10 Movie Co-Stars Who Shared Iconic Roles
Sherlock Holmes is TWO Avengers?
Mark Ruffalo, the third/fourth/fifth actor (depending on how you count) to play the Hulk once said of the role, "I look at it as my generation's Hamlet." Ruffalo does not mean that when Bruce Banner gets angry he transforms into a giant green Shakespearean tragic hero, he means that the role gets passed around many great actors of the time, much like Hamlet, and many other Shakespearean roles, used to be.
With countless remakes, reboots, and re-castings in movies these days, the same roles, like Hulk and Hamlet, often get played by many different performers. No actor has a monopoly on a single role anymore. Even iconic performances, such as Anthony Hopkins as Hannibal Lecter or Heath Ledger as the Joker, have found themselves recast.
Sometimes, the actor to take over the role has performed opposite the first actor before in another film. Before seeing the two actors in the same role in two different projects, you can see them in the same project in different roles.
This list won't include actors who played the same role in the same movie, such as Kate Winslet and Gloria Stuart in Titanic.
Here are ten co-stars who shared roles in other projects.
10. Catherine Zeta-Jones And Helen Mirren - Catherine The Great
The Bruce Willis-led action sequel RED 2 features a star studded cast, including Anthony Hopkins, John Malkovich, Mary-Louise Parker, and two Oscar winning actresses: Catherine Zeta-Jones and Helen Mirren.
Zeta-Jones and Mirren share more than an appearance in RED 2 and a golden statue. Both actresses have played the legendary Russian Empress Catherine the Great in a biopic.
Zeta-Jones took on the role in a 1995 TV movie called Catherine the Great, which focused on the leader's love life in her younger years. Mirren appeared in a different Catherine the Great, a 2019 miniseries which focused on the title character's golden years.
Appropriately, Zeta-Jones also plays a Russian in RED 2, portraying a secret agent.
9. Marlon Brando And Robert De Niro - Don Vito Corleone
Don Vito Corleone, alongside the Joker, is one of two characters to win Oscars for two different actors. In the first Godfather film, Marlon Brando made the role his own, dominating every scene, and in the second, Robert De Niro expanded upon it. However, the pair never overlapped in Frances Ford Coppola's trilogy, with Brando sitting out of The Godfather Part II entirely.
Years later, Brando and De Niro finally shared the screen in the 2001 film The Score, which happened to be Brando's final film. Directed by Frank Oz (of Yoda fame), the film is, much like the Godfather trilogy, a crime drama about ageing, so the two Don Vitos ultimately appear in a Godfather-like film together.
8. Frank Welker And Zac Efron - Fred Jones
Since his very first appearance in 1969's Scooby-Doo, Where are You!, trap expert and Mystery Machine driver Fred Jones has been voiced by legendary voice actor Frank Welker. In 2002's What's New Scooby-Doo?, Welker also took over the voice of the titular talking dog himself, and has voiced both characters in nearly every adaptation since.
Welker reprised the role of Scooby-Doo in 2020's feature film Scoob!, but, since the human characters were voiced by big-name actors, he gave up the role of Fred to Zac Efron. As such, Scoob! features two actors who have played Fred.
Similarly, Welker and Don Messick, the original voice of Scooby-Doo, also work as a pair of co-stars who shared a role, since both voiced Scooby.
7. Aidan Gillen And Richard Madden - John Reid
The first of two pairs of Game of Thrones co-stars on this list, Aidan Gillen and Richard Madden, both played major roles in the iconic HBO fantasy series. Gillen made his mark as the villainous Littlefinger for the first seven seasons, and Madden brought to life King in the North Robb Stark for the first three.
Though the pair don't share any screen time in Game of Thrones, they do share the role of music manager John Reid. Reid managed both Queen and Elton John, and therefore featured in both of their recent biopics. In Bohemian Rhapsody, Gillen plays Reid in a supporting role, and in Rocketman, Madden takes on the role as the main antagonist.
Unfortunately for Littlefinger, managing Queen is the closest he ever came to royalty.
6. Bryce Dallas Howard And Emma Stone - Gwen Stacy
At this point, Spider-Man has been rebooted so many times that some of its stars must have appeared together in other films. While no combination of the Peter Parkers, Tobey Maguire, Andrew Garfield, Tom Holland, or Jake Johnson, have ever appeared in a film together, two Gwen Stacys have.
