10 Most Terrifying Horror Movie Cults
Let's talk about sects.
Whether greeting you on your own doorstep like a spiritual salesman or inviting you into the seemingly quaint traditions of their remote rural community, nothing says creepiness quite like the superficial amiability which masks the sinister practices of a religious cult.
Of course, it's not just figurative masks that make cults prime nightmare fuel. Most of them come readily equipped with literal masks, hoods and a whole litany of ominous ceremonial paraphernalia just perfect for establishing an atmosphere of dread.
Scariest of all, though, is that cults are not simply your average evil-for-evil's-sake horror villains. They have the genuine terror of the true believer. These are people with an unbending spiritual certainty that what they are doing is for the greater good, that nothing they do crosses a line, however horrific, if the ends could justify the means.
This list has decided to leave horror movies about straight-up devil worship for another time, so no place for the Satanic cults of Rosemary's Baby or The Devil Rides Out here. We're more concerned right now with cults who genuinely believe that their creepy rituals and sacrifices will make the world a better place.
Here, then, are ten of the most disturbing instances that really deliver on the "cult" in "cult horror." (There will be spoilers for all the movies mentioned here)
10. Children Of The Corn - Children Of The Corn
The most enduring horror movie cult, the Children Of The Corn are still going strong after four decades, a record which would put most of the short-lived cults of the real world to shame.
Stephen King's 1977 Penthouse Magazine short story about the small town of Gatlin where the children sacrifice all adults to He Who Walks Behind The Rows, a being that lives in the neighbouring cornfields, may not be the master of horror's best work, but it is the one that has spawned the most movies.
Since the original 1984 movie there have been nine further instalments (up to 2018's Children Of The Corn: Runaway) and a made-for-TV remake, so there's definitely plenty of audience still for the message of creepy child preacher Isaac's mix of Old Testament evangelising, Amish-style costume and huge quantities of maize-based folk art.
And, hey, maybe you can see why, because unlike the idols worshipped by some movie cults, the object of the Children Of The Corn's devotion doesn't just talk the talk, but also genuinely walks the walks (behind the rows), actually providing them with lush corn harvests at the mere the cost of the life of anyone over 19.
9. Jötunn Worshippers - The Ritual
Essentially Blair Witch meets Trollhunter, 2017 Brit horror The Ritual sees a group of university friends, led by Rafe Spall's Luke, hiking in the far North of Sweden and encountering some of the charming local folklore.
Like any lads on tour scenario, this is a trip marked by bad decisions. In this case, though, it's less a matter of an ill-judged obscene tattoo in Magaluf and more one of a poorly considered shortcut deep into woods full of occult symbols carved into trees and effigy statues of dismembered bodies sprouting antlers.
All of this leads to an encounter with the local cult, worshippers of the Jötun, an ancient giant creature from Nordic mythology who Marvel fans may recognise from their reimagined form as the Frost Giants in Thor.
The titular Ritual involves Luke either joining the cult or being sacrificed to the Jötunn in order to grant immortality to the cult members. Most of them, though, appear to be long dead, mummified and, it turns out, very flammable.
8. The Invitation - The Invitation
Not every cult is full of masked pagan ritual, bonfires and maypoles. In the twenty-first century cults are as likely to come clothed in the paraphernalia of self-help support groups as they are a full deer's head. Such is the case with the eponymous cult at the heart of 2015 indie thriller The Invitation.
Director Karyn Kusama's previous horror flick, the far more mainstream Jennifer's Body, got decidedly mixed reviews, but she is on considerably more unsettling ground with this lo-fi entry into the "awkward dinner party turns into something far worse" genre.
In The Invitation a divorced husband returns to his former home for a dinner invite from his ex-wife and her new husband. As if that wasn't uncomfortable enough, the dinner turns out to be an excuse for the ex to promote the New Age spiritual philosophy which she has discovered to help handle the grief over their son's death (the thing which led to their divorce in the first place).
Much like the dinner party itself, The Invitation cult starts out as some mildly uncomfortable evangelising for the power of mystical healing and descends into something much more horrific with the realisation that all it's really interested in is spiritual peace through death.
