10 More Movies That Killed Completely The Wrong Character

Death is part of life. It just did not have to come so soon for these characters.

Star Wars The Last Jedi Trailer Luke Skywalker
Lucasfilm

Unfortunately, few things sell drama in movies quite like death and the threat of it. There is nothing quite like sitting through a film and drinking in the entire experience only to lead with huge pangs of sadness after one of your favourite characters meets a grim end. Sometimes, of course, their send-offs are warranted to help move the story along but, with others, there can be suspicions that the trigger was pulled for the sake of some easy impact.

But, like it or not, death is a certainty in the movie business. The one small mercy is usually the fact that the best and most important characters are protected by thick plot armour. They might appear to be in danger, but they'll usually come through fine in the end.

Usually, but not always.

Sadly, movies do still kill off characters who shouldn't have met their end. And in some cases, you literally could reel off a huge number of other who should have been written out of the script instead. Life just isn't that fair, though.

Sure, it's an easy way to get people talking about your film franchise, and indeed to sell the idea that EVERYONE can be under threat, but that doesn't mean it isn't heartbreaking...

10. Lenore Mills: Taken 3

Lenore Mills Taken 3
Fox

The Death: Liam Neeson’s ex-wife Lenore is murdered just as it looks as if whatever they had back in the 1990s was about to be rekindled. It’s a cruel blow given the circumstances - yet nobody really gives it a second thought. This was a character who, after two films, the audience did not know that well while her daughter, on the other hand, was more of a familiar face.

Who Should Have Died Instead: Kim Mills

The first Taken film was good, the second predictable and the third just entirely unnecessary.

And speaking of unnecessary, Lenore's death really is. She is the mother of Neeson’s daughter who has already been through the ringer at this point having been kidnapped and ultimately rescued twice before. Therefore, she's nothing more than a side character, despite making two previous cameos prior the finale.

Neeson's daughter and Maggie Grace’s character Kim is kidnapped twice before the third instalment and the fact that she is the most precious thing in Neeson’s world means her death would have been entirely justifiable. However, potentially aware that her demise would probably turn Mills into a non-functioning mess, the script-writers chose to give Lenore the chop instead - paving the way for a drab, pointless movie in the process.


9. Luke Skywalker: The Last Jedi

Mark Hamill As Luke Skywalker In The Last Jedi
Lucasfilm

The Death: Luke Skywalker perishes after fooling Kylo (and cinema-goers) by transmitting an image of himself across the galaxy with his body vanishing in a similar fashion to that of Obi-Wan Kenobi’s back in A New Hope, allowing the Resistance to escape the clutches of the First Order in the process.

Who Should Have Died Instead: General Leia Organa

Fans had extremely high expectations when it came to seeing Luke in Star Wars: The Last Jedi. People had waited two years to await the outcome of his meeting with Rey, what his reaction would be to seeing his old lightsaber and how he would plot to overthrow the villainous Kylo Ren and his First Order army.

If you had said before the movie that you would see Mark Hamill’s character train Rey, interact with Yoda, face down the First Order and Kylo Ren with his trademark blue lightsaber in his hand and have one final, emotional conversation with sister Leia then fans would have snapped your arm off. Hell yeah, who doesn’t want to see that?

Yet the Last Jedi’s adventurous nature appears to have been its undoing with Star Wars fans young and old having mixed feelings about Rian Johnson’s work. And the sight of Luke dying had many up in arms - particularly as it was not the ending many envisaged for the hero of the Original trilogy and, arguably, face of the entire saga.

Star Wars missed a trick with Hamill still capable of doing a third film while Carrie Fisher, who plays Leia, having passed away in December 2016. It would have made more sense to give Fisher and Leia the send-off she deserves rather than kill off Luke.


8. Budlofsky: Pineapple Express

Budlofsky Pineapple Express
Columbia Pictures

The Death: Unfortunately for Budlofsky he never makes a meal he spends the entire film promising his dearly beloved. Craig Robinson's Matheson guns him down as he shows a minute’s mercy to Franco’s Saul towards the film’s finale, with Matheson then in turn biting the dust after McBride’s Red comes speeding along to not only mow him down, but shoot his foot off.

