10 Movie Casting Choices That Were Total Misdirection
Didn't see that coming?
Casting is everything in a movie - get it wrong and the rest of the film can be derailed no matter how good the writing or direction might be, but get it right and you've got an indelible all-timer character on your hands, and maybe even an Oscar-winning performance.
But sometimes, movie studios and filmmakers will deliberately cast an actor in a role intended to throw audiences off and keep them from guessing a big reveal, be it the untimely death of an A-lister early on, an actor known for their villains actually playing the hero, or simply distracting audiences from a twist hiding in plain sight.
In each of these 10 cases, the casting announcements made sense and garnered plenty of excitement, only for the filmmakers to flip the script and use the actors in a totally different way from the expected.
While in some instances the sleight-of-hand left viewers angry or confused, for the most part it helped generate an air of nervous intrigue, and in the very least, can be commended for toying with the safe, predictable bubble in which most big-budget Hollywood movies are made...
10. Bryan Cranston - Godzilla
What Everyone Expected
It's fair to say that Warner Bros. knew exactly what they were doing when they cast Bryan Cranston in a (seemingly) lead role in Gareth Edwards' 2014 Godzilla.
With Cranston's hit series Breaking Bad concluding mere months before the film was due to release, the studio was clearly banking on the hype of a Walter White vs. Godzilla showdown to put butts in seats, with the movie's trailers cut to place Cranston's Joe Brody front-and-center.
What We Got
In actual fact, Cranston's casting was a crass bait-and-switch, as he dies almost exactly one-third of the way through the movie, after which his son Ford (Aaron Taylor-Johnson) is revealed to be the stealth protagonist.
Given that few could've expected Johnson to be handed the responsibility of carrying a $160 million tentpole, Cranston's involvement was clearly an attempt to warm the audience up to the actor in the first act with a heartfelt sob-story, while guaranteeing a certain amount of buzz based on Cranston's popularity alone.
Presumably Warner Bros. wasn't convinced Cranston would sell tickets with teenagers, though, so of course, he had to end up handing the movie off to his dreamboat son, to the collective disappointment of just about everyone over the age of 17.
9. Ben Kingsley - Iron Man 3
What Everyone Expected
Fans rejoiced when the brilliant Ben Kingsley was cast as Iron Man's iconic comic book foe The Mandarin in Iron Man 3, given both his Oscar-winning acting chops and the fact that Kingsley's casting would seemingly avoid any potentially iffy Asian stereotypes associated with the source material.
The trailers teased The Mandarin as a ruthless, fiercely intelligent terrorist who posed the greatest threat to Tony Stark (Robert Downey Jr.) yet, and with an actor as statuesque as Kingsley in the role, it was easy to believe it.
What We Got
As it turned out, Kingsley wasn't playing The Mandarin at all, but rather an actor stooge, Trevor Slattery, who was employed to act as a proxy Mandarin, allowing the supposedly "real" Mandarin, Aldrich Killian (Guy Pearce), to operate undetected.
And while the Mandarin twist left many fans outraged, it was at least a clever subversion of audience expectations based on an actor's prominence.
Who could've ever expected that acting vet Kingsley would end up playing a comic relief character, while the lesser-known Pearce would transition into the primary antagonist role in the film's second half?
It wasn't a choice that worked for everyone, but as a cinematic parlour trick, it was mightily effective indeed.
8. Drew Barrymore - Scream
What Everyone Expected
Drew Barrymore was featured extensively in the marketing for Wes Craven's classic horror-satire Scream, being given the most prominent placement on all of the movie's posters, while the trailers implied she had a starring role equivalent to that of her co-stars Courtney Cox, David Arquette and Neve Campbell.
Given that she was by far the most famous member of the cast, it was pretty reasonable to assume that she was at least a major character, if not the final girl herself.
What We Got
In an expectation-shattering twist, Barrymore's Casey Becker appears in the film's very first scene and...that's it.
Casey is Ghostface's first victim in the movie - well, the second if you count her boyfriend - and Barrymore lasts a mere 12 minutes of screen time before making her exit.
Though it might've been a disappointing move for the Barrymore die-hards out there, killing off the film's most note-worthy cast member in the very first scene set a precedent of unpredictability which carried throughout the remainder of the movie.
It threw the old genre rulebook out and told the audience that anyone could die at any moment, while the final girl mantle was instead passed to Neve Campbell's Sidney Prescott.
