10 Most Unlikely Horror Movie Leads

Blood! Gore! Who?

The horror movie genre is more popular than ever, with its influence felt right across popular culture like a blood spatter from a slashed artery. Audiences are happy to suspend disbelief and strap themselves in for a good old frightfest, a sensory rollercoaster ride that'll make eyes pop out of sockets and bathrooms get frequently used. However, sometimes there's an element that just doesn't sit right amongst the mayhem. More often than not, that factor is the lead actor or actress! Does it matter if there are plenty of heads flying around, or if you're stuffing a cushion into your face every thirty seconds? Well, yes. Even if the film is really delivering the gory goods, that mismatched central figure can really start to bug you. What were the producers thinking? Give it some time and the true terror may turn out to be the maniac in the casting department... Get ready to be entertained yet baffled by ten key examples of unlikely horror movie leads - implausible for various intriguing reasons. Either due to a lack of acting ability, being too recognizable from a totally unrelated field, or simply because they're too damned good looking...!

10. Robert De Niro - Mary Shelley's Frankenstein

There's a certain simplicity to the classic movie monsters. Take Dracula for example. Sure, he's an ageless, sensual romantic with an appetite for the red stuff, but he's also mysterious. The less you know, the more powerful he becomes. Bram Stoker's Dracula, worked to death and beyond by Francis Ford Coppola and Gary Oldman, put so many whistles and bells on the basic idea viewers didn't know where they were. For Frankenstein, heavyweight thesp and director Kenneth Branagh was selected to give proceedings a bit of class. That's all well and good. After all, Boris Karloff gave a widely-respected turn as the Creature in the definitive Universal entry. But when Branagh went to the master of method acting Robert De Niro to bring Mary Shelley's creation to life, it was like sending a nuclear scientist to repair an egg whisk. It takes a brave contributor to say the great actor gave a bad performance, and no-one could claim he did that. However, did audiences really need someone who agonized over what the beast had for breakfast, what shoes he'd wear, whether he could blow his nose without it shooting out his ear...? The sight of Branagh stripped to the waist with a poodle perm was odd enough. Same goes for De Niro's scene with British sitcom stalwart Richard Briers! The central attraction became more of a distraction in a film overloaded with worthiness.

9. Ross Noble - Stitches

Many out there know the story of Stephen King's It, where a group of friends got together to destroy the malevolent, unearthly clown Pennywise, who terrorized them as children. Brit comedy horror Stitches, written and directed by Conor McMahon, turned the idea on its head by having the rubber-faced entertainer being the one seeking revenge on the teens he held accountable for his demise back when they were kids. The title pie-flinger had to be a memorable presence. McMahon ensured that by casting surreal improvisational comedian Ross Noble. Famous in Britain for his alarmingly authentic ramblings on panel shows like QI and Have I Got News For You, this was his first major movie role, and what a place to start! Viewers in countries where Noble's comedy stylings hadn't travelled probably wondered who the creepy guy with the long face was under all the panstick. His army of fans on the other hand knew exactly who wore the clown trousers and this - together with the outrageous acts of low-budget violence he perpetrated - made the splatterfest a bit more jarring than intended.

8. Stephan Smith Collins - Hellraiser: Revelations

The Cenobites have existed for centuries, so the Hellraiser film franchise is relatively young, clocking in at just under thirty years to date. Creator Clive Barker is returning to oversee a reboot of the concept. The reason he's doing this may lie in the last recorded sighting of his iconic masochist, and every hatmaker's nightmare, Pinhead. Doug Bradley dominated the saga as the man who can't go through a metal detector, but rush job entry Revelations had to find another villain when the veteran declined the chance to get his hooks into the part. Filmed hurriedly for contractual reasons to prevent the rights lapsing from Dimension Films, the shoot welcomed Stephan Smith Collins, in his first and only appearance as Barker's imposing leather-wearer. It was a great opportunity for Smith, but producers should have realized the original star is irreplaceable. There's more to Pinhead than sitting in a make up chair for a few hours and the poor actor struggled to make an impression. Revelations could almost be a fan film tribute to the legacy! Guess who's being cast in the new chapter? Yep - Mr Bradley.

