10 Lame Movie Heroes It Was Impossible To Root For
Heroes are people we can look up to. They are role models that bring out the best in us and tend to be the most iconic characters in popular fiction. When executed correctly, a hero's story should be one that the viewer takes with them feeling empathy and fear along with them. This isn't always the way things turn out. Otherwise good films can be ruined by the lack of a strong protagonist as you will see. There are some heroes that can only be described as lame. Whether they have top billing or merely sidekick status they have failed in their task to be enjoyable or useful within the narrative. I'm sure many of you have shouted at the screen due to a character's stupidity and these are the types of offenders I am casting an accusing gaze over. This article is here to shed light on those films whose heroes left a great deal to be desired and this can be down to a number of factors: whether it be the actor, the direction or even the writing. What is certain though is that a narrative which contains a poorly formed or ludicrous hero cannot very easily be enjoyed. Please not that this article contains SPOILERS.
10. Vincent - Silent Hill Revelations
The Silent Hill films have tried to stay relatively close to the source material, the first one being a reasonably successful horror film in its own right. Then came Revelations 3D to retroactively undo this achievement by being as terrible as it possibly could be. Luckily, in being bad it is one of those films that are great to watch with a few beers and pretend is intentionally funny. Kit Harrington from HBOs fantasy powerhouse Game of Thrones enters the narrative as Vincent who combines the desirable attributes of leather vests and creepy stalking. Despite being warned repeatedly by her father Harry, played by the one and only Sean Bean, Heather (Adelaide Clemens) follows Vincent to Silent Hill. Shock, horror! We learn that Vincent is the son of the main baddy yet immediately regrets the decision to bring Heather to them. We now switch to Vincent's secondary attributes which are apologizing and cowering, despite seeming desperate to put out a macho image with his Arthur Fonzarelli costume. Although Vincent does sort of save Heather from the creepy nurses his big to prove that he is indeed heroic comes right at the end of the film. What great feat of bravery is this? He stands up to his mother. I appreciate that Silent Hill needs to show off the trademark monsters being spooky and that they inexplicably thought a Pyramid Head sword battle would be an appropriate climax but why cast Jon Snow if you're not going to give him a chance to save the day.
9. Matthew Farrell - Die Hard 4.0
John McClane is a hard person to match up with a sidekick. The clear winner in this category would be Samuel L. Jackson as Zeus who matches Willis' badassery with little issue. The most recent attempt saw us being forced to empathise with the emotional equivalent of a slab of concrete in the form of Jai Courtney, whose whiny father son relationship arc did not do the franchise any favours. I'm landing in between these two with the character played by Justin Long, the most useless sidekick of them all, Matthew Farrell. In a plot derived from a 1997 article on cyber terrorism called 'A Farewell to Arms' we are told to believe that Timothy Olyphant and a van full of laptops could take over mainland USA. Being an old timer, John McClane doesn't know how to use these new fangled computer doodads so is forced to enlist the help of hacker extraordinaire Matthew Farrell. So begins an awkward attempt at rapport between the two of them which just comes off as Justin Long saying how cool Bruce Willis is repeatedly as things explode around him. While at times he tries to be brave and battle the enemy with computers it never really pays off to much effect, proving McClane's theory that the old ways are the best. So they fight through all that the baddies sent their way in typical Die Hard fashion by throwing cars at helicopters and crushing people down lift shafts until they catch up to Olyphant's villain. After the catchphrase of the whole Die Hard franchise is censored and everyone is sad, the film decides to twist the knife by insinuating that John McClane's badass daughter (Mary Elizabeth Winstead) would instantly go to mush over the self proclaimed social pariah that is Farrell.
8. Elliot Moore - The Happening
I could write numerous essays about why The Happening is god-awful but I admit this is mainly because I was tricked into seeing it. I knew it was directed by M. Night Shyamalan, but I gave him the benefit of the doubt. What daring twist would he attempt in this film? I was ready for anything but the actual answer, that the bloody trees were doing it. One review called it "an incoherent and unconvincing trifle", which I disagree with as trifle is delicious. I digress, opinions aside for a moment, the hero of the piece is one Elliot Moore (Mark Wahlberg) who is a high school science teacher. He is really concerned about the reduced number of bees and what effect this will have on the world. That is about all the character development we get from him as we follow him around the country looking pleasantly surprised at everything going on. Look at the picture above before watching the film and prepare yourself to witness that face throughout its 90 minute run time, usually at very inappropriate points. At one point he talks to a tree before realizing it's plastic, asking it if he can use the toilet. I don't care if this segment was played for laughs, in the context of the wider narrative and Wahlberg's character up to this point it just comes off as tragic. The highlight of the whole film is where Elliot puts two and two together about the deadly toxin and he and his small group literally run away from the wind. I wish I was joking.
