10 Massively Underrated Horror Movies

Let Michael, Jason and Freddy have a night off.

Halloween 3: Season of The Witch
Universal Pictures

Horror is often overlooked at the Academy Awards, but a number of the genre's finest have gotten the plaudits they deserve, with the likes of The Omen, An American Werewolf in London and Rosemary's Baby taking home Oscars.

Other fright fests may not have gongs, or even commercial success, to their names, yet have still managed to attract glowing write-ups and garnered a cult fanbase through word of month alone.

Somewhere in between are the massive horror series which are basically critic-proof. You won't find many Texas Chainsaw Massacre or Halloween sequels that are certified fresh on Rotten Tomatoes, but these franchises still rake in big bucks at the box office and have proven as undying as their masked protagonists.

Michael Myers and Leatherface don't require any additional PR, as their army of fans is almost on par with their kill counts, but there are horror movies out there that both need and deserve some extra fanfare: the underappreciated gems that have done more than enough to earn their chance to scare this Halloween.

Not all of the films on this list made a critical or commercial splash, but in a genre where quality often drowns in quantity, they're worth a look if nightmare-free slumber isn't your thing.

10. House Of The Devil

The House Of The Devil
Dark Sky FIlms

Ti West's House of the Devil works as both a homage to vintage '70s and ‘80s horror, and an unsettling supernatural-slasher hybrid in its own right. The film was shot using 16mm film to give it a stylish, old-school look and is chock full of great scares.

Although the setup is generic, involving a financially struggling college student who takes on an ill-fated babysitting job, the movie shuns gratuitous gore and brash jump-scares in favour of slow-burning suspense and palpable tension.

It's Hitchcockian in its build-up and effortlessly straddles the line between the slasher and haunted house subgenres, while evoking memories of classic films from both.

The characters are complex and their motivations fleshed out, but the vintage cinematography is the star of the show in House of the Devil, making it one hell of a love letter to the glory days of contemporary horror.


9. Eden Lake

Eden Lake Michael Fassbender
Optimum Releasing/The Weinstein Company

Sometimes the most chilling horrors are the most plausible ones, and Eden Lake is the nightmare scenario everyone has contemplated during their most paranoid hours.

This British gem from director James Watkins stars Kelly Reilly and Michael Fassbender as a couple whose romantic getaway is ruined by a gang of knife-packing chavs, who terrorise, stalk and torture them.

There are undertones of Deliverance and Straw Dogs throughout, and its poignant commentary on class prejudice is only becoming more relevant as time goes by.

Eden Lake is unrelenting, and at times downright ugly, but this is everything you want from a horror film, with social commentary thrown in for good measure.


8. Halloween III: The Season Of The Witch

Halloween 3
Universal Pictures

Depending on your point of view, Halloween III is either an insult to one of the most iconic horror series of all time, or its most unique instalment. The film tends to polarise opinion, but most overlook it entirely.

The concept of a Michael Myers-free Halloween was borne out of John Carpenter and Debra Hill's bold ambitions to reshape the successful slasher franchise as an anthology series, focusing on a different scary story each time.

Needless to say, it didn't go down well among hardcore fans, but Halloween III must be judged on its own merits, of which there're many if you give it a chance.

Telling the story of a pagan cult disguised as a toy company and its plan to kill the youth of America with a line of cursed Halloween masks, Tommy Lee Wallace's black sheep of the family is one of the most original horror movies of its generation.

A solid performance from Tom Atkins carries the film and there are some shocking moments in there too, among all of the oddity, such as the relentlessly bleak ending. Don't allow Michael's absence to weight heavy in your mind and you'll be in for a treat, and a few tricks as well.


7. Triangle

Triangle Melissa George
Icon Entertainment

Fear comes in waves in this high seas horror movie. Triangle is a mind-bending experience that twists and turns in every direction throughout.

The setup sees a bunch of friends hit some bad weather during a yachting trip on North Atlantic Ocean, forcing them to take refuge on another boat. It's plain sailing until people start turning up dead, but that's only the beginning.

This swashbuckling fight fest is as weird as it is gripping when the party's doppelgangers start showing up, so much so that repeat viewings of Triangle are advised, purely so you can appreciate some of the film's deepest, darkest intricacies.

The only reason you might not have heard of this one is because it was barely advertised when it came out in 2009. Had it launched to more fanfare, it would probably have raked in enough dough to spawn several inferior sequels by now.


6. A Tale Of Two Sisters

A Tale of Two Sisters
Cineclick Asia

A Tale of Two Sisters never really caught on in the Western world, and that's a real shame because it's Korean horror at its terrifying best.

This film has everything a horror hound could ever ask for: buckets of blood, suspense, a wicked stepmother, supernatural terror and a cupboard scene that will leave you with a permanent phobia of kitchens.

