10 Massively Underrated 1990s Movie Performances

Winona Ryder in Little Women, Reese Witherspoon in Cruel Intentions, Matthew LIllard in general...

Nicolas Cage 8mm
Columbia Pictures

Every decade of cinema has its unsung heroes, and the alternately grungy and DayGlo nineties are no exception to this rule. The decade that brought us everything from The Craft to Space Jam is no stranger to being misremembered and underrated (still waiting on the Library of Congress to honour Mermaids over here).

Some performances are simply too ahead of their time to be appreciated but go on to influence countless lesser flicks in years to come. Other films feature rightly lauded central turns, but the critical love heaped on their central cast leaves lesser known contributors out in the cold despite their invaluable contributions.

Whatever the case, we here at WhatCulture would like to take this opportunity to shine a light on some of the underappreciated turns throughout the decade of cinema which saw the dream team of Tarantino and Rodriguez come to prominence, the rise and fall of American indie cinema, and the wholesale integration of CGI by Hollywood.

And who knows? Hopefully this list will be able to turn a few eyes toward some performances that time has vindicated in the decades since—Matthew Lillard Appreciation Month when, folks?

10. Benicio Del Toro As Fred Fenster - The Usual Suspects

Usual Suspects Line Up Laughing
PolyGram Filmed Entertainment

Any time a movie pulls together an incredible ensemble cast, it’s pretty inevitable that one of the star’s contributions will go under-remembered. Everyone loves the Oceans franchise, but how many people recall Casey Affleck and Scott Caan’s role therein? Anyone out throw on The Godfather trilogy to bask in James Caan’s great performance? Hell, we’re not even sure if Jeremy Renner knows he’s one of the Avengers.

In the same vein, Gabriel Byrne and Kevin Spacey may leave instant impressions on first viewing as Bryan Singer’s twisty 1995 mystery thriller The Usual Suspects unfolds. But upon a re-watch, the hilarious Benicio Del Toro really gets to shine, and it’s clear the man swaggered into the film to rob every scene he appears in.

It’s much easier to justify not guessing the film’s big twist when you consider that Benicio’s bombastic, goofy performance, complete with impossible-to-place molasses-thick accent, is an ever-present distraction from the convoluted plotting.

It turns out the best trick the devil ever pulled was hiring a camp, slurring thief to pull focus away from his machinations.


9. Nicholas Cage As Tom Welles - 8MM

8MM Nic Cage
Columbia Pictures

Late in his career, it can be hard to recall how huge a force of nature Nicholas Cage once was onscreen. The nephew of Godfather helmer Francis Ford Coppola, Cage spent the nineties as a blockbuster-tier leading man who could stand shoulder-to-shoulder with Bruce Willis and Harrison Ford thanks to flicks like Con Air and The Rock.

Meanwhile, the actor also enjoyed a stellar reputation as a serious method actor and the star of a wide range of more artistic, experimental flicks from Vampire’s Kiss to Leaving Las Vegas. For a while there, it seemed inconceivable that the actor would ever end up as the straight-to-DTV meme lord he’s now known as.

The two sides of his onscreen abilities are showcased in Joel Schumacher’s grimy 1998 thriller 8MM. Alongside a young, effortlessly charming Joaquin Phoenix and Peter Stormare in full Leering Villain Mode, Cage plays a private eye investigating a snuff film ring, and the actor more than convinces in a role as challenging as it is dark.

It would have been as easy role to overdo and the film would suffer were the character too reserved and stoic, so it’s all the more impressive that Cage can vacillate between sombre seething and moments of explosive emotion with grace and verve, anchoring a potentially outlandish and exploitative plot with soul and believable heft.


8. Matthew Lillard As Stu - Scream

Scream Video Store
Dimension Films

Okay look, you can take your pick on this one. Matthew Lillard has been consistently underrated throughout his career, which is nearing three decades this year. The goofy character actor has been a reliably funny, nervy, and often intense presence throughout projects as diverse as Twin Peaks: The Return and Without a Paddle.

And that’s not mentioning his definitive portrayal of Orville “Shaggy” Rogers in countless iterations of the Scooby Doo franchise, a role he lost without warning over last summer, prompting outrage among the show’s considerable fandom.

The best distillation of what Lillard brings to an ensemble cast can be seen in 1996’s Scream, Wes Craven’s meta-slasher masterpiece. The lanky, loose-limbed goofball charms throughout the film, gurning his way through one-liners whilst simultaneously maintaining a constant edge of seething rage just below his placid, grinning surface.

