10 Most Surprising Underdog Oscar Victories
They say that every dog has its day.
It wouldn’t be straying too far from the truth to say that certain films, directors and actors are practically a shoo-in for at least a nomination if not an outright win at the glittering, annual film industry talent fest that is the Academy Awards. After all, there’s a reason why terms like Oscar bait exist and why Meryl Streep seems to receive a nomination for pretty much anything.
But every now and then a dark horse contender swoops in from left field and scoops themselves an Academy Award even in the face of fierce competition, proving that sometimes even an outlier can be in with a chance of securing Oscar glory. Romance still exists even in the cynical goldfish bowl of the Oscars.
With several underdog contenders up for nomination at the forthcoming 89th Academy Awards including indie films Moonlight and Hell or High Water, it’s possible we could see another unlikely nominee come good again this year.
And they will be in exalted, if surprising, company...
10. Marisa Tomei
Before her Best Supporting Actress win for her role as Joe Pesci’s
feisty, fast-talking Italian American fiancée Mona Lisa Vito in the 1992 comedy
My Cousin Vinny, Marisa Tomei had only a few bit roles in movies – including an
uncredited role Troma’s cult classic The Toxic Avenger – and a handful of TV
jobs under her belt.
So, her win came as quite a surprise especially considering the calibre of the fellow nominees she triumphed over like esteemed British actresses Vanessa Redgrave and Miranda Richardson. Even more surprising was that while her fellow contenders were nominated for more dramatic roles, Tomei’s was a comedic performance – not something usually rewarded with an Oscar.
That isn’t to say Tomei’s performance wasn’t fantastic and her subsequent Best Supporting Actress nominations in 2002 for In the Bedroom and The Wrestler in 2009 are proof she’s definitely an Oscar-worthy actress. Nevertheless, her win was still quite the feat.
In fact, her win was so surprising that it actually spawned its own conspiracy theory involving a drunken Jack Palance reading the wrong name from the teleprompter while presenting the award and the Academy being too embarrassed to admit the error.
The theory has been debunked, however, so Tomei can rest assured that her award was fully deserved.
9. The Artist
At the 84th Academy Awards in 2012, French director
Michel Hazanavicius’s The Artist notched up an impressive five wins – including
Best Picture, Best Director, Best Actor, Best Original Score and Best Costume
Design – tying only with Martin Scorsese’s first 3D outing Hugo in terms of
Oscar victory that year.
What made The Artist’s Academy Award success all the more impressive was that it wasn’t really your typical sweep the board kind of suspect. As well as earning boasting rights as the first French film to ever win a Best Picture Oscar, it also became the first silent film to win since Wings in 1929 and the first film shot entirely in black and white to win since The Apartment in 1961.
Star Jean Dujardin didn’t do too badly either becoming the first French actor to scoop a Best Actor nod and one of just a handful of French talents to win acting Oscars overall.
8. Beatrice Straight
Throughout Academy Awards history, certain actors have proved
themselves so talented that even their relatively short amount of screen time have
managed to bag them a much-coveted acting Oscar.
In recent years, we’ve seen Anthony Hopkins win Best Oscar for just under sixteen minutes on screen for his role as cannibal Hannibal Lecter in The Silence of the Lambs and Judi Dench scoop Best Supporting Actress for her performance as Queen Elizabeth I in Shakespeare in Love in which she featured on screen for around eight minutes.
But way before Dench and Hopkins’ wins Beatrice Straight managed to nab herself the Best Supporting Actress Oscar for her role as the jilted wife of a TV news executive in Sidney Lumet’s 1976 media satire Network pipping her fellow nominees Piper Laurie and a young Jodie Foster to the post predominantly for just one scene that clocks in at under six minutes long.
7. Roberto Benigni
Comedy-drama and the Holocaust might not seem a likely pair yet
Italian actor and director Roberto Benigni’s Life Is Beautiful proved it’s
possible to infuse comedy, albeit of the bittersweet and black variety, into
even the darkest of subject matter.
The film was rewarded with a number of best film and best foreign film nods from the likes of the Cesar Awards and the European Film Awards and won the Grand Prix at Cannes Film Festival. It’s not unusual for a film from the continent to do well on the European awards circuit, but Benigni’s success at the Oscars certainly came as a surprise.
Life is Beautiful took not only the awards for Best Foreign Film and Best Original Dramatic Score, but earned Benigni the Best Actor Oscar too even when up against fierce competition including Ian McKellen’s performance as troubled Frankenstein director James Whale in Gods and Monsters and Edward Norton’s role as a reformed neo-Nazi in American History X.
Perhaps Benigni’s most memorable moment of the evening, however, was when he climbed over the backs of chairs and other audience members’ heads when making his way to the stage to accept the Best Foreign Film award in quite possibly the most enthusiastic victory walk in Academy Award history.
6. Hilary Swank
Before winning her first Oscar in 2000, Hilary Swank had only a
handful of big screen appearances under her belt, the most noteworthy of which
were a bit part in Buffy the Vampire Slayer and a lead role in franchise closer
The Next Karate Kid.
A stint on Beverly Hills 90210 followed but thankfully she was fired from the show which left her free to audition for her brilliant breakout role as murdered trans man Brandon Teena in director Kimberly Pierce’s critically acclaimed feature debut Boys Don’t Cry.
