10 Most Violent Westerns Ever Made

Fancy your Western movie with a side of disembowelment, exploding skulls and scalping?

Bone Tomahawk Kurt Russell
RLJ Entertainment

Violence and Westerns - they go hand in hand don’t they?

Westerns show off the American Wild West in all its gun swinging, wheat chewing, horse rearing glory. Whether the Italians are coming in to add their own spice in Spaghetti Westerns or old time classic directors are showing the depths of the dark badlands, the genre has proved that it’s more than simple fun (though it is that too lots of the time).

Of course, Westerns have always lent themselves to being super brutal, but the films on this list have really taken things to the next level. While gunfights and the tension of a pistol shootout are fun, sometimes movies go that one step further. These films feature depraved, brutal acts of violence, bleak journeys and a harrowing look at both the human condition and the Wild Wild West. They span 60+ years of cinema and show that no matter what changes in the world, the public will always have an appetite for violence. The films won’t just put you off your dinner for a while but they’ll shock you in ways you didn’t expect.

If you think you’ve got the stomach to handle them, be our guest and continue on…

10. Mannaja (1977)

Mannaja, otherwise known as The Man Called Blade, came out at the tail end of Italy’s Spaghetti Western era. Directed by Sergio Martino, the 1977 film is extremely violent.

The story centres around Blade, the snide, cold bounty hunter arriving in town, aiming to settle some past scores along the way. He’s enlisted to track down the daughter of the town’s mayor before quickly becoming embroiled in ulterior schemes as well as his own past feuds. It starts off with a man losing his hand to a tomahawk... then it finds a way to become even better.

Violence is key to Mannaja and our tomahawk wielding hero provides the film with ample opportunity for nastiness. There are some brutal moments and excellent gunfights all across this film but the best part is seeing how quick Blade is with his weapon. Equally as happy to throw his hatchet as shoot his gun, Blade’s skills are blended with Martino’s own artistic directorial style to show violence.

Although Mannaja is often compared to Castellari’s Keoma (which was released just one year before), the film is often cited as one of the last great Spaghetti Westerns. Fighting through a genre that had become laden with parody, this film is stylish and a great send off to a well loved era of cinema.


9. The Proposition (2005)

One of Nick Cave’s greatest albums was all about murder ballads, so it’s no surprise he wrote such a brilliant and brutal screenplay in the form of 2005's The Proposition. Set in the Australian Badlands, the film follows the bleak path of a bushranger (Guy Pearce) on the the hunt for his outlaw brother.

The film opens up with images of corpses and things continue to get bleaker from there. The ordeals that bodies go through in this film are extreme: skulls explode, spears pierce through bodies, people are smashed to pieces and others are viciously beaten. Blood and grime are smeared all over this John Hillcoat directed film and souls are lost in order to save a life.

The Proposition often feels hopeless as we learn more about the cold badlands and its heartless inhabitants. Unlike Western tropes, The Proposition isn’t an exciting tail of gunslinging fun where the good guy gets the woman and everything’s okay again - it’s a gruelling, fearsome film as saddening as it is viscious.


8. Scalps (1987)

The film is called Scalps, of COURSE it’s brutal.

A massively underseen film from genre director Bruno Mattei, Scalps is a more female centric Western starring Mapi Galán as Yari, a Native American tribe chief’s daughter out to get brutal revenge.

When the local tribe will not sell Yari to Confederate soldiers, they burn down the natives’ home and kidnap her. Yari escapes and finds herself with a young rancher named Matt Brown (Vassili Karis) who despite hating the Indians, is an ex-soldier and hates the Confederates more. Like the best mismatched couples do, the two join forces to exert revenge.

Brown hates the idea of violence and vengeance but Yari is out to take down the soldiers in any depraved, dark way that she can… and yes, she is not above scalping a man. Mattei’s late spaghetti Western is not above violent torture or decapitations and if you can find an uncut version of this film, try not to watch it whilst eating.

Scalps isn’t a great film, but it IS brutal. So if that’s what you’re looking for, scour the internet for a copy of this long lost Western.


7. Four Of The Apocalypse (1975)

Described as “Unrelenting in its Mournful and Mesmerizing Moodiness,” Four Of the Apocalypse is not a light hearted family romp but a brutal Western set in the Utah Badlands. Directed by the “Godfather of Gore”, Lucio Fulci, the film lives up to all expectations. Fulci doesn’t disappoint and brings along the kind of bloodiness and savagery that features in his classic films such as The Beyond and Zombie, and went on to inspire the likes of Quentin Tarantino.

Four of the Apocalypse follows four criminals travelling across the Badlands in order to flee an attack on their frontier town. The group is made up of a gambler, an alcoholic, a prostitute and a gravedigger, 3 men and a woman who are met by the sadistic Chaco, who attempts to join the group.

On the surface, Four of the Apocalypse is a violence-ridden redemption story, but digging deeper shows a love of literature and the story of personal growth. Fulci’s horror roots encompass the entire film with mournfulness and the director loads it with metaphor and blood splatter to equal measure. The film plays with both psychedelia and horror featuring the kind of scenes you’ll never forget.


6. The Searchers (1956)

The oldest film on this list by a considerable amount of time, The Searchers is a classic, even amongst director John Ford’s incredible back catalogue. Other than simply being a great film, The Searchers marked the beginning of Ford breaking down his own ideas of the American Wild West. He took the genre that he had been so instrumental in creating and began to subvert stereotypes and ask questions.

Deviating from the American Hero he was built up to be, in this film John Wayne plays Ethan Edwards, the anti-hero who, throughout the film, manages to surprise you with an unpredictable grimness. After his family are brutally massacred, Edwards must go on a hunt to rescue his niece (Natalie Wood) from the Natives that have captured her.

