10 Movie Battles The Heroes Only Won By Fluke

Sometimes it's better to be lucky than good.

It is imperative that the threat of failure loom over a cinematic protagonist's head; without it there's no drama. Do you remember how riveting the subway fight was between Agent Smith and Neo at the end of the first Matrix film? How about Luke Skywalker's face off with with his estranged father at the end of The Empire Strikes Back? Of course you do. Cinema is littered with examples of battles like these, where the protagonist (or protagonists) is not just evenly matched with the antagonist, but seriously outgunned. Sometimes though cinematic match-up can be so skewed to the villain's favor that the only way a hero ends up winning is through luck, an amazing coincidence, or a deus ex machina moment. This outcome can sometimes be to the detriment of a film, but other times it can make a particular character, scene or film more memorable. Take Indiana Jones for example. That famous movie archeologist seems to live for getting his head kicked in. Often times he only comes out on top due to a circumstantial fluke, but that's just part of his charm. In this article we will look at similar situations - both bad and good - where a "fluke" is responsible for the heroes eventually triumphing. Here are ten examples of heroes who couldn't quite carry themselves through on their own steam.

10. Babe - Final Herding Competition

While this may not be a technical battle, Babe the Pig's victory during the final herding competition in 1995's Babe certainly qualifies as a situation where the hero wins by fluke. During the scene in question, Babe, who throughout the film is attempting to transcend his destiny of ending up on Farmer Hoggett's dinner plate, is taken to compete at a herding competition after having displayed great skill at herding the farmer's sheep at home. A massive problem arises however when the sheep simply choose to ignore him. This completely stymies what was Babe's typical technique of asking the sheep politely if they would mind moving this way or that. The little pig is only saved by the kindly intervention of Hoggett's sheepdogs Fly and Rex, who run back to the farm and ask the sheep for the secret password that will prompt the competition sheep to listen. After receiving the phrase of "Ba ram you" from Hoggett's flock, Babe proceeds to herd the sheep successfully. This password prompts the sheep to perform flawlessly, winning the competition for Babe, and the heart of Farmer Hoggett in the process.

9. Raiders Of The Lost Ark - Indiana Jones vs. German Mechanic

As mentioned in the article's introduction, Indiana Jones is the poster child for getting worked over in films. Despite being a formidable fighter, viewers can basically count on each entry to the franchise containing THAT fight, where Indy comes across an impossibly strong behemoth who pummels him mercilessly. In Raiders of the Lost Ark, this scenario revolves around the German Mechanic, a ferocious Nazi who Indy and Marion encounter as they make their escape from the crypt containing the Ark of the Covenant. Indy handles himself well enough in the fight, and this battle basically introduces his inventive fighting style which includes dirty moves like throwing sand into his enemy's eyes and even biting him at one point. Still, despite Indy's strong showing, the German Mechanic remains relatively unfazed throughout the battle, shrugging off many of our hero's strongest haymakers and eventually sending him sprawling and stunned into the dust. Indy only ends up winning due to the Mechanic seeming to forget where he is fighting, and not observing the two razor sharp plane propellers spinning in the near vicinity. This undoubtedly was a lucky break for the archeologist, as the Mechanic looked like he was just getting warmed up, while Indy looked like he could barely stand up.

8. LOTR: The Return Of The King - Battle At The Black Gate

There are many battles throughout The Lord of the Rings where the heroes are saved at the last second by some previously unseen force or ally. However, one of the victories achieved by a technical fluke is during the The Battle at the Black Gate, where Aragorn, Gandalf, and Merry and Pippin make a final stand against Mordor. Severely, almost hilariously outnumbered, the remainder of the original Fellowship (in addition to a small band of warriors from Gondor) puts on a valiant show against the loathsome forces of Sauron's evil during this battle, yet it is to no avail. Just when defeat seems imminent however, salvation arrives from an unlikely place. Inside of Mount Doom the loathsome Gollum - who has spent the entire franchise trying to get back his "precious" - chooses to finally attack Frodo for the Ring of Power, eventually causing himself to fall into the lava of the volcano. This is an incredibly lucky break, as director Peter Jackson explicitly shows that Frodo is unwilling to throw the ring into the pit on his own accord. Without Gollum's selfish but ultimately valuable actions the ring wouldn't have been destroyed. Also, the Fellowship would have met a horrific fate, as Jackson shows that the only reason the hordes of Mordor stop fighting is because they witness Sauron's eye crumble and finally explode.

