10 Most Controversial Directors Of All Time

quentintarantino Controversy has always existed in cinema. Perhaps the first controversial film was DW Griffith's The Birth of a Nation from 1915 which glorified the Ku Klux Klan and was a hateful, racist piece of work. Controversy can come to directors by accident if a film is greatly misunderstood or because of the political climate at the time of contemporary release, only to recover its reputation later. Many films are also deliberately provocative, often either in a way to express a political point or in a self-indulgent way that is far too common. Some directors have made a career out of controversy and have themselves become more individually famous than their films. A way to establish a reputation and to get noticed in the film industry is by being controversial and it worked for numerous directors all over the globe. Controversy can be a good and a bad thing. It can help a film that is innocent and misunderstood reach an audience it might not have done without all the media attention, but can also be a tool for attention-seeking directors to elevate their nonsense to a larger audience.

10. Harmony Korine

harmony korineMost Controversial Film: Kids (as a writer) Harmony Korine rose to infamy quicker than most. At age 18, he wrote Kids which was directed by Larry Clark (more on him later) and the result was a horrible and problematic piece of cinema, but nonetheless, Korine's star was shining, mainly because of his age. Kids' depiction of rape and underage sexual activity bordered on the pornographic and it feels as if it was written by a jumped up teenager, which it obviously was. Because of the nature of Kids, all eyes were on Korine's career, which so far has been littered with narcissistic, self-indulgent trash and it is his writing that has generated the most controversy and attention around him. His most recent and biggest commercial success thus far is Spring Breakers, which features a handful of attractive, young women spending 90 minutes wearing nothing but bikinis. Korine overtly sexualises the women and has his camera leer at them gratuitously. Korine's career has been funded by controversy and his tiresome avant-garde efforts are so incredibly desperate for attention, but he's not even good enough to create a public outcry anymore. His most controversial works were as a writer in Kids and Ken Park, and a personal feeling is that he hopes one of his films reaches those levels of notoriety again. Korine also once attempted to steal from Meryl Streep and was subsequently banned from David Letterman's show.

9. Bernardo Bertolucci

bernardobertolucciMost Controversial Film: Last Tango in Paris Much of the controversy that surrounds the famed Italian director comes from one movie alone - Last Tango in Paris. The film, infamously features a graphic sex scene that features anal sex and various foods. Aside from the lengthy and extremely explicit scene that had Conservative commentators up in arms, a great amount of controversy resides over Bertolucci's treatment of star Maria Schneider. Schneider believed she was sexually humiliated on set and that Bertolucci exploited her greatly, not telling her about the graphic sex scene in detail beforehand. Marlon Brando also felt exploited by Bertolucci and refused to speak to him for 15 years. Schneider's belief that she was violated and her recent death have led the controversy surrounding the film and the director to live on more emphatically than most. The director in February of this year said that he felt guilty for treating Schneider the way he did, solidifying all of the criticism, protest and controversy that has never gone away.

8. Larry Clark

522399-larry-clarkMost Controversial Film: Kids One of the most exploitative directors of modern times, Larry Clark is a man who seems to get off on inserting young people, and by young I mean underage, into provocative situations that are often sexual. His 1995 debut written by the aforementioned Harmony Korine features adolescents in situations such as rape, underage sexual activity, drug abuse and every other gaudy scenario you can dream of. Misogyny is rife within the film, but it's not an exploration of misogynism, it's just there because the writer and director seem to have a particularly awful view of women. Clark enjoys the controversy his films receive and in response, he makes each film more sexually explicit and outrageous than the last. Clark's films are borderline child pornography as he fetishises his characters to the point of nausea. Distributors now tend to stay as far away from his films as possible, realising that he just brings too much hassle and that the potential profit isn't large enough.