7. Marilyn Chambers - Rabid

"Connoisseurs" of adult movie material got a big surprise watching David Cronenberg's Rabid. Following on from the cerebral Canadian's body horror classic Shivers, this effort saw a young woman go on a sexually-charged, highly infectious rampage through the metropolis after she acquired weird, zombie-like tendencies after an operation. Foreshadowing the likes of Under The Skin and other predatory female films, the production became as memorable for its casting as its vivid subject matter. After attempts to hire Sissy Spacek fell through, Cronenberg was pointed in the direction of porn star Marilyn Chambers. In some ways it made perfect sense to give Chambers her first major acting role. Her desirability would fuel enough gory spectacle to put The Walking Dead to shame. In others, it was an extraordinary piece of surprise casting that some never recovered from. The section of the audience who knew who she was (without wanting to admit it!) were faced with an alarming new take on their erotic performer of choice. A Triffid-like attack prong coming out of her armpit ensured her fans got scarred for life!

6. Elijah Wood - Maniac

William Lustig's low budget slasher entry of 1980 was fondly-remembered, in as much as the story of a deranged young man who kills and scalps his victims can be thought of that way! As with other grungy, micro-money horrors such as The Texas Chainsaw Massacre, enterprising producers sought to remake the mini-masterpiece, bringing it bang up to date and including a coat of twenty-first century gloss for good measure. Who did Franck Khalfoun want for the part Joe Spinell made his own thirty years previous...? Elijah Wood. Yes, the dewey-eyed, adorable presence who made Frodo's journey to the heart of Middle Earth that little bit sweeter. The Hobbit hole dweller shaving the hair off his toes and roaming the streets at night butchering unfortunate young women... audiences were praying for Samwise Gamgee to pop up behind him, give him a slap, and tell him to stop being so ridiculous! There's casting against type, and then there's getting a puppy to poo on your neighbour's doorstep. Some things just aren't done, and soiling the minds of Lord Of The Rings fans forever falls squarely into that category! In the same sense that Gollum would look weird starring in High School Musical, so Wood appeared wildly out of place here.

5. Billy Connolly - Fido

Glaswegian titan Billy Connolly has had many twists and turns to his career in entertainment. He was a welder, a folk musician, a singer, a comedian, an actor and then... a zombie! Needless to say, fans of his output were caught off guard by that development, and this was coming from a man who scaled the heights of the unexpected in his stand up routines. He took the undead title part in Fido, a warped comedy directed by Andrew Currie about the aftermath of a human v corpse conflict in an alternate history. Playing a domesticated member of the undead saw Connolly broaden his range like never before. However, just as Ross Noble raised a few eyebrows as a marauding, vengeance-obsessed clown in Stitches, so the maverick Scot's admirers couldn't get their heads around him painted grey and shambling round 1950s Canada. The movie was intended as a comedy and received good reviews, but the film became as famous for its unusual choice of lead as it did for pushing the horror envelope. It was the sort of risky decision that resulted in puzzled expressions and dark laughter in equal quantity. Day Of The Dead it ain't!

4. Alan "Fluff" Freeman - Dr. Terror's House Of Horrors

The rickety train carriage that formed the setting for Amicus horror anthology Dr Terror's House Of Horrors contained a raft of British acting talent. For starters, you had Peter Cushing as the title character, and Christopher Lee as a bewildered passenger. That's gruesome gold from the get go! A young Donald Sutherland joined the fright-based fun, alongside Neil McCallum and variety performer Roy Castle. Castle was a peculiar selection for sure, and seeing this sprightly trumpet player come up against the power of voodoo only boosted the bizarre nature of his story. However the movie had an even bigger credulity-stretching ace up its sleeve, in the shape of DJ Alan Freeman. Yes, the man nicknamed "Fluff" from the BBC wound up battling a killer plant! If Freeman had possessed hidden depths when it came to performance it would have helped. But he didn't. In fact he spent much of the time looking bemused. Why wouldn't he, some might ask? All part of the sheer entertainment value of the studio's definitive shocker, yet a stake through the heart of its dramatic credentials...