7. 2054 Apocalypse Cult - Sound Of My Voice
Before making it big with seriously weird Netflix show The OA, director Zal Batmanglij and his co-writer and star Brit Marling made this almost as odd psychological thriller/sort of sci-fi featuring Marling as a charismatic cult leader claiming, quite convincingly, to have come from half a century in the future to save a chosen few from the coming dystopia.
Sound Of My Voice isn't exactly a horror film. Certainly this cult is responsible for a few less dismemberments and creative human sacrifices than the others on this list. In fact, it's kind of hard to pin down what genre the movie is and where it stands on whether Marling's Maggie is a manipulative charlatan or the real deal.
That, though, is precisely what makes it so unsettling. As the documentary filmmakers who are our viewpoint characters, and who initially set out to expose Maggie as a fraud, fall under her spell and join in her rituals, we in the audience are left unclear on where we stand.
Just like its cult, the movie offers no easy answers, which may be frustrating for some would-be followers. In the latter's case, though, the explanation is more simple. It was supposed to be the first in a trilogy and the other two parts never got made.
6. Eden Parish - The Sacrament
The mumblegore indie horror movement gave us its take on cults with this 2013 found footage story loosely inspired by the 1970s People's Temple and the massacre at Jonestown.
Director Ti West had made his name with an engaging pastiche of 70s satanic panic stories in The House Of The Devil's blood-loving devil worshippers. Here, however, he is working much more in the realm of the chillingly plausible.
Eden Parish is a remote, utopian, self-sufficient commune led by "Father" Charles Anderson Reed, a magnetic preacher who gives new hope to recovering addicts and others that society has failed.
Of course, the difference between a remote retreat for the soul and a prison from which there is little hope for escape can be surprisingly little. The armed guards certainly don't help!
And neither does the increasingly paranoid Father's evasive answers to the interview questions from our VICE journalist heroes. (The Sacrament gets away with a much more professional style of shooting than most amateurish found footage movies by making its cameraman character an actual professional).
Even somebody whose only knowledge of the real Jonestown is a tasteless "drink the Kool-Aid" joke can see where this is all headed, and sure enough Eden Parish has a shockingly well-stocked drug store for a commune in the middle of nowhere.
5. The Goddess Cult - Apostle
Successful Welsh director Gareth Evans took a long time to make a feature in his home country and, when he did, it didn't exactly paint it as the most welcoming and salubrious of surroundings.
Evans made his name by bringing the attention of the world to the Indonesian martial art of pencak silat thanks to high octane action movies like The Raid. But for the horror anthology flick V/H/S 2 he stepped a little beyond this comfort zone with a story of a demon-worshipping Indonesian cult committing ritual sacrifice at the "Time Of Reckoning."
It seems that his contribution to V/H/S was the perfect recruiting tool to bring Evans into the fold of sinister cults as he would later make a whole cult feature with Apostle, a movie that could perhaps best be described as "The Wicker Man, but Welsh."
And who better to step into the Christopher Lee role as the dynamic cult leader, only more Welsh, but Port Talbot's finest: Michael Sheen. Here Sheen leads a cult of turn of the century ex-convicts on a once barren Welsh island where blood sacrifices to a local goddess have apparently rendered the land fertile.
And you know a horror movie cult has really crossed the line when it turns out that even their own goddess wants to get away from them!
4. Children Of The New Dawn - Mandy
The good Nicolas Cage movie about cults (in that it doesn't involve him being covered in bees while repeatedly yelling "not the bees!"), Mandy is a sadly underseen gem which makes perfect use of the oddball star's manic bursts of feral energy and capacity for pairing genuine emotion and extraordinary violence.
Mandy's Children Of The New Dawn and their leader, Jeremiah Sand, are straight out of the Manson Family school of hippie cults, fuelled by acid trips, excrutiating psychedelic folk rock, and a misplaced confidence in Sand's sexual magnetism.