7. Gaspar Noe

irreMost Controversial Film: Irreversible A provocative filmmaker by nature, Gaspar Noe is fast becoming one of the most unique auteurs in cinema. He shot to worldwide attention with his 2003 film, Irreversible, a picture most famous for its unbroken rape scene that lasts nearly 10 minutes. There were reports of people passing out whilst watching Irreversible, it is that distressing. It's an intense experience unlike any other and that lengthy rape scene is unbearable to most of the audience. Charges of homophobia were also issued against the film as the rapist is found to be a gay man. Gaspar Noe countered these claims by saying that he is featured in the gay club scene masturbating to show he is not above homosexuals. Noe's dream project Enter the Void was also the subject of controversy, as it shared the same extreme aesthetic of Irreversible. We are greeted with countless shots of nudity and graphic sex, much of it alongside the theme of incest. Noe is a modern-day provocateur who treads the line between art and exploitation very carefully, and he will continue to make controversial movies for many years.

6. Quentin Tarantino

Quentin TarantinoMost Controversial Film: Django Unchained Quite possibly the most famous and recognisable director in the world, Quentin Tarantino has an ardent fanbase that will defend him unquestionably at every turn, no matter how many 'N' words he throws in his films. Tarantino's obsession with that particular word has always been alarming, right from his debut with Reservoir Dogs to his most recent picture, Django Unchained, which is set during the Civil War era. Django Unchained is essentially a white man's fantasy and a really problematic movie for a number of reasons. The grotesque and gratuitous violence of the film is also completely unnecessary and self-indulgent. Violence in cinema is not a problem, but gratuitous, meaningless violence is and Django Unchained is sadly full of it as it ignores saying anything interesting. Slavery was not a B-movie western, Quentin, it was one of the darkest times in American history and doesn't need trivialised.

5. Oliver Stone

359090_NpAdvHoverMost Controversial Film: Natural Born Killers Oliver Stone made his name in cinema by being outlandish, daring and controversial and creating vivid and aggressive pieces such as Scarface and Platoon. Stone didn't really gain significant controversy until the 90's with the release of JFK which was released to a storm of media attention surrounding the factual accuracies of the film and the implication that Lyndon Johnson was involved in a conspiracy to assassinate Kennedy. Despite the controversy that overwhelmed the film, it became a phenomenal critical success and received 8 Academy Award nomination. Stone didn't become fully embroiled in controversy until 1994's Natural Born Killers, Stone's visceral and frenzied Bonnie and Clyde like tale that was also a slamming indictment of the MTV generation, America's bloodlust and the media fascination with monstrous killers. Natural Born Killers had several battles with censorship and has faced several accusations of inspiring copycat crimes. Most notably, the film has been linked to the Columbine High School Massacre as the perpetrators of that vile act were known to be fanatical about the film. Stone has also received much controversy more recently for his documentary work which much of the anti-socialist media of America has condemned. His films, South of the Border and Commandante, both explore the new wave of socialism that has spread over South America, which obviously if you know anything about American politics, you'll understand why they have received a controversial reception in the States. Stone is a single-minded director who is not afraid of dealing with controversy and he seems to get a kick out of it.

4. Lars Von Trier

larsMost Controversial Film: Antichrist Like Oliver Stone, Lars Von Trier appears to be a man that loves a bit of controversy. It gets people to see his movies and keeps the attention on him. It's not just movies such as The Idiots, Antichrist and Breaking the Waves that have given Von Trier an infamous reputation, it's his stupid and attention-seeking comments such as those at the 2011 Cannes Film Festival where joked he was a Nazi. Judging the director on his work alone and it's clear why such a controversial aura around him exists. The Idiots is a nasty piece of work and also features scenes of unsimulated sex in what is a wholly awful film. Film critic, Mark Kermode, hated it so much he swore at the screen in bad French during the film's premiere at the Cannes Film Festival. Antichrist is the film which courted the most controversy for the Danish director is Antichrist, another explicitly sexual film with dubious moral values. Opinions on the film are fiercely divided and the grotesque scenes of self-harm, most notably when Charlotte Gainsbourg's character cuts off her own clitoris with a pair of scissors. Von Trier's relationship with women is incredibly suspect and he and his films have displayed misogyny on numerous occasions, most obviously in Antichrist. With his new film, Nymphomaniac, set to feature large amounts of unsimulated sex, it doesn't seem as if Von Trier is going to shrug off the controversial label any time soon.