3. Tom Cruise - Interview With The Vampire

The news that Hollywood poster boy Tom Cruise had been cast as Anne Rice's anti-hero Lestat in Neil Jordan's adaptation of Interview With The Vampire drew more howls of protest than a werewolf convention running low on steak. This was the guy who whooped his way through Top Gun. How could he possibly bring this powerful figure to blood-curdling life? On the whole, "the Cruiser" proved his critics wrong, dying his hair and embodying the ominous grace the role demanded. Even so, the overriding impression in some quarters was - it's Tom Cruise playing a vampire! Never in a million years would audiences have thought that this full-of-beans fighter pilot/exasperated relative of Dustin Hoffman/racing car petrolhead would be chewing necks across the centuries! The star rarely strayed that far from his comfort zone again (aside from projects such as Magnolia and Collaterol), making this an intriguing curio performance that divided opinion. In the main, Cruise went back to his groove as the clean-cut dude up to his collarbone in trouble, as opposed to draining veins as one of the big bads.

2. Keith Chegwin - Kill Keith

TV presenter Keith Chegwin hadn't done any acting for donkey's years when director Andy Thompson approached him to make Kill Keith, a blood-spattered romp that saw the nation's favourite cheeky chappie play himself. The plot, such as it was, concerned a psychopath out to nail the Saturday Superstore host, but the point of it was to create a unique horror film around a deeply unusual subject. "Chegger"'s unlikeliness as a screen hero was exactly the point, but the gamble didn't pay off. Whether the problem lay in the casting, the execution (and the film certainly rated highly on executions!) or the simple fact people didn't want to see a horror film starring Keith Chegwin... the project came and went like a chainsaw through a midriff! To this day, punters go into charity shops, see the name on the DVD spine and pick it up, staring wide-eyed at the image of the jolly central performer in tight yellow spandex, sprayed with human claret. In a funny sort of way maybe the movie did go down in the annals of screen infamy...

1. Alexandra Daddario - Texas Chainsaw

The most recent revival of the popular "hungry, hungry hicks" franchise put forward some pretty crazy ideas. It kicked off with the revelation that somehow the Texas Chainsaw Massacre house had a large extended family living in it at the same time the twisted events of the original were taking place. Lord knows where they were. Sitting in the cupboard? Hiding under the sofa? Anyway, turned out the Sawyer clan were far more than just a handful of nutjobs. Fans then discovered a baby girl had survived the carnage that ensued when the good old boys descended on the Sawyer home to wipe them out once they'd gone too far. Now, the Sawyers were at best a rogues' gallery. None of them were going to win any prizes for beauty, unless Leatherface was the spit of Brad Pitt under that flesh mask. Nevertheless, the upshot was that the talented but ever-so-slightly-out-of-place Alexandra Daddario joined the cast as new character Heather. The gene pool didn't so much fluctuate as have an electric cable jammed into it. How in the name of god a gorgeous young woman like that came into the mix is a question for the ages, and one that still has people scratching their heads today. Maybe as a scream queen lead... that would have been fine. But director John Luessenhop wanted us to believe Daddario's DNA was hotwired for bloodlust! Her first scene had her working in a butchers shop for Christ's sake - even sawing up liver she looked pretty damned perfect. Great for the aesthetics, ludicrous for everything else! What do you think of this list? Do you agree with the choices, or are there any glaring omissions? Let us know in the comments section!

Contributor
Contributor

I am a journalist and comedian who enjoys American movies of the 70s, Amicus horror compendiums, Doctor Who, Twin Peaks, Naomi Watts and sitting down. My short fiction has been published as part of the Iris Wildthyme range from Obverse Books.