10 Most Nonsensical Plot Holes In The MCU
They’re called plot holes because you have to make a massive leap to get past them...
The Marvel Cinematic Universe is notorious for studio micromanagement: every facet of every movie is pored over and approved by the powers that be, including super-producer Kevin Feige, who usually represents the final word on most subjects.
Given that this is the case, it remains surprising that so many plot holes continue to slip through the net. That may be a function of the complexity of the universe, of course - over the last thirteen years we’ve had two dozen movies and a growing number of television shows, all of which share the same world and the same narrative continuity.
Now, for the contrarians amongst you, let’s establish a few ground rules. Plot holes are defined as inconsistencies that fly in the face of the story being told. Plot holes could include incidents that don’t follow on from one another (“a minute ago he couldn’t walk, now he’s climbing up drainpipes?”); gaps in internal logic (“but they literally just said that her powers don’t work that way!”) ; or even gaps in ordinary logic (“okay, he’s a smart dog, but he still can’t operate an iPhone”).
Of course, if you look hard enough or for long enough you can find inconsistencies in any movie. However, a real plot hole is one which is so nonsensical that it affects your suspension of disbelief, taking you out of the story (even if only for a few moments)...
10. Just How Many Stones Does Thanos Have Before Infinity War?
In The Avengers, set in 2012, Thanos sends Loki to obtain the Tesseract (containing the Space Stone) and subjugate Earth, giving him the Sceptre (containing the Mind Stone) and a Chitauri army to help accomplish this task.
There’s a lot of lazy writing going on in The Avengers - for example, it’s never explained how, when S.H.I.E.L.D. fiddles with the Tesseract and opens a random wormhole, Loki is at the other end. It’s also never made clear why Thanos gives Loki - a newcomer to his forces with a reputation for untrustworthiness - the only Infinity Stone he’s managed to obtain so far.
However, although plot holes are always due to lazy writing, lazy writing isn’t always a plot hole - so let’s look at the Thanos we meet in act two of Avengers: Endgame, during the Time Heist. Because the plot mechanic is time travel, the movie establishes that it’s 2014, the time period of the events of the first Guardians Of The Galaxy movie. The Infinity Stone being sought by his forces on the planet Morag is the Power Stone, just as it was at the beginning of that film.
So why do Gamorra and Nebula, in discussing their father’s plans, make it very clear that this is the first Infinity Stone Thanos has managed to find?
Nebula: “Father’s plan is finally in motion.”
Gamora: “One stone isn’t six.”
Nebula: “It’s a start. If he gets them all...”
Remember, this isn’t an alternate universe, it’s a single, coherent timeline, two years after The Battle Of New York. By 2014, he should have already found the Mind Stone and the Space Stone - he knows they’re on Earth, at the very least - so this should be the third Infinity Stone he’s found.
By this point, Thanos is only a couple of smash n’ grab raids away from being halfway to his genocidal objective. His plan has been in motion for years.
9. Why Does Hydra Think Stephen Strange Is A Threat?
Formerly a death cult that evolved into the science division of the SS, Hydra was thought dormant after the disappearance of the Red Skull in 1945. However, the MCU’s equivalent of the real-life Operation Paperclip (in which the US co-opted the scientific minds of the Third Reich after World War II) saw the Red Skull’s former deputy Arnim Zola rebuild Hydra inside the newly-created S.H.I.E.L.D.
In Captain America: The Winter Soldier, like a parasite growing within its host, the fascist collective bursts out of S.H.I.E.L.D. as a fully formed terrorist paramilitary organisation. The plan, based on Zola’s own algorithm, involves using S.H.I.E.L.D.'s Project Insight (a network of satellites linked to three heavily armed Helicarriers) to target Hydra’s enemies.
Zola’s algorithm identified current enemies of Hydra and predicted potential future enemies of Hydra, based on an analysis of public data found online and private data within financial and medical records, voting patterns, emails and phone conversations.
So why on earth did it identify Stephen Strange as a possible threat? This is 2014: he’s two years away from the accident that cost him his neurosurgery career, and three years away from becoming Sorcerer Supreme.
True, he’s a prodigy… but a targeted bombing campaign against a sarcastic narcissist with nimble fingers and an interest in neurogenesis seems like overkill.
8. Rhodey And The Magic Battlesuit
In Avengers: Endgame, Thanos’ missiles destroy the Avengers' base and Rocket, War Machine and Hulk are buried together, only Hulk’s raw power preventing a whole huge section of the building from collapsing on them. Jim Rhodes - a paraplegic who relies on technology to move below the waist - is trapped inside the non-functional War Machine armour.
Desperately calling out the emergency command (“canopy! canopy!”) , his armour opens like a hi-tech mummy’s tomb, freeing him to crawl to Rocket and lever him out of the wreckage. However, water is cascading in, and Hulk can't hold the building up forever.
When we next cut to them, Rhodes, Hulk and Rocket are trapped between the rubble and the rapidly rising water, with only inches to go. Rhodes' armour is long gone. Busted anyway, it's now exposed and under at least twelve feet of water. With no help coming, he resigns himself to his fate and says goodbye to his buddy.
