10 Insane Harry Potter Fan Theories

But of course Voldemort is bin Laden...

For many, the magic of JK Rowling's Harry Potter books and their ensuing movie adaptations was very real. It cast a spell on children across the globe and inspired a whole generation of creative, inquisitive minds who continued to read widely and voraciously as a result of these early, beguiling stories. Plus it inspired a whole generation of creative, inquisitive perverts who came up with increasingly weird and deranged pairings of fictional wizards they wanted to see do the nasty. Ah fan fiction, what would we do without you? Be able to sleep at night, probably. The books and films have long since finished (although Rowling keeps them alive with the Pottermore website and the upcoming Fantastic Beasts And Where To Find Them spin-off film), but the enormous fandom surrounding Harry Potter still lives on. In web forums, at conventions and - especially - on Tumblr, you'll come across true Potter fanatics who continue to produce fan works and pick apart the original texts, arguing about allegiances and the foreshadowing of plot twists and major deaths. Amongst all of that, you might stumble across something stranger. Yes, stranger than that story about Severus Snape and the unicorn. Just about. The strangeness in question are fan theories, the in-universe (but sometimes OOC, or out of continuity) flights of fancy where people other alternative takes on characters, scenes, or entire storylines that occurred throughout the books and films. There has been suggestion that the writing style is modelled on a form of computer programming, that ancient myth and legend plays a bigger part in the story of Hogwarts than originally thought, and that Dumbledore...ugh, well, we'll get to that. Hold onto your socks, because they're about to blown off by ten insane fan theories about Harry Potter.

10. It's All In Harry's Head

For starters, we should probably get out of the way one of the most enduring and bafflingly popular theories people like to try and apply to every piece of childhood fiction they can get their grubby paws on. People have done it for everything from The Fresh Prince Of Bel Air to Courage The Cowardly Dog, but at least the Harry Potter version has a little more evidence behind it: the idea is that, rather than escaping the abusive, neglectful childhood where he's locked in the cupboard under the stairs of his uncaring Aunt and Uncle Dursley to attend Hogwarts School Of Witchcraft And Wizardry, all of Harry's high-flying adventures are happening in his head, as an escape from the depressing reality of his life as an orphaned prisoner. This variation on the theme manages to be a little more detailed. The starting point is definitely more convincing than "Will Smith imagined going to live in Bel Air after being left brain damaged by bullies on a basketball court", because what troubled and abused kid wouldn't retreat into a far-off fantasy world full of spells and owls? As if that wasn't morbid enough, however, this theory goes on to suggest that all the injuries Harry suffers whilst at Hogwarts are actually the result of the physical abuse enacted on him by the Dursleys, and the reason he's not allowed to use magic outside of the school is because IT'S NOT REAL. Then the only reason rules like that get broken - and the general inconsistencies that appear as the series continues, along with the darkening tone - are because he's slowly starving to death in his cupboard, and his mind's starting to go. Fun!

9. The Books Were Written Python-Style

In case you didn't know - and, honestly, there's no real reason for you to - Python is a programming language that can be used to make just about anything you want within the confines of your computer, but only if you're operating at a very high level of geekery. We can profess to have but a minor understanding of HTML (we can make our text go big!), but there are a bunch of enterprising smart people out there who are adept at Python; including, possibly, JK Rowling herself. At least that's according to one Python obsessive who routinely writes out their thoughts on all things programming on their blog and, apparently, began to notice some similarities between the construction of code in the language and the way that Rowling writes her prose in the Harry Potter books. We guess if we spent all day staring at Python we'd start seeing it everywhere we looked, too. Without getting into too much tech lingo (because we don't understand too much of it either), the point one Guido van van Rossum is making is that Rowling often seems to trace over the previous books in the series and highlights things that were often off-handed remarks or invents things based on previous writings €“ like, she probably came up with the name Tom Riddle after realising it was an anagram of €œI Am Lord Voldemort€ - which, as it happens, is the same as how "successive versions of Python are constrained by pretty serious backwards compatibility requirements." Which is actually just a roundabout way of trying to explain how "continuity" works, something that has existed for as long as series of books (or films, or TV shows, or games...) have. So more likely Rowling just...knows how to write, than is aware of Python. Sorry, nerds!

8. Harry Is The Reincarnation Of King Arthur

Throughout the series which bears his name, Harry Potter is something of a living legend. His reputation as the Boy Who Lived precedes him, the expectations he is expected to reach scholastically are ridiculously high thanks to his €œdefeat€ of the dark lord Voldemort when he was only a baby, and the way people fawn over him earns him half of Slytherin as an instant enemy before he's even had chance to meet them. That and the fact that he's apparently destined to eventually take down Voldemort again is rather a lot of responsibility to carry in the first place, and that's before you throw in the theory that he's the descendant of King Arthur. Or possibly reincarnation. As if he didn't have enough to live up to, tsk. Be warned: this particular theory is almost as long as a Harry Potter book itself. And we're not talking about those flimsy first three in the series, we mean a meandering, phonebook-thick tome on par with Order Of The Phoenix. The crux of it is that JK Rowling was supposedly foreshadowing a plot twist all along which would reveal the Potters were descented from Arthurian legend, that there's a load of parallels to the famous pulling of the sword from the stone (something to do with the Sorting Hat, apparently), and that he's not the only one with royal blood; after all the Weasleys Arthur, Bill, Charlie, Fred, and George and are all named after British monarchs. Wait, so everybody€™s descended from kings? Or something? This one is so insane we're not sure the person writing it even understood it.