7. Ray Owens - The Last Stand
Arnold Schwarzenegger's return to action hero fame was always going to have some bumps in the road. His performance in The Last Stand was certainly one of these. The film focused on an escaped drug cartel kingpin and his super fast car as much as it did character development which meant everyone was lacking. The only person you really get a feel for is Johnny Knoxville but predictably this is as the town crazy person in contrast Forrest Whitaker seems to be confused the whole time he is on screen as if he wasn't aware of the plot before turning up on set. With this being the standard set it should be no problem for Arnie to shine through as Sheriff Ray Owens. The problem is that he just doesn't. The issues don't stem from him being a large Austrian small town sheriff, we've seen Schwarzenegger play these unconvincing characters before but the difference is that we're usually invested in what happens to them. As Owens he really doesn't seem affected by anything as he's just a stoic, cut and paste hero with little to no character at all. Couple this with the fact that he's essentially a side story in this film and there isn't even any time to build a motivation apart from the black and white standard of let's stop the baddie. The character of Ray Owens isn't on this list because he was terrible or ridiculous, quite the opposite. He just didn't make much of an impression and I'd struggle to remember anything memorable he did during the narrative.
6. Aang - The Last Airbender
Another entry featuring a Shyamalan character, what are the chances? I'm not on a witch hunt here though, The Last Airbender simply had to be on this list or I'd get a lot of grief. With access to the rich and colourful source material of the animation, Shyamalan decided that instead he would whitewash the main cast and give roles to the first child actors to walk through the door. I can only assume the latter is true and couples with the terrible visual effects and paper thin narrative; there wasn't much chance of critical success. The central character is the titular Last Airbender, Aang. We follow him and his companions in a quest to avoid capture by the sinister Fire Nation. Of course the inevitable occurs and they must do battle but by this point you won't really care. Aang learns Waterbending, travels to the spirit world and accepts his destiny as the Avatar to overcome all odds to emerge victorious. While this all sounds thrilling, I can assure you it is not. If you can make it through the entirety of this film on the back of Noah Ringer's performance as Aang, you're a trooper. Granted he's a young actor and the direction of Shyamalan clearly leaves a lot to be desired but when it gets to the point that you're actively rooting against the hero of the piece, you ain't doing it right.
5. Robin - Batman & Robin
Dick Grayson, a character with a tragic history parallel to Bruce Wayne's and a desire to fight crime. This was not how Chris O'Donnell chose to portray him in 1997's universally mocked Batman & Robin. Instead we were treated to whining, jealousy and bat-nipples. Joel Schumacher's vision of the Caped Crusader was campy, which is not necessarily a bad thing as seen in the 60s show starring Adam West, but in an attempt to be tongue in cheek it reached the point of being unbearable. We were never given a chance to like the character of Robin in this film. Right from the off he's crying and moaning that Batman doesn't trust him enough, in a much parodied sequence, angrily yelling at him ('aaaarrgh!') from a rooftop when he takes off after Mr. Freeze alone. Couple this angsty teen attitude with such wonders as bat-skates or air surfing on metal doors and the whole movie adds up to a great unintentional joke. Chris O'Donnell has even said in an interview since the film that he felt like he was shooting a toy commercial, what hope did his character have? He even competes for the affections of the clearly evil Poison Ivy against Batman, at one point challenging him to bid for her at auction. Despite his stellar observation that The Dark Knight is wearing 'a utility belt, not a money belt' he is bested by the Bat credit card. I have to stop talking about this it's making me sad.