The actor also went above and beyond for the role, improvising the iconic line “I always had a thing for ya, Sid!” during the tense closing chase—as well as unintentionally improvising the equally iconic “You hit me with a phone—Dick!” when co-star Skeet Ulrich accidentally smacked him with a landline during filming. Impeccable instincts.


7. Joey Lauren Adams As Alyssa Jones - Chasing Amy

Chasing Amy
Miramax

Okay, so this is a difficult entry to do, because the movie in question may actually be as imperfect as you recall - or worse. Kevin Smith’s first post-Clerks attempt at maturity may be a far better effort than the previous year’s Mallrats, but it’s still a movie whose emotional centre is a shiftless comic book nerd played by a young Jason Lee, so… Let’s just say Judd Apatow’s often insufferable arrested development slacker protagonists were still a step up from the previous decade’s offerings.

Nonetheless, there’s a charm to the film’s clumsy handling of “modern dating”, and while many of the female characters may struggle with unconvincing dialogue, some manage to succeed despite the material on offer.

Enter Joey Lauren Adams, aka one of the most memorable voices from the nineties—for better or worse. The squeaky-voiced actress plays the love interest of Ben Affleck’s Holden with charm and aplomb, navigating the uneasy territory of possessiveness and sexual mores with a tenderness and righteous strength that still feels revolutionary despite the film’s dated gender politics.

It’s not an easy film to revisit, given how many superior flicks have trodden over similar territory in the decades since its release, but in Addams’ performance there’s a microcosm of everything likeable about Chasing Amy - imperfect, loud, and sometimes cloying, but undeniably funny, sweet, and sincere.


6. Stephen Rea As Fergus - The Crying Game

The Crying Game
Miramax

Neil Jordan’s The Crying Game is a movie which deserves reappraisal in general; an early attempt by a mainstream filmmaker to incorporate LGBTQ+ themes into an accessible genre movie, the film is an underrated success, both thrilling and moving in equal measure.

Understandably given the film’s central twist, much of the acclaim heaped on the flick upon its release fell on the shoulders of love interest Jaye Davidson, who had never acted before securing the pivotal role. Davidson’s performance is indeed stellar, but upon re-evaluation Stephen Rea’s understated depiction of a conflicted IRA man on the run from his former collaborators and the law alike is a powerful piece of acting.

Rea moves through a range of emotion during the film’s lengthy runtime, approaching both love and fear with the same sense of nervous intensity which makes him both relatable and volatile. The performance swerves between being deeply empathetic and unsparingly harsh, and Rea navigates difficult emotional territory with grace and apparent ease.

It’s a shame we didn’t see more of the actor as a put-upon anti-hero, as The Crying Game gives the impression of a charming, brooding leading man in the making.


5. Paul Rudd As Josh - Clueless

clueless paul rudd josh
Paramount Pictures

In the decades since Amy Heckerling’s teen comedy masterpiece Clueless hit our screens, we’ve seen Paul Rudd master roles ranging from schlubby suburban dad in a string of Judd Apatow produced comedies to, well, schlubby superhero in the Ant Man series.

Despite the actor’s omnipresence since the mid 2000’s revived his comedy career with a supporting role in The Forty Year Old Virgin, he wasn’t always the first name to call for a likeable romantic lead. When A Night at the Museum was released, Rudd played the eminently hateable replacement dad to Ben Stiller’s slacker hero, a serious reversal of fortunes from his charismatic turn in Clueless.

It’s not that the guy doesn’t have range—although whoever decided on Rudd for the role of Nick Carroway in the 2000 television movie version of The Great Gatsby was way off. But he opted out of frothy comedy a while after Clueless, and it’s a shame that it took a decade for the actor’s talent in the genre to be recognized.

As the archetypical aloof, pretentious nineties poseur, Rudd is disarmingly charming and a funny, believable romantic foil for Alicia Silverstone’s larger-than-life Cher Horowtiz.


4. Robin Williams As Alan Parrish - Jumanji

Jumanji Robin Williams
TriStar Pictures

It’s pretty common knowledge that Robin Williams gave some of his greatest performances when he left the safety of comedy superstardom for the riskier and more rewarding territory of serious drama in the late eighties. From Good Morning Vietnam to Dead Poet’s Society to Good Will Hunting, the funnyman’s later career is filled with dramatic turns that illustrate the diverse range of his talents.