Given that Sand is the kind of egomaniacal cult leader who truly believes that God has granted him the right to have and to take anything that he wants, you can imagine that he's the kind of guy that won't take rejection well. Like "setting people on fire" levels of not well.
It must be said, though, that even if the Children Of The Dawn and their cannibalistic biker gang cohorts are scary, they're no match for an anguished, vengeful Nicolas Cage with a crossbow and chainsaw.
Had Mandy found more of an audience, director Panos Cosmatos envisioned a sequel with Cage's Red Miller "fighting Nazi punks in a bombed-out city", but maybe it was always destined to be a cult movie on every level.
3. Summerisle Cult - The Wicker Man
The undoubted lynchpin of the entire horror cult genre, the pagan worshippers of the Hebridean island of Summerisle have had a huge influence over many movie cults on this list and beyond.
The Wicker Man partly works as well as it does because it is grounded in real world British folk traditions and the revival of Celtic paganism as a belief system within the modern world.
It takes the familiar, if archaic, little Englander tweeness of maypoles and morris dances and puts back in all the uncanny weirdness that most of us seem to have detached from such things. By extrapolating such traditions back to an imagined pagan pre-history, the people of Summerisle ultimately see little difference in the age old traditions of waving hankies and bells, or those of bringing blood and flame.
All that means that the celebratory medieval folk song Sumer Is Icumen In (previously heard on screen in Errol Flynn's Adventures Of Robin Hood) is now forever associated with the sight of a cop being put inside a giant flammable effigy.
The Summerislanders' dedication to their belief is especially disturbing given that it appears to have no foundation in reality. Unlike the Children Of The Corn of the goddess worshippers from Apostle, the people of Summerisle have seen no obvious demonstrations of real supernatural power granting their land fertility, but they believe in it enough to murder nonetheless. Now that's properly creepy.
2. The Cult - Kill List
Most of the cults on this list have a clearly defined set of beliefs, often with a demagogic leader given some big, grandstanding monologues to spell out precisely what they think all these fancy dress rituals and human sacrifices will achieve. That is very much not the case, though, with Kill List, where the slightly frustrating mystery at the heart of the story just makes its esoteric cult all the more disturbing.
In fact, at first Kill List doesn't seem like it's a movie about cults at all. For quite a while in its first half, Kill List isn't even the hitman thriller it was marketed as. Instead it presents as a slice of downbeat social realism about a former soldier with PTSD and his disintegrating marriage.
Sure, there's the occasional occult symbol carved into the back of a bathroom mirror, but the sudden appearance in the final act of figures in masks made of twigs, conducting torchlight rituals in the woods definitely comes out of leftfield.
Your mileage may vary on the lack of any clear explanation for the finale's ritualistic, violent masked knife fight with the "Hunchback" and its shocking reveal, but that vagueness will definitely make the creepy imagery stay with you long after watching.
1. The Hårga - Midsommar
In just two movies director Ari Aster has proved himself a master of stories about dysfunctional families and relationships wrapped up in some really creepy cult stuff. Following from the suburban devil worshippers of Hereditary, Aster last year gave us the sun soaked Swedish pagans of Midsommar's Hårga.
Aster's Scandi-cultists offer a veritable smörgåsbord of the horror movie cult tropes on this list: remote rural communities, vulnerable outsiders whose existent grief and trauma are easy to exploit, seriously retro costumes, psychedelic hallucinogens, extended folk song and dance performances, weird symbols and occult texts, maypoles, fertility rituals, ceremonial suicide, people being burnt alive. It's got it all and a bear to boot.
That's not to say that the Hårga offer nothing new to potential converts of horror movie cults. Aster doesn't just expose the darkness beneath the perennial sunshine of this Swedish pastoral idyll, he also gives his cult story an outcome which is unsettling in an unusual way.
While some movie heroes' encounters with cults lead to them fighting back and others to them becoming the cult's sacrificial victim, Midsommar's Dani does neither. She converts. The murderous cult gives her a place in the world and she joins the Hårga. Maybe that's the most terrifying cult victory of all.