Just as all hope seems lost, all of the restored heroes arrive to face off against Thanos and his army - and as Ant-Man rescues his trapped friends, powering up to Giant-Man size to bust them all out, emerging from his opening hand we see Hulk, Rocket and... hang on, is that War Machine?
What happened to his armour being futzed? How did he reclaim it from under tons of rushing, rising water with no legs and no assistance? This isn’t Stark’s nanotechnology: the War Machine armour is a good old-fashioned clunky mech-suit.
It wouldn't matter so much if their jeopardy hadn't been created by Rhodes being forced to abandon his broken-down armour: as War Machine, he could have freed Rocket and himself in seconds and left Hulk to smash his way out...
7. When Exactly Did Thor Inspire Legends?
The idea behind the Asgardians referring to themselves as ‘gods’ stems from their visits to Earth, or Midgard, sometime between the later post-classical period to the Middle Ages. Possessed of enormous strength and power, long-lived and very hard to kill, the Asgardian warriors were worshipped by the Germanic and Scandinavian tribes of the time.
The thing is, though… Thor mentions in The Avengers that he’s only visited Earth one time prior to that:
“When I first came to earth, Loki's rage followed me here and your people paid the price. And now again…”
That would be during the events of the first Thor movie, which is where Loki first properly turned against his brother (i.e., while not pulling some horrifying and/or sadistic prank on his lunk-headed brother). However, if that’s the case then when was it that the Germanic tribes met Thor, sufficiently to worship him as a God?
How do we have legends of Thor throughout that part of the world when he’d never been there before the 21st century?
As an aside, Avengers: Infinity War has Thor cite himself as being 1500 years old, meaning that he was born around the 6th century AD. That’s 500 years after the first mention of Thor in Tacitus’ book on the German peoples - but you probably have to be a mythology geek to consider that a plot hole.
6. How Does Ant-Man Keep Changing Size In Endgame?
Avengers: Endgame makes a significant plot point out of the fact that, with the Pyms and Van Dynes dead, the Avengers have a limited supply of Pym particles with which to make the Time Heist happen.
That's why, when Stark screws up getting the Tesseract in 2012, he and Cap have to travel back to Camp Lehigh in the seventies to get more Pym Particles in order to get home.
That being the case, with such a limited supply available how does Lang change size during the Time Heist, and during the huge battle at the end of the movie?
Some people have tried to bridge this plot hole by asserting that simply shrinking to a small size or growing to a massive size uses up less Particles than shrinking to sub-atomic size to make time travel possible.
However, the movie makes it pretty clear that there's no difference between the two. Scott Lang even makes a joke out of it, saying that they have enough spare for two test runs and then fumbling his regulator and shrinking, immediately returning to normal size and saying, "Okay, one test run." It's not like he accidentally went back in time in that scene.
Let's not even mention the fact that, in Ant-Man, Hank Pym specifically tells Lang that Pym Particles work by shrinking the distance between atoms, which would make it physically impossible for them to shrink you to a subatomic size in the first place...
5. Cap Can't Possibly Return The Stones
At the end of Avengers: Endgame, Captain America leaves 2023 with 2014’s Mjolnir and a case full of Infinity Stones, intending to return them all to the timelines that they were stolen from.
Now you have to assume that Cap's quantum GPS wristwatch gadget had all the necessary journeys keyed into it, and that Cap had enough Pym Particles to make all of those journeys without running out of gas at any point. That’s a given, or the whole mission would be hopeless.
The thing is, well… the mission is pretty much hopeless anyway. The original Time Heist took several teams of superheroes to pull off, of which Cap was only one. How did he expect to do it on his own - sneak the Sceptre back to Hydra or return the Orb to the laser-protected vault on the planet Morag?
Even if your answer to that question is something like "because he's Captain America", he doesn't have the Orb or the Sceptre - or the Tesseract for that matter. He has no way of transforming the Reality Stone back into its gloopy Aether form.
He also doesn't have a way of getting to Vormir. Black Widow and Hawkeye travelled there from Morag on the Benetar, the Guardians' ship, which had been shrunk down to pocket size. By the time Cap makes the trip, the Guardians had the Benetar back.
Imagining this as an awesome untold Captain America adventure is one thing - what happened when he met the Stonekeeper version of the Red Skull? cooooool - but the film simply doesn't give him the tools he needs to even come close to completing the mission.
4. How Exactly Does A Nexus Event Work?
Prior to the end of season one of the Loki TV show, the Time Variance Authority have been ruthlessly pruning any branching timelines to create one single ‘sacred’ timeline. Those branches are created by Nexus Events - as explained in the show, the moment when someone strays from their path on that sacred timeline, becoming a variant.
Since that's the case, surely Sylvie's Nexus Event was simply being female - yet she was already a young girl when she was grabbed by the TVA, so her branch had been going for a fair few years, subjectively speaking.