Who Should Have Died Instead: Red

Pineapple Express has many memorable characters. There’s Seth Rogen as the ditzy Dale Denton, James Franco as the spaced-out Saul and Brian McBride’s brilliant Red, not to mention Craig Robinson’s Matheson and Gary Cole’s villainous Ted. For a stoner film, the cast of this 2008 film is seriously packing and it delivers with laughs aplenty for its entire two-hour run time.

As a result, Budlofsky goes seriously under the radar. Kevin Corrigan’s character appears unwilling to be dragged into Ted’s crazy schemes, preferring the finer things in life instead - such as dinner with his wife. Forget the drugs, guns and madness that unfolds, this man just wants some steak - and who can blame him?

Red, contrastingly, is a dead man walking throughout the majority of the movie. McBride's man survives a bong to the head, being shot, being caught up in a huge explosion and yet somehow is still alive at the end of the film, where he sits down with Denton and Saul in a cosy American diner.

Now, comedy movies don't necessarily need to be realistic but there's no way Red, who was also at one point taped to a wheelchair and left to bleed out, would survive.


7. Uncle Monty: A Series Of Unfortunate Events

A Series of Unfortunate Events
Paramount

The Death: Uncle Monty welcomes the unfortunate Baudelaire family into his home after their mistreatment at the hands of the villainous Count Olaf. However, posing as reptile expert Stefano, Olaf gets his revenge on the kids by killing their Uncle and attempting to blame it on one of the friendliest snakes known to mankind - The Incredible Deadly Viper.

Who Should Have Died Instead: Count Olaf

Uncle Monty is just so nice. The 2004 version of the books by Lemony Snicket puts Billy Connolly in the role as Montgomery Montgomery who proves to be everything the children did not have under Olaf: caring, sweet, kind and, above all, willing to put them first.

The film does a splendid job hitting you hard with Monty’s death. And you feel genuine sadness and devastation when Olaf ends up surviving and, worst of all, getting away with the murder of one of the film’s most popular and likeable characters. His attempts to blame it on the Viper fail to pay dividends and when he is rumbled, he flees off into the night and manages to evade capture, leading him to terrorise the children for one more act of the movie and 11 more books in total.

It would have been perfect to imagine the children living happily with Uncle Monty, who planned to take them on an incredible trip to Peru. Olaf’s schemes and villainy, coupled with Jim Carey’s good albeit slightly irritating portrayal, meant is it a downright injustice that his vile character was allowed to live on.


6. Patches O’Houlihan: Dodgeball

Dodgeball Rip Torn
20th Century Fox

The Death: Patches O’Houlihan spends plenty of his time in Dodgeball teaching the inept members of Average Joe’s gym how to play the game. Dip, dive, dodge, duck and…dodge again. It’s ironic because for all his insistence you should always see something coming, he is never able to predict that a falling sign would cut an end to his time as teacher, leaving Vince Vaughn to emerge as Average Joe’s talismanic figure for the rest of the film.

Who Should Have Died Instead: Justin

Dodgeball came out 14 years ago but still Patches is revered as one of the best characters introduced in the film. Whether it is lines such as ‘Why do I drink my urine? It’s sterile and I like the taste’ and ‘You’re about as useful as a c*ck-flavoured lollipop’ only serve to increase his popularity and make audiences genuinely fond of his character.

Patches bites the bullet and, though Dodgeball continues to be funny after his accident, it isn’t quite the same. Vaughn’s character leads the team in battle against Ben Stiller’s Globogym but is unable to rival Patches when it comes to the comedy stakes, with Rip Torn thriving in the role of the wrench-throwing maniac.

It begs the question. Why couldn't Justin Long's character Justin have gone instead? The teenager spends the majority of the film being pushed around, chasing after a girl well out of his league and dropping chubby cheerleaders right on his face. Right before the team's semi-final clash, he abandons his team at the crucial moment. And, for that reason, he deserved a big sign saying the words 'luck of the Irish' to fall right on his head.

In a comedy movie, you've got to be funny. And Justin just isn't. He's mopy, petulant and scared at anything, by far the least funny character in the entire film and the fact he gets a happy end, while Patches doesn't, just simply isn't fair.


5. Bodhi: Point Break

Point Break Patrick Swayze
20th Century Fox

The Death: Point Break ends with Bodhi drowning at sea after Agent Utah allows him one last surf. The success of the film meant there was easily grounds for a sequel and, although Patrick Swayze’s character gets the send-off he himself wanted, his death ended any chances of a second instalment.