Despite being up against other talented and arguably more established actresses including Annette Bening and Julianne Moore – not to mention Meryl Streep who is basically never not nominated for an Oscar – Swank managed to walk away with the little gold statuette for Best Actress.
Just five years later Swank proved her merit as an Oscar-worthy talent once again when she scooped Best Actress a second time for her performance in Million Dollar Baby.
5. Eminem
Eminem went down in Academy Award history in 2003 when he shared
the win for Best Original Song for 8 Mile’s Lose Yourself with co-writers Jeff
Bass and Luis Resto, marking the first time a rap song had ever won an Oscar.
Award presenter Barbra Streisand seemed surprised announcing Lose Yourself – which contains one ‘god damn’, two ‘hoes’ and two ‘motherf*ckings’ – as the winner. Considering that some other winners from around that time include Randy Newman, Phil Collins and schmaltzy Titanic theme tune My Heart Will Go On, Streisand’s surprise is quite understandable.
Unfortunately, the man of the moment himself had chosen not to attend the Oscars thinking he wouldn’t be in with a chance of winning and was reportedly dozing at his Michigan home while his daughter watched cartoons when co-writer Resto stepped up to accept the award.
4. Rocky
It’s no big secret that the John G. Avildsen directed boxing drama
Rocky was the surprise hit of 1976. Penned by star Sylvester Stallone in just
three and a half days and filmed on a relatively modest budget of just over $1
million, the movie went on to gross $225 million worldwide and since 2006 has resided
in the Library of Congress’s National Film Registry for its cultural
significance.
Its success at the 49th Academy Awards was Rocky’s most surprising triumph, however. Mirroring the movie’s rags to riches tale of a Philadelphian underdog come good, Rocky was nominated for a total of ten Oscars and scooped three including Best Picture, Best Director and Best Film Editing.
Rocky’s Oscar victories were all the more unexpected considering the calibre of the films it was up against. The critically acclaimed All the President’s Men, Network and Taxi Driver were all nominated for Best Picture too but it was Rocky that boxed its way to glory on the night.
3. Kathryn Bigelow
Kathryn Bigelow scored a massive win for female film industry
talents everywhere when she became the first female director to win scoop the
Oscar for Best Director. Where fellow female nominees Lina Wertmuller (nominated
for Seven Beauties), Jane Campion (The Piano) and Sofia Coppola (Lost in
Translation) failed to bring home the bacon in previous years Bigelow finally did
in 2010 for her Iraq War drama The Hurt Locker.
Not only did Bigelow triumph over fellow nominees including Quentin Tarantino for Inglourious Basterds and Lee Daniels for Precious, she also managed to stick it to her ex-husband James Cameron who was also up for Best Director for his big budget sci-fi fantasy Avatar in the process.
The Hurt Locker also won against Avatar in the categories of Best Picture, Best Sound Editing, Best Sound Mixing and Best Film Editing. Not bad considering the massive differences between each movie’s production budgets – a rather humble $15 million for The Hurt Locker and an estimated $237 for Avatar.
Cameron seemed to take the defeat in good spirit. Well, apart from pretending to strangle Bigelow at the awards ceremony and later saying he thought The Hurt Locker would’ve been better in 3D. Bad sport.
2. Three 6 Mafia
Eminem might’ve been the first rap artist to receive the Oscar for
Best Original Song but Memphis hip hop group went one step further when they
not only won that very same award – for their theme song It’s Hard out Here for
a Pimp, no less, from the movie Hustle & Flow – but also performed the
winning song during the Academy Awards ceremony.
Most had expected Dolly Parton’s Transamerica theme tune Travelin’ Thru to scoop the award, but Three 6 Mafia triumphed and quite possibly can lay claim to having written the most unlikely titled Best Original Song winner of all time.
After the group got up and gave a very happy and enthusiastic speech, host Jon Stewart remarked ‘That’s how you accept an Oscar!’ and quipped ‘For those keeping track, that’s Three 6 Mafia – one, Martin Scorsese – zero’. Yep, that’s right: at one point in Academy Award history, Three 6 Mafia could boast an Oscar win to their name while the revered Scorsese could not.
The song was toned down somewhat during the group’s performance at the ceremony, however, with the word ‘bitches’ swapped up for ‘witches’ so as not to offend any Hollywood bitches present in the audience.
1. Haing S. Ngor
By the time Cambodian doctor Haing S. Ngor emigrated to the USA in
1980 he had already led an extraordinary life. A skilled surgeon and
gynaecologist practicing in the Cambodian capital Phnom Penh, Ngor was forced
to leave the city when the brutal Khmer Rouge regime took power and spent four
years in a concentration camp before escaping to Thailand and eventually
America.
His remarkable life journey didn’t end there though. Unable to practice medicine in the US, he got into the acting industry after being spotted at a Cambodian wedding in California and cast as real-life Cambodian journalist Dith Pran who had also survived the Khmer Rouge in the 1984 film The Killing Fields.
Ngor went on to win Best Supporting Actor for his movingly realistic portrayal of Pran and to date remains the only actor of Asian descent to ever win the award. At the time of winning, he was also only the second non-professional actor to win Best Supporting Actor joining fellow winner Howard Russell for his role in 1946’s The Best Years of Our Lives.
He continued acting for the rest of his life which was sadly cut short in 1996 when he murdered in a gang shooting. Nevertheless, his legacy lives on in the annals of Academy Award history.