It gets sillier. How about the alligator Loki? His Nexus Event was supposedly eating the neighbours' cat. Not being transformed into an alligator in the first place, or whatever happened there: eating a cat. Classic Loki's Nexus Event isn't surviving Thanos' assault on the Asgardian fleet, or anything that happened in the years - probably centuries, possibly even milennia - of isolation that followed
Come to that, why are the Lokis the variants, instead of the Nexus Events that brought them about? And how are Nexus Events possible without some external influence - time travellers, or extra-dimensional visitors, for example?
Look at our Loki again. Supposedly everything the Avengers did in messing with the timeline was "what was supposed to happen", the timeline proceeding like clockwork... so if their time travel wasn't a random external influence, a spanner in the works, how was Loki's variance from that timeline even a possibility?
3. What If..?'s Steve Rogers Shouldn't Be A Main Character
What If..? episode 1 shows what might have happened if, shot by that Nazi saboteur during the Project: Rebirth super soldier experiment, Steve Rogers had been unable to continue - and Peggy Carter had received the serum instead, becoming Captain Carter.
However, the episode goes on to showcase Rogers in a leading role afterwards, continuing to get to know both Agent Carter and Howard Stark.
Rogers was only selected for Project: Rebirth because of Abraham Erskine's personal recommendation, and Erskine is now dead. Carter may have a soft spot for him, but as the show itself is at pains to point out, Carter has almost no influence with the US military at that point. She's "lucky to even be in the room".
It makes absolutely no sense that a man with no military or combat experience - medically invalidated from serving his country due to a list of chronic conditions as long as your arm, and with a fresh bullet wound - would still be anywhere in the house, let alone room-adjacent enough to develop a relationship with a top secret super soldier and the scientific genius attached to the war effort.
It also makes no sense that said genius would develop the Hydra Stomper battlesuit for that war effort… only to give it to Steve. But What If…? wants to keep the Carter/Rogers relationship intact, despite the changed history, and skates blithely over the huge plot holes required to do so.
2. Zemo's Plan In Civil War Is Nonsense
In Captain America: Civil War, Colonel Helmut Zemo stages an elaborate plot to avenge himself against the Avengers, having learned that Captain America’s childhood friend was the Hydra assassin that killed Iron Man’s parents.
The trouble is, the rest of Zemo's master plan to obtain the hard evidence he needs - from the Winter Soldier himself - only works because the story says it does. Under the slightest scrutiny, the whole thing falls apart like wet cake.
At every step, Zemo’s plan relies on something happening that he has little to no control over. That the Joint Terrorism Task Force can find Barnes when no one else has. That if they do, they’ll capture Barnes without killing him and bring him to Berlin (where Zemo’s keeping an EMP device). That if they do, they’ll fly in a psychiatrist that Zemo can easily replace despite looking nothing like him. That, if they do, he can easily escape JTTF HQ and, despite his cover being blown, can travel to wherever else he needs to go to do whatever else he needs to do (because until he speaks to Barnes, Zemo has no idea what further steps he’ll need to take to reach his goal).
Finally, his plan revolves, pure and simple, around the Avengers being that easy to turn against each other. He has no way of knowing that, independently of his plan, the Sokovia Accords has already split the team along party lines, much less that it’ll be Team Cap vs Team Stark; and he has no way of knowing that Rogers has enough of a connection with Barnes that he’ll side with the brainwashed terrorist who killed his old war buddy over that war buddy’s only son and the rule of law.
You know what would have made sense? Zemo using his peerless planning skills and vast resources to locate and capture the Winter Soldier himself. But then we wouldn’t have had as many cool set pieces, would we?
1. Loki Should Have Been Erased When Cap Returned The Stones
In Avengers: Endgame, when 2014's Thanos, his Black Order and his entire army travel to 2023 but don't make it back again, that means that their original timeline would have been one without a Thanos. Avengers: Endgame tries to resolve that issue by claiming that Captain America returning the Infinity Stones stolen in the Time Heist closes off the branching timelines caused by their removal, thereby nullifying any changes made. The Thanos & co. that were disintegrated in 2023 were therefore orphans of a now-nonexistent timeline: spilled milk that Tony Stark's sacrificial 'snap' then mops up.
The same rationale prevents there from being a 2012 where Hydra have been tipped off that Captain America is on to them, two years before they were due to show their hand - or where 2012's Cap has been tipped off two years early that Bucky is still alive. 2023's Cap returns the Time Stone at the moment it was stolen, closing down that branching timeline as the Ancient One requested.
The presumption is that, according to the tortured logic of Endgame and Loki's time travel mechanics, that's why the Time Variance Authority didn't come down on the Avengers like the wrath of Kang: because Cap pruned the errant timelines and Stark effectively pruned the variant Thanos et al.
However, if that was the case , Cap returning the Time Stone should also have removed any need to prune Loki himself. After all, 2012's Loki didn't travel in time when he absconded with the Tesseract, he just hopped a few thousand miles into the desert. He was still in the branching timeline caused by the removal of the Time Stone, so Cap returning it should have erased him, too.