It would have been perfect had another film been made that consisted of Keanu Reeves' Jonny Utah chasing Bodhi across South America before, finally, catching the fugitive, rather than providing a death scene that, though satisfying, felt rather rushed and thrown in.

Who Should Have Died Instead: Agent Jonny Utah

The 1990s was the era that saw action movies literally scale new heights. Speed came…speeding along, Die Hard 2 and 3 had people using their landline to express their excitement to one another and the Matrix had people’s heads, and later bodies, doing flips out of sheer wonderment.

However, Point Break is arguably the best of the lot. Reeves’ Utah goes undercover as a surfer to infiltrate a rogue group led by Swayze’s Bodhi, whose thirst for all things crazy sees them robbing banks, jumping out of planes and throwing dogs at anybody who dares get in their way.

But the brutal fact is that Utah lacks the charm and charisma to carry this film - whereas Bodhi has it in abundance. Reeves does a good job at playing the FBI rookie but his character does not have the complexity as the individual he's trying to arrest.

Swayze's character steals every single scene he’s in, with his unpredictability making him an intriguing individual whose mind and next decision is always hard to read and determine. Psychopaths are usually hard to read and this surfer come bank robber-cum-adrenaline junkie is no exception, keeping those watching on the edge of their seats. His demise was a huge mistake and maybe Utah should have drowned at sea instead.


4. Captain Barbossa: Pirates Of The Caribbean: Curse Of The Black Pearl

Barbossa Geoffrey Rush
Disney

The Death: The first Pirates of the Caribbean is still, to this day, regarded as the best in the franchise. What follows next, however, experiences varying levels of success.

Hector Barbossa dies at the end of the first film, taking a bullet to the heart after Jack Sparrow, Will Turner and Elizabeth Swann all succeed in lifting the curse that has seen members of the Black Pearl consigned to a lifetime of immortality and Barbossa’s involvement appears over when Jack shoots him at point-blank range.

Who should have died instead? Jack Sparrow

Curse of the Black Pearl sees Captain Jack at his swashbuckling best, Will and Elizabeth established as far more entertaining than your standard run of the mill movie couple and Barbossa blossoms in the role as antagonist, with his Black Pearl crew giving young children at times nightmares and even sending shivers down the spines of seasoned moviegoers worldwide.

And then comes the sequel, and the bizarre decision to resurrect Geoffrey Rush’s character. First of all, bringing back a character an audience has already seen die stinks of panic. Secondly, you really want the audience to believe that Barbossa would want Jack, already back again? Because if the answer to that question is no, then he's really not alone.

Jonny Depp's Jack is the undisputed star of the first movie and face of the entire franchise. However, he has only been legitimately funny in just one movie - the first one. He seems to get steadily less amusing with each film, with the second film bringing smiles and nothing more, the third seeing audiences sighing and the fourth and fifth having viewers tearing their hair out.

Disney rely on Jack to sell the movies because people still hold hope that the swashbuckling Captain Jack will return even if all the signs point to that never happening. Sparrow's ship has sailed.


3. Luke: The Place Beyond The Pines

The Place Beyond The Pines Ryan Gosling
Focus Features

The Death: The Place Beyond the Pines really is glorious cinema - for a whole 40 minutes. Then, Bradley Cooper's character Avery comes in and shoots our protagonist, Ryan Gosling's Luke, dead.

The rest of the film shows Cooper, boring and not-as-exciting as Gosling’s Luke, struggling to come to terms with what he did and ends with the two character’s children feuding and fighting. Luke’s death, however, stops this film upgrading from good to great.

Who should have died instead? Avery

When The Place Beyond the Pines hit cinema screens in 2013, people thought they knew what they were getting themselves in for. The trailers suggested that Gosling’s character would pursue a career in bank robbing to help fund his son’s future while Cooper’s NYPD officer Avery tried to track him down and reel him in.

Except, that is not the entire film. Instead, it is merely the first act. Luke does rob banks, forging a productive working partnership with Ben Mendelson’s Robin - and together they make quite a pair. The money rolls in, plenty of beer gets drank and many cigarettes are puffed on throughout the film’s opening scenes as they revel in their success and plot more ways to ensure the money continues to roll in. And then Cooper's increasing prominence sees the film fall.