7. Arnold Schwarzenegger - Terminator 2: Judgment Day
What Everyone Expected
Tough though this might be to believe nowadays, back when Terminator 2 was awaiting release, James Cameron made pains to keep a firm lid on the precise nature of the cyborg characters played by Arnold Schwarzenegger and Robert Patrick.
In fact, a sinister early teaser trailer for T2 quite brilliantly played off of Schwarzenegger's terrifyingly villainous performance in the original Terminator, implying that the sequel would see another T-800, again played by Arnie, sent back through time to stamp out the human resistance.
And though the film's final trailer did let the cat out of the bag regarding Arnie's actual role, back in 1991 it was far easier to miss these things.
As such, many fans saw the movie for the first time assuming that Schwarzenegger was the villainous T-800 and Robert Patrick was the hero cop sent to protect John Connor (Edward Furlong) from the machines.
What We Got
Of course, T2's great twist is that Arnie is playing a benevolent T-800 this time, while Patrick is actually the advanced T-1000 Terminator sent back through time to murder John.
It's fair to say that had T2 been released today, its big conceit would've been ruined for everyone during production, yet pre-Internet it was far easier to keep spoilers under control, and only in the film's final marketing push was the big reveal given away.
When Arnie's casting in the movie was first announced, though, surely nobody could've ever expected in what capacity, or the subsequent glut of nostalgia-fuelled sequels it would lead to.
6. J.B. Smoove - Spider-Man: Far From Home
What Everyone Expected
One of the greatest strengths of the MCU Spider-Man movies has been their diverse and eclectic casts, and so fans were overjoyed when Curb Your Enthusiasm's brilliant J.B. Smoove was cast in an unspecified yet apparently "major" role in Spider-Man: Far From Home.
This quickly prompted speculation from countless fans and outlets that the hilarious motormouth Smoove would be playing a contemporary, rebooted version of The Daily Bugle's editor J. Jonah Jameson.
And given the MCU's tendency to veer sharply away from prior iterations of iconic comic book characters, going with a totally new and radical Jameson was perfectly believable.
What We Got
In reality, Smoove ended up playing Julius Dell, Peter Parker's (Tom Holland) teacher and one of his class' chaperones through Europe.
Hilariously, he was cast in the part after the filmmakers enjoyed his chemistry with Parker in an Audi commercial made to promote Spider-Man: Homecoming two years prior.
But the true genius of Smoove's casting is that it got people so tangled up in speculating about him possibly being Jameson that they totally forgot about J.K. Simmons, who of course made a jaw-dropping return as Jameson in Far From Home's mid-credits scene.
While you can argue this misdirect was more a result of fans playing themselves rather than any overt chicanery on Marvel Studios' part, it worked splendidly whether intentional or not.
5. Jon Bernthal - Wind River
What Everyone Expected
The casting of the brilliant Jon Bernthal in Taylor Sheridan's directorial debut Wind River raised quite a few eyebrows when he didn't appear in any of the movie's marketing.
Between his curious absence in trailers and the fact that he played a murderous creep in the Sheridan-scripted Sicario - not to mention Bernthal's general deference towards playing bad apples - it seemed likely that he'd end up revealed as the movie's shadowy serial killer. If the glove fits, right?
What We Got
In actual fact, Bernthal only appears in the film for a single scene, and he's a good guy. Even more bizarrely, the scene is a flashback which ends with Bernthal's nice guy being beaten to death for attempting to prevent the rape of the film's focal murder victim, Natalie (Kelsey Chow).
Better still, Natalie's actual rapist and murderer is a random nobody called Pete, played by relatively unknown character actor James Jordan.
Hiding Bernthal from audiences definitely helped perpetuate the belief that he'd be the third-act big bad, so this was a majorly clever misdirect, especially for a first-time director.
As brilliant as Bernthal is at playing thoroughly detestable characters, he absolutely nailed this rarest of opportunities to play not merely a decent man but a tragically heroic one.
4. Janet Leigh - Psycho
What Everyone Expected
Janet Leigh already had more than 30 feature film roles under her belt when she starred in Alfred Hitchcock's Psycho, and audiences quite rightly assumed that her character Marion Crane would be the movie's protagonist.
Fitting all the bills of a prototypical Hitchcock leading lady - blonde and beautiful, basically - audiences of the time were totally reasonable in assuming she'd be facing off against a crazed killer for the entirety of the movie.
What We Got
In perhaps the first notable instance of a decoy protagonist bamboozling viewers, Marion is actually killed less than half-way through the film, stabbed to death in one of the most iconic movie murders of all time.