7. Magic Is Controlled By Physics

So, you think that the spells and other magical stuff that goes on in the Harry Potter books is all just a fantasy, huh? It exists purely in our imagination? You couldn't oh, we don't know, hope to explain all of the magical phenomena that crops up over the course of the books and films using a 7000-word document that breaks them all down in terms of actual, tangible real-world physics? Well, friend, you've got another thing coming, because that document totally exists. And it is mind-boggling. And almost certainly certifiably insane because, honestly, who is smart enough about physics to be able to spin out a 7000-word document on how you can apply it to Harry Potter? And yet, the whole thing kind of works. So far as we can follow, anyway. String theory is a part of what we call theoretical physics, because it's something that's widely accepted with actually being testable. It posits that, instead of the world being made up of tiny little round things called particles, those particles are actually more like strings. This makes it a a self-contained theory of everything that takes into account not only the construction of the universe but also things like gravity and other forces. This Potter dork claims that the wizarding world takes advantage of a hitherto unknown €œeleventh€ vibrating string of existence, which the pupils of Hogwarts take advantage of to do a load of things which shouldn't be possible according to conventional physics. Oh and they did the calculations as to how to make flying broomsticks a reality, so that's pretty neat. Not sure it's what Rowling had in mind...

6. Hufflepuff Are Stoners

Oh, Tumblr, you've given us so much - from memes to otherkin and all the way back, the social network-cum-blogging service is a treasure trove for weird crap on the internet. Perhaps the greatest bounty to ever have been harvested from the site, however, is a fan theory that relates to a certain school of Hogwarts described by Hagrid as €œa lot o' duffers€. The Sorting Hat, when introducing the different houses, describes Hufflepuff as €œWhere they are just and loyal, those patient Hufflepuffs are true, and unafraid of toil." Or, as the Hat may as well have said during the process, €œHufflepuff=4/20 blaze it!!!!!!€ At least, that's if you subscribe to shelltheworlddestroyer's line of thinking. Which we totally do, because it's hilarious. In a widely circulated text post the Tumblr hive mind put together inarguable proof that Hufflepuff is a house for stoners. Like, everybody who gets put into that house of Hogwarts will just spend all their time getting baked. Look: they are mostly considered to be nice and peaceful, they live in the basement right by the kitchens, their head of house teaches something called €œHerbology€ (but what kind of herbs, Pomona Sprout?), and a badger is exactly the sort of animal a pothead would think to conjure using their magic spells. The name is Hufflepuff, for crying out loud! HUFF le PUFF. It's all been right in front of us all along! Fittingly, this is exactly the sort of theory a stoned person would come up with and think was totally mind-blowing.

5. It's A Metaphor for 9/11

Besides the "it was all in their head!" or €œeveryone's dead!€, the "it's a metaphor for 9/11!" is one of the more favoured lines for fan theories. It's been applied to the obvious (Cloverfield) and the less obvious (The Dark Knight), but we think that the comparison of the World Trade Centre terrorist attacks to Harry Potter might be our favourite. Not least because the theory originates from a 2011 Reuters article which boasts the marvellous headline "Eerie links between Harry Potter, bin Laden". Why, there are not only links between one of the deadliest terrorists of the 21st century, but eerie ones! Surely we cannot deny that this magical series of children's books might have something to do with 9/11 if the connections are so eerie? The theory goes that the pair are inextricably linked: the first Harry Potter film, The Philosopher's Stone, was released a scant few months after the attacks; Voldemort is a formless bogeyman that a whole nation fears, not unlike Osama bin Laden; Harry is often referred to as "the anointed one", a title right-wing pundits like Rush Limbaugh have used to derisively describe President Barack Obama; oh, and both bin Laden and Voldemort were finally struck down on the same date of May 1st. Well, actually May 2nd (and in 1998) for the Voldemort/Potter showdown, but close enough, right? And the film of Harry Potter And The Deathly Hallows: Part 2 came out not long after Osama carked it, so there's your big parallel!