3. Pier Paolo Pasolini

pier-paolo-pasoliniMost Controversial Film: Salo, or the 120 Days of Sodom Long before his final film, Salo, or the 120 Days of Sodom was in production, Pier Paolo Pasolini was a highly controversial figure as he was noted for being both a communist and homosexual, two things frowned upon now, let alone in post-war Italy that was still highly fascist. Censorship had always been an enemy of Pasolini as his films featured characters that were pimps and prostitutes and portrayed a grim view of reality. From his poetic debut, Accattone to his infamous final masterpiece, Salo, or the 129 Days of Salem, Pasolini fought for his artistic integrity and in many ways, his life mirrors that of the pimp from Accattone. Pasolini really reached another level of controversy with Salo which was released shortly after his tragic murder at the young age of 53. Salo features scenes of horrific violence in the most explicit manner, but beneath the brutality of the piece is a scathing attack on fascism and corrupt politicians. The film, set in 1943, after the fall of Mussolini's fascist rule focuses on four men of power as they kidnap 9 teenage girls and 9 teenage boys and subject them to months of intense torture and sadistic humiliation. It's a powerful piece of genius that is often misunderstood, but it's clear to see why it has become so infamous and controversial. The scenes of torture are unrelenting and take a lot of will to stomach. In a poetic way, the fierce, angry and personal Salo was a perfect way to conclude a majestic and very controversial career.

2. Stanley Kubrick

stanley-kubrickMost Controversial Film: A Clockwork Orange Stanley Kubrick attracted controversy in a variety of ways. Most famously through his masterpiece, A Clockwork Orange, but claims that he was anti-American, a demanding tyrant on set (he particularly drove Jack Nicholson and Shelley Duvall mad on the set of The Shining) and his reclusive nature made him one of the most talked about directors of the last century. A Clockwork Orange became so controversial that in an unprecedented move, Kubrick himself banned it, and that ban lasted up until his death in 1999. Threats were sent to him and his family so he decided it wasn't worth it and convinced Warner Bros to stop distributing the film in the UK. One art house cinema that played the film in 1993 was shut down permanently. A Clockwork Orange after all this time is still a shocking work, and not just for the rape scenes either. It's violence is brutal and the constant erotic imagery is also unsettling. A Clockwork Orange wasn't the only Kubrick picture to receive controversy, Dr. Strangelove with its satirical portrayal of the Cold War was greeted with some skepticism and its release date was pushed back because of JFK's assassination. Kubrick personally received a lot of heat for his actions on the set of The Shining for his perfectionist nature that aggravated stars Jack Nicholson and Shelley Duvall, who became severely ill after the stress of working with the famed director. As Kubrick's actions over A Clockwork Orange prove, he wanted to avoid controversy, but that just wasn't possible as his films were hyped massively prior to release and his constant dabbling in demanding material meant his films were always meticulously analysed and scanned for controversial elements.

1. Sam Peckinpah

00846Most Controversial Film: Straw Dogs Sam Peckinpah courted controversy his whole life as the legendary director is infamous for his volatile temper and alcohol abuse. Peckinpah was a renegade who made movies on his own terms and the results often shocked people as his films featured a level of violence that was uncommon at that time. Peckinpah is most renowned for his western masterpiece, The Wild Bunch, but his most controversial work is Straw Dogs, which was catastrophically remade a few years back. Straw Dogs is a ferocious and tough film and a piece of genius that was overshadowed by the outcry over the much debated rape scene. Peckinpah received accusations that the film was misogynist, sadistic and a fascist celebration of violence. In this writer's view, it is a grueling exploration of the psychology of violence but the controversy has never subsided since the film's release in 1971. Because of Peckinpah's persona, he attracted much more controversy than he perhaps deserved. His films were all about men and featured high levels of violence that repulsed much of right-wing America and Straw Dogs was only released unedited in the UK in 2002 after years and years of debate. Peckinpah was the catalyst for cult films and is rightly regarded as one of the finest American directors of all time, but also the most controversial as his abrasive personality mixed with difficult subject matter made him perfect for an assault from the censors and media.

Contributor
Contributor

Articles published under the WhatCulture name denote collective efforts of a number of our writers, both past and present.