The rest of the movie shifts the perspective to Marion's sister Lila (Vera Miles) and boyfriend Sam Loomis (John Gavin), who arrive at the Bates Motel to investigate Marion's whereabouts.
Casting the gorgeous starlet and plastering her face all over the marketing only for her to last barely 45 minutes was a bold move, and one that paid off brilliantly.
As with Drew Barrymore's unexpected demise in Scream, it kept audiences on their toes and likely helped prevent them from guessing the film's real twist, that motel owner Norman Bates (Anthony Perkins) was the killer all along.
Legend dictates that Hitchcock insisted upon no late patrons being admitted to screenings of the film, in case they arrived after Leigh's death and complained about her absence from the film.
Furthermore, Leigh's agent advised her against taking the role due to its brevity, only for her to brilliantly retort, "Ah, but who are they talking about the rest of the film?"
3. Sean Bean - Flightplan
What Everyone Expected
While it wouldn't be fair to call Sean Bean typecast, he is best known for two things in his movie roles - playing bad guys and dying. Dying a lot.
And so, when he was cast as the airplane pilot in 2005's Hitchcockian thriller Flightplan - where Jodie Foster's daughter goes missing mid-flight - most audiences believed they were being set up for yet another villainous Sean Bean reveal.
With the trailers implying that Bean's character was trying to gaslight Foster's hero into believing she'd lost her mind, what other conclusion could viewers possibly arrive at?
What We Got
Though the film isn't particularly good, it does smartly toy with the audience's perception of Sean Bean, because as it turns out, his character is just a totally normal, regular guy with no ulterior motives whatsoever.
He only doubts Foster's protagonist because, you know, her story does actually sound pretty far-fetched out of context and there's no proof supporting it.
Once she's proven to be telling the truth at the end of the film, he even soundly apologises for not believing her, and better still, actually survives the movie!
The real villain, in case you're curious, is revealed to be air marshal Gene Carson (Peter Sarsgaard).
2. Tom Skerritt - Alien
What Everyone Expected
Before Tom Skerritt appeared in Ridley Scott's 1979 sci-fi masterpiece, he already had almost two decades of acting work under his belt, and despite not being quite as established an actor as co-star John Hurt, nevertheless received top billing on the movie's posters.
Skerritt of course played Dallas, the captain of the Nostromo, and audiences quite understandably assumed that between his fame and rank onboard the ship, he was to be the protagonist (and a probable survivor) of the horror to follow.
What We Got
Though Scott's film initially focuses more intently on the ensemble cast than any one character or actor, Dallas does seem to be the hero of the piece at first, until he becomes one of the xenomorph's victims mid-way through the movie.
After this, Ripley (Sigourney Weaver) is left in command of the Nostromo and assumes the protagonist role for the film's remainder, ultimately ending up its sole human survivor - with the crew's cat Jones, of course.
With an ensemble cast including acting vets such as Skerritt, Hurt, Harry Dean Stanton, Veronica Cartwright, Ian Holm and Yaphet Kotto, Weaver was by far the least-experienced and least-famous cast member, having just two prior feature acting credits to her name.
As such, positioning Skerritt as our archetypical hyper-masculine hero was a perfect bait-and-switch, allowing Weaver to fill the void in his absence and deliver a surprising, star-making performance in the process.
1. Steven Seagal - Executive Decision
What Everyone Expected
Back in the mid-90s, Steven Seagal was at peak popularity as a rising action star, hot off the success of Under Siege.
And so, when he was cast opposite Kurt Russell in the 1996 action-thriller Executive Decision, as well as receiving top billing and having his face plastered across most of the posters, audiences anticipated a Seagal-led genre romp.
What We Got
Hilariously, Seagal doesn't even make it inside the hijacked aircraft, with his Lieutenant Colonel Austin Travis sacrificing himself at the end of the movie's first act, much to most viewers' slack-jawed surprise.
The death of Travis came so abruptly that fans have theorised ever since that a production or scheduling issue resulted in Segal's role being reduced last-minute, yet more recent reports suggest that he simply did the role as a favour to the studio.
Either way, with the film releasing at a time when Seagal was an untouchable, on-the-rise badass, him being ejected from a plane so unceremoniously was a major shock.
Thankfully the rest of the movie is still trashy fun, even if those who turned up largely on the basis of Seagal's presence - likely a significant portion of the audience - were surely left baffled.