4. Harry Used The Time Turner To Go Watch His Parents' Death

One of the most discussed (and, consequently, theorised upon) parts of Harry Potter's tragic origin story was the revelation by Rowling in an interview - always with the revelatory interviews - that someone besides Voldemort was at Godric€™s Hollow the night of Harry's parents' murder. Eventually it transpired that this someone was Snape, and he was trying to help out, but it didn't end up going down like that. And so Harry became the Boy Who Lived, fitting neatly into the tragic orphan stereotype that typifies so many hero's journeys, from Hercules up through Luke Skywalker. Still, before Rowling stated categorically that the rubbernecker in question was old Severus, there was some serious speculation as to who that fourth figure was. And one theory had it down that Harry himself had gone back to see his parents die. Which is...kinda morbid. Which book did he go through his goth phase? To be fair, insane those this theory is, it is based in some pretty sound logic. We'd already been introduced to the concept of the Time Turner in the Prisoner Of Azkaban, a Ministry-sanctioned time travel device that Hermione had gotten her hands on and was using to swat up by going to extra classes at Hogwarts. Unfortunately, travelling back in time with the Turner doesn't allow you to actually change events in history, since they already happened. Unless it's Buckbeak and Sirius Black, for some reason. So Harry went back, hoping to save his parents and change history, but realised he wasn't able to. Which is actually even more sad than his parents being killed whilst he was a baby: seeing it happen again, and not being able to stop it. Yeesh.

3. How Dumbledore "Turned" Gay

Now, this is one which we don't in any way buy into or endorse, but it is certifiably insane. And insane Harry Potter theories is what we promised you, and we always deliver on our promises. Always. And so, we present to you, the reason that Albus Dumbledore €œturned€ gay: it's a combination of a couple of different fan theories, taking in JK Rowling's revelation once the books had ended that the headmaster of Hogwarts had been gay all along (but it had never come up in the text itself), and some weird idea that at some point in the distant past - honestly, we don't know where this came from - Dumbledore's sister was assaulted by a bunch of muggles. And the young Albus watched, for some reason? Or saw it? Anyway, after seeing how they had treated a woman, he swore off sex with females for the rest of his life and became homosexual. Which is a totally insane theory because, honestly, Rowling didn't even mention his sexuality in the book, would she really have planted a bunch of references to a rape in her series of children's books? Also, it's based on the incredibly problematic thinking that something can €œturn€ someone gay. People don't "turn" gay. He's not like a sexual Batman or something, his libido changed irrevocably by a tragic event so he dedicates himself to knobs. Shame on you, Lama.a. If that is your real name.

2. JK Rowling Isn't A Real Person

Whenever a woman achieves any modicum of success, a bunch of conspiracy theorists come out of the woodwork hoping to diminish her achievements in some way. It's the reason so many Victorian female writers took male or gender-neutral pen names, it's why you see people spreading nonsense about Beyonce all over the place, and it's almost certainly the same line of thinking which started off the ridiculous fan theory that JK Rowling doesn't exist. Or rather, she does exist, just as a pen name for a bunch of writers who were the ones who actually wrote the Harry Potter books. Because we guess the idea of a broke single mother writing a goofy story in a cafe achieving worldwide fame and popularity is just too believable...? Actually this particular theory originates with Norwegian film director Nina Grünfeld, who admits that the party line is a "fantastic" story, that "gives hope", but that it couldn't possibly be real. "But can a person be so productive and commercially successful in a media industry where nothing is left to coincidence? Is it possible that a person can write six thick books that are translated into 55 languages and sell more than 250 million copies in less than 10 years? Is it probable that the stories then get filmed and commercially exploited to the degree seen here, without any well-thought-out strategy or highly professional players behind them?" Of course not! Makes way more sense that Rowling is an actress paid to act as a front for a shadowy cabal of authors and filmmakers. And she has kept schtum all these years. And kept the money.

1. Or Else She Is, And All Magic Is Too

Now, suggesting that JK Rowling is a made-up person is certainly an insane theory. Worryingly, though, it isn't the most insane theory a fan has had about Harry Potter. Not, that dubious honour must go to the blog of Mike Bacior, freshman at Penn State, who suggests that perhaps not only is JK Rowling not a fictional construct, but neither is anything she has ever written about. Everything that happens in the Harry Potter books actually happened. In real life. And, just as in the text and films, us muggles were completely unaware of it. Or at least we would be, if Rowling hadn't been on hand to write down and document all these amazing events as they happened. Somehow managing to ignore the concept of an "imagination" whilst displaying a pretty fervent one himself, Bacior asks €œDo we honestly believe that this woman simply sat down one day and came up with all of these great details?€ before going on to outline his alternative hypothesis. He suggests that Rowling herself is a "squib" (a person involved in the magical world with no magic powers themselves), and that "she has taken the 20th century history of the magical world and wrote it down as 'fiction' for the Muggle (non-magical) World, knowing that we would be unable to conceive it as reality. We eat the 'fiction' up, not knowing that all of these events actually took place." Erm...right. Then he gets into the nitty gritty of this theory, suggesting that every major conflict since the Cold War has suffered some influence and motivation from the magical world ("Voldemort and his followers used our world in a battle to gain control of the Earth, as the Order of the Phoenix opposed him via the United States of America"), and that the destruction of Voldemort in 1991 coincided with the end of the conflict by the US and Russia. And a Death Eater controlled George W Bush's mind and forced him to invade Iraq to distract us from Voldemort's return. Honestly, we've heard worse explanations...

Contributor
Contributor

Tom Baker is the Comics Editor at WhatCulture! He's heard all the Doctor Who jokes, but not many about Randall and Hopkirk. He also blogs at http://communibearsilostate.wordpress.com/