it sure as hell paid off.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.