Most of The Searchers’ most brutal moments come from its unpredictability; however the characters are still bloodthirsty, savage and violent.

Brutality aside though, John Wayne’s Ethan Edwards is one of the all time great, complex Western heroes and the reason why this film ranks so highly on everyone’s genre lists. Even though Ford was shakily attempting to write complex heroes, he ends up almost unconsciously doing it perfectly.


5. El Topo (1971)

Known as being everything from a puppeteer, mime, psychoanalyst and draughtsman, it’s no surprise that director Alejandro Jodorowsky is also the director and leading actor in a film as acid-soaked and insane as this.

Manson-esque in his portrayal of gunslinger El Topo, Jodorowsky begins the film by travelling across the desert with his own son walking behind him with only a hat and shoes on - and it somehow gets weirder.

We follow El Topo through the desert on a spiralling quest to kill four gunmen, however on the way there’s monks, mutants, castration, sex and crucifixion, just to name a few things. The film is about as maddening and violent as it gets, but it's equally fun and hilarious. Like Sergio Leone but with no sense of morals, Jodorowsky has written a film with a bizarre dreamscape that acts as a metaphor for questioning religion and your own sense of spirituality. There’s a lot to get out of a film like El Topo, however you will be left clawing on to your own sanity.

El Topo is a surreal, grotesque, revolutionary and testing movie. It’s one of the craziest films you’ll ever see but it is so worth the time.


4. Django (1966)

A film so violent that the British boards banned it outright from appearing in this country, Django immediately became a cult classic. It took almost 25 years for it to be shown in the country but even now it hasn’t lost an inch of what made it unrateable.

The bodycount on Django was the highest of any Western film at the time; the way that the leading character (Franco Nero) plowed through bodies like they were dominoes using his machine gun is still massively fun. Violence keeps the film running: Django and Maria (Loredana Nusciak) become caught in the middle of a feud between racist Southerners and Mexicans. All we know about Django at the start is that he carries around a coffin, but what’s in it we don’t know.

If you haven’t guessed yet (or didn’t already know), Sergio Corbucci’s Django has gone on to not only influence filmmakers in terms of story but in the incredible title and name of the leading character. Western-loving Tarantino has explicitly shared his love for the film so much so that he included Franco Nero in his 2012 film Django Unchained and even took the name.

Django’s gone on to influence lots and change the game for violent Westerns… but the bar was still pushed further, spectacularly.


3. Bone Tomahawk (2015)

The newest film on the list, Bone Tomahawk is the brutal cannibals vs gunslingers Western that combines a love of the classics with the modern work of filmmakers like the Coen Brothers.

Living somewhere between Western, Comedy and Horror, Bone Tomahawk is a strange blend of genres, made hard to watch by some of the stomach-churning violence and macabre themes. The story centres around a mis-matched group of Wild West stereotypes travelling across the desert to rescue three innocent townsfolk from a group of cannibals.

Despite being brutal and maddening, director S. Craig Zahler marches the film along at an unconventional pace and isn’t afraid to tell the story through dialogue and travel. He builds himself an interesting cast of characters with their own hangups, melds them with humour and the film flies by.

By the time we hit the end of Bone Tomahawk and the violence comes, it’s extreme. If you think you’re the kind of person that can watch a man being scalped with a bone tool, let’s see you try. Zahler conjures up the kind of depraved violence that makes the most brutal horror seem like a walk in the park. The film builds up to a climax and boy does it not disappoint.


2. The Wild Bunch (1969)

Crooked, savage and twisted, Sam Peckinpah’s depiction of the West makes Wild an understatement - it’s pure brutality.

Set on the eve of World War I, The Wild Bunch begins with a colony of ants devouring a scorpion before it shifts attention to the likes of gunning down civilians and bombing bridges. In his story about a group of outlaws looking for one last score, Peckinpah uses the decline of the Wild West to usher in a new generation of Westerns that focus on the gloomy side of the badlands.

You don’t know who to root for in the Wild Bunch - your goodies are bad and the lawmen just as crooked. There is no hero and you have to live with it. Lou Lombardo’s editing on the film has gone down in history as some of the very best with his revolutionary and seminal use of slow motion truly bringing out the violence of the situation.

Ahead of its time and truly special, The Wild Bunch uses violence to ask the question "Is it better to burn out or fade away?" And the spectacular 2 hours that follow proves that sometimes you have to go out in a blaze of glory.


1. Cut-Throats Nine (1972)

When a wagon load of prisoners are attacked by bandits on their way to prison, the only survivors are a Sergeant, his young daughter and seven hardened prisoners. All the Sergeant has to do is protect his daughter, avoid the bandits in pursuit, keep the prisoners in line and get to the prison. See how this might get hairy? We’ll let you imagine just how bad things get on this trip, but think disembowelment or worse and you’re on the right lines.

It’s every man for themselves in Joaquin Romero Marchent’s Cut-Throats Nine and a certain tension that could only come from having some of society's worst convicts in such close proximity. This film is conventionally loopy in its camera work, over the top and so brutal that it has become both a Western and a Horror classic.

Perhaps it’s not the film with the most cinematic merit on the list, but in terms of a film with unforgettable bleakness and savagery, look no further than Cut-Throats Nine. Don’t believe us? Well cinemas had to hand out ‘Terror Masks’ to movie-goers so they could hide their faces when it got too viscious. Now THAT’S a violent movie.


Contributor
Contributor

An encyclopedia on European cinema, hardcore music and Lana Del Rey.