7. Star Wars Episode I: The Phantom Menace - The Battle Of Naboo

The Battle of Naboo is the climactic action set piece of the The Phantom Menace, and continues the tradition started in The Empire Strikes Back where the climax takes place on several different fronts simultaneously. In Episode I this format involves a land battle - where the Gungans rumble with Trade Federation's droid army - and a space firefight, where several Naboo pilots desperately attempt to take on the Federation's droid command vessel. What is funny about both different battles is that the outcomes are decided largely by accidental behavior. During the land battle the notorious Jar Jar Binks takes down scores of battle droids, but not through his own volition. Consider the scene where he gets his foot tangled in a partially destroyed battle droid (which can still fire) and begins destroying droid after droid, or when he brings down an entire tank through his bumbling, clumsy idiocy. Similarly, the cherub known as Anakin Skywalker - who mistakenly gets inside a Naboo fighter - helps turn the tide of both battles. After spinning around on the celestial battlefield for awhile, he inadvertently finds himself inside the control ship. There, he accidentally unleashes his ship's main weapons, provoking a cataclysmic explosion which ends up not only destroying the command ship but immediately deactivating all the droids on the Naboo surface. This blatant stroke of luck couldn't have come at a better time, as all of the film's heroes were moments away from being routed. Of course, with one of those heroes being Jar Jar Binks, maybe that wouldn't have been the worst thing in the world.

6. The Matrix Revolutions - The Battle Of Zion

One of the main problems with The Matrix Revolutions is that it's basically one long and rather tiring battle sequence, which transpires predominantly in the last bastion of human civilization: the subterranean Zion. Not everything about the scene is a total waste however. Despite being rather derivative, the mech warriors that the human defenders use to repel the machines' invasion are pretty neat. Additionally, the scene contains a pretty vicious level of brutality, which is practically unheard of now with big budget films. The mood that the Wachowskis create in this scene is also notable. Essentially, the human defenses are rather futile; they are a last-ditch effort, a Hail Mary. Still, the resolution that the directors came up with for the conflict is bewildering and in no way satisfying. What finally puts an end (at least temporarily) to the acrimonious conflict between man and machine is Keanu Reeves' Neo, who successfully negotiates a treaty with a being literally referred to as the Deus Ex Machina, also known as the central interface of the Machine City. While this spares the human race in Zion and gives them a "victory" which could never have been achieved through force, it hurts the film overall. It prompts a highly inconclusive ending, and leaves questions like: "What will the machines do for power now that they are freeing those people still plugged into the Matrix?" and "What exactly happened to Neo?"

5. Star Wars Episode VI: The Return Of The Jedi - Luke vs. Darth Vader And The Emperor

To some this may seem like an erroneous entry. In The Return of the Jedi, Luke Skywalker - after finally giving into his anger - does manage to overpower his father Darth Vader without the assistance of a "fluke." However, Vader is only part of the equation in this battle, and while Luke does manage to defeat him, this still leaves Emperor Palpatine to contend with. As established in the prequel series, The Emperor (also known as Darth Sidious) is a enormously powerful Sith lord, something that Skywalker learns after defiantly refusing to join him. Palpatine unleashes the full power of his Force lightning at the Jedi after being rebuffed, which drives him to the floor and leaves him withering in agony. It is only by begging his father for help that Luke is spared. The fluke in this situation is of course Vader choosing to redeem himself and come to his son's aid. It's an unexpected, elementally moving scene because while Vader had previously vacillated to a small degree between the light and the dark side of The Force, for a majority of the series he had been an ice cold enforcer of The Emperor's will. This touching moment is an enormous victory for the Skywalker legacy, which, as established in the prequels, was prophesied to destroy the Sith once and for all. By deciding to redeem at the last moment, Vader gave his son a victory that couldn't have been achieved any other way, and achieved one for himself.

4. The Avengers - The Battle Of New York

In 2012's The Avengers Joss Whedon brought together the different super powered figures from the Marvel Cinematic Universe. However, despite the immense level of power held by the the titular team, the apocalyptic threat unleashed by Loki during the film's climactic Battle of New York threatens to overwhelm them all and doom Earth to his rule. This is primarily due to a numbers game. At the beginning of the film Loki manages to get the Chitauri army to work for him (after promising The Other that he would deliver him The Tesseract). He then is able to send wave after wave of these beings towards the small band of super powered defenders. The group puts up a remarkable effort against this aggression. In fact, one of 2012's great scenes is when the team finally assembles to begin doling out the pain to Loki's army in a glorious, seamless fashion. Still, in keeping with the comics, Whedon shows that the power of these heroes is not infinite. This is a group that can tire, that can eventually make mistakes, and can ultimately lose. In fact, what eventually opens a path to victory is not some new gadget from Iron Man's suit or an act of strength from Mark Ruffalo's Hulk; the game-changing weapon proves to be a good old fashioned nuclear missile. Ordered by the film's World Security Council, with no regard for the human cost of destroying Manhattan, the nuke ironically provides the team with a quick method for ending the conflict and limiting the loss of life. Iron Man selflessly seeks to direct the missile towards the opening of the portal where the Chitauri are attacking from, eventually hitting the alien mothership on the other side. This is undoubtedly a valiant act of heroism, but one that wouldn't have been possible without the amoral, unexpected behavior of the clandestine Council.