Gosling is terrific as Luke, whose silent and staring demeanour is not too dissimilar to the character he played in Drive, which was released two years previously. Cooper, contrastingly, is a dud. He starts the movie as a rookie cop and his involvement in Luke's death hinders him.

For the rest of the film he spends his time regretting his actions but audiences find it hard to sympathise given Gosling was the best thing about the entire thing, while Avery's later treatment of his son ends any hope of people seeing the world through his eyes. Cooper is a great actor but his character was BORING.


2. Harry Osborn: Spider-Man 3

Harry Osborn Spider-Man 3
Sony

The Death: Harry Osborn’s contribution to Sam Raimi’s old-school Spider-Man trilogy ends when he sacrifices himself for the web slinger. The New Goblin puts himself between Peter Parker and Venom, taking a spear through the midriff from his own glider as a result.

Who Should Have Died Instead: Spider-Man

By the time the end credits roll, Spider-Man is done. He really is. The third film provides a bittersweet conclusion to a bittersweet trilogy and audiences leave the cinema screen already knowing that Parker will spend the next film battling the same old problems: making time for Mary Jane, juggling his job as Spider-Man and his one with the Daily Bugle and spending the majority of his time on screen acting the dork.

In killing off Harry, Sony got rid of the one character who could have returned for a fourth film with a plot to build around. Venom is too rushed to be memorable and the decision to make Sandman Uncle Ben’s killer was just WRONG while Harry, as the Goblin, could have returned as an antagonist even if he does decide to help Peter take down the two aforementioned bad guys in order to save Mary Jane.

James Franco’s character does not get the fitting finale he deserved. Prior to the film, many were expecting him to make a real fist of being the Green Goblin, following in the footsteps of his father. However, script writers instead decided to make Franco spend the majority of the film suffering from amnesia and when his memory returns, the film takes a notable turn for the better with Harry and Peter’s scenes together one of the few highlights from the entire movie.

Spider-Man has no real purpose after this. He has no best friend, there’s no super bad guys to fight and his relationship with Mary Jane was, finally, back on track. Giving him a huge death would have been one of the biggest moments in cinema history but instead they bottled it.


1. Darth Maul: The Phantom Menace

Darth Maul Star Wars
Disney

The Death: Unfortunately, George Lucas messed it his Star Wars prequel trilogy up. Darth Maul gets the chop (literally) with Obi-Wan slicing him in half and, with it, leaving the saga a mountain to climb. Count Dooku came in next but his character was drab and dreary compared to Maul who, without doubt, should have been used right up until Anakin Skywalker’s transformation into Darth Vader. A huge case of what might have been - even if he was later brought back from the dead via the Clone Wars and Rebels TV series.

Who Should Have Died Instead: Jar Jar Binks, Boss Nass, take your pick

There can be no denying the 1998’s The Phantom Menace lacks the sparkle of its original predecessors and brought in pointless characters in the form of Jar Jar Binks, Qui-Gon Jinn and Boss Nass. Maul, though, was a rare success with the character instantly seeing Lucasfilm's merchandise profits soar and, prior to the film's release, was being tipped to go down in Star Wars folklore as a character capable of rivalling Darth Vader for baddie of the series.

It speaks volumes of Maul’s popularity that a character who speaks just 31 words throughout the entire film is held in such high regard by even the snobbiest of Star Wars fans. Forget the fact he only features in a handful of scenes, his memorable red and black face paint lingers in the memory and his double-bladed lightsaber makes him one of the most formidable sword fighters of all time. The same cannot be said for the likes of Jar Jar and Boss Nass.

These characters are two of the worst EVER TO BE PUT ON A CINEMA screen. Jar Jar is sheer annoying with Lucas horrifically misjudging the character who he thought would have the same loveable charm as the Ewoks from Return of the Jedi, while Boss Nass was so pointless it is a miracle no investigation has ever been launched to get to the point of what purpose his character actually served. Maul deserved better.


Contributor

Sport and Film. I love them both. And I'm extremely lucky to write about two of my biggest passions in life. Most of the time, I'm at the Daily Express newspaper writing about football, tennis and F1. But, when I'm out of there, I let my imagination run wild and pen down my thoughts on the film series' I love. WhatCulture gives me the chance to write about the movie industry - an industry I really care about. And for that, I'm extremely grateful. And hope you, if you're reading this, enjoy what I think about stuff.