Which makes Jumanji even more worth revisiting. The mid-nineties adventure is primarily a family film and succeeds admirably as a madcap kids flick in its own right thanks to a brilliant turn from Kirsten Dunst and a game villain in the form of Jonathan Hyde.

What is sure to shock you upon a re-watch, however, is the depth of Williams’ performance. The actor has to juggle a lot of tones in a script which switches from him finally escaping a game after decades of isolation, catatonic, to learning of his parents’ death, devastated, to dealing with a pack of marauding zoo animals wreaking havoc on his small hometown immediately afterward.

It’s a funny, sad, and surprisingly human performance given the goofy nature of the material, and Williams gives the potentially lightweight flick real heart in his innocent romance with a traumatised, if gradually won over, childhood sweetheart Bonnie Hunt.


3. John Goodman As Delbert McClintock - Arachnophobia

Arachnophobia Delbert
Buena Vista

Yes, this one is a little more obscure than the mostly starring roles listed here, but it’s also an all-time great John Goodman performance, so pipe down.

Frank Marshall’s 1990 creature feature Arachnophobia is itself a pretty underrated flick, a minor entry into the “monsters terrorize small town” subgenre begun by Jaws and popularized in the eighties by Joe Dante’s Gremlins. With its cast of well-drawn oddballs and local outcasts, Arachnophobia could pass for a Dante film, and it’s mostly down to a stellar turn from comic relief legend Goodman.

As the stoic exterminator Delbert, Goodman wrings countless deadpan laughs out of the film’s premise, whether he’s identifying the structural faults in Bill Pullman’s new home (“Bad wood”), or uncovering the desiccated remains of the spider’s latest kill (“Holy smokes they got the professor!”).

It’s a perfect performance, relying on Goodman’s stellar timing as well as a hilariously out-of-place swanky sitcom theme which follows the character’s every appearance, courtesy of nineties composer du jour Trevor Jones.


2. Winona Ryder As Jo March - Little Women

Christian Bale Winona Ryder Little Women
Columbia Pictures

With Greta Gerwig’s recent reimagining being adored by critics and snubbed by the Academy, it’s worth revisiting the last big screen adaptation of Louisa May Alcott’s classic coming-of-age novel. Starring a typically superb Susan Sarandon and featuring an adorable early performance from Kirsten Dunst, the 1994 film is a warmer and less consciously meta affair than Gerwig’s flick, focusing more on character than (sometimes cringeworthy) attempts at “modernisation” and hamfisted social commentary.

Most important, the film is anchored around a superb central turn from emerging star Winona Ryder. In the hands of the Beeetlejuice star, the character of Jo March isn’t a boorish author obsessed with her sisters and her own genius, but a tough and warm-hearted heroine who is all the more formidable for her vulnerability and indecision. It’s a riskier reading of the character, and her explosive anger at the young Amy would leave audiences struggling to sympathize with a lesser actress.

But Ryder carries Jo with both spirit and fragility, combining sparks of passion with believable insecurity and grounding the nostalgic narrative in recognizable reality for a modern audience.


1. Reese Witherspoon As Anettee Hargrove - Cruel Intentions

Cruel Intentions Reese Witherspoon
Columbia Films

Roger Kumble’s Cruel Intentions is a film that requires, to put it mildly, a little more suspension of disbelief than you might remember. Yes, it’s a sexy, twisty dramedy starring a cast of upper crust NY teens who screw each other over in between bouts of simply screwing each other, but the campy tone is more Gossip Girl than Rules of Attraction, and upon a re-watch there’s an adorable goofiness to how over-the-top the entire enterprise is.

Any teenager who can relate to Sarah Michelle Gellar’s Biblical downfall by the movie’s denouement should probably be in therapy, but the film is nonetheless a fun, silly bit of escapism, and the tone is captured perfectly by then-rising star Reese Witherspoon.

As the very publicly chaste object of Ryan Philippe’s affections, Witherspoon is charming, funny, and just extra enough to convince without jumping into wholesale goofiness (cough Selma Blair cough). It’s a performance which won over Philippe as well as the audience, and the couple’s onscreen chemistry crackles despite the corny and overwrought dialogue they’re burdened with.

The result turns a potentially cringeworthy teen drama into a witty, light-as-a-feather guilty pleasure thanks to a winning central turn from the future megastar.


Contributor

Cathal Gunning hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.