3. Aladdin - Aladdin vs. Jafar

Rarely has there been a more one-sided altercation than the one that plays out at the end of Disney's 1992 classic Aladdin. In one corner there is the titular street rat, who possesses striking athleticism, a sharp tongue and who can swing a mean sword. In the other is Jafar, who appears to be a force of almost limitless power. He is capable of manipulating the elements; passing through roaring flames without being harmed; and shape shifting at will. While Aladdin manages to hold his own in this brawl - even when Jafar transforms himself into a giant serpent - the villainous sorcerer eventually does get the better of the wily ragamuffin. After grabbing him with his massive coils he seems prepared to deliver a final crushing squeeze. Thinking quickly, Aladdin hedges his bets on a desperate idea. He uses Jafar's megalomania to his own advantage, and convinces him that he actually needs to use his third wish to transform himself into a genie. There was no guarantee that this ploy would work. Aladdin, Agrabah and perhaps the Universe itself end up catching an incredibly lucky break when Jafar agrees with the boy's idea and overlooks the salient fact of a genie's existence. Despite possessing phenomenal, cosmic power, the lamp of a genie still dictates where they go and what they do. It's an amazing fluke that brings about this great villain's downfall. It also provides a great, cathartic sense of closure to the story, at least until the sequel was released a few years later.

2. The Dark Knight Rises - Batman vs. Bane

For those who grew up consuming Batman comics or habitually watching the animated series, it was an exciting prospect that when the design of Bane was released for Christopher Nolan's The Dark Knight Rises, it did not include a comically large (not to mention vulnerable) tube used to pump venom throughout his body. At long last it appeared that Batman was going to have to find a more inventive of way of defeating one of his most formidable opponents. Oh how wrong we were. In the film's climax, Batman has a long awaited rematch with Bane after having his spine broken earlier in the film. One of the flaws of this sequence is that the Dark Knight does not choose to employ a more strategic fighting style this time around. He again throws wildly telegraphed punches, and tries to overwhelm Bane through strength alone. This goes about as well as expected. Nolan shows quite explicitly that the Caped Crusader is outclassed, with Bane clearly driving Batman backwards and having the upper hand when they engage in a little mid-air arm wrestling. Unfortunately, the only thing which prevents Batman from once again ending up as a pile of broken bones at Bane's feet is a fluke to end all flukes. One of the Bat's frantic swings manages to knock a piece of Bane's pain-inhibiting mask loose, which almost immediately shifts the odds to Batman's favor. This fluke provides the hero of the film with the victory he needed. However, it also crushed the hopes of fans eager to see a brawl between The Bat and Bane play out differently than it had in previous incarnations.

1. Harry Potter And The Deathly Hollows: Part II - The Battle Of Hogwarts

The climax of the Harry Potter and The Deathly Hollows: Part II does a great job in once again establishing the fiendish power of Voldemort - who is a dark wizard truly without peer. Despite his tenacity and his indomitable will power, The Boy Who Lived is simply not a match for him. The only thing which allows for the teen wizard to emerge triumphant is how the heroes of the story eventually surmise what the Elder Wand is and just how its power truly works. Basically, to access the powers of the Elder Wand (considered the most powerful wand in existence) one has to defeat its owner in battle. When Voldemort goes in search of the object he mistakes who the owner of the wand is, and thus kills the wrong person. Earlier in the story, Harry disarms the owner of the Elder Wand - which makes him its true owner. Ultimately though he does not keep the wand with him, which allows Voldemort to eventually hold it, but not own it. This led to the outcome of the final battle, where even though Voldemort was wielding the Elder Wand and attempting to use his favorite spell Avada Kedavra, he had not actually gained ownership of the "Death Stick." The spell ends up rebounding and ultimately killing him, as one of the qualities of the wand is that it cannot harm its true master. This is an exceptionally fortunate turn of events for the heroes of J.K Rowling's epic tale, but also one that is anticlimactic. The greatest villain in Wizarding World history is defeated through nothing more than a dumb mistake. Do you agree with our list? Do you have any ideas for other heroes who won the day through an accident or stroke of luck? Let us know in the comments section.

Contributor
Contributor

Adam Mohrbacher has been afflicted with an obession for film since his earliest memories. In addition to his work with WhatCulture, Adam has been a contributor with Filmophilia.com, FilmMonthly.com and Examiner.com. You can also check out his personal blog here: adammohrbacher@wordpress.com. A devoted fan of all film genres and styles, Adam gets equally giddy over the sensitive, existential musings of Ingmar Bergman, and the brawny brilliance of Arnold Schwartzenegger. He loves fish tacos and misses the work of Heath Ledger and Jack Lemmon on a daily basis.