Gwen Stacy makes her film debut in Spider-Man 3, where she is played by Bryce Dallas Howard. Howard would go on to appear in the 2011 Best Picture Nominee, The Help, alongside Emma Stone. A year later, Stone would go on to play the rebooted Gwen Stacy in The Amazing Spider-Man, and again in 2014's The Amazing Spider-Man 2.
Hopefully, all of the Gwen Stacys, Peter Parkers, and the rest of the Spidey supporting cast can appear together in a live-action Spider-Verse sometime soon.
5. Paul Rudd And Tobey Maguire - Nick Carraway
Although he never appeared in a movie with any other Spider-Man, Tobey Maguire shared a major role with another of his co-stars from a different film.
In 1999, Maguire appeared alongside the never-ageing Paul Rudd in The Cider House Rules. A year later, Rudd would play Nick Carraway in a television film version of F. Scott Fitzgerald's book, The Great Gatsby. In 2013, Maguire would also play Nick, in Bad Luhrmann's adaptation of the book.
In the opening line of Gatsby, we learn that Nick's father always said, "Whenever you feel like criticizing any one, just remember that all the people in this world haven't had the advantages that you've had." Rudd and Maguire, having shared a role, can criticize each other.
4. Robert Downey Jr. And Benedict Cumberbatch - Sherlock Holmes
Avengers: Infinity War brought together almost every Marvel superhero to fight against Thanos, such as Captain America, Black Panther, Spider-Man, the Guardians of the Galaxy, and... Sherlock Holmes?
In fact, two Sherlocks appear in the massive Marvel movie: Robert Downey Jr. and Benedict Cumberbatch. Downey played the role in Guy Ritchie's 2009 Sherlock Holmes and its 2011 sequel, Sherlock Holmes: A Game of Shadows. Cumberbatch played the famous sleuth in the BBC series Sherlock from 2011-2017.
Both have also portrayed MCU superheroes, with Downey playing Tony Stark/Iron Man and Cumberbatch as Doctor Stephen Strange. Iron Man and Doctor Strange finally meet in Avengers: Infinity War, and the pair also share a brief scene in Avengers: Endgame.
Coincidentally, both of their respective Watsons, Jude Law and Martin Freeman, have also appeared in the MCU, though never alongside either Sherlock.
3. Evan Peters And Aaron Taylor-Johnson - Quicksilver
In 2014 and 2015, X-Men: Days of Future Past and Avengers: Age of Ultron confused audiences everywhere by introducing parallel versions of the same character, Quicksilver. The X-Men's version, Peter Maximoff, was played by Evan Peters, who would reprise the role in X-Men: Apocalypse and Dark Phoenix. The Avengers' version, called Pietro like his comic counterpart, was played by Aaron Taylor-Johnson and appeared in a major role in the film before his death in the climax.
Before Taylor-Johnson got his ass kicked by Ultron, he portrayed another comic book character, the title character of 2010's Kick-Ass. Kick-Ass's friend Todd is played by Peters, meaning that the film had two different Quicksilver actors.
Even though it's true, don't tell confused fans that Quicksilver is "the guy from Kick-Ass." It's not helpful.
2. Lena Headey And Emilia Clarke - Sarah Connor
Lena Headey and Emilia Clarke are the second pair of Game of Thrones co-stars to make it onto this list. Both actresses played a leading role on all eight seasons of Thrones, with Headey starring as Cersei Lannister and Clarke as Daenerys Targaryen.
Before playing Cersei, Headey played Sarah Connor from the Terminator films in a TV spinoff called Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles. Years later, Clarke took on the role for the 2015 sequel Terminator: Genesis after having worked with Headey for five seasons.
In hindsight "Sarah Connor will take the Iron Throne" isn't that bad of a Game of Thrones prediction.
1. Chevy Chase And Joel McHale - Chevy Chase
Community's Jeff Winger may think he's nothing like his frenemy Pierce Hawthorne, but the two have more in common than they might think. In the 2018 Netflix film a Futile and Stupid Gesture, which tells the story of comedy writer Doug Kenny, Jeff's actor Joel McHale appears as one of Kenny's real life friends, Chevy Chase.
Chase's body of work includes Vacation, Caddyshack, and Community, on which he played Pierce for four seasons.
Chase also appeared in the first ever Saturday Night Live cast, acting as himself in the weekend update segment. So, technically, both Joel McHale and Chevy Chase have played Chevy Chase.
Chase can't say his famous catchphrase, "I'm Chevy Chase, and you're not," to McHale anymore.
Watch Next
The IMPOSSIBLE Sherlock Quiz