Part family drama, party surrealist nightmare, A Tale of Two Sisters is a twisted version of the Korean fairy tale The Story of Rose and Lotus, but it isn't all horror and trauma. There's some beautiful cinematography in there too, and the transition between light and dark imagery is what the film does best.

A remake of the movie was released in the West in 2009 in the shape of The Uninvited, but this was a pale imitation of the original and a poor advert for the horrors it holds. Stick to the original for a true K-horror experience this Halloween.


5. No Telling

No Telling
Glass Eye Pix

No Telling is a little-known horror from 1991 which plays out like a cross between a Frankenstein derivative and an extended PETA advertisement.

Stephen Ramsey plays a medical researcher who starts kidnapping the local pets to perform experiments on them. His wife is none the wiser and his employer doesn't seem to care so long as the whole thing stays hush hush.

Innocent animals are sown together and resurrected, and while that's horrible enough to spark debate about the ethicality of this type of research, the truly frightening part of No Telling comes from its examination of marriage. This is a chilling look at the dark secrets lurking within relationships that forces the viewer to ask themselves how well they really know their significant other.

No Telling is low-budget horror with originality and substance, punctuated by some skillful cinematography and pointed visual metaphors.


4. The Funhouse

The Funhouse
Universal Pictures

The Funhouse was the first major studio effort from Texas Chainsaw mastermind Tobe Hooper, a slasher movie with enough suspense, jump-scares and chills to rival anything the Friday the 13th series has ever produced.

Unlike Jason Voorhees and his mother, Funhouse failed to spawn a mega franchise, but that's no indication of its quality. This was a victim of the genre's over-saturation during the early 1980s, and being unfairly pegged as a 'video nasty' in the UK didn't much to help its cause.

Hooper's take on teenage slaughter was every inch a vintage slasher, but it was a cut above most of its genre counterparts thanks to its creative practical effects from Craig Reardon - the man behind Sloth from The Goonies - and its commentary on societal outcasts.

Don't let the fact it wasn't followed by the obligatory seven sequels fool you, Funhouse is a hack and slashathon that shouldn't be overlooked.


3. Slither

Slither Michael Rooker
Universal Pictures

Long before James Gunn landed a big-money Marvel contract and scored critical and commercial success with Guardians of the Galaxy, he made a little-known sci-fi-horror called Slither, and it bombed.

As is the case with many films on this list, that says nothing about its watchability. With Slither, Gunn delivered a tongue-in-cheek pastiche of at least a dozen '80s horror films and turned so many stomachs in the process.

The film is set small American town in the wake of a meteor strike, an event that turns the place into a hell of parasitic alien worms and transforms one of its residents into a tentacled, slug-like monster.

Slither is essential B-movie stuff, paying effective homage to The Thing, The Blog, Shivers and Night of the Creeps. It celebrates everything that made these movies great, and has more than a few disgusting tricks of its own up its sleeve.


2. The Exorcist III

The Exorcist III
Fox

The Exorcist is the fourth-highest grossing horror movie of all time, but none of its sequels have ever come close to equalling its acclaim, notoriety or box office feats. One almost matched its chills and sheer quality, though.

Directed by William Peter Blatty, who wrote the books the original film and its second sequel were based on, The Exorcist III follows the philosophical police lieutenant William F. Kinderman from the first movie as he investigates a series of murders that appear to have a Satanic motive behind them.

Father Karras from the original also returns, albeit from beyond the grave with the spirit of a deceased serial killer in control of his body and mind.

Exorcist III is a different animal to the first film, at times channelling the sheer terror and thought-provoking depth of its classic predecessor, while at others going for laughs with successful black humour or spacing the audience out with David Lynch-esque weirdness.

Blatty's director's cut was butchered by the studio and only pieced together and released for the first time last year, but even in its heavily altered cinematic form, the Exorcist III was never anything less than a worthy sequel.


1. Hush

Hush film
Blumhouse

Blumhouse is an endless production line of horror, and every once in a while, a real gem quietly drops off it, sandwiched between the noise and hype of the latest Paranormal Activity and Purge instalments.

This was the case when Hush made its debut on Netflix, creeping onto the streaming service and unexpectedly establishing itself as one of its top rated horror movies.

Hush is a good old-fashioned horror-thriller which follows a deaf mute woman as she's stalked by a masked man at her secluded home, and she quickly learns than his only motivation is to kill her for entertainment.

There's little dialogue in the film, but director Mike Flanagan bombards the audience with audio stimuli and ambient sounds, and cranks up the suspense in all kinds of creative ways. Hush somehow succeeds in being both a homage to silent movies and a terrifying work of sonic art.


In this post: 
Halloween
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Been prattling on about gaming, movies, TV, football and technology across the web for as long as I can remember. Find me on Twitter @MarkLangshaw