4. Hal Jordan - The Green Lantern
Before I start I must say that I believe Ryan Reynolds gets a lot of hate he doesn't deserve. He's a talented comedic actor with some successful dramatic roles under his belt and I enjoy watching him in films. This being said, his performance in The Green Lantern certainly left a lot to be desired. His sub-par Hal Jordan is mainly down to the plotting of the film, which squandered a fantastic cast on what was basically a 2 hour light show. Jordan, an earnest yet cocky test pilot for Ferris aircraft is chosen to join the Green Lantern Corps by a magical ring. He chosen as the guardian of Sector 2814 as the ring believed him to be a worthy successor to the previous Lantern Abin Sur. From here we are given a hackneyed story about accepting responsibility with the character of Jordan nowhere near layered enough to make him a compelling. This is a huge disappointment due to the plethora of source material and the relatively success of super hero movies at the box office. Too much time was spent on the visual aspects that the cast fell by the wayside, it's not right to be too hard on the actors when they were secondary to what the film was trying to achieve. It amounted to watching Ryan Reynolds going through the motions, which is fine in films like R.I.P.D. but perhaps not for a DC property as important as The Green Lantern.
3. Matt Murdock - Daredevil
Now we come to the reason why people have been tearing their hair out over the casting decisions of the next Superman film. Ben Affleck may have matured and changed his ways somewhat with a stellar directing career and more nuanced performances but few will ever forget the internet hate magnet that is Daredevil. In the film he played Matt Murdock, a blind lawyer living in New York's Hell's Kitchen. His affliction was caused during a toxic waste accident as a child. After this tragic event his other senses heightened and gave him sonar capabilities enabling him to see through sonic vibrations. He uses this, coupled with his martial arts training to become the crime-fighter known as Daredevil. While this does indeed sound like the recipe for a top notch superhero film, the results were anything but. With a narrative consisting of martial arts sparring in a playground, soppy clichés and for some reason Daredevil's ability to launch himself through the air as if he has actual superpowers we are never drawn in enough to care about our protagonist. The character's only motivations are displayed in flashback form and from then on he's just some guy in a costume. The convoluted plotting and wooden performances only serve as the final nail in the coffin.
2. Mutt Williams - Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull
Shia LaBeouf has a contentious history of starring in films and then slagging them off afterwards. With the fourth Indiana Jones film he may have been right to, but that doesn't excuse his part in causing the disaster. In the film he plays Henry "Mutt Williams" Jones III, who turns out to be Indiana Jones' son. This would be a lot more palatable if the rest of the film up to that point had not made us actively hate the character. Where to begin? There is the face-palm inducing car sword fight, the constant tired jokes about Indiana Jones' age or the most criminal of them all; swinging on vines with terrible CGI monkeys. Those alone should be enough to deter those who haven't yet seen it. Those who did came to see an Indiana Jones film but were instead offered a story of LaBeouf's teen greaser maturing from Mutt into Henry and learning to respect his father. Taking focus away from Harrison Ford's Indiana is criminal enough to deserve a spot on this list, but to do it in such a spectacularly terrible fashion is unforgivable. The biggest crime against nostalgia happens at the very end. Indiana Jones and Marion finally tie the knot, as Mutt... picks up the legendary hat and puts it on. Although Indiana tried to make light of the situation and takes it back from him, the damage is already done.
1. Anakin Skywalker - Star Wars Episodes II and III
Now we reach the number one spot and a character with all the hallmarks of an unlikeable hero played by professional whiner Hayden Christensen. Anakin Skywalker's journey to the dark side was meant to be the most compelling aspect of the prequel trilogy yet instead became a case study into the petulant adolescent tendencies of a moody teenager. He didn't face an epic struggle with temptation and the dark side he just hopped over the fence without as much as a second thought. George Lucas' writing does sometimes leave a lot to be desired but with capable actors such as Ewan McGreggor's spot on performance as a younger Obi Wan Kenobi, it shows up those who can't cope all the more. I couldn't say what inspired them to choose Christensen for the role but surely it must have become apparent fairly quickly during shooting that there was nothing likeable about his portrayal of Anakin Skywalker. There was nothing to relate to in him, very little nobility and sense of what it is to be a Jedi despite all his training. As for his romance with Natalie Portman's character, there was more playful chemistry between the original Anakin (Jake Lloyd) and Padmé (Portman) in Episode I which is all kinds of wrong. For such an important character in pop culture Darth Vader to have his origin assassinated as it was is one of the biggest crimes against cinema ever committed, it makes no sense alongside the original trilogy and removed any sympathy for the supposedly tragic character of Anakin